Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why was this allowed in the 80s/90s?

205 replies

Anxiousanx · 14/03/2023 08:49

My parents were allowed to decline my ASD diagnosis ?

At age 8 the school started pushing for meetings with them and I was having severe difficulties. They didn’t want to engage.
The following year the school had someone come in to observe me.
My parents made it clear to me I wasn’t to ‘get a label’ and needed to ‘behave normally’

2 years later at a different school with even more difficulty I was involved in meetings and had to go to what i assume was camhs or whatever it was called then ?
I saw doctors and a speech therapist and I think a psychiatrist?
My parents were given the likely diagnosis and asked did they want to proceed with that and said no as again, didn’t want me to have a label and this was allowed ?
I’ve seen some of the clinic letters in recent years and I’m really astounded and don’t understand why this was allowed ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 16:42

Sorry that was a bit garbled, but I hope what I meant is clear. It's really sad that so many parents of adults who suffered with no diagnosis or understanding still behave in this way and refuse to try to engage in discussion when their children try to find a way to heal their wounds and move forwards. And also refuse to support their children trying to provide better childhoods for their grandchildren; in fact in so many cases they actively try to undermine their children trying put that in place for their own children, driving their children even further away from them and destroying any chance of mutual understand and acceptance, expecting their children to sacrifice their own children's wellbeing to avoid "offending" them and them having to recognise that their parenting was lacking, to put it kindly. It's really sad.

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 13:37

"This navel gazing is self-indulgent", "people didn't have time for such unhelpfil introspection and complaining in the past", "we had so much harder childhoods and just got on with it" etc. In my case massively ironic giving said people did nothing to protect me from sexual abuse then left me to live alone and provide for myself as a traumatised, undiagnosed autistic 16 year old. 🤣 While they went on very expensive holidays. Because housing me wouldn't "fit with their commitments". The irony is lost on them, apparently.

There is something about that generation in question where - and of course this is a generalisation, but it seems remarkably common - they tend to have a huge inability to admit when they have made a mistake. Or even utter the word "sorry", or recognise the impact of their behaviour and (lack of) parenting in particular. As if they somehow think it's beneath them to admit that they are flawed humans like the rest of us, and made mistakes, and own the impact of those mistakes or even discuss them openly. And that in itself compounds the damage done.

Again, I know from all of my adult autistic friends that I am very far from alone in this experience. In fact many NT adult friends have experienced similar attitudes from their parents on other topics. It seems to be a generational problem about a tendency (again not all of them!!! But a large proportion) being unable to apologise or communicate properly or acknowledge the impact of their behaviour on others. And this destroys family relationships that could be repaired. The OP's parents seem to have a similarly defensive and damaging attitude - rather than being open about the situation at the time and their reasons and being defensive and shutting down any conversation, invalidating her experience, rather than reflecting and explaining why they did what they did and acknowledging the impact it had and how, even in those circumstances, they could have done more to support her at home at the very least - and that is a great shame.

saraclara · 16/03/2023 13:30

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 13:23

@saraclara it would be a lot easier to forgive the choices many parents made at that time if they would acknowledge that it did do damage, that instead of denying their children needed any support that wasn't available in education they'd at least have tried to show support and understanding at home and not punish autistic children for having sensory difficulties and meltdowns, and if now that they are adults and finally have diagnoses they'd stop gaslighting their children pretending it's not real - "in my day we called it personality", "this attention-seeking does you no favours", "stop being a drama llama", "just get on with it and stop complaining" etc - and then telling us we are "damaging" our own children by showing them love, understanding and support and giving them the tools they need to navigate life more successfully without huge damage to mental health, instead of ignoring their needs and telling them they are weak and pathetic and need to "get a grip".

It's one thing to say society wouldn't have helped us with a diagnosis. It's another entirely to excuse parents who could see their children were different and struggling and either punished them for that or ignored it entirely. It would be a lot easier to forgive the mistakes if they acknowledged the mistakes, and stopped trying to gaslight us into not supporting our own children properly either because that might reflect badly on their own parenting or lead to uncomfortable questions about their own conditions that they don't want to engage with. How utterly selfish: to be prepared to ruin the lives for another generation of ND children because you find the topic uncomfortable. I know I am far from alone in this experience.

I'm sorry that you've endured that, and I don't excuse present day ignorance and intolerance.

I think you can forgive the choice, while still expecting, if not an apology, at least some consideration. And active cruelty is inexcusable whatever the context.

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 13:23

@saraclara it would be a lot easier to forgive the choices many parents made at that time if they would acknowledge that it did do damage, that instead of denying their children needed any support that wasn't available in education they'd at least have tried to show support and understanding at home and not punish autistic children for having sensory difficulties and meltdowns, and if now that they are adults and finally have diagnoses they'd stop gaslighting their children pretending it's not real - "in my day we called it personality", "this attention-seeking does you no favours", "stop being a drama llama", "just get on with it and stop complaining" etc - and then telling us we are "damaging" our own children by showing them love, understanding and support and giving them the tools they need to navigate life more successfully without huge damage to mental health, instead of ignoring their needs and telling them they are weak and pathetic and need to "get a grip".

It's one thing to say society wouldn't have helped us with a diagnosis. It's another entirely to excuse parents who could see their children were different and struggling and either punished them for that or ignored it entirely. It would be a lot easier to forgive the mistakes if they acknowledged the mistakes, and stopped trying to gaslight us into not supporting our own children properly either because that might reflect badly on their own parenting or lead to uncomfortable questions about their own conditions that they don't want to engage with. How utterly selfish: to be prepared to ruin the lives for another generation of ND children because you find the topic uncomfortable. I know I am far from alone in this experience.

saraclara · 16/03/2023 13:00

Your parents were making choices in very different circumstances from education today. They did what they thought was best for you.

That. I was teaching in a special school back then, and autism diagnosis was actually quite rare.
But fundamentally there was a huge feeling that 'labelling' was a bad thing. Obviously those of us in special education didn't believe that, but in the general population it was pretty much what everyone thought. SEND help in mainstream schools was almost non-existent, so parents would think there was no point, because it's not as though the diagnosis would open any doors.

Seriously @Anxiousanx , as parents we can only do what feels right at the time. I understand your frustration, but your parents were far from alone in thinking and acting this way. They'd be a minority now, as awareness and support ad proressed massively (if still not enough). But back then they were in the majority in feeling this way.

I do hope that you will now get the help you need, but I can also understand your mum doubling down out of defensiveness. It's hard to deal with having let your child down, even though you thought you were doing the right thing.

Osiansmummy1 · 16/03/2023 12:55

Hi cahms told me that had happened here north wales.. Op you dont need parents involvement at all.

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 12:43

And OP - yes you can get a diagnosis even without anybody to provide history. You have some documents and information. Many peoole end up going through diagnosis without parents to input either because they won't or because they are dead, given so many of us were missed in childhood.

I hope far fewer parents of this generation choose to deny their children diagnosis because the damage that does can be immense.

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 12:36

I encounter these attitudes still from my parents. I and my siblings struggled through school with no diagnoses or support. No self-understanding. Trashed self-esteem. One sibling (straight A student all through school, first at University) because an alcoholic. Then emigrated to the other side of the world and has no contact with family. I ended up suicidal. Also straight A student, same stuff, good career... but, the damage done is huge. No support with social relationships, trashed self-esteem, bullying. We were so vulnerable and nobody protected us. I waited until 30 to marry, someone I'd known and lived with long term. But they turned out to be abusive. The damage is huge, of living life undiagnosed. I know many autistic adults diagnosed as adults and without exception diagnosis has been positive for every single one.

This article resonates with many of the adult autistic women I know:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-64953941

My parents still want to pretend autism isn't real, it doesn't exist, call it a "label". It's not a "label" any more than any other medical diagnosis. It's a statement of reality. Denying it invalidates the experiences of autistic people and makes us suffer in silence.

The NHS put my young children on the pathway but told me that they'd be waiting until pretty much the end of primary to have the assessment. Meaning their learning and ability to enjoy school and engage and be supported in early education would be trashed. And then no surprise that going to secondary they'd disengage entirely like I did. My attendance during GCSE years was 12%. Why would I want to repeat this for them? Yes I still got A*s because I'm academically able, but that doesn't mean my life wasn't a living hell.

So I've funded private diagnosis for them both, and they have got that now from early primary school. It's all very well saying that support in schools is meant to be needs based and great that some schools adhere to that but I was fobbed off and blamed and ignored until they had the diagnosis. Now it's a different story.

Untitledsquatboulder · 16/03/2023 12:03

@Osiansmummy1 where have you heard this? Which country?

Osiansmummy1 · 16/03/2023 10:55

Hi I have heard of some children who have been diagnosed suing the diagnoser for "ruining their lives with the diagnosis " maybe your parents (incorrectly) thought this would adversely affect you instead of help you get support and know yourself better. How do you feel about them refusing the diagnosis?

Airz · 16/03/2023 09:32

i had a similar problem I went to my doctor and they referred me to the ADHD service after asking me a series of questions, before my appointment I was messaged links to fill in asking about my life now as a child and school about my work life eck I answered all questions as best as I could as I have no contact with my dad and mum is deceased, I then had my appointment where they went into the questions asked in a bit more detail and was diagnosed with ADHD I am 40 now, see if you can go down this route and good luck

TomeTome · 16/03/2023 00:35

he is clearly in need of some sensory integration therapy and some social skills courses and a label would really help with getting that how? Diagnosis isn’t linked to support in that way here (SW)

Overnightoats1 · 15/03/2023 23:26

Have a friend at the moment who refuses to "give his son a label".. he is clearly in need of some sensory integration therapy and some social skills courses and a label would really help with getting that for this sweet child who is really struggling .. it is so much easier when kids are given therapy when they are younger too instead of lletting them struggle for years x

T1Dmama · 15/03/2023 23:26

Parents still have to give permission for assessments.

Firsttimer9981 · 15/03/2023 22:02

My comment was in response to the OPs about not being able to get a diagnosis as an adult...

Firsttimer9981 · 15/03/2023 22:01

You don't need a parent to do your childhood history. My husband did my informant form and he's only known me since I was 20. I filled in as much as I could about my own childhood. Got a diagnosis a few weeks ago at the age of 35.

Clarabe1 · 15/03/2023 21:58

My mum still still thinks it’s a terrible thing for a child to be given a ‘label’. It was the thinking back then I’m afraid. Pull yourself together and act normal

JhsLs · 15/03/2023 21:56

In the borough I work in, you need parental consent to even raise a child in question with the Ed Psych, let alone for them to be observed or worked with. It makes pursuing any sort of diagnosis impossible if the parents decline.

JudgeRudy · 15/03/2023 21:42

Flymum70 · 15/03/2023 18:51

This....my son, 13, is clearly neuroduverse, major sensory issues, meltdowns (usually in the evening after a day at school masking), always interrupts. He has visual stress, is exceptionally hyperactive (luckily he's sporty), but is in the bottom sets at school as just can't focus long enough. He holds grudges against anyone who has ever wronged him, has such a clear cut opinion if what he considers right or wrong.

I did start to go down the private diagnosis route, but the school's evidence just wasn't strong enough and I gave up. To be fair the SENCO did say "we just deal with the child we're dealt with on the day" so will try and support him if he's having trouble. But is a big school with children with bigger issues, so mostly his issues at school are largely ignored unless he really disrupts the class. But I know it means their academic expectations for him are much lower than they should be. He's as quick as anything, visual/auditory learner, but whiteboards and books don't work for him.

He's also seen pyscologists and counsellers over the years and I watch on as he fools them with his alter ego, the butter wouldn't melt in his mouth approach. None of them suggested we get an ASD diagnosis

His dad also is neuroduverse, as someone neurological, I eventually realised I could not live happily with his different approach to life. When I suggested to his dad he may have ASD, he flew off the handle, was highly insulted and that was the nail in the coffin for our marriage. I think if he'd accepted it we may have found ways to work round his quirks, instead he said he couldn't live with someone who thought he was "mental". No matter how much I tried to explain it was just because we thought on different plains, he was not willing to.listen. Subsequently his dad has never been supportive of my getting him diagnosed.

I am exhausted most of the time, relieved when my son behaves 'nornally', but always on edge expecting a meltdown. The other day he had a complete meltdown because his den, where he watches TV was too messy and he didn't know where to start with tidying it, so I had to help him methodically tidy it. His dad can calm him down as they have a similar approach to life, but I have my son 90% of the time, so his behaviour is down to me to manage.

....that just felt very good to get off my chest...a bit of therapy in my chaotic world with my son!

@Flymum70 I hear you. That's the best I can offer I'm afraid but sometimes it is helpful for you to know that someone understands. ❤

Riv · 15/03/2023 21:10

This is a book written by a woman diagnosed as autistic as a very capable adult teacher and skilled training provider. It’s easy to read and explores different perspectives about autism and diagnosis from a variety of autistic people. It’s well worth reading.
Here’s a link to the book

midmodmad · 15/03/2023 20:56

Following

ewright86 · 15/03/2023 20:37

Sadly all of that still happens now.

sunshinemode · 15/03/2023 20:01

I work for CAMHS. We refer our YP to another agency for ASD assessments. Parents can refuse the assessment but once the child reaches 16/17 they have to give their consent too. From about 17 years old if parents refused and was having the difficulties you describe an assessment could be done without parents, they would look for alternative evidence such as information from school or in your case the letters you have from the time you were 8. As an adult your parents will not have to give a history. You will be able to tell them yourself of your struggles

Mrsthingamy · 15/03/2023 19:44

Just wanted to add my experience.
At 2 I expressed concern my daughter had extreme reaction to noise, covering ears and cowering. I was somewhat poo pooed, and told she was just shy.
I decided not to push further, still not sure if I regret this, and she is unsure, but we always had the feeling she was on the spectrum, and I realised later we had accommodated for this by sometimes adapting what we did as we just didn't want her upset.
At 15/16 she decided to seek diagnosis so she 'had a reason and wasn't just weird'.
3 years later she was assessed, I also answered questions, and during lockdown in her university halls she got the diagnosis over a video call.
She said it was a slight anticlimax, and just thought to herself 'I was right'.
Has anything changed since diagnosis? Possibly, she obviously posted on social media her diagnosis, and was astounded by the responses of 'welcome' making her feel more normal, she is quite proud to be who she is, although sometimes gets frustrated with her mind. I don't know if it's just being at university, or that she understands herself better, but she definitely has a greater confidence and is more comfortable with who she is

Hurdling · 15/03/2023 19:22

Hi, you can be diagnosed without a parents interview as an adult especially given the amount of evidence you seem to have from your childhood that can be referred to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread