Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why the NEU aren’t sitting down and talking about pay?

187 replies

Isntthatapippette · 14/03/2023 18:47

Genuine not goady.

Dear parents and carers,

I’m writing to update you ahead of the strike action planned by the National Education Union on Wednesday and Thursday this week.

This industrial action will mean more disruption to children’s education and to your lives too – whether that’s work, arranging childcare, or changing other plans.

I am extremely disappointed that many young people will once again miss invaluable time learning with their teachers and friends, particularly after their education was significantly disrupted during the pandemic.

It is made worse by the fact that this strike action is completely unnecessary. As I said to the NEU three weeks ago, I want to get around the table and engage in serious talks on teachers’ pay and other issues to resolve disputes.

My only condition was that strike action is paused so those discussions can take place in good faith and without disruption.

This was the same offer, and the same condition, made to unions representing nurses, ambulance workers and physiotherapists. Those unions accepted that offer, paused their strikes and are now negotiating on behalf of their members in private.

The NEU instead seems focused on strikes and all the needless disruption that brings.

This morning I have written to the unions again to invite them to have those talks on Wednesday and Thursday this week – all they need to do is call off strikes which are unnecessary and benefit no one.

The single best thing the NEU could do for both its members and for children and young people would be to sit down and talk about pay.

I will continue doing everything I can to end the disruption your family is facing as quickly as possible, particularly because I know exams for older pupils are coming up fast.

I hope any arrangements you make this week mean that pupils’ education can continue – even if not in the classroom – and that the next time I write it will be with news that this disruption has been brought to an end.

Yours sincerely,

The Rt Hon Gillian Keegan MP
Secretary of State for Education

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Yoyo2021 · 15/03/2023 07:36

Callmenat · 15/03/2023 07:19

Not being goady but I think teachers need to get out their bubble, realise how good they have it and get back to work and stop damaging the kids eduction who have already had a few turbulent years.

I think the same!!!! They have every evening, weekend and school holiday off! Working with 30 odd children is always going to be tough but there are lots of other tough jobs about I’d like to see how they would cope on a minimum wage job in a care home! 😂

i hope they are happy today are kids have had to face enough time off. Shame that for two days some kids are not getting a hot dinner at all!

Fullrecoveryispossible · 15/03/2023 07:35

I do actually understand Gillian’s approach. ACAS has a terrible track record and is very bullish, so I’m not suprised she doesn’t want to go via them. It is strange that the NEU is so hung up on not discussing directly. Gillians quite a character and I highly suspect the NEU has already shot itself in the foot now if it was hoping to get a good deal.

Sirzy · 15/03/2023 07:28

Callmenat · 15/03/2023 07:19

Not being goady but I think teachers need to get out their bubble, realise how good they have it and get back to work and stop damaging the kids eduction who have already had a few turbulent years.

What is damaging children’s education is the constant erosion of it by the government.

the teachers are fighting for better conditions for everyone. Don’t forget that the last “pay rise” wasn’t funded so in order for schools to cover that they had to take away from limited funds available in school already.

teachers fighting for better isn’t the reason education is a mess

Saschka · 15/03/2023 07:24

Callmenat · 15/03/2023 07:19

Not being goady but I think teachers need to get out their bubble, realise how good they have it and get back to work and stop damaging the kids eduction who have already had a few turbulent years.

Nope, you are being goady.

I’m not a teacher, not married to one, don’t work in a school, and I can see they don’t have it great.

Callmenat · 15/03/2023 07:19

Not being goady but I think teachers need to get out their bubble, realise how good they have it and get back to work and stop damaging the kids eduction who have already had a few turbulent years.

Lisbeth50 · 14/03/2023 22:30

I think Gillian Keegan needs to sort this out before it starts affecting this summer’s exams.

Most definitely. Having had one dc do GCSEs during covid, I most definitely do not want another dc adversely affected.

noblegiraffe · 14/03/2023 22:16

I will continue doing everything I can to end the disruption your family is facing as quickly as possible

What have you done, Gillian? 4 days of strikes and missed education and disruption for families. What have you done about it? No offer, no negotiations, just snotty letters about how disappointed you are. You've even managed to piss off Geoff Barton.

Changes17 · 14/03/2023 22:09

I think Gillian Keegan needs to sort this out before it starts affecting this summer’s exams. Education has been underfunded for years and they need to start investing in the future workforce. I speak as a parent - I’m not a teacher.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 14/03/2023 21:58

I will continue doing everything I can to end the disruption your family is facing as quickly as possible, particularly because I know exams for older pupils are coming up fast

She needs to make an offer fast- the NEU have a mandate until July, and further dates haven't been ruled out.

I think it's unlikely they would call strike dates during exams, but just before very possible.

Lisbeth50 · 14/03/2023 21:56

The disappointing thing about Gillian Keegan is that on paper she looks like a really good choice for Ed Sec. Left school at 16, did an apprenticeship, keen on vocational training, seems to understand her brief.

Having just looked her up, she has 10 O'levels, a business degree and an MSc.

Does she not realise that most teachers are parents lot of other parents also work in schools?

noblegiraffe · 14/03/2023 21:49

I think that was very clear from their WhatsApp messages.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 14/03/2023 21:46

noblegiraffe · 14/03/2023 21:40

What actually is their end game here?

I don't think they have one. I don't think they engage in any long-term thinking. If they did, they wouldn't have underfunded education and the NHS for so long, because they'd have realised it would have come to this.

So they lurch from crisis to crisis, prime minister to prime minister till the whole country falls over.

You're right of course- I think that's what scares me the most.

I almost wish there was some nefarious plan to all of this. But the idea that the people who are running the country have no idea what they are doing is pretty terrifying.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 14/03/2023 21:45

I think, as well, it's worth bearing in mind just how many cracks schools are papering over right now.

There's another thread on Mumsnet tonight where people are asking why someone would report a safeguarding concern to a school. But honestly, as a one off, it probably wouldn't reach the threshold for social services involvement.

Schools deal with this sort of thing all the time, and hold things together for students to keep them from needing major social care interventions.

CAMHS waiting lists are insane. And even if you get seen, you can often be discharged very, very quickly. Again, schools are the ones often providing support, linking up with other agencies, keeping quite seriously unwell children safe on a day to day basis.

Waiting lists for SEN diagnosis are also very long, and again, schools step in, offer support, give interventions, advise parents, help young people grow up and manage the transition into adulthood. I know there are some students with SEN who are badly let down by schools, and they system, but in most cases, schools try their very best to support.

As funding gets further and further stretched, so will this support, and more and more young people will end up in some kind of crisis.

noblegiraffe · 14/03/2023 21:40

What actually is their end game here?

I don't think they have one. I don't think they engage in any long-term thinking. If they did, they wouldn't have underfunded education and the NHS for so long, because they'd have realised it would have come to this.

So they lurch from crisis to crisis, prime minister to prime minister till the whole country falls over.

noblegiraffe · 14/03/2023 21:36

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/03/2023 21:33

How does Strike Action stop Gillian Keegan from negotiating with teachers?Confused

The same way that 'pay negotiations' stopped her attending the ASCL conference at the weekend (first ed sec since 2006 to miss it).

i.e. not at all, but she'll say they did.

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/03/2023 21:33

How does Strike Action stop Gillian Keegan from negotiating with teachers?Confused

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 14/03/2023 21:32

noblegiraffe · 14/03/2023 20:37

I think she was saying that there was money that was supposed to be split between nurses and teachers but because nurses called off their strikes and were in talks, teachers would miss out because it would be offered to the nurses.

Load of bollocks. No way is there a pot for 'nurses and teachers' only and it's just trying to set us against each other. Junior doctors didn't call off their strikes either.

If there was a pot of money for teachers, why is the 3% for September totally unfunded?

Do they want to see some of their academy trusts go under?

What actually is their end game here?

(I mean I know what it is- limp to the next election without looking "weak" and who cares about the damage along the way?)

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 14/03/2023 21:29

Parents ought to be desperate for these strikes to work.

A huge number of teachers are leaving the profession or looking to leave. Recruitment onto training courses this year was dire, and it looks just as bad, if not worse for September.

You can say what you like about our working conditions, our pay, but if they were as good as people think, people would be queuing up to be teachers, and they aren't.

Instead, there are many schools that are massively understaffed and papering over the cracks with unqualified teachers, with supply, with Art teachers teaching maths, classes of 34 and so on. And I'm sure someone will pop up with examples of why this is absolutely fine, but for me, secondary state education in England, right now- it's not what I'd want for my own children. I don't want it for the children I teach, either.

At the moment, all the pay rises are unfunded as well- which means they come at the expense of resources for schools, or worse, at the expense of redundancies. A lot of schools are in massive deficits- and the costs of this will start to hit parents more and more.

Keegan can grandstand all she wants. All it will really mean is that more teachers give up, and leave the profession. I'm striking because I want to make things better in education- it's not to make a specific political point, or to pick a fight with the Tories.

But I look at kids I teach in Y7, and wonder what their education will look like by the time they hit Y11 or Y12. I worry they might not be able to access science A-levels, or if they do, it'll be in a class of 20+. I worry they won't have the practical skills needed, because they're in a class of over 32, so it's not safe to do much practical work. I wonder if they'll be taught by subject specialists all the way through, if they'll ever get to be taught by a physics specialist.

Last year, I had students in my tutor group, who would go all day solely being taught by supply and cover, and they accepted that as normal by the end of the year.

Livpool · 14/03/2023 21:26

Tomorrow is the third (and Thursday the 4th) strike day that has affected my son's school. I fully support the strikes

noblegiraffe · 14/03/2023 21:24

LivingDeadGirlUK · 14/03/2023 20:16

I listened to Gillian being interviewed about this on Newscast and I've never heard a more disingenuous load of mud slinging in my life. She certainly isn't in the role to improve education for the majority.

The disappointing thing about Gillian Keegan is that on paper she looks like a really good choice for Ed Sec. Left school at 16, did an apprenticeship, keen on vocational training, seems to understand her brief.

But just trots out the same old tired Tory bollocks.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 14/03/2023 21:19

The NEU have always been ready to sit down and talk- indeed they have been trying.

The NEU would have been happy to talk any time last summer when these strikes were first being talked about seriously/planned- and there is no way the DfE wasn't aware of that.

All autumn, when we were balloting, the NEU would have engaged with talks.

Serious offers of talks only came after the NEU won their strike ballot- but even then, there was no serious offer made around pay. And during all of this, the recommendation for September is a 3%, unfunded, pay rise.

The major unions have all been trying to talk, but until recently, Gillian Keegan wasn't taking it seriously- that's the words of ASCL and NAHT, not the NEU.

The major teachers unions asked her to negotiate via ACAS (very common in industrial disputes) and she refused.

She refused to meet unless strikes were called off, but NEU membership said they weren't happy to call off strikes unless a pay offer was on the table (as in Wales).

The NEU are desperate to sit down and have a serious conversation, but Keegan won't engage, and instead is trying to play divide and rule (not sure how she thinks it will actually work).

TheMoth · 14/03/2023 21:09

After 20 years, you kind of get used to being hated by everyone- kids, parents, ofsted, sometimes your own slt, the government....

But sometimes, you look up from your endless marking or pointless tick box initiative and just ask yourself: why? Out of all the professions in the country, why the constant hate?

I don't go to work to make anyone's life worse. I want them to do well. Even the kids who give me endless shit; I want them to succeed. Because there's still a teeny tiny part of me that imagines that a world, with an educated, thoughtful populace, would be a good place to live. But I don't think tory governments want that.

Piggywaspushed · 14/03/2023 20:40

Dear Gillian

Many teachers are also parents.

Kind regards

The Professionals

noblegiraffe · 14/03/2023 20:37

Saschka · 14/03/2023 20:32

So she’s saying fuck all was going to teachers anyway then?

I think she was saying that there was money that was supposed to be split between nurses and teachers but because nurses called off their strikes and were in talks, teachers would miss out because it would be offered to the nurses.

Load of bollocks. No way is there a pot for 'nurses and teachers' only and it's just trying to set us against each other. Junior doctors didn't call off their strikes either.

Leggingslife · 14/03/2023 20:35

Not just about pay. Your children deserve more than severely underfunded schools, poorly resourced lessons and not enough teachers to actually go round.