Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aaargh! WIBU to say if I’m such a strong candidate, why didn’t you give me the bloody job!

87 replies

Swosh · 14/03/2023 18:10

So 4 interviews over the last 2 weeks. All really great roles at a higher salary and better conditions. 3 through employment agencies who had already remotely interviewed me and said I would be great for their roles.

Feedback from actual job interviews were that I came cross really well, my answers were great and I was a ‘very strong candidate’ but I was ‘pipped at the post’ for all of them! Obviously a lie to make me feel better at wasting my time.

What on earth am I doing wrong?

Two interviews involved walking up flights of stairs to get to the interview room (why couldn’t the damn room be on the ground floor?!) and as I’ve put a bit of weight on over the last year as working from home, I admit that I was a bit breathless almost keeled over at the start of the interview.

Could it be because I’m fat? Most of the roles were WFH though and I look fine head and shoulders wise.

I dress smart, well groomed, well spoken (don’t smell of BO).

At the interview I had this morning they said they had more interviews lined up for the rest of today and all day tomorrow so would come to me on Thursday but they called me at lunchtime to say that I was great but pipped at the post again and they had struggled to choose between me and another candidate, which I thought was odd. What about the other interviews they had apparently had lined up for today and tomorrow?

WIBU to ask my thread title when I inevitably get knocked back from the two interviews I’ve got lined up next week?

I resigned from my last job due to toxic environment and crap pay last month (bit heat of the moment) so desperately need to get another one!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 17:18

The Op left previous employment very suddenly due to a toxic environment

The OP got very out of breath going up stairs. Not a good look if concerned about potential high sick leave

The OP always tries to inject humour into interviews and makes the interviewers laugh

I would say that all three of the above are the reasons for the last of success to various degrees

JackiePlace · 15/03/2023 16:19

JackiePlace · 15/03/2023 16:16

No, because their minds are already made up. They are just wasting everyone's time so they can tick "equal opportunity employer" boxes or similar nonsense.

This works the other way too. I was in a crappy job that I hated for years when (finally!) something came up in my very niche field. The company had a hiring freeze on so the post was filled by a 'temp' in the short term. When they finally could recruit, the former temp was hired. There were only two candidates (me and him). It was clear from the nature of the (very specific) questions that they had already decided he was going to get the job.

JackiePlace · 15/03/2023 16:16

Twinedpeaks · 14/03/2023 18:57

@JackiePlace wouldn't it be worse if they just have internal candidates the job with no competition?!

No, because their minds are already made up. They are just wasting everyone's time so they can tick "equal opportunity employer" boxes or similar nonsense.

gloriousmulch · 15/03/2023 16:15

Sometimes a very good candidate is beaten by a slightly better or more experienced one. It’s frustrating but as a PP has said there’s usually only one job. Keep at it and good
luck!

MakeMineABombay · 15/03/2023 15:59

I think advertising posts externally when you have a worthy internal candidate is very much a thing in the public sector

I'm private sector and we do this. It's because we have various organisations that the business wants to be a member of that require commitment to various E&D directives.

I agree with you @Dinopawus that it is shitty. It's happened to me where I went for an interview for something and thought it went really well and then when I saw who got the job I was really angry I'd wasted my time. To give you an idea, it was like going for a football related role with senior good experience working for the Football Association and then finding out the person who was appointed was Gary Lineker.

I suppose it gets justified on the basis that if some like Pele/Sepp Blatter [not best example but can't think of anything better] whoever had applied they would have got it but everyone knows that it is so unlikley that the other candidates are being mucked about especially if called for interview.

Dinopawus · 15/03/2023 11:19

I think advertising posts externally when you have a worthy internal candidate is very much a thing in the public sector - certainly in healthcare. As PP said it's supposed to increase diversity by advertising to a wide audience of candidates and thus reaching the best person.

Which is lovely and laudable in theory but can be miserable for candidates. Internal candidates sometimes miss out on worthy promotion - I've had sorry experience of helping someone to develop themselves ready to move into a new role only for a more experienced candidate to apply.

It's also often a complete waste of external candidates time and emotional energy.

Rinkydinkydoodle · 15/03/2023 11:09

Interesting thread, lots of good guidance for answers. Hope you get one of next week’s jobs OP!

MakeMineABombay · 15/03/2023 11:00

Why would any company do this? Recruitment costs a lot of time and money, what possible benefit do you see from going through a Recruitment process if they already know who is going to get it

@Obbydoo Oh so naive! we do this all the time because we have an equality and diversity policy that requires outside advertising of every single post as a point of principle. We are required to have an E&D policy that provides for this or at least it's frowned on if you don't in the modern world.

Sometimes it is really annoying because the post has only arisen because of a specific external candidate that is wanted. Usually it's internal promotion though.

With external like Chairman happens to meet Ms A leader in field and gets a hint A is in the market to move. Coffee had. A writes in letter of application. at that point there isn't even a job, they just want A because A is so good. Then what happens is there is a flurry of activity creating an external job advert to match the policy. It's not entirely impossible that someone else could get the job in that case but its just not very likely and you'd really have to be stellar.

Obbydoo · 14/03/2023 23:45

JackiePlace · 14/03/2023 18:37

So annoying when they advertise the post to external candidaes when they already know who they want.

Why would any company do this? Recruitment costs a lot of time and money, what possible benefit do you see from going through a Recruitment process if they already know who is going to get it? The truth is this never happens, it is simply a cover story for people who didn't get the job to make themselves feel better for failing.

user1471459761 · 14/03/2023 23:15

I think you should take the responses at face value! If there is just one role available, it is common that there is more than one person interviewed who is easy capable of fitting it. Sadly if there is only job, a decision needs to be made.

k1233 · 14/03/2023 22:21

And you never know when the place you interviewed with might recommend you to someone else. I've gotten jobs that way, which turned out to be much better than the role I applied for.

k1233 · 14/03/2023 22:20

JackiePlace · 14/03/2023 18:30

I have often thought this. They would never tell you the real reason, though.
I think if there are two cadidates of equal merit, the more attractive one will get the job.

No. That's not it. It's about finding the person who will fit best with the weird people you work with. The over sensitive person, the snappy person, the gossiper etc

By the time you get to the interview, people have assessed your skills as being in line with what they're looking for. The interview is about them as a person, how they deal with questions they may not necessarily know the answers to, how they build rapport with the interview panel.

If you have two candidates with similar skills and capabilities, then picking the person with industry experience makes sense. They have less to pick up.

Never burn your bridges OP. Ask for feedback and take it constructively. You never know when the preferred candidate might pull out or not work out and you made a good impression so they give you a call to see if you're still available.

minisoksmakehardwork · 14/03/2023 21:45

I applied for 3 identical jobs - all civil service, same title. Just different areas of the country. 1 declined me at prescreening - I didn't meet criteria. 2 have interviewed me and 1 so far has offered me the job. I don't think I'll be offered from the final one.

But that just goes to show that where job description, pre-screen and interview were all identical, there can be very different outcomes. The reason for me being offered the job I was, was for my enthusiasm for the role. I felt at ease with the interview panel. The most recent one, despite knowing some of them and the company already, had a different feel about it.

If you're getting as far as interview, on paper you have the goods. Maybe you're lacking in confidence about your skills and ability due to your career gaps. Don't see them as deficits but an alternative way of working for a while.

bonzaitree · 14/03/2023 21:44

Don’t overthink the feedback. It’s a no- move on.

surely it won’t be because you’re overweight. Maybe being overqualified?

rosiebl · 14/03/2023 21:38

Did you tell them that you had already resigned from your previous role and tell them why? You say you are het up about that, did that come across in the interview?

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 21:18

we have an internal candidate and are going through the motions

Just on this - we never treat internal candidates as shoo-ins. They have to prove themselves at interview like anyone else. They don't always get it, either.

I always counsel people not to make assumptions about internal candidates being a given for a role.

EarringsandLipstick · 14/03/2023 21:14

Not only on my posts but the others you’re judging, yet you claim to not judge IRL. Deluded or bullshit

What are you talking about? 😂

I am judging you on your obnoxious posts (although now I don't actually believe you interview anyone, tbh)

Of course I 'judge' interview candidates, if by 'judge' you mean assess and evaluate - that's the purpose of an interview. However unlike you apparently I do so according to proper procedure & equally with all candidates - not your suggested snap judgments.

HTH

alwayslearning789 · 14/03/2023 21:09

OP keep your job search going and don't take it personally. There are so many candidates per vacancy and employers can only offer one person the specific role.

You will find the company that thinks you are the best fit for them (and them for you) in due course.

Dinopawus · 14/03/2023 20:54

I'll be honest, it's feedback I've given before.

It depends on the role but if you've got a bunch of candidates who all meet the person specification, on the day you could appoint any one of them.

You end up appointing the candidate who scores highest, either because they have additional skills or experience or because they come across as likeable and a good fit for the team.

When you feedback to unsuccessful candidates you can't say "oh you didn't have a certificate in fine embroidery" if you didn't ask for it. They have the skills, (on paper) that's why you are interviewing them. So the real reasons are
A) we liked person x better
B) we didn't believe what you said and weren't convinced you live up to your application
C) we have an internal candidate and are going through the motions.
D) person x is genuinely more experienced at making sausages so we scored then higher.

Whatever the actual reason, you tell the unsuccessful people a version of D.

At interview you need them to like you, to believe you and to know what skills & experience you have. Good Luck.

Sodullincomparison · 14/03/2023 20:54

Recently I have had people turn up for interviews in trainers or jeans and jumpers.

it is a professional wear workplace so this is completely wrong and shows me they don’t get who we are.

FlightyFoxing · 14/03/2023 20:50

It's often just a numbers game. 4 interviews isn't many.

We often have 50+ applicants for 1 job opening. We interview maybe 6-8 of the applicants. Only 1 of them can get the job.

Is it a physical job?

How long is your career gap?

MakeMineABombay · 14/03/2023 20:46

In my field feedback requests are very common and 'pipped at the post' wouldn't be acceptable. If we gave that feedback, we'd expect a come back asking for more specific feedback that allowed the candidate an opportunity to improve and identified areas of weakness as compared to other candidates.

admittedly a highly litigious field where we are v careful about E&D but personally I wouldn't accept pipped at the post and I would go back and politely ask for more constructive feedback that identified your areas of weakness (where exactly the pipping occurred). you may get platitudes but you may get something.

having said all of that it does sometimes happen that 2nd place candidate is highly employable and the only difference between 1st and 2nd is just a shade more charm/personality/panel warming to them - which is utter shite I know but the real world and something hard to articulate. To put it another way, think of a pair of people you like -comedians or TV presenters often are good for this exercise - Ant & Dec, Reeves & Mortimer, the Two Ronnies - and imagine you had to pick one to come to live in your house for 24 hours - which would you pick - assuming you like them both. It just comes down to the one you feel you'd have more chemistry with - a better fit. It's shitty but impossible to articulate well to a candidate without a law suit.

Close but no cigar may mean just that. Close but trivia as a distinguisher. Unlucky in other words.

evemillbank · 14/03/2023 20:42

I doubt you are doing anything wrong. It's a numbers game. Keep going I'm sure you'll be successful.

The vacancy my dept advertised last month had almost 700 applicants. Lots of great people will not get the job.

Sandinmyknickers · 14/03/2023 20:37

Well there's often only one job to fill at the company and lots of candidates. So yeah, even if you're good and there's no obvious "no", you might still lose out to someone who just slightly "pips you to the post" for whatever reason. I think you're overthinking it. It's not like you've had tons of interviews. It's simple numbers

bluetongue · 14/03/2023 20:34

I’m so nervous in interviews I’m going to ask my GP for a beta blocker or similar. My nerves manifest in nausea, diarrhea, dry mouth and sweaty hands. Everyone says ‘oh I hate interviews and get nervous’ but I’m pretty sure they don’t have crippling nerves like I do.

It’s part of the reason I’ve been stuck in my current toxic workplace for way too long.

Then I see some of the new people my office hires and some of them are duds (they really are). It’s incredibly frustrating.