Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I have to accept that it is in fact me that’s the issue?

307 replies

MumsTheIssue · 14/03/2023 14:36

DC is 8, Y4. This has been going on since Y2.

Perfect at school, no behaviour issues at all, no issues with academics, small but close group of friends. Quite quiet but will speak when spoken to and in the last few months growing in confidence. Eats fine.

ExH says they’re perfect there, quiet but easy going and will chat when wants to. Eats fine.

At home they’re the complete opposite:

  • Violence aimed at me, repeatedly no matter what I do they keep going for up to 3 hours – if I ignore it carries on, if I try and tell them off it carries on, if I change rooms they follow me, if I put them into a different room they laugh and come back, if I talk to them they laugh and carry on

  • Will not eat unless it's on a specific plate or bowl

  • Does not respond to praise

  • Does not respond to being given an instruction such as “Can you tidy up your toys please?” if I repeat it more firmly “Tidy up toys please” they still ignore me – if I take all their toys away they just shrug, if I stop screen time (they can earn 4 hours to be used at the weekend) they just shrug, if I stop them going to parties/activities etc. they just shrug and say they don’t care.

  • I literally cannot punish them as they just don’t care. They won’t stay in timeout/a spot if they’re being violent towards me, I have tried returning them but they just laugh and think it’s a game

  • Tells me they hate me regularly and they are going to live with their dad as soon as they’re old enough (they see him EOWend for 1 night only, never for school runs or appointments or anything else “boring”) but only when in a violent rage, when calm they say the love me a lot but never that they want to live with me, but they also don't say they want to live with ExH either

  • School refuses – we’re regularly late for school but as soon as we’re there it’s like a lightbulb and they’re suddenly all sweetness and light

  • Will not go to sleep – returning them to bed is a game again, they then fall asleep in class

What I’ve tried:

  • A meeting with school for repeated lateness and falling asleep in class – they blamed me, told me to get DC up earlier (I can’t get them up any earlier, we’re already up at 6am, and they go to bed at 7.30pm) and said I needed to be “More persistent” with returning them to bed, even though DC told them it’s a fun game. They’ve told me they’ll refer it to Social Services if it keeps happening. I asked for a CAMHS referral to rule out SN and was told that DC doesn’t meet the criteria

  • Took them to a private GP to rule out a medical cause – got brushed off and told it’s schools problem without them even checking DCs ears or any kind of examination - yes I demanded my money back, I was expecting at least a basic examination so I know that DC is healthy, I wasn’t demanding to the GP, I just expected a check of the ears, throat, chest (maybe nose), and maybe a basic urine test – my grandparents paid for this and where willing to pay for anything above that if the GP felt it necessary but I wasn’t even given any advice just told it’s behavioural and schools problem

  • Spoke to someone for a private diagnosis of SN and told that I need schools backing for them to do so I can’t go down that route

  • Took them to a private physio when they complained of pain (again my Grandparents paid for this) – who was very very good, but couldn’t find a physical issue and just advised me to get some properly fitted shoes for DC (which I did and hasn’t improved the behaviour at home)

I feel like I’m going mad. I’m looking into an EHCNA, but Sendiass have said if school are saying it’s a home problem and ExH is saying he has no issues with DC there then it will be an uphill battle that may not be won. I’m considering asking for a course of private play therapy from my grandparents, but I don’t want to keep taking money off them if I can help it.

Do I just accept I’m the issue? And if so how do I change? ExH will not parent full time so I have to. So it’s not an option for me to give in or give DC up though at times I have considered it

Does this sound familiar to anyone? Being fine at school and the NRPs but then coming home and just exploding. DC is always sorry but can’t seem to explain what happens when they’re in those moods. It’s not all bad, but I am so exhausted and feel like I can’t relax in case DC explodes.

OP posts:
apparentlynothin · 15/03/2023 09:39

Phineyj · 15/03/2023 09:11

I think the missing element (that the books I suggested deal with well) is that if destructive or violent behaviours are the result of anxiety or overwhelm, unmet additional needs, emotions that aren't understood or named, etc, strict authoritarian parenting is very likely to make the problem worse.

OP has not detailed what kind of violence she is experiencing but in our case it was shin kicking, hitting and punching, spitting etc.

At the very least if you are going to up the ante and encourage a battle of wills, you need safe handling training or someone could get badly hurt.

The other element posters are ignoring is the need to keep the sibling safe.

Traditional parenting courses and approaches are very little help with this and can make things worse.

And to quote Ross Greene, behaviourally challenging kids are challenging because they’re lacking the skills to not be challenging.

Punishing a child for lacking developmental capacity is unfair and counterproductive.

OP - as other have suggested, if you move to Special Needs/SEN boards, you'll be with parents dealing with similar challenges, without the crank element AIBU attracts.

Phineyj · 15/03/2023 09:11

I think the missing element (that the books I suggested deal with well) is that if destructive or violent behaviours are the result of anxiety or overwhelm, unmet additional needs, emotions that aren't understood or named, etc, strict authoritarian parenting is very likely to make the problem worse.

OP has not detailed what kind of violence she is experiencing but in our case it was shin kicking, hitting and punching, spitting etc.

At the very least if you are going to up the ante and encourage a battle of wills, you need safe handling training or someone could get badly hurt.

The other element posters are ignoring is the need to keep the sibling safe.

Traditional parenting courses and approaches are very little help with this and can make things worse.

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 09:01

premicrois · 15/03/2023 08:44

@ColonelDax

You were boring yesterday...

By all means get an assessment but if a child is well behaved in every environment except one, there is a very good chance it's the environment that is the problem, and not the child.

This is actually bullshit.

As opposed to your constructive additions....

premicrois · 15/03/2023 08:44

@ColonelDax

You were boring yesterday...

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 08:39

User4891 · 15/03/2023 07:42

The problem that's been highlighted here is that any threats or escalation you make have to be followed through as you're essentially just creating an epic battle of wills with your child. If your kid is stubborn enough then it kindof has to end with solitary confinement in an empty bedroom and a kid who eventually submisses and grows up anxious/resentful in the process which is why I don't personally like it as a discipline method. You can be firm be instill fair consequences and make the focus more on meeting the child's needs than your own needs. This is important to remember whatever conditions the child does/doesn't have

I have thought about this post again and it warrants a longer response.

The implication here is that if you get into a battle of wills with a child, it will inevitably be damaging for them. I don't see that. Previous posters are focusing on one incident that i described where things came to a head when my youngest tried to push her boundaries, and we couldn't back down in order to show her that when we say things, we mean them. It doesn't characterise our relationship and to be honest, having a blow up incident where you prove you wont budge is good thing as it sticks in memory and means you really don't have to do anything for 95% of future occasions, just refer to it and remind your kids that you mean what you say. That's far easier and kinder on them than dealing with incident after incident after incident as they come, which is what some of the other parents I used to be friends with faced, particularly in the tween/teens years.

Children need structure and clear boundaries and to know that if their parent says something, they mean it. This can be misportayed as the 'strict' parent only caring about punishment, while the 'kind' parent gets to the bottom of the behaviour and fixes it at source. Really its far more complicated, I was proudly a strict parent, but i also talked with my children constantly and sought to understand why they were doing what they were doing and then to work through their behaviour, but if it warranted it and they pushed me, I pushed right back and I never backed down.

I think you need both approaches in conjunction, the kindness and understanding only approach, with no real consequence to poor behaviour isn't the way either.

The idea that being strict and not giving in when your kids are being stubborn and unreasonable inevitably leads to anxious, damaged children who resent you is nonsense and I have no doubt is something that parents who can't discipline their kids tell themselves to feel better.

apparentlynothin · 15/03/2023 08:30

Perhaps let's not get derailed?

OP will have her own parenting values, including in respect of physical chastisement and extended punishment, and will no doubt be weighing respective contributions, and relative experience and understanding of neurotypical and neurodiverse behaviours, accordingly.

Kenworthington · 15/03/2023 08:00

I’ve not rtft sorry but agree with many pp, this exactly describes my autistic ds1 (he’s now 24), right down to school not believing and hun being angelic with other people.

It started when he was around 3 or 4 but really hit crisis point at home when he was about 6/7, when I ended up sending him to his godparents for a weekend. And he was difficult with them too. I have never been so relieved in my life.

That week I went straight to the gp with my list of concerns and was at total breaking point. They referred him straight away and he was actually diagnosed at his first paediatric appointment. Trust me, it’s not you. You can refer him via your gp yourself. good luck op

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 07:49

User4891 · 15/03/2023 07:42

The problem that's been highlighted here is that any threats or escalation you make have to be followed through as you're essentially just creating an epic battle of wills with your child. If your kid is stubborn enough then it kindof has to end with solitary confinement in an empty bedroom and a kid who eventually submisses and grows up anxious/resentful in the process which is why I don't personally like it as a discipline method. You can be firm be instill fair consequences and make the focus more on meeting the child's needs than your own needs. This is important to remember whatever conditions the child does/doesn't have

Why would they grow up anxious or resentful? None of mine have.

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 07:49

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 07:44

and she didn't really have toys at 9)
🤔

really? And this was pre computer games.

So you 9 year old used to do what? Just read? And you took that away from her

It was 2013?

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 07:46

@ColonelDax

may I ask what your current situation is? All adult children moved out, correct? Do you have a partner? Work?

the reason I ask is you seem… not sure how to delicately word, so I won’t

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 07:44

and she didn't really have toys at 9)
🤔

really? And this was pre computer games.

So you 9 year old used to do what? Just read? And you took that away from her

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 07:42

So your daughter was never ever rude again? Never. That harsh punishment went so deep she was NEVER rude again to you

User4891 · 15/03/2023 07:42

The problem that's been highlighted here is that any threats or escalation you make have to be followed through as you're essentially just creating an epic battle of wills with your child. If your kid is stubborn enough then it kindof has to end with solitary confinement in an empty bedroom and a kid who eventually submisses and grows up anxious/resentful in the process which is why I don't personally like it as a discipline method. You can be firm be instill fair consequences and make the focus more on meeting the child's needs than your own needs. This is important to remember whatever conditions the child does/doesn't have

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 07:30

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 07:26

You are absolutely correct @ColonelDax

i am fixated (although actually more disturbed) by your punishment of stripping your 9 year old’s bedroom of everything bar a bed and forbidding her from even reading. For 2 days until she saw sense and apologised

she didn’t mean that apology. She was desperate for her books back and wanted her toys and teddies back

I know she didn't. I'm curious why you think that matters?

She learned that if you do bad things and break the rules, you receive consequences. As soon as she apologised and did as she was told she got all her books and TV back, which she knew was the case right from the start (she never got teddies removed and she didn't really have toys at 9)

The apology was just for behaviour modeling so she knows what she should feel in future. As I said before, it worked and we never had to get to that stage again.

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 07:26

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 07:23

Telling that the offence was trivial enough to forget

but many years later you very much remember the punishment

and I guess your daughter will be the same

I already said, she got it for not doing as she was told and being rude. That's not trivial and if you think it is then I dread to think how your children behave.

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 07:26

You are absolutely correct @ColonelDax

i am fixated (although actually more disturbed) by your punishment of stripping your 9 year old’s bedroom of everything bar a bed and forbidding her from even reading. For 2 days until she saw sense and apologised

she didn’t mean that apology. She was desperate for her books back and wanted her toys and teddies back

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 07:23

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 06:33

Why? Telling of what?

Telling that the offence was trivial enough to forget

but many years later you very much remember the punishment

and I guess your daughter will be the same

Phineyj · 15/03/2023 07:14

I forgot something else.

Sleep problems are very common with ADHD. There's a report by one of the ADHD charities called 'Sleep Seekers' with statistics. I found it really helpful to know that 2-4 hours to fall asleep was not average (unless you have ADHD).

We've used melatonin, which has changed our lives. It was prescribed by the paediatrician we saw privately and our GP took the prescription on.

Phineyj · 15/03/2023 07:08

Hi again OP, I didn't have time for a long post yesterday but I wanted to second (third) the recommendation of the book The Explosive Child and also another one, which I found really helpful, is 10 Days to a Less Defiant Child (Jeffrey Bernstein). They are both very practical and supportive of parents.

A technique that might help you is called NVR (non violent resistance). We saw a guy called Jack at New Leaf NVR. He was way more helpful (and less expensive) than the many healthcare professionals of various types (although it has been very helpful to have a diagnosis so we know what we're dealing with, can access appropriate support etc). Buy there are other practitioners - Yvonne Newbold is another well known one.

I haven't tried pm on here since switching to the app, but somewhere I have a report from the University of Durham about violence of children to parents (well, mums). I participated in the study. Pm me if you want me to look out a copy. There is a significant taboo on talking about it, but it's more common than people think. You are not alone.

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 06:37

tothelefttotheleft · 14/03/2023 22:59

How is she not enforcing the rules if she does things like takes toys away?

Because I've asked her twice now how long she does it for and if she is consistent.

No response which makes me think she caves easily and her child pushes their luck because they know they can outlast their mother and if they make it difficult enough she will just give up. That's far more likely to be a big factor in this than anything else

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 06:33

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 06:00

Do you of think it’s telling @ColonelDax thatyph very clearly remember the punishment

but have no recollection of the offence that your 9 year old actually did to warrant such a punishment

Why? Telling of what?

ColonelDax · 15/03/2023 06:33

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 05:58

Exaggerate?

You said that everything was taken out other than her bed
YOU said that @ColonelDax

You described it as “effectively solitary confinement. “. YOU @ColonelDax

and YOU @ColonelDax said your deprived her if any books for two days and would have whipped one away from her if she was caught with one

so where have I exaggerated?

and back to my question… would you want your dd to do this to your gd?

I answered you in the quoted response. Of course I'd be happy for her to.

You are oddly fixated on me and the way I brought up my kids. 🙄

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 06:00

Do you of think it’s telling @ColonelDax thatyph very clearly remember the punishment

but have no recollection of the offence that your 9 year old actually did to warrant such a punishment

Lovelyveg82 · 15/03/2023 05:58

ColonelDax · 14/03/2023 20:52

Please don't exaggerate. She lost access to her books and her TV.

And of course I would. Like I said, she could have had them back at any time. It was entirely self imposed until she did as she was told and apologised.

Exaggerate?

You said that everything was taken out other than her bed
YOU said that @ColonelDax

You described it as “effectively solitary confinement. “. YOU @ColonelDax

and YOU @ColonelDax said your deprived her if any books for two days and would have whipped one away from her if she was caught with one

so where have I exaggerated?

and back to my question… would you want your dd to do this to your gd?

OverCCCs · 14/03/2023 23:40

MumsTheIssue · 14/03/2023 20:00

Thanks everyone, will definitely look at these issues.

ExH will not be involved more, no matter what I do, he's been offered multiple times via my solicitor to his, mediation and even court he just does not want DC more.

DC doesn't respond to praise, I can say "You did very well drawing that picture" and they'll either change the subject or just carry on with what they're doing.

I did say it wasn't all bad, we do spend a lot of time 1-1. We go to the library and read once a week together, we swim, we cook or bake at home. I try and play with DC when they're playing on the floor but they don't really like it, so I just chat to them while they play, we watch films at home and at the cinema etc. We do lots together and I do value those times, it just seems to be after school and after seeing ExH they just are violent.

They can be very affectionate and loving towards me though, especially after a violent outbrust, they come to me and say sorry and hug me. And I always kiss them goodnight and say I love them.

Holidays are a strange one, sometimes they go to holiday club and are fine after, other times they come home and be violent, again they last a similar amount of time.

Sleep is another strange one. No matter what time I put them to bed they take 1-2 hours to fall asleep, so an 8.30pm bedtime could mean they're awake until 10.30pm - which is my bedtime. At least with 7.30pm if they fall asleep around 9.30 I have an hour to myself before I also go to bed. They get up and come out of their room to chat to me, and find it funny when I return them to bed. Just ignoring them has no affect they still come out of their room.

I also work, I did work 3 days but had to spread my hours avross 5 days instead to see if DC was better when not in ASC (which they were slightly) but it does increase my feelings of no rest or break for myself because between work and looking after DC I'm hardly alone.

Maybe you can try giving them more space, especially when they’ve just returned from their dad’s or school?

The bits about the unwelcome comments on their artwork, trying to play alongside them on the floor when they want to be left alone, and then sitting in the background talking at them instead make it sound like you might be frequently annoying them. Especially if DC has recently returned from a stressful environment and wants to decompress in peace (like so many of us do after work!) you may be setting off an already short fuse on a young child who isn’t mature enough to say “I need some alone time right now.”