Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aaargh! WIBU to say if I’m such a strong candidate, why didn’t you give me the bloody job!

87 replies

Swosh · 14/03/2023 18:10

So 4 interviews over the last 2 weeks. All really great roles at a higher salary and better conditions. 3 through employment agencies who had already remotely interviewed me and said I would be great for their roles.

Feedback from actual job interviews were that I came cross really well, my answers were great and I was a ‘very strong candidate’ but I was ‘pipped at the post’ for all of them! Obviously a lie to make me feel better at wasting my time.

What on earth am I doing wrong?

Two interviews involved walking up flights of stairs to get to the interview room (why couldn’t the damn room be on the ground floor?!) and as I’ve put a bit of weight on over the last year as working from home, I admit that I was a bit breathless almost keeled over at the start of the interview.

Could it be because I’m fat? Most of the roles were WFH though and I look fine head and shoulders wise.

I dress smart, well groomed, well spoken (don’t smell of BO).

At the interview I had this morning they said they had more interviews lined up for the rest of today and all day tomorrow so would come to me on Thursday but they called me at lunchtime to say that I was great but pipped at the post again and they had struggled to choose between me and another candidate, which I thought was odd. What about the other interviews they had apparently had lined up for today and tomorrow?

WIBU to ask my thread title when I inevitably get knocked back from the two interviews I’ve got lined up next week?

I resigned from my last job due to toxic environment and crap pay last month (bit heat of the moment) so desperately need to get another one!

OP posts:
Cloverforever · 14/03/2023 18:34

Do you have visible tatoos, lots of piercings, smell of smoke?

maddy68 · 14/03/2023 18:31

I Interview regularly. Sometimes people have all the skills and requirements for the job. But so does someone else and frankly I either like them better or I feel they will be a better fit for the team

Always ask for feedback but often they are kind with comments. It's tough to say you had bad breath or you looked crumpled or something personal I'm not saying that's the case at atl But sometimes you just get a better "feeling" about a candidate

Turnipworkharder · 14/03/2023 18:30

They probably had the role already filled internally.

JackiePlace · 14/03/2023 18:30

I have often thought this. They would never tell you the real reason, though.
I think if there are two cadidates of equal merit, the more attractive one will get the job.

Swosh · 14/03/2023 18:28

Thanks. I have had feedback as in my OP.

The one today said they’d gone for someone already working in the area so assuming internal candidate which is annoying.

Others said ‘just pipped at the post’.

OP posts:
Elphame · 14/03/2023 18:28

I know I've interviewed 2 or 3 candidates and quite frankly any of them could have done the job. I might just as well have pulled a name out of a hat.

SgtCawood · 14/03/2023 18:24

Thing is, presumably there’s only one job at the end of it. I’ve just been recruiting and have had to turn down strong candidates “pipped at the post”. My feedback has always included why we went for someone else (more experience of x situation, slightly stronger evidence of y) but they’ve all been people who would have been perfectly suitable for the job. But I haven’t got an unlimited number of posts.

If you like the company, it’s worth asking what else they might be recruiting for at the moment…

MrsDoylesDoily · 14/03/2023 18:23

Why are you not asking for feedback?

shropshire11 · 14/03/2023 18:20

I’m sorry to read this OP.

The modern climate of offence-taking and litigiousness has put employers in a tough situation. If you “give it straight” to a candidate about being under- or over-qualified, or giving off a certain vibe, you feel vulnerable. As a result, many will fudge the answer.

I would consider pushing them - nicely - for more detailed feedback. But you may have to accept that useful constructive feedback is a thing of the past.

MissLucyLiu · 14/03/2023 18:19

I think you are overthinking. It’s your own insecurity and projecting. Not every failure is due to appearance and weight. If it’s WHF job mostly then why would they even care about that? It’s a generic statement people say and that is not to say you are not good they just found someone better. For people who are genuinely quite good you want to keep them sweet you never know another role open up and and they can call you back again.

TheChosenTwo · 14/03/2023 18:17

Have you asked for feedback? I know people who have been rejected at interview stage and one reason was that someone else was better qualified (but they were both interviewed in case one really failed it I guess) and the other was told she didn’t appear confident with the company visions.
Sorry you’ve had such crappy luck but do ask for feedback, and good luck - you’ll get something.

Cheeseandhoney · 14/03/2023 18:16

What sort of job is it you’re going for that your weight is a signficant factor? Is it a gym or modelling or something physical?

how overweight are you, very morbidly obese can have an impact in all jobs though, it shouldn’t but it can,

Swipe left for the next trending thread