Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aaargh! WIBU to say if I’m such a strong candidate, why didn’t you give me the bloody job!

87 replies

Swosh · 14/03/2023 18:10

So 4 interviews over the last 2 weeks. All really great roles at a higher salary and better conditions. 3 through employment agencies who had already remotely interviewed me and said I would be great for their roles.

Feedback from actual job interviews were that I came cross really well, my answers were great and I was a ‘very strong candidate’ but I was ‘pipped at the post’ for all of them! Obviously a lie to make me feel better at wasting my time.

What on earth am I doing wrong?

Two interviews involved walking up flights of stairs to get to the interview room (why couldn’t the damn room be on the ground floor?!) and as I’ve put a bit of weight on over the last year as working from home, I admit that I was a bit breathless almost keeled over at the start of the interview.

Could it be because I’m fat? Most of the roles were WFH though and I look fine head and shoulders wise.

I dress smart, well groomed, well spoken (don’t smell of BO).

At the interview I had this morning they said they had more interviews lined up for the rest of today and all day tomorrow so would come to me on Thursday but they called me at lunchtime to say that I was great but pipped at the post again and they had struggled to choose between me and another candidate, which I thought was odd. What about the other interviews they had apparently had lined up for today and tomorrow?

WIBU to ask my thread title when I inevitably get knocked back from the two interviews I’ve got lined up next week?

I resigned from my last job due to toxic environment and crap pay last month (bit heat of the moment) so desperately need to get another one!

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 14/03/2023 20:30

JackiePlace · 14/03/2023 18:37

So annoying when they advertise the post to external candidaes when they already know who they want.

I worked for NHS. They interviewed for 2 jobs. Both positions had been filled temporarily with 'Bank staff'. Despite both doing the job well for nearly 6 months neither were offered the permanent position. One person was very upset and took this as a personal slight. The interview consisted of a panel including someone who knew neither the role or the candidates.
The interview does not guarentee the best candidate, it garentees the candidate who can demonstrate the best potential on the day. The bank person got feedback, learnt about the interview process....and secured a permanent role later.
Most publ8c sector jobs work this way....unfortunately some really do chose who they like the look of.

bluetongue · 14/03/2023 20:26

Look on the bright side OP. At least you didn’t get as far as a police check and reference checks and still miss out like I did last year. Devastating.

SarahAndQuack · 14/03/2023 20:24

(And FWIW, I worked until recently in a sector where, because it's a small world, I had personal friends at many different levels of seniority - I'd been interviewed by some and had interviewed others, and friends had been competing candidates alongside me, or alongside each other in interview sessions I was part of. I am absolutely, completely sure people were being honest when they told excellent candidates they were excellent, but someone else was better. I saw people who were amazing not getting a job, simply because there were loads of great candidates. In some situations the panel is almost reduced to choosing by tossing a coin. It's very, very common for everyone to acknowledge that the whole shortlist could be hired, but sadly, they have to choose someone.

I'm not saying it's like this in every job field, but it is in many. Jobs have just got much more competitive to get.)

JudgeRudy · 14/03/2023 20:20

Just to declare, no background in HR or recruitment. Heres my take......
The first three interviews were through employment agencies. I'm assuming you weren't head hunted and just submitted a CV and had a chat (interview) with them. It's probable they've forwarded your generic CV to a potential client and you (just about in their opinion) meet the essential criteria. What have they got to loose? OK not all agencies are like this but I've been for interviews where there was definitely a mis match with expectations.

Another reason might be you have the skills and experience but didn't demonstrate it well. Telling someone you have 'great communication skills' or are a 'great team player' is very different to describing how you managed an angry client or stepped in to cover for a colleague. Look what skills they required and answer the question 'tell me about a time you conducted yourself with patience/persuaded someone to do something/had to time manage well....etc

The most likely reason is there were better candidates. Ones who had more than the minimum skills and experience or ones that demonstrated them better. Or there could just be a first aid certificate in it.

I'm realistic. It's possible that someone took a dislike to you or made judgements/assumptions based on your presentation. A red sweaty face might come across as anxiety or lack of confidence. If its your looks then what? Asking for feedback is fine but you won't always get it. There's a good chance however that someone from the agency has heard back. Ask for a frank talk.

And finally....there's nothing as unappealing as negativity. You sound almost angry stating they're wasted your time. Be careful not to slag your former employer off. Why did you leave?" "Well sadly the job didn't offer the development opportunities I was expecting" not the manager was a bully. There's lots of further advice on line on how to answer these questions."So how long have you been unemployed".."It's just been a few weeks since I left which has allowed me to complete ABC etc"...so look for the positive.

Be realistic. It might take a while before you find another suitable job. A few weeks reallybisnt anything.

SarahAndQuack · 14/03/2023 20:19

I doubt it, OP.

I wonder if you need to reset your expectations about jobs. I think a lot of people imagine if they're qualified and they interviewers really think they're excellent, then it's almost shocking not to get the job. But there's only one job going! And often, many candidates will have been qualified and excellent. Why assume people are lying when they say this? A weirdly entitled attitude, I think.

FinallyHere · 14/03/2023 20:18

desperately need to get another one!

I think this 'need' to get a new job is skewing how you are feeling about these interviews and making it even harder for you.

I'd earnestly advise you to reframe it, find out what you can learn about yourself and the potential new job and how you would work together.

Hold your nerve, keep plodding along and tbd right job will show up. Meanwhile, are you networking like crazy to leave no stone unturned

Good luck, it's going to happen for you.

Lemons1571 · 14/03/2023 20:16

I’m in a similar boat. Got down to the last 2 candidates twice. Then told a version of “we chose the other candidate as we felt it would be less of a transition for them”.

So, reading between the lines - they’re basically saying I’m from a traditionally slow ploddy sector, the other candidate is from the much “safer” private sector. We like you but can’t take the risk with you that doesn’t exist with the other candidate.

It’s tiring and disheartening. Gets on my nerves tbh. But gotta keep pressing forward otherwise I’ll never find anything..

Oh and my BMI is 20. It’s not helping me (professional office hybrid roles).

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/03/2023 20:07

What on earth am I doing wrong?

Almost certainly nothing, or you wouldn't be getting that many interviews.
I'd wonder if they think you'd be too expensive because of your past experience, but since they could work that out from your CV I doubt it'll be this either

Very possibly it's more than just one which went to a pre-selected candidate, but depending on sector it's probably just a numbers game and a question of pressing on

Iminpatchinghell · 14/03/2023 20:00

I did a lot of interviews in a previous job and sometimes you can be perfect for a job but you might just not fit in as well with the team as a different candidate. How the team works together is a key part of recruiting for a role, if someone else gels better than you, that’s just the way it is.
Keep going, the right role and company will turn up. I’ve never not employed someone because they smelled, or were fat, or had a face tattoo, or bright hair.

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 19:54

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 19:38

Yes, that's right. I've judged you on what you have written here & your nasty responses to another poster. That's all I can judge you on.

You are a terrible interviewer if you make snap judgments, then conclude an interview as quickly as possible.

That's poor performance, not honesty.

Oh the irony!

Not only on my posts but the others you’re judging, yet you claim to not judge IRL. Deluded or bullshit?

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 19:39

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:35

It is toe curling to see an interview as a chance to make them laugh, inject humour.

It is very very David Brent.

Unless you are going for a job involving being a comic… avoid trying to make interviewers laugh.

For a start… you have absolutely bugger all idea of what their sense of humour is like

💯

It can also seem like nerves. Of course it's fine to smile & exhange informal pleasantries at start & finish but interviewing is a long, busy day & the panel is there to get a job done. Best not to try to be funny.

Beesandhoney123 · 14/03/2023 19:38

What reason do you give for leaving your last job? Leaving because of a toxic environment can mean anything. It could mean you were asked to leave as you caused it! I would be careful with that- perhaps say you are looking for a more team based collaborative culture than your last role which was rather more isolating. Or something like that. Have you a good reference from your last boss?

I am looking and didn't get something i thought would be perfect, which is a shame but they know what they want and lovely as I am:) someone else had more honed skills. I don't mind, maybe I dodged a bullet.

They have told you why- it's always about a team fit. This is a tenuous area. Who knows?

Perhaps do some contract work/ mat cover and build your network in the meantime.

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 19:38

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 19:34

@EarringsandLipstick

And yet you’ve judged me on a couple of sentences on an anonymous forum?? That doesn’t match your holier than thou attitude does it?

I’m just being honest - something I find lacking on Mumsnet threads about jobs and interviewing.

Yes, that's right. I've judged you on what you have written here & your nasty responses to another poster. That's all I can judge you on.

You are a terrible interviewer if you make snap judgments, then conclude an interview as quickly as possible.

That's poor performance, not honesty.

GoodChat · 14/03/2023 19:35

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 19:31

I don't want to work anywhere where you can't have a bit of a joke.

Me neither, and it's fine to be relaxed and conversational at the start / end but definitely not when answering questions. It's about focusing on the task in hand, it's not the place to be humorous.

Oh yeah that's fair - you can't answer a serious question with a joke or it looks like you're avoiding the question.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:35

It is toe curling to see an interview as a chance to make them laugh, inject humour.

It is very very David Brent.

Unless you are going for a job involving being a comic… avoid trying to make interviewers laugh.

For a start… you have absolutely bugger all idea of what their sense of humour is like

LondonTripPlanning · 14/03/2023 19:34

@EarringsandLipstick

And yet you’ve judged me on a couple of sentences on an anonymous forum?? That doesn’t match your holier than thou attitude does it?

I’m just being honest - something I find lacking on Mumsnet threads about jobs and interviewing.

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 19:31

I don't want to work anywhere where you can't have a bit of a joke.

Me neither, and it's fine to be relaxed and conversational at the start / end but definitely not when answering questions. It's about focusing on the task in hand, it's not the place to be humorous.

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 19:29

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:28

I always try to bring a bit of humour into interviews though

do NOT do this OP. Seriously.

I agree.

It's fine if something naturally happens but in general, play it straight.

GoodChat · 14/03/2023 19:29

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:28

I always try to bring a bit of humour into interviews though

do NOT do this OP. Seriously.

Nonsense.
If it's appropriate for the conversation there's absolutely nothing wrong with being lighthearted.

I don't want to work anywhere where you can't have a bit of a joke.

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 19:29

@LondonTripPlanning

You sound awful - as an interviewer & in your responses to @mellicauli

Judging someone immediately is really poor on your part. When I interview, everyone gets the same opportunity, questions & time. Then they are scored. It is true that sometimes it is immediately clear if someone isn't going to work out, but I will always give a full opportunity.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:28

I always try to bring a bit of humour into interviews though

do NOT do this OP. Seriously.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:27

Not laugh a minute but try to make them laugh a few times*

noooooooooo!!!!

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:27

So these were all positions with only one interview involved?

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 19:27

OP, you say you got feedback but you didn't really.

You can ask for your interviews scores, and what the appointable mark was. This will show you if you were close to being appointed, and give you an idea of how you were assessed.

I don't think it had anything to do with weight at all.

I do think you might need to work on balancing previous high-level experience with the current roles. Making it clear why you are interested & that you are.

Good luck! Don't despair, there's a role out there for you.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 19:25

How long is a “long” career break?