Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe the pension changes reported are good but not enough; Hunt should scrap the taper too?

62 replies

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 18:40

Senior doctors and other professionals are quitting en masse because (amongst other things) they hit the lifetime allowance, together with the inflexibility of the NHS pension scheme.

If Jeremy Hunt raises the lifetime allowance to £1.8m it would be a big step. On the surface, an annual allowance increase to £60K would also be very useful for retention.

However, what is often missed when talking about pensions is the the taper. It means those high earners in their 50s who neglected their pension earlier can't really top it up much; in reality the £60K annual allowance is whittled down to as little as £4K per year.

Yes, people rightfully won't feel sorry for those on £312K a year who can only contribute £4K into their pension instead of £60K - but neither should be surprised when such people have enough in the bank/investments to just retire early. This type of high earner in their 50s would contribute over 10 times more in tax than the median earner for each year they kept working, whilst probably using very few public services in return.

In general, there are very few years in life when professionals can earn these large sums, and they tend to be concentrated in the 50s. These are exactly the years when it makes sense (from our society's viewpoint) to keep them working on.

Keeping a senior consultant who does 2 days a week private work active for 5 more years would massively benefit the exchequer, the NHS and the country. Punishing the 'rich' consultant (or investment banker/lawyer, for that matter) will just make them retire a few years early and pay much less tax.

The tapering of the annual allowance was a huge mistake. Let's hope Jeremy Hunt has the guts to stand up and abolish this. On the surface it would be a giveaway to the rich. In reality, based purely on the extra tax take, it would be of most benefit to those who rely heavily on public services.

If Jeremy Hunt is really going to scrap the 'senior doctor tax', he should do it properly.

I am not a doctor.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 19:11

@yoyo1234 Yes the NHS pension scheme seems particularly stupidly inflexible.

I think they have very slightly improved it recently so the scheme can pay the extra tax rather than having to come out of income directly, but it's still terrible that senior doctors effectively get punished for working on.

OP posts:
yoyo1234 · 14/03/2023 19:07

From earlier thread the annual allowance is very important for senior NHS doctors. The NHS pension is all or nothing and if it is defined by acturies as having increased in value above the annual allowance the doctor has to then pay back all of the "tax relief" on the additional value it has increased by. This is the growth that it will be calculated to have grown by when it is drawn (potentially in decades time). So they will be hit by 5 figure (or sometimes more) tax bills with potentially no huge corresponding increase in salary.

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 19:05

@tenbob Exactly. I think senior doctors (and other well-paid professionals in their 50s) retire early for lots of reasons - burnout, they 'hit their numbers', want to spend more time with grandchildren, want to travel while they are still in full health, etc. They often have the financial means to do these things.

What doesn't make sense to me is the government effectively punishing them for working on, making the choice to retire easy, and losing massive amounts of tax in the process.

OP posts:
tenbob · 14/03/2023 18:58

Quveas · 14/03/2023 18:45

I'm sure that the vast majority of people with state pensions only will give a damn.

But maybe they should, and then we wouldn’t have higher earners using buy to let to top up their pensions, or senior doctors quitting the NHS

The idea that no one should care about anyone doing better than they are is pathetic and blinkered

The economy is an ecosystem and those at the bottom of it should be as interested in how to improve it as those at the top

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 18:57

@maeveiscurious I think Labour would slap IHT on DC pensions (at the full 40% tax) almost immediately. At which point they would cause many more senior staff to retire.

It is probably quite politically easy because DB pensions wouldn't be in scope beyond spousal transfers, so public service high earners would not pay. However, from the point of view of keeping private sector high earners working longer it would be an absolute disaster.

OP posts:
maeveiscurious · 14/03/2023 18:55

Quveas · 14/03/2023 18:45

I'm sure that the vast majority of people with state pensions only will give a damn.

Biscuit
maeveiscurious · 14/03/2023 18:54

I think the best option is to limit tax fee cash to £1m and therefore 25% tax free.

Then unlimited pension and life time allowance.

Everything over £1.5m is taxed at 20% for Inheritance tax

Simple tax efficient and will keep senior staff in work.

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 18:52

@DuvetDownn Yes, but even if the lifetime allowance is increased massively (as suggested by the media), those earning over £240K won't be able to make use of it because of the taper.

For reference, not only am I not a doctor, I don't earn over £240K either.

However, I can see how incentives work, and the societal need to help high earners to keep working.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 18:50

Also @Quveas do you think it's better to give a ~£25K tax deferral per year to someone earning £312K per year which means they will contribute around £125K in income tax per year, or to effectively push them into retirement at which point they will pay close to 0 in tax?

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 18:47

@Quveas How would you incentivise senior doctors to stay on then? Or do you think NHS waiting times for complex treatments which need senior doctors will magically get better?

OP posts:
Quveas · 14/03/2023 18:45

I'm sure that the vast majority of people with state pensions only will give a damn.

DuvetDownn · 14/03/2023 18:43

The lifetime allowance was one of the biggest reasons for my banker DH to retire at 55.

Swipe left for the next trending thread