Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why was this allowed in the 80s/90s?

205 replies

Anxiousanx · 14/03/2023 08:49

My parents were allowed to decline my ASD diagnosis ?

At age 8 the school started pushing for meetings with them and I was having severe difficulties. They didn’t want to engage.
The following year the school had someone come in to observe me.
My parents made it clear to me I wasn’t to ‘get a label’ and needed to ‘behave normally’

2 years later at a different school with even more difficulty I was involved in meetings and had to go to what i assume was camhs or whatever it was called then ?
I saw doctors and a speech therapist and I think a psychiatrist?
My parents were given the likely diagnosis and asked did they want to proceed with that and said no as again, didn’t want me to have a label and this was allowed ?
I’ve seen some of the clinic letters in recent years and I’m really astounded and don’t understand why this was allowed ?

OP posts:
Untitledsquatboulder · 15/03/2023 19:11

3WildOnes · 15/03/2023 09:51

@Daftasabroom I'm curious how you found a diagnosis beneficial once you got to teens and university? In my experience the main benefit of a diagnosis in the older years is being able to read up on asd and gain more insight and understanding of your own behaviours as well as feeling less alone and like you are less 'defective'.

A friend of mine is emoyed by our local University to support students with SEN. Sometimes this means she scribes for them but on several occasions she has worked as a companion for students with asd, accompanying them to lectures, the library, shops, social events etc for the first term to provide support whilst they accustom themselves to the campus and University living.

Bakingcupcake · 15/03/2023 19:03

I work in adult mental health, we send out patient questionnaires one is the CAST questionnaire for parents/carer to fill out if possible, but it's not a defining questionnaire so parents don't have to be involved as many older adults may not have communication with their said parents/carers still or they may not be around etc

LaughingCat · 15/03/2023 18:58

Anxiousanx · 14/03/2023 10:19

The bit that makes me most upset is my mother told the school to treat me as if it was bad behaviour and make no allowances because she thought that would make me ‘behave normally’ and I had a particularly nasty head of year at secondary who made my life hell and reminded me my mother had asked her to have ‘zero tolerance’

That would massively upset me as well. My parents told the school to challenge me with harder work and less flexibility for my ‘quirks’ so I remember things getting really bleak - I would have been 6 in 1989, so only two years behind you.

I’ve got the diagnosis now - you can fill in your own childhood examples and have someone provide evidence of your behaviour now (so they don’t have to have known you as a child). My other half did mine for me on that basis. I, too, went to my mum and some of the things she said…well, let’s just say, I didn’t think it worth involving her further in the process.

Good luck - it really will change your life x

niugboo · 15/03/2023 18:57

Take the paperwork to a doctor. You would get a diagnosis no problem.

Flymum70 · 15/03/2023 18:51

JudgeRudy · 14/03/2023 23:34

Sadly it works both ways. There are parents describing bizarre or out of control behaviour at home but because the school have not observed it, it's very hard to even get approved for an assessment. The parent is presumed to be doing something wrong. This happens especially with autistic girls who only feel 'secure enough' to be their true self at home, sometimes even only with mum.

This....my son, 13, is clearly neuroduverse, major sensory issues, meltdowns (usually in the evening after a day at school masking), always interrupts. He has visual stress, is exceptionally hyperactive (luckily he's sporty), but is in the bottom sets at school as just can't focus long enough. He holds grudges against anyone who has ever wronged him, has such a clear cut opinion if what he considers right or wrong.

I did start to go down the private diagnosis route, but the school's evidence just wasn't strong enough and I gave up. To be fair the SENCO did say "we just deal with the child we're dealt with on the day" so will try and support him if he's having trouble. But is a big school with children with bigger issues, so mostly his issues at school are largely ignored unless he really disrupts the class. But I know it means their academic expectations for him are much lower than they should be. He's as quick as anything, visual/auditory learner, but whiteboards and books don't work for him.

He's also seen pyscologists and counsellers over the years and I watch on as he fools them with his alter ego, the butter wouldn't melt in his mouth approach. None of them suggested we get an ASD diagnosis

His dad also is neuroduverse, as someone neurological, I eventually realised I could not live happily with his different approach to life. When I suggested to his dad he may have ASD, he flew off the handle, was highly insulted and that was the nail in the coffin for our marriage. I think if he'd accepted it we may have found ways to work round his quirks, instead he said he couldn't live with someone who thought he was "mental". No matter how much I tried to explain it was just because we thought on different plains, he was not willing to.listen. Subsequently his dad has never been supportive of my getting him diagnosed.

I am exhausted most of the time, relieved when my son behaves 'nornally', but always on edge expecting a meltdown. The other day he had a complete meltdown because his den, where he watches TV was too messy and he didn't know where to start with tidying it, so I had to help him methodically tidy it. His dad can calm him down as they have a similar approach to life, but I have my son 90% of the time, so his behaviour is down to me to manage.

....that just felt very good to get off my chest...a bit of therapy in my chaotic world with my son!

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 15/03/2023 18:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BertieBotts · 15/03/2023 18:16

fairycakes1234 · 15/03/2023 11:32

My son is currently on waiting list to be assessed, I suspect he has aspergers, its very mild whatever he has and my family have said , its just him, why are you getting him assessed. I said i suspect I also have apspergers or ADHD, and their answer is, well it didnt stop you having a successful career, and youre married with kids, so why put a label on him,they reckon if i had of known would i have achieved these things or would i have limited myself? I am still getting him assessed regardless but it did give me food for thought. I always thought i was a bit different, but my friends always say im just quirky

This is really interesting, I would like to understand this mindset. The part about would you have done all these things or would you have limited yourself.

Is that perhaps coming from a place of self image, so they worry that if you see yourself as a person with XYZ then you'll use that as a reason just to sit back and not try?

That's really strange to me because I've always seen it as quite the opposite. Like I'm just some fuck up so I shouldn't try, whereas if I can see oh no, I'm actually not, it was my ADHD interfering with that. Well then I know what I need to work around.

This must come from perhaps some kind of, is it a Protestant work ethic thing? The idea that nobody really wants to work hard, but it's morally right to do so, so you have to make yourself. But anybody would take an excuse if they could, not to have to work because nobody wants to really. And therefore there ends up with this kind of gatekeeping around what they see as excuses vs genuine reasons.

Huh. Well that suddenly makes many things make a lot more sense.

MrsWeasley · 15/03/2023 18:10

Still happens now. If parents refuse to engage or listen there is nothing schools can do in terms of getting a diagnosis however all schools will offer support to ensure a pupils needs are met (diagnosis or not).

pollymere · 15/03/2023 18:10

It still happens now 😢 People are scared to get support for their kids because they're scared of labels.

Miisty · 15/03/2023 17:57

My son was one of the first to be diagnosed in Somerset with ADHD we got asked did we smack him punish him all by a bullying headmaster who made it clear he didn’t want him at his comprehensive Spent more time at home No school work set up doomed to fail several attempts at suicide His sisters are both successfull No support from social services and then CAMNHs stopped between 16-18

fairycakes1234 · 15/03/2023 11:32

My son is currently on waiting list to be assessed, I suspect he has aspergers, its very mild whatever he has and my family have said , its just him, why are you getting him assessed. I said i suspect I also have apspergers or ADHD, and their answer is, well it didnt stop you having a successful career, and youre married with kids, so why put a label on him,they reckon if i had of known would i have achieved these things or would i have limited myself? I am still getting him assessed regardless but it did give me food for thought. I always thought i was a bit different, but my friends always say im just quirky

JazbayGrapes · 15/03/2023 11:01

Because back then, you would have been barred from education, jobs, even driving a car. The support systems for neurodiverse people also barely existed.

Lozois99 · 15/03/2023 10:21

Anxiousanx · 14/03/2023 08:56

No because I need someone to do my childhood history and my mother refuses so I don’t think I can ?

I had this issue and it can also be done by a friend or a partner who has known you a very long time.

3WildOnes · 15/03/2023 10:15

@worstofbothworlds and you wouldn't make those adjustments for someone without a diagnosis but who needed them? I know that we have been incredibly lucky that nursery and both schools have been happy to make adjustments without.
That wouldn't really be applicable for my son currently but it is good to know and I will bear it in mind and let him know that once he gets to university that there may be avenues of support cut off from him if he doesn't have a diagnosis.

Daftasabroom · 15/03/2023 10:11

Self awareness and being able to contextualise the dynamics between himself and the world. It also unlocked a lot of support at university that would not otherwise been available.

worstofbothworlds · 15/03/2023 10:10

3WildOnes · 15/03/2023 09:51

@Daftasabroom I'm curious how you found a diagnosis beneficial once you got to teens and university? In my experience the main benefit of a diagnosis in the older years is being able to read up on asd and gain more insight and understanding of your own behaviours as well as feeling less alone and like you are less 'defective'.

I'm a lecturer and we have quite a lot of adjustments allowed for students with diagnoses/additional needs. For example, a student who found crowded rooms stressful could sit their exams in a room on their own/with just one or two others.

3WildOnes · 15/03/2023 09:51

@Daftasabroom I'm curious how you found a diagnosis beneficial once you got to teens and university? In my experience the main benefit of a diagnosis in the older years is being able to read up on asd and gain more insight and understanding of your own behaviours as well as feeling less alone and like you are less 'defective'.

3WildOnes · 15/03/2023 09:46

Daftasabroom · 15/03/2023 08:29

@3WildOnes I'd urge you to read this thread.

I am not sure how that thread is relevant to my situation. The parent in that thread is, understandably, upset that her son was excluded from accessing support from the children's disability team and at school. It seems that the school were negligent in taking the time to understand her son and make reasonable adjustments.
My child would be so so far from reaching the thresholds for receiving help from the child disability team. He wouldn't meet any thresholds for accessing support from camhs, diagnosis or not.
Our nursery and primary school were excellent at picking up that my son has sone additional needs. We had a fantastic transition meeting with the senco before he started and they made adjustments from day 1 that enabled him to thrive in primary school. I know that we were incredibly lucky in this regard and in most cases a diagnosis and an EHCP would be needed to unlock the level of support we received. We were aware that the transition to secondary school is often a tricky time and luckily we could afford to go private. We chose a school that has lots of experience supporting children with high functioning asd and thankfully all is going well so far. My son knows that he has 'autistic traits' as defined by camhs and salt so he is able to read up on what that means and explore his feeling around what that means for him.

My post was never intending to discourage others from seeking a diagnosis. If our circumstances had been different and we had found support lacking then we would have.

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 15/03/2023 09:01

Dh has mild dyslexia and less mild dyscalculia. In the 70s his parents refused to have him tested as it would have been the end for him - and to be fair at that time in his area he would have been written off. (And nobody had heard of dyscalculia then anyway).

In the late 90s I took my son to a private child psychiatrist and was told I was a fussy middle class mum and that all children are different.
Ds is autistic.
He flunked school and was miserable there, viewed as a lazy geek not living up to his potential (by teachers).

Things were very different, even 25 years ago.

Daftasabroom · 15/03/2023 08:29

@3WildOnes I'd urge you to read this thread.

Daftasabroom · 15/03/2023 08:26

3WildOnes · 15/03/2023 08:15

I honestly have zero prejudices. We have read books on asd together. I have offered more support that he would ever have been offered through the NHS and I know the process well as I work in mental health. I regularly see how children struggling with anxiety and depression are dismissed as soon as camhs are aware that they have an asd diagnosis. I see that once you have a diagnosis you are left to fend for yourselves. Obviously there are circumstances where it is beneficial to pursue a diagnosis, especially when your chiold needs more support in school that school are offering but we weren't encountering those particular barriers.

Then there are the restrictions a diagnosis places on emigration.

In our experience it wasn't really the external support we got, or didn't get. And it wasn't such a big deal when he was younger. The biggest difference was being able to navigate teens and now University.

3WildOnes · 15/03/2023 08:15

Daftasabroom · 14/03/2023 22:08

He's obviously too young to make that choice but, I just asked DS 20yo, diagnosed 7yo; he would prefer a diagnosis than not to know.

My life would have been incredibly different if I had had an understanding of how AdHD affected me.

It helps a person to understand their dynamics with others. Sorry that's very badly phrased.

Don't let your prejudices damage your children.

I honestly have zero prejudices. We have read books on asd together. I have offered more support that he would ever have been offered through the NHS and I know the process well as I work in mental health. I regularly see how children struggling with anxiety and depression are dismissed as soon as camhs are aware that they have an asd diagnosis. I see that once you have a diagnosis you are left to fend for yourselves. Obviously there are circumstances where it is beneficial to pursue a diagnosis, especially when your chiold needs more support in school that school are offering but we weren't encountering those particular barriers.

Then there are the restrictions a diagnosis places on emigration.

Fifi0000 · 15/03/2023 00:31

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 14/03/2023 15:19

This 100% my diagnosis mh diagnosis(not autism) has almost got me killed multiple times by nhs hospitals

I already have MH diagnosis of depression on there from when I was teen !!! I absolutely don't want another one added, it would make it worse. I've started using private healthcare when I can I just don't trust the NHS and I see it a lot. Someone was left with months with a huge ovarian cyst they blamed it on mh issues she had so nothing was done and in the end had to have open surgery as it had grown so large. It's so common to be labelled as a hysterical woman the added ASD diagnosis would make things worse.

JudgeRudy · 14/03/2023 23:34

Sadly it works both ways. There are parents describing bizarre or out of control behaviour at home but because the school have not observed it, it's very hard to even get approved for an assessment. The parent is presumed to be doing something wrong. This happens especially with autistic girls who only feel 'secure enough' to be their true self at home, sometimes even only with mum.

JudgeRudy · 14/03/2023 23:26

PsychoHotSauce · 14/03/2023 08:57

Do you mean why were they allowed to just dismiss your likely diagnosis and not forced to pursue it?

Don't forget that understanding and support was very different and lacking back then. I grew up in the 90s and kids at school with obvious ADHD were dismissed as "brats with no discipline at home and too many E numbers in their diet".

Autism, particularly high functioning, was waved away as being pig-headed, stubborn and selfish/lacking empathy.

I think I can understand your parents thinking. It feels unfair to put a label on a child but have little to no support to go with that "label". Its different now.

My adult cousin is an electrician. He's a normal decent balanced individual with a great personality. He also has dyslexia. In 70s/80s he attended a 'special school' for 'the retards and the spazs'. His IQ is at least average. In his class were kids with behavioural problems, mental ill health, epilepsy, autism, polio etc. His self esteem went down until he teansferred to a mainstream school with appropriate special ed provision. When someone from the next generation was 'suspected ' of having ADHD the parents were understandably reluctant to engage. His 'label' did not help him one bit...his sports coach did!

Swipe left for the next trending thread