Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe the pension changes reported are good but not enough; Hunt should scrap the taper too?

62 replies

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 18:40

Senior doctors and other professionals are quitting en masse because (amongst other things) they hit the lifetime allowance, together with the inflexibility of the NHS pension scheme.

If Jeremy Hunt raises the lifetime allowance to £1.8m it would be a big step. On the surface, an annual allowance increase to £60K would also be very useful for retention.

However, what is often missed when talking about pensions is the the taper. It means those high earners in their 50s who neglected their pension earlier can't really top it up much; in reality the £60K annual allowance is whittled down to as little as £4K per year.

Yes, people rightfully won't feel sorry for those on £312K a year who can only contribute £4K into their pension instead of £60K - but neither should be surprised when such people have enough in the bank/investments to just retire early. This type of high earner in their 50s would contribute over 10 times more in tax than the median earner for each year they kept working, whilst probably using very few public services in return.

In general, there are very few years in life when professionals can earn these large sums, and they tend to be concentrated in the 50s. These are exactly the years when it makes sense (from our society's viewpoint) to keep them working on.

Keeping a senior consultant who does 2 days a week private work active for 5 more years would massively benefit the exchequer, the NHS and the country. Punishing the 'rich' consultant (or investment banker/lawyer, for that matter) will just make them retire a few years early and pay much less tax.

The tapering of the annual allowance was a huge mistake. Let's hope Jeremy Hunt has the guts to stand up and abolish this. On the surface it would be a giveaway to the rich. In reality, based purely on the extra tax take, it would be of most benefit to those who rely heavily on public services.

If Jeremy Hunt is really going to scrap the 'senior doctor tax', he should do it properly.

I am not a doctor.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:57

@Tryingtokeepgoing However, in the NHS doctor case, they are forced to contribute the full whack to their pension (or opt out altogether) - and then either pay tax out of their take-home pay, or get penalised at extortionate interest rate if the scheme pays. I am not surprised that many just stop working.

It's true those are failings with the scheme rather than pensions generally. With DC pensions and a sympathetic employer who is prepared to e.g. pay more in salary and less into pensions you can plan a lot more effectively.

However I do think that high taper rates are a big disincentive for very high earners. They may easily decide to work less, or just retire. In both cases, the country would get a lot less tax overall compared to the £27K saving you mention. This is particularly a problem because many people on such salaries are in their 50s.

OP posts:
debbidoodah · 14/03/2023 20:56

I voted Yabu because its budget day tomorrow not today. You haven't seen the detail yet op, so who knows what's in it.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 14/03/2023 20:52

I’m affected by the taper, and I’m relaxed about it. Let’s be honest, I can save enough from post tax income to give a comfortable lifestyle. Looking at it another way, if the annual allowance is raised to £60k and they eliminate the taper I’ll get £27k of tax relief. On an average salary of £30k then that’s almost 10 average tax payers working just to fund my tax relief. That can’t be right, and I can’t believe that doctors think it’s right either?

ChristinaXYZ · 14/03/2023 20:39

Agree with you OP. No point disincentivising work and to those mentioning those on low wages /state pension - people with the lowest incomes are completely dependent on the NHS for their health care into old age and will benefit more than those higher paid (who could go private) from an effective, well staffed NHS.

It is like a reflex with some people - even if they know the country is better off with a political decision that is bit too capitalist for them, they have to flash their socialist credentials. Even if the worst off in society would be better for, in this case, having more doctors, it matters more to be seen to be left-wing than making a decision that helps everyone.

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:37

In any case, if they earn £100K after retirement (which I think is more than many actually would) then I suspect tax will be no more than £30K, as some of that income won't be subject to income tax, or be subject to savings/dividend/capital gains allowances.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:31

@MereDintofPandiculation Yes I was wrong about this, sorry. However it seems what you get paid is far far worse when you take it at 55 compared to e.g. 65 in the NHS scheme.

OP posts:
MereDintofPandiculation · 14/03/2023 20:30

They wouldn't be able to draw on their pension until late 60s. Pensions other than State Pension can usually be drawn on from about 10 years before the state retirement age.

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:28

Actually I'm wrong, it seems the NHS scheme allows drawdown from 55 but at a poor rate.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:26

@MereDintofPandiculation They wouldn't be able to draw on their pension until late 60s.

Between early retirement and pension age, their income would be mainly from investments, for which the taxes applicable would be CGT/dividend tax and income tax on property/bank interest. They may also draw down on savings in which case no income tax would be payable.

You may be right that they have investments earning large passive income but I doubt the tax generated would be comparable.

OP posts:
FixTheBone · 14/03/2023 20:26

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:14

@FixTheBone Yes, I think as a general principle the government should do always try to make it worthwhile for people to earn every extra pound you can (as long as it's earned ethically of course) - that's an extra pound they can charge income tax on.

Loss of child benefit for mid/high earners, loss of childcare provision/loss of personal allowance for high earners, and annual allowance tapering for very high earners all work aganist this principle.

For the lower paid, tapering of Universal Credit has a similar disincentive, which is why it's good the government have improved the taper rate.

I wouldn't even mind paying the exact same tax overall, but there's points where you earn an extra hew hundred quid and end up taking home less.

Prime example was my wife (salaried GP) who got a backdated 1. 5% pay rise which took her into a higher tax bracket, and increased her pension contributions by 1.8%, reduced her take home by £60/month.

I think tax overall needs to be simplified and linear to prevent this.

MereDintofPandiculation · 14/03/2023 20:22

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 18:50

Also @Quveas do you think it's better to give a ~£25K tax deferral per year to someone earning £312K per year which means they will contribute around £125K in income tax per year, or to effectively push them into retirement at which point they will pay close to 0 in tax?

Someone earning £312k pa is unlikely to retire on less than £50, more likely £150k, so they’re not going to be paying almost zero tax

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:22

@FixTheBone On pay: it is perhaps surprising that the Tories are ignoring market forces. 50% pay increases are never going to happen, and they shouldn't, but there should be more acknowledgement that mid or senior doctors can earn much more abroad.

I think doctors should be able to get stinking rich working for the NHS, as long as they serve it faithfully for many years. If they could get an excellent salary in the NHS then there would be less private work and less agency wastage etc. Same with dentists.

For such large pay increases, there would have to be improvement in processes/outcomes at the same time though - it would need to move closer to e.g. the pre-Blair GP contract with compulsory weekend/evening rotas for community GP practices though.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:14

@FixTheBone Yes, I think as a general principle the government should do always try to make it worthwhile for people to earn every extra pound you can (as long as it's earned ethically of course) - that's an extra pound they can charge income tax on.

Loss of child benefit for mid/high earners, loss of childcare provision/loss of personal allowance for high earners, and annual allowance tapering for very high earners all work aganist this principle.

For the lower paid, tapering of Universal Credit has a similar disincentive, which is why it's good the government have improved the taper rate.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:10

@YankeeDad /@yoyo1234 That is awful. The mess that is the NHS pension scheme has a lot to answer for.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 20:10

@TreadLight The NHS desperately needs to retain staff, especially senior staff. Taxpayers will pay their salaries (and eventually, pensions) but hopefully all the extra healthy people who can go back to work more after senior doctors treat them can more than justify this, purely financially! The moral obligation that people should get NHS treatment quickly by senior specialists where appropriate is even more important.

OP posts:
FixTheBone · 14/03/2023 19:49

I'm a relatively junior consultant, 3 years, age 42...

The three things that hurt me the most and have disincentavised extra work have been the cliff-edge tax thresholds...

Loss of child benefit at 60k despite being the sole earner at that point...

Loss of free child care at £100k desperately trying to stay under that at the minute....

The threat of an annual allowance bill though, is my biggest worry, far more so than LTA. Knowing I could get spanked with a £30k bill to pay immediately, any time, for a benefit I may or may not receive in the future.....

The LTA I'm not so fussed about with the proposed increase tomorrow, provided it also keeps pace with inflation, same with wages... I known consultants will be asking for pay restoration like the juniors, except their demand is likely to be 50%... Again, I'd take 10-15% if it had a link to inflation.

TreadLight · 14/03/2023 19:48

But if we give high earners these tax breaks, who is going to pay the doctor's high salaries?

yoyo1234 · 14/03/2023 19:45

Scheme pays is akin to an inflation inked equity release scheme on the pension pot (cumulative interest is generated) .

YankeeDad · 14/03/2023 19:41

@LargeDeviation I do not have direct experience or exposure, but documents from the NHS that I have found online do indicate that the amount of tax charge paid by the scheme is treated as a notional negative-balance Defined Contribution account on which interest is charged at CPI +2.4% until retirement

So for a year with 10% CPI that would be a +12.4% increase in that balance, which is effectively something akin to a debt secured against their own pension, which would then get "repaid" through getting a lower annual pension, using a multiplier that might also be very unfavourable to the pensioner. I have not worked out how to identify the specific multiplier, but I have no reason to believe it would be favourable to the pensioner, and in fact it might be quite the opposite if it is anything like the multiplier used to convert a portion of the pension to become a tax-free lump sum.

kegofcoffee · 14/03/2023 19:37

I think the annual taper is an insane concept. It would be fairer on everyone and simpler if we just limited tax relief to 20%.

But I understand the lifetime allowance, once hit you can just opt out of your pension.

Plus £1mil annuity at retirement is £50k a year, plus state pension you're looking at almost £60k a year.

WeAreBorg · 14/03/2023 19:28

Agree with you OP. I don’t begrudge bankers or lawyers or anyone else their salary one bit. People making the efforts to plan for their retirement are sensible. Bankers pay a lot of tax, it would be better to scrap the taper so they can continue to contribute.
The fact that I’m trying to channel my DS in law or finance is neither here nor there 😂

LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 19:27

@YankeeDad Is that right - doctors are charged interest for paying via the scheme??? That is really bonkers.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 14/03/2023 19:25

@Amboseli Who knows, I'm certainly not a financial advisor...

I think DC pensions might still be useful even if subject to IHT (because at least the investments within them would be free of dividend tax and capital gains tax, and surely even Labour wouldn't change that) - so they would effectively become something like a 'semi-ISA' which is free of some investment taxes but not income tax.

I guess Labour might want people with DC pensions to spend them to get the income tax rather than passing pension pots on to their children, but one of the biggest psychological reasons people save up in the first place is to be able to pass something on.

I would think that putting IHT on pensions will mean fewer pension contributions even if IHT would be payable outside the pension in any case, which I regard as a quite negative outcome even before the extra early retirement it would cause.

OP posts:
YankeeDad · 14/03/2023 19:15

@LargeDeviation you have it right ... and if the senior doctor pays the extra tax out of the scheme, they have to do it by "borrowing" against their pension pot at potentially punitive terms. It would be much better either to increase the annual allowance at all income levels, or to introduce some flexibility into the contributions so that people hitting the "ceiling" can contribute less, or a bit of both.

Amboseli · 14/03/2023 19:14

@LargeDeviation I'm thinking labour will tax pensions too. Have no idea whether we should keep paying into pensions or not. If not where to put the money? ISA also subject to 40% IHT but without the tax relief that pensions benefit from. What a mess.

Swipe left for the next trending thread