Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aaargh! WIBU to say if I’m such a strong candidate, why didn’t you give me the bloody job!

87 replies

Swosh · 14/03/2023 18:10

So 4 interviews over the last 2 weeks. All really great roles at a higher salary and better conditions. 3 through employment agencies who had already remotely interviewed me and said I would be great for their roles.

Feedback from actual job interviews were that I came cross really well, my answers were great and I was a ‘very strong candidate’ but I was ‘pipped at the post’ for all of them! Obviously a lie to make me feel better at wasting my time.

What on earth am I doing wrong?

Two interviews involved walking up flights of stairs to get to the interview room (why couldn’t the damn room be on the ground floor?!) and as I’ve put a bit of weight on over the last year as working from home, I admit that I was a bit breathless almost keeled over at the start of the interview.

Could it be because I’m fat? Most of the roles were WFH though and I look fine head and shoulders wise.

I dress smart, well groomed, well spoken (don’t smell of BO).

At the interview I had this morning they said they had more interviews lined up for the rest of today and all day tomorrow so would come to me on Thursday but they called me at lunchtime to say that I was great but pipped at the post again and they had struggled to choose between me and another candidate, which I thought was odd. What about the other interviews they had apparently had lined up for today and tomorrow?

WIBU to ask my thread title when I inevitably get knocked back from the two interviews I’ve got lined up next week?

I resigned from my last job due to toxic environment and crap pay last month (bit heat of the moment) so desperately need to get another one!

OP posts:
GoodChat · 14/03/2023 19:25

What are you saying when they ask why you left your last job?

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:24

Taking a candidate up stairs and having them very breathless and clearly suffering would certainly be at the back of my mind, as I’d be worried about high level of sick leave

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 19:23

mellicauli · 14/03/2023 19:12

You said you knew if someone was a definite no in 10 seconds and then brought the interview to a close as soon as possible. Just judging you on what you said.

These people have spent hours on your recruitment process. They've given up holiday to come see you. It costs them money to come on the train. Maybe they are nervous but rather than think "clicking fingers, a little odd, oh well let's see if we can find some positives" you've jumped to "no".

Get over yourself! I bet you live in a perfect Cliche world.

MrsBunnyEars · 14/03/2023 19:20

It’s so tough. Usually be a final round interview for my team you will have been screened by a recruiter, I’ve seen your CV, you’ve had a first round interview and done a practical test (it’s a senior and we’ll paid team, so people are fine with these steps).

If you’ve got through that, you almost certainly are very good and could do the job. But if I only have one role, you still won’t get it if I like the other person more.

I honestly don’t know whether that’s more useful feedback than the bland ‘pipped at the post’ stuff.

mellicauli · 14/03/2023 19:12

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 18:53

Also, I said end it as soon as politely possible. That is at least 15 minutes so I do give them more than five minutes!

You said you knew if someone was a definite no in 10 seconds and then brought the interview to a close as soon as possible. Just judging you on what you said.

These people have spent hours on your recruitment process. They've given up holiday to come see you. It costs them money to come on the train. Maybe they are nervous but rather than think "clicking fingers, a little odd, oh well let's see if we can find some positives" you've jumped to "no".

Swosh · 14/03/2023 19:07

I always try to bring a bit of humour into interviews though. Not laugh a minute but try to make them laugh a few times. Don’t talk about personal stuff, very polite and certainly not shy or brash. Thank them for their time etc.

I’ve been told I’m a bit intimidating because I come across as a bit posh and like I’m overqualified by colleagues in my last role, had comments before of ‘how come you’re doing this job’.

Used to be in high level admin roles (Chief Execs PA) but took long career breaks after having my DC so conversely told not enough recent experience to get back into those kind of roles so going for mid/senior level admin roles now.

OP posts:
Twattergy · 14/03/2023 19:07

When I interview I'd only give feedback saying 'you were a strong candidate' to a genuine strong candidate. Others I'd just give honest feedback about where they didn't have the experience/skills of our preferred candidate. So I think you are getting positive feedback. Have you ever had interview training? The most common mistake I see candidates make is over-talking and not answering the question. Overly nervous or overly confident/brash doesn't play well either.

RoseBucket · 14/03/2023 19:05

Burgoo · 14/03/2023 18:53

Also when asked "what quality would you bring to the role?" and they say some version of "team player", "commitment", "good work ethic" and "conscientious". ERGH! SO generic! I want some actual meaty answers! One person once said "banoffee pie, positivity and nuance whilst also being straight talking and direct" - instant offer! What won me over was the brownies. It showed she didn't take herself too seriously, had a sense of humour, knows that there is more to life (and a personality) than generic platitudes. One of the best hires in a long time

I was offered a job as on Friday during the interview when asked about working in a team, I said I make a cracking brew, like a laugh and taught myself to be less sarcastic.

It was actually for a serious role with a lot of responsibilities and it wasn’t the answer they were looking for 😆 but the panel laughed and said I’d fit right in.

MajorCarolDanvers · 14/03/2023 19:04

I detest giving feedback and would probably say similar.

Very likely you are not doing anything wrong. Just that the winning candidate was the better fit.

EyesOnThePies · 14/03/2023 19:03

I have conducted interviews for loads of roles.

Sometimes it really is a decision between 2 or more equally good candidates.
And you really can’t give them meaningful feedback on what they could have been stronger on.
Sometimes you do have a good internal candidate and you need to interview a wider field alongside them. Sometimes they get the job, sometimes they don’t.
Sometimes it does come down to ‘who do we want in the office if there is a serious crisis? Who will deal best with the office maverick when they fail to submit their invoices in time? Who will cope with that client who…’, all a bit random and subjective because they are neck and neck.

Sometimes I have been on panels where a member or two would veer towards some discriminatory factor, like weight, in a tricky decision, but have been set straight by other panel members. In my sector, anyway.

KBO OP! The right job is out there for you somewhere.

Quveas · 14/03/2023 19:02

Twinedpeaks · 14/03/2023 18:57

@JackiePlace wouldn't it be worse if they just have internal candidates the job with no competition?!

I'm not a fan of it, but almost all my employers roles are now advertised internally only. It's assumed that you can't do that. You can and its easy.

tourdefrance · 14/03/2023 19:01

Unfortunately it is much harder to get a job when you are already unemployed so that may be a factor.

Quveas · 14/03/2023 19:00

If you want an honest opinion, (a) you quit your job without one to go to, which is a red flag, (b) you assume that not getting the job is an excuse as opposed to the truth - you just weren't the best candidate, and (c) if you are desperate to get a job that comes across in interviews and is often off-putting.

Twinedpeaks · 14/03/2023 18:57

@JackiePlace wouldn't it be worse if they just have internal candidates the job with no competition?!

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 14/03/2023 18:56

I've found that the specific sort of phrasing you mention usually means that they have appointed an internal candidate. In my experience, the person was earmarked for the position long before they advertised it for legal reasons. It's shit but sadly, it seems to be the way of the world now.

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 18:53

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 18:51

OMG you’ve made that judgement without knowing the first thing about me or the jobs I’m recruiting for.

One guy clicked his fingers at me before shaking my hand - there’s one example.

Before YOU judge, engage your brain FFS!

Also, I said end it as soon as politely possible. That is at least 15 minutes so I do give them more than five minutes!

Burgoo · 14/03/2023 18:53

Also when asked "what quality would you bring to the role?" and they say some version of "team player", "commitment", "good work ethic" and "conscientious". ERGH! SO generic! I want some actual meaty answers! One person once said "banoffee pie, positivity and nuance whilst also being straight talking and direct" - instant offer! What won me over was the brownies. It showed she didn't take herself too seriously, had a sense of humour, knows that there is more to life (and a personality) than generic platitudes. One of the best hires in a long time

Mummadeze · 14/03/2023 18:52

I would take it as a positive that you nearly got both roles and feel good about it. It is only a matter of time before someone sees you as exactly the right fit. Don’t let a few knock backs affect your confidence.

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 18:51

mellicauli · 14/03/2023 18:48

@LondonTripPlanning You sound very closed minded. What would it cost you to give them the benefit of the doubt for 5 minutes?

OMG you’ve made that judgement without knowing the first thing about me or the jobs I’m recruiting for.

One guy clicked his fingers at me before shaking my hand - there’s one example.

Before YOU judge, engage your brain FFS!

Newname10 · 14/03/2023 18:51

Hi OP, sorry you missed out on the roles! I’m a recruiter and I very much doubt it had anything to do with your weight! I’ve never heard of that happening in my entire career. Sometimes it is the case that credible candidates can narrowly miss out on the role, it isn’t always a lie! Don’t let this discourage you

Burgoo · 14/03/2023 18:49

Firstly yes this is incredibly frustrating. Most people say "you were a strong candidate" if they haven't the balls to just be honest. It is a nice way of letting you down gently as most people just go "oh, okay. Not too bad then" and leave it at that.

I interview a fair amount and there is absolutely no reason why you can't ask for feedback. I wouldn't be as forceful in the demand to know why, because as a hirer I would find that very off-putting and it would certainly taint my view if you applied again. Just asking for constructive feedback is a good position; frame it that you respect their expertise and want to do better next time.

As for reasons, I think it is lazy to assume it is a weight issue. It essentially shifts the problem onto the interviewer and stops you being able to take ownership of things to improve.

If I give the "strong candidate" answer I will usually quantify it. Usually (and this happens ALOT) there are 2,3,4 or more candidates that are equally experienced and qualified to do the job. What does it come down to? Attitude, confidence and personality. The fact is, I can teach you to do any job in our organisation but if you don't "fit" the team from a personality perspective you won't get it. I shape my team depending on what I think will fit. Too loud and boisterous? No chance. I don't need a boat rocker. Shy and aloof? I don't need to work hard to get you integrated into the team. 99% of the time humour is the clincher. All things being equal, I want someone who has a wonderful work ethic, interest, experience, qualifications AND a sense of humour. Humour for me is the glue that holds the team together. If people are hyper-professional and snooty they won't fit the team. The job is hard enough without having to always watch what is being said.

Other issues that are less quantifiable are things like nervousness. Fine in some jobs but in my area of work you must cope under a huge amount of pressure and not "look" pressured. I need to see that despite your nerves you can hold it together but that is because in my area we deal with people's lives. It isn't a retail or administrative job.

Things that will inevitably get a no from me...

  1. Too opinionated/brash/over-confident - striking the balance is hard. I want free-thinkers AND at the same time I need people who will play ball and accept when they need to just get on with the job.
  2. I always throw in some curve-ball questions - asking what the person has failed at in life and what they learnt is one I use. Also telling me of a time when they did something really awful and what they learnt. If they say something like "I was too perfectionistic" they won't get it. Don't BS me with a positive masquerading as a negative!
  3. Waffle - get to the point. I don't want a text-book recital. You better know the subject matter and be able to explain it in a way that doesn't look contrived. Also I want to know the key points in a clear, succinct fashion. I am not interested in 20 years ago, get to the point now!
  4. Stupid answers - I've heard everything in my time. Anti-LGBT or BME language, impulsive responses that aren't thoughtful etc. The worst is when they say "I want to progress my career and this is a good step toward X", because it is saying "I will take your training then go elsewhere"... not a good look at all. Whilst I don't like the answer, I much prefer someone be honest and say "the money, I want to have a good income". That is MUCH better than some waffle about how much you care about the work.
  5. Bringing personal into the interview - Okay so I don't mind SOME experience of your life but don't start an answer with "speaking as a X" (add black man, woman, lesbian, disabled person etc). I want to know your thoughts because you are UNIQUE and because you have good, nuanced examples. I don't do the divisive, categorised nonsense. It screams "attitude problem", even if it doesn't mean the person has one.

Sorry for the mega-answer. Just some thoughts.

mellicauli · 14/03/2023 18:48

@LondonTripPlanning You sound very closed minded. What would it cost you to give them the benefit of the doubt for 5 minutes?

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 18:43

I have interviewed for many roles over the years. I can honestly say you know within the first 10 seconds if someone is a definite no and try to remain professional but end the interview as quickly as politely possible. How long did your interviews last?

Also, the real reason for turning someone down is rarely given out of politeness or legalities, especially in small companies.

YeahNahWhal · 14/03/2023 18:42

Looking like a good team player is something I can't quantify but is often the deciding factor when the candidates are close. My team is diverse, but we all have a sense of humour and a strong drive for solutions/outcomes and I'm looking for people who will complement that.

JackiePlace · 14/03/2023 18:37

Turnipworkharder · 14/03/2023 18:30

They probably had the role already filled internally.

So annoying when they advertise the post to external candidaes when they already know who they want.

Swipe left for the next trending thread