Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why was this allowed in the 80s/90s?

205 replies

Anxiousanx · 14/03/2023 08:49

My parents were allowed to decline my ASD diagnosis ?

At age 8 the school started pushing for meetings with them and I was having severe difficulties. They didn’t want to engage.
The following year the school had someone come in to observe me.
My parents made it clear to me I wasn’t to ‘get a label’ and needed to ‘behave normally’

2 years later at a different school with even more difficulty I was involved in meetings and had to go to what i assume was camhs or whatever it was called then ?
I saw doctors and a speech therapist and I think a psychiatrist?
My parents were given the likely diagnosis and asked did they want to proceed with that and said no as again, didn’t want me to have a label and this was allowed ?
I’ve seen some of the clinic letters in recent years and I’m really astounded and don’t understand why this was allowed ?

OP posts:
StopStartStop · 14/03/2023 11:15

Still allowed. Parents have say. That's a good, protective thing but who knows if they will make the right decisions or not. My dd is pursuing ADHD diagnosis for dgd, instead of autism or both, 'to avoid the stigma of autism'.

I was diagnosed as autistic in my early sixties. I love my diagnosis, my 'label'. As I often say 'Everything I am is autism!' But I'm at the far end of life. People who have to make their way in today and tomorrow's worlds will have to make their own decisions on what is right for them.

AxolotlOnions · 14/03/2023 11:14

@Fifi0000 Autistic people are at greater risk when they are ill for many reasons. There is ignoring them, thinking they are being uncooperative or surely due to tone or sensory issues, thinking they are having a mental health breakdown when they are overwhelmed. Communication issues can mean that autistic people can minimise or not adequately explain their symptoms and discomfort levels. Having a diagnosis on your notes will reduce the risk of these things happening. You say you are good at masking but how is your masking when you are in pain and haven't slept for 2 nights on a noisy ward?

There are positives to diagnosis and those positives become greater and greater as stigma reduces and education increases.

Fifi0000 · 14/03/2023 11:13

bunhead1979 · 14/03/2023 11:07

My “label” has been life changing for me. I don’t feel such a complete failure and now i know why i find everything so difficult compared to others, I understand my reaction and know how to keep a better eye on my mental health.

You don’t have to tell anyone. My nhs doctors don’t know, nor do my workplace, i disclose on a “need to know basis”.

in the 90s when i was a teen, anything “different” or related to mental health was swept under the carpet to keep up appearances. My parents knew how bad things were for me (eating disorders, terrible mental health, self harm) but had no idea how to approach it.

This is good , I'm not advocating that people don't get a diagnosis. I know I do have ASD I work in the field but working in the field has allowed to accept myself many of the staff are also ND. If I worked somewhere that just had NT people I would really struggle. As I work in this field I know how hard it is for patients to get equal access to physical healthcare. We are working on it but it will take years for complete equality. As I can function and assimilate with NT people when needed I don't think a diagnosis would be helpful on my medical records.

bellswithwhistles · 14/03/2023 11:11

It absolutely still happens now. I teach a child who clearly has ADHD and ASD. Mum and Dad in denial and even talk about 'those type ' of children and aren't we thankful our child isn't like that.

mychildrenarealiens · 14/03/2023 11:10

Fifi0000 · 14/03/2023 11:03

Well it's your son , diagnostic over shadowing affects females more than males. Women are thought of as being more hysterical already add on a diagnosis and health inequalities rise.

The same goes for my DD. We just have more experience with DS having other conditions.
This is just our experience, as we all know, the health service in the UK varies wildly but it's only been a positive experience for us. (Getting the diagnosis on the other hand...)

bunhead1979 · 14/03/2023 11:07

My “label” has been life changing for me. I don’t feel such a complete failure and now i know why i find everything so difficult compared to others, I understand my reaction and know how to keep a better eye on my mental health.

You don’t have to tell anyone. My nhs doctors don’t know, nor do my workplace, i disclose on a “need to know basis”.

in the 90s when i was a teen, anything “different” or related to mental health was swept under the carpet to keep up appearances. My parents knew how bad things were for me (eating disorders, terrible mental health, self harm) but had no idea how to approach it.

GettingStuffed · 14/03/2023 11:07

My husband refused to get our son assessed for ADHD as he didn't want him labelled.

mychildrenarealiens · 14/03/2023 11:04

SpinningFloppa · 14/03/2023 10:56

It has for me I took my daughter to the doctors for something (physical problem) and as soon as I told the doctor she was autistic (I had to because dd was being difficult and not wanting to cooperate in showing them) the doctor decided there was no problem and put it down as attention seeking. Thought I won’t mention it next time!

This is a doctor problem not an autism problem. Many parents with dc with Autism will quickly become more knowledgeable than some (not all) GPs and it imperative that you learn to advocate for your child (same sentiment goes for some schools/teachers etc).

Fifi0000 · 14/03/2023 11:03

mychildrenarealiens · 14/03/2023 10:55

My DS has autism, as well as other conditions, and it has never affected/hindered the diagnosis of another condition.

The only effect the ASD has had, is the methods used to treat other conditions. For example he may have a play specialist available when starting a new treatment or they may discuss with us first the best way to proceed before starting a treatment, he see's a specialist dentist etc etc.

So in our experience having the Autism diagnosis has only ever been a positive thing.

Well it's your son , diagnostic over shadowing affects females more than males. Women are thought of as being more hysterical already add on a diagnosis and health inequalities rise.

brianixon · 14/03/2023 11:03

The remark upthread about "just badly behaved brats with too many E numbers in their diet" reminded me of our neighbours.
The boy and another one terrorised the junior school, were trouble makers in the Comp but 'grew out of it' by teen age.
If they had been classified; would the condition have perpetuated?
I am aware of the contradictions in this post but it reflects attitudes that were fairly common.

SpinningFloppa · 14/03/2023 10:56

It has for me I took my daughter to the doctors for something (physical problem) and as soon as I told the doctor she was autistic (I had to because dd was being difficult and not wanting to cooperate in showing them) the doctor decided there was no problem and put it down as attention seeking. Thought I won’t mention it next time!

mychildrenarealiens · 14/03/2023 10:55

Fifi0000 · 14/03/2023 10:40

Because of diagnostic over shadowing it affects all your medical care it even causes death. If you go in saying you are having physical health issues it's common they will look to blame your diagnosis instead of thoroughly investigating. I would only pursue a diagnosis if it was severe. I know I have ASD, I was bullied had very repetitive routines. I had to train myself to understand socialising and mask. School did say they wanted to get me assessed and maybe I would be happier in a special school. I was actually intelligent and my parents knew a special school didn't offer many qualifications.

I still wouldn't pursue an NHS diagnosis now because it's mild. I've learnt to mask , masking feels like second nature to me but as soon as I get home I let go and allow myself to stim etc. I sometimes even stim at work where theres a lot of ND people. I don't think a diagnosis would help me in the long term. I accept who I am and have the coping mechanisms in place. The world will always have some discrimination so if I can get by without the diagnosis I will.

My DS has autism, as well as other conditions, and it has never affected/hindered the diagnosis of another condition.

The only effect the ASD has had, is the methods used to treat other conditions. For example he may have a play specialist available when starting a new treatment or they may discuss with us first the best way to proceed before starting a treatment, he see's a specialist dentist etc etc.

So in our experience having the Autism diagnosis has only ever been a positive thing.

springrises · 14/03/2023 10:54

I work with young people who have ASD and am part of the assessment team.
I'm always a bit depressed when people say "what's the point of a diagnosis" and pedal myths about it being a bad thing on your
NHS records. You don't have to disclose the diagnosis if you don't want to. It's entirely personal. The single most important benefit of a diagnosis, imo, is not the support you either do or don't get afterwards, but the self acceptance and understanding of self which emerges as a result of the diagnosis. Most of the older teens and adults I've seen post diagnosis are just massively relieved that finally they understand why they've felt different their whole lives, why they feel like a triangle shoved into a square, why they're anxious, couldn't attend school, have OCD, have an eating disorder, sensory sensitivities, social awkwardness, struggle with eye contact, struggle to form friendships etc.
For the first time, they realise they're not broken or defective, but have a neuro developmental condition which affects the structure of their brain. To deny it, or to decline a diagnosis, is neglectful at best, abusive and harmful at worst.

Sugarfree23 · 14/03/2023 10:52

@Fifi0000 I honestly don't know if I'm doing the right thing or the wrong thing keeping DC on the list 🤔 I've never disclosed it to anyone.

When I was in school I never told anyone that it was suspected I was dyslexic. I was ashamed, embarrassed, hurt, 😳 😔 😟 I struggle to put into words how I felt. Now I couldn't give a toss who knows. And I did eventually pursue a formal diagnosis. It's my short-term/ working memory that shit.

So from that aspect I think I'm doing the right thing but ....

NeedToChangeName · 14/03/2023 10:49

GeorgiaGirl52 · 14/03/2023 10:34

As a parent and a school counselor in the 80s - 90s, I saw both sides of this.
ADHD could be cured by diet = no red food dyes, no sugar, and a cup of black coffee every morning before school. For boys, a few laps around the playground would calm hyperactivity.
There was no autistic "spectrum". Severe autism was mental illness and exclusion from public school was the cure. Mild behaviors - OCD, lack of appropriate emotion, etc. were quirks dealt with by the individual teachers.
Many parents refused psychological testing because they did not want their child labeled as "mental" in official records.

@GeorgiaGirl52 Also highlighting this great post

NeedToChangeName · 14/03/2023 10:48

HoppingPavlova · 14/03/2023 10:26

@Anxiousanx Aspergers okay, so the diagnosis you were going to receive must have been after 1994 as it literally could not have been a diagnosis before then (can’t formally diagnose if not in DSM). The fact the school flagged something in the 80’s is moot as nothing could have come if this prior to 94 so your parents were not at fault at all prior to this.

It seems you are looking at a diagnosis through today’s lens. In the time period you refer, schools were not set up to support this, it took quite some time to roll out so you are really expecting your parents to agree to what is a new diagnosis not known/understood at that time that would have received zero support at a school as it took them several years to get their heads around it and associated required supports. That’s quite unreasonable.

Before the overhaul of the DSM at this time and then the years it took for people/schools to ‘implement’, people who would have subsequently been diagnosed with Asperger’s were often shifted off to the area Special School with odd labels that often included forms of retardation (not my term, but the term in use at time), simply because there was nothing that ‘fitted’ before then. This created stigma. It wasn’t necessarily an individuals’ parents stigma but societal stigma at that point. The Special School in my area in this era was actually called ‘xxx School for the Retarded’. This is where people like yourself would likely have gone in this era with a label before people got their heads around what the DSM revisions really meant in practice. Not sure how guilty your parents are for being cautious in this time period.

@HoppingPavlova I'm highlighting this post so more people see it

Untitledsquatboulder · 14/03/2023 10:45

It was allowed then, as it is now, because in law parents not the state, make the majority of decisions about a child's wellbeing, including educational and medical decisions. The presumption is that parents have the child's best interests at heart and generally this is the case. The threshold of state interference in bringing up a child is quite high. In most cases this is a good thing.

FrownedUpon · 14/03/2023 10:41

Still happens, particularly with borderline cases. Parents can take a diagnosis or not. It’s bonkers.

Fifi0000 · 14/03/2023 10:40

Sugarfree23 · 14/03/2023 10:22

Why wouldn't you want it on NHS records?

Because of diagnostic over shadowing it affects all your medical care it even causes death. If you go in saying you are having physical health issues it's common they will look to blame your diagnosis instead of thoroughly investigating. I would only pursue a diagnosis if it was severe. I know I have ASD, I was bullied had very repetitive routines. I had to train myself to understand socialising and mask. School did say they wanted to get me assessed and maybe I would be happier in a special school. I was actually intelligent and my parents knew a special school didn't offer many qualifications.

I still wouldn't pursue an NHS diagnosis now because it's mild. I've learnt to mask , masking feels like second nature to me but as soon as I get home I let go and allow myself to stim etc. I sometimes even stim at work where theres a lot of ND people. I don't think a diagnosis would help me in the long term. I accept who I am and have the coping mechanisms in place. The world will always have some discrimination so if I can get by without the diagnosis I will.

Dixiechickonhols · 14/03/2023 10:40

Do you know your family history? There may have been a friend or relative ‘sent away’ that prayed heavily on their minds.
I went to a photography exhibition based on a local asylum and what struck me most was how recent some of the photos were - dating from my childhood yet very young children and adults with Down’s syndrome etc shit away in a Victorian institution.

DaisyBoop · 14/03/2023 10:39

It’s not just the 80s/90s, definitely not.

cocksstrideintheevening · 14/03/2023 10:37

I have recently had an asd diagnoses, at 43. My mum will not engage or talk about it at all. Apparently labels don't help. Well it's helped me massively.

NettleTea · 14/03/2023 10:37

you also have to take into account that there are hereditary elements to ASD, and so often parents may not notice things, or want comments about things / labels, because they do the things themselves and consider them quite normal. Plus they may feel that the eyes turn on them, and they DEFINATELY dont want a lavel, especially if they come from an older generation where any kind of disability was a stigma.

Its often only when the wheels come off that they notice that there is a problem, and it highlights it. And todays world is far more stressfull and involves alot more sensory input than even a few years back, so the struggles often show up where they may not have done in the past. Looking back through the generations I can follow my ASD down the family line.

Zone2NorthLondon · 14/03/2023 10:36

To reassure you,any clinical assessment is about you,not your mum,you
The doctor will ask you about what you experience,mood,behaviour, your education and social history. An account of your presentation growing up. Were you under CAMHS etc? If yes the Doctor will seek their documentation. Your mother is not involved in your assessment

GeorgiaGirl52 · 14/03/2023 10:34

As a parent and a school counselor in the 80s - 90s, I saw both sides of this.
ADHD could be cured by diet = no red food dyes, no sugar, and a cup of black coffee every morning before school. For boys, a few laps around the playground would calm hyperactivity.
There was no autistic "spectrum". Severe autism was mental illness and exclusion from public school was the cure. Mild behaviors - OCD, lack of appropriate emotion, etc. were quirks dealt with by the individual teachers.
Many parents refused psychological testing because they did not want their child labeled as "mental" in official records.

Swipe left for the next trending thread