Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that not everyone has the tools to make great life choices?

135 replies

malificent7 · 14/03/2023 20:26

I hear a lot of talk on mn about life choices. Especially in the context of benefit recipients or single parents.

I used to make very poor life choices. I suffered abuse from mum and in my teens/ early 20s, from my ex.
I therefore made bad decisions and suffered from horrendous mental health.

This resulted on me rebelling against my mum, not doing medicine asshe wanted me to ( regret this now,), turning to booze and choosing a bad dad for dd.

Since emdr therapy, I have been making much better choices but my upbringinghas definately has held me bk.

Aibu to think that if a person from a relatively affluent middle class family can make poor life decisions, so can anyone if their mh is poor. Not everyone can choose a decent partner, not to be an addict or a decent career.

I do feel like i threw a lot of my opportunities away as a young woman.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JuliesBicycle · 16/03/2023 17:43

Or being murdered as one of my relatives was. She was in her bed at home.

Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 17:36

badgermushrooms · 15/03/2023 08:36

The "poor choices" brigade are coming from the same place as the people who think rape is the result of women wearing short skirts and drinking too much. They've seen that the world us a scary place where bad things happen and they deal with it by pretending to themselves that bad things won't happen to them because they do the "right" thing. Unfortunately for them it's bollocks, I can tell you no amount of Russell Group degrees and sensible career decisions will prevent your husband developing cancer in his 40s.

Well said. Lots of the poor choices, take responsibility group have no idea what they are talking about.

BigFatLiar · 16/03/2023 12:01

I didn't have the pick of the guys, except as a friend - the good ones went for girls that looked like you and then moaned to me about it all 🤣.

We have a number of single male friends and that's pretty similar to what they would say only they had trouble with any girl.

From what they say they were on the shy side and lacked self confidence. By the time I got to know them they were fine but settled into single life. Great 'uncles' to the children and always happy to help out.

Sometimes you just make the best of it.

Maverickess · 16/03/2023 11:40

elodiesmith · 16/03/2023 00:14

But if we are being completely honest.. I am Master level educated with a good job.. tall slim blond, did catwalk modelling. That made it easier for men to overlook some emotional instability I would show at times.
So I am aware that I had a good choice of men...

I didn't have the pick of the guys, except as a friend - the good ones went for girls that looked like you and then moaned to me about it all 🤣.

But on a serious note, I just don't think I was or am conventionally attractive enough to warrant being a partner, obviously it wasn't my personality because I had plenty of friendships and people wanted to spend time with me, just didn't fall in love. I'm overweight now but I wasn't always, and was physically fit and active, I'm just well, a bit ugly I think - that's not me seeking sympathy or being woe is me, I really do think it's the truth of the matter and men just don't find me very attractive.

Those who were interested have always turned out to be screwed up and some, abusive. So I'm single, and have been for many years because I don't know how to attract the 'decent' ones and I don't want any more duds! The thing is, having a partner in life helps with so many other things (or can) than just sex/companionship and I've not had that. You can't 'choose' a decent man if none are romantically interested in the first place.

Society always expects the coupling up and there's usually people willing to tell you that there's 'someone out there for everyone' or that you 'find someone when you stop looking' and there's plenty of negative association attached to being single as a woman who is getting older - the stereotypical 'crazy cat lady' being one.

So on that score, I don't think I stood to be successful at all, if I'd 'chosen' someone from the pool of men available to me, it'd have been another disaster and choosing to stay single is the only other alternative, but has it's drawbacks too.

ohfook · 16/03/2023 08:28

This has been proven and it's linked to Maslow's hierarchy of needs basically if you're basic survival needs (food, shelter, safety) are insecure it's exceptionally difficult to have the presence of mind to make good long term decisions when you have to focus on the immediate.

A good analogy is if there's a wolf that follows you and your kids around, you know it could kill your but it hasn't so far but randomly now and then it attacks you pretty badly. Try concentrating on getting your education or improving your prospects for the future when you just need to make sure the wolf doesn't come back today.

Now replace the wolf with an abuser, or a landlord that keeps putting the rent up or a recurring mental illness or hunger or a child with a terminal illness or a hundred other things.

Franticbutterfly · 16/03/2023 08:02

I think that everyone is different, but there is no doubt that your baby and childhood have a deep impact on your personality and decision making throughout life. Not everyone inherits good mental wealth.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 16/03/2023 07:22

Adverse childhood experiences did fuck up my life. I've done ok in terms of lifestyle but there's been a streak of unhappiness and unworthiness and I've never been able to hold down a job because my self esteem is so low.

I could have been so much more. I used to describe myself as a Russian doll without the insides. I lost of my sense of self and I was just reacting, not proactively living my life.

Saying people aren't resilient when they have shitty childhoods and then make poor choices is completely false. Still being on this planet and not killing themselves is fucking resilient. I mean, I remember my first time of wanting to kill myself when I was 5. I used to walk to school age 9 chanting "I want to die i want to die" with each footstep. I'm still here though 3 decades later with my brain still telling me to opt out, and you tell me that's not resilience in fucking spaces!

How can you do your best and make proactively good choices when your brain is beating you up like that?

elodiesmith · 16/03/2023 00:14

But if we are being completely honest.. I am Master level educated with a good job.. tall slim blond, did catwalk modelling. That made it easier for men to overlook some emotional instability I would show at times.
So I am aware that I had a good choice of men...

elodiesmith · 16/03/2023 00:10

Personal experience is completely the opposite.

Absent dad, physically abusive mum. Poverty. According to any textbook, I was bound to choose a poor father for my DC.

But.....

I could not bear any 'loser' man near me, I'd absolutely lose my shit if I was ever treated badly by a bf. It was like a reminder that if I choose a bad man, my life will become my childhood again. I felt as a kid I didn't have choices, but I did as an adult.

As a result I waited a long time and didn't settle, and found a kind, handsome, very successful DH. He dotes on our baby. Our child is completely set up for life (and me for that matter).

It's almost like I've become very calculated because of my shit childhood. I would do anything to build myself a finally successful, calm and peaceful adulthood.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 15/03/2023 23:45

I think background and upbringing play a huge part. But it some point it can explain things but no longer excuse them. When the victim becomes the abuser, either through violence or neglect, then at what pint do we say "no more!"?

And resilience plays a HUGE part in this. I went through some monumental crap and was able to grit my teeth, put in emergency plans for worst case scenarios, and day by day fight my way out of the hellhole I had been dropped into.

And sadly, the "not coping" can happen many years into adulthood because the person hides everything. My exH never overcame his background even though for many years it appeared that he had. As a result he totally destroyed mine and my DC's lives. (My Hellhole was courtesy of him.)

nokidshere · 15/03/2023 23:45

But if you have no awareness that those people and influences are negative because that's all you've known then it's not that simple.

I've never said it was simple. It really isn't.

NothingSafe · 15/03/2023 23:45

nokidshere · 14/03/2023 20:47

Whilst I agree that 'making bad choices' can be a result of upbringing and trauma I also believe that there comes a point in life where you have to take responsibility for your own choices. You might need help, therapy, medication etc but once you are away from the crap influencers on your life any help you get should be firmly directed at accepting that your decisions are now yours and only you can move forward.

Until that happens, moving on from those people and influences will be very hard indeed.

Without the right grounding, though, you don't know what you're doing wrong or even that there IS an alternative.

I come from a deprived background, with a complex and chaotic family, quite severe poverty. I got into a good high school some distance away from where I grew up due to a weird local authority quirk and when I started school at 11, I knew so LITTLE. Didn't know people actually ate their tea at a table outside of films. Didn't know most people didn't know someone who'd been in prison. Didn't know most people didn't have to hide from the Provident woman regularly and thought debt was normal. Didn't know adults could disagree without shouting and screaming. Didn't know what an example of a healthy romantic relationship looked like. Didn't think it especially shocking or unusual to get pregnant at 15 and your parents not to bat an eyelid other than to get you on the council housing waiting list the second you turned 16. Didn't think people actually saved money. Didn't really understand that people who were very mentally ill or with addiction issues could access treatment and get better instead of just slowly destroying their own life. And all these things that were outside of my experience still seemed alien to me even when I did learn about them.

20 odd years later, a good job in a professional industry, an education, a mortgage, a happy and healthy marriage... I'm still working through some of that stuff and it crops up in the strangest of ways in my life.

I still feel weirdly pretentious when I eat at the table at home, which is objectively ridiculous. I still struggle with a kneejerk distrust of authorities like the police or the council or bank managers - even though I'd never show it, I still have a baked-in fear response. There's a million little things.

And I was so lucky because if I'd gone to the high school nearest to where I lived I'd have spent time with lots of other kids from similarly deprived backgrounds or worse and my perception of the world would have been very different. I got to see an alternative version of the world early enough for it not to be too late for me to do things differently than my parents did, but I know plenty of people from my childhood who didn't and whose life choices many people would judge now. But their world view is so normal to them that it's not that they're not taking responsibility - they don't realise in lots of cases there's anything to take responsibility for.

Lastofyou · 15/03/2023 22:30

nokidshere · 14/03/2023 20:47

Whilst I agree that 'making bad choices' can be a result of upbringing and trauma I also believe that there comes a point in life where you have to take responsibility for your own choices. You might need help, therapy, medication etc but once you are away from the crap influencers on your life any help you get should be firmly directed at accepting that your decisions are now yours and only you can move forward.

Until that happens, moving on from those people and influences will be very hard indeed.

But if you have no awareness that those people and influences are negative because that's all you've known then it's not that simple.

JuliesBicycle · 15/03/2023 22:22

I am not officially a boomer by a year. Education was affordable to middle class kids and some working class kids.
But most people did not go to university. Most ordinary working class kids left school at 16 and went into full time work.
You have to understand that university being free was irrelevant to most kids.

MPY24 · 15/03/2023 22:12

Antst · 15/03/2023 18:40

@MPY24, I can't even say "good try." That reply doesn't make much sense.

Education WAS affordable for Boomers. So was housing. So was medical care. When I had to move yet again for work a few years ago, it took three years even to get signed up at a GP practice and another 1.5 years to get an appointmentand that was when I had a cancer scare. I have never had NHS dental care. I am no spring chicken but have never found a practice that can take me. Boomers are now spending decades in retirement that we're paying forand most after having stable jobs that didn't require education.

You are in denial about what is going on.

I never said education wasn't affordable or that healthcare wasn't easier. You said it was easier for boomers to make good choices due to these things. Ignoring what the post is actually about. Regardless of how affordable education is or how easy medical care is to access all generations, including the hated boomers, possibly had abusive parents, had undiagnosed conditions like ASD or ADHD (or is it just younger people who can have these things?) or sometimes just made plain stupid teenage decisions etc.
Also regardless of how free and easy education apparently was, not everyone could actually do it anyway. My dad started work at 15. His mum couldn't afford for him to go to college or university. She couldn't support him. He had no choice but to go to work. I'm not denying at all it would have been easier for him to get a job than these days. But the decision to get a job was not relevant to how cheap education was.

And if it makes you feel better. My boomer father also couldn't get a doctor to take him seriously when he had a cancer scare. They refused to refer him at first and when they finally did the appointment took months to come through. He died of cancer 6 weeks after diagnosis. He was 64. So you'll be pleased to know he didn't get to enjoy all those years of retirement that you're paying for. Instead he enjoyed working for 50 out of 64 years then died without ever getting to relax.

Johnisafckface · 15/03/2023 21:43

I definitely agree with this. I grew up in an abusive home, my DM was very manipulative and would guilt trip us kids if we didn't do as she wanted. My mom would give my dad the silent treatment for days over some small indescretion (altho i'm sure the abuse caused her to be very resentful). My dad never really wanted children, so at times he was abusive (physically and emotionally) to us as well.

It shaped who I am and how I made decisions in life. Many of them bad, so that I now have physical scars, a lagging career, anger issues, not many friends, no relationship/bad relationships, eating disorders, etc.

trulyunruly01 · 15/03/2023 18:58

First off, luckily I have managed to steer clear of abusive relationships, drink or drink problems.

My older sister recently reminded me of the August night in the early 80s when I faced up to my mum and dad and told them I wasn't going back to sixth form, I intended to get a job. OMG it went on for hours and the furore involved everyone in the house including the dog.

The only regret I have is my earning power. There was a window in the mid-90s when an opportunity presented itself which could have put me back on track with earnings but circumstances and obligations then forced a decision against.

So one of those life choices was made in the foolishness of youth, and the other was made as a mature woman with obligations. One road was taken selfishly, the other was taken selflessly.
But whatever I did, I thought it was for the best at the time, and I am the master of 'eyes front and ahead'.

Antst · 15/03/2023 18:40

@MPY24, I can't even say "good try." That reply doesn't make much sense.

Education WAS affordable for Boomers. So was housing. So was medical care. When I had to move yet again for work a few years ago, it took three years even to get signed up at a GP practice and another 1.5 years to get an appointmentand that was when I had a cancer scare. I have never had NHS dental care. I am no spring chicken but have never found a practice that can take me. Boomers are now spending decades in retirement that we're paying forand most after having stable jobs that didn't require education.

You are in denial about what is going on.

Daftasabroom · 15/03/2023 18:11

Oblomov23 · 15/03/2023 14:00

@Daftasabroom
I never said it was easy. But you have to do some counselling. Read. You have to at least TRY.

How should people pay for counselling?

Maverickess · 15/03/2023 17:52

Oblomov23 · 15/03/2023 14:00

@Daftasabroom
I never said it was easy. But you have to do some counselling. Read. You have to at least TRY.

But how do you know people aren't TRYING? Or what they've TRIED? What they continue to TRY?

Because effort alone does not equal success, you've no idea if that person is trying, and what they're trying, but people see that they're not 'succesful' (by their own personal measure) and decide lack of success=lack of effort.

To some my just above nmw job with 'manager' in the title is a result of my trying, to others because it's an 'unskilled' unvalued occupation and poorly paid it's evidence that I didn't try hard enough.

And I probably read more when clinically depressed than at any other time in my life, and I've had several lots of counselling - it didn't change the factors affecting my life that made me depressed, it didn't change the past, nor the way I viewed it, and it certainly didn't make the people who were used to treating me with contempt change their behaviour either.

I never knew I could cope because from being very small, I'd been told by the people in my life that were my guides, that I couldn't, that I wasn't capable and was useless at just being.

Some people have no concept of this because they've had people who believed in them and that instilled self worth, they never had reason to doubt their own worth - I never had reason to doubt my uselessness, lack of self worth was as natural to me as self worth is to others.
I was taught that if I went after what i wanted and needed, I was being selfish and negatively impacting everyone else, others could do this because they were worth it, I wasn't worth it so it was wrong. That was just normal to me. And whatever went wrong it was because I made it go wrong.

You actually have to realise that what you feel about yourself is wrong before you can change it.

Mamamia7962 · 15/03/2023 17:07

I agree to a certain extent but I know someone whose parents were both alcoholics and lived in a filthy house as a child. As a result of this she rarely drinks and her house is always tidy and clean ( not obsessively).

Daftasabroom · 15/03/2023 17:00

Oblomov23 · 15/03/2023 14:00

@Daftasabroom
I never said it was easy. But you have to do some counselling. Read. You have to at least TRY.

People don't make bad choices because they are not trying or because they are lazy.

Daftasabroom · 15/03/2023 16:56

Oblomov23 · 15/03/2023 14:00

@Daftasabroom
I never said it was easy. But you have to do some counselling. Read. You have to at least TRY.

It's incredibly naive and really, truly, exceptionally insulting to explicitly state that people who only have bad choices available to them just need to "at least try".

U2HasTheEdge · 15/03/2023 14:41

YANBU.

Some people simply have no idea, as we can see from this thread.

I have made choices due to my past that will always impact me today. I have made good choices too, but it took me years to build up any self-belief to be able to make those choices.

I bloody hate the word resilience though. It's always thrown around with no real meaning behind it.

Am I resilient because I get up and get on despite what has happened in my life? Or is it survival?

Sometimes people praise you for being resilient when you're sick of having to be. Or worse, feel you are not resilient because you struggle in life due to what you have experienced. I wish the word would fall out of existence.

Oblomov23 · 15/03/2023 14:00

@Daftasabroom
I never said it was easy. But you have to do some counselling. Read. You have to at least TRY.