Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
TheGuv1982 · 14/03/2023 13:04

Whatever the “market rate” is, which given the make up of the industry probably needs to be global(ish).

It doesn’t even have to be wholly salary that makes the package worthwhile. Numerous good ideas on this thread fit into that, from capped hours to the covering of fees and training.

Bumpitybumper · 14/03/2023 13:03

@Botw1
There isn't a bottomless pit of money for anything and if Labour get elected then they too will grapple with this problem.

We need sensible discussions about how the NHS can realistically be funded and resourced going forwards. It was never intended to be what it has grown to be and it is clearly unsustainable in ita current guise, Tories or no Tories.

Giving in to pay demands will only reduce the amount of public money left to spend on vital life saving treatments and training new doctors (heavily subsidised by the government even if the students fees). Too many people on this forum like to be #kind and are desperate to say that they think every cause (immigrants, food banks, nurses, teachers, junior doctors, the disabled etc etc) should be better funded. Of course that's what everyone would ideally do, but most people when they grow up realise that budgeting and economics don't work like that. Spend your money on one thing and you can't afford something else. I wish we could have meaningful discussions about this instead of just banging on about Tories and inefficiencies, which whilst undoubtedly problematic, they are not the root cause of the problem.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 13:02

If you Google doctors leaving the NHS the first top 5 hits are articles saying 4 in 10 junior doctors are leaving /intending to leave

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 13:01

@mids2019

You keep saying this

'think conditions do need improving but increased pay does not solve this; more staff will'

And keep ignoring the fact that we can't get more staff

If there are plenty of doctors why do we have a staffing crisis right now with poor conditions?

If we have plenty of doctors why do we need more?

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 12:57

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 12:46

Botw1 - I don't care. You win. However, doctor's will not get public sympathy if they go for 35%. If you don't like it then leave. Work privately or go abroad. There, I said it. I have actually worked 'abroad' aligned to healthcare and no, doctors pay is no better when taken in the round (ie. purchasing power). If WaitingForEgg is still around than I'd still love to know where the stats on doctors leaving are.

I’m not a statistician. I’m speaking from my personal experience and someone who knows a hell of a lot of doctors. I never claimed to have some kind of log book of how many are leaving. I can tell you that not a single GP practice in my area has a full staffing of doctors. I can tell you that every rota in my local hospital is running on 50-70% of the required doctors. I’m extremely worried about the state of our health service. People cannot get GP appointments. Doctors are burning out.

Frankly I don’t wish to be the last one standing when all my colleagues have left. I’m still here in the nhs working because that’s what I wanted to do. I actually do overall love being a doctor despite the negatives and don’t particularly want leave unless I feel I have to… which I am fast approaching.

I decided to train as a doctor 10 years ago. I did not know that in that time our pay would be what it is now. I didn’t realise than in that time floods of doctors would leave the health service. Neither did the other doctors who “chose” this.

“less people stuck in hospital better for doctors” shows you have never actually worked in a hospital. Obviously these people use minimal amounts of doctors time. We spend most of our time with the sickest patients, not people that are simply waiting for carers. However I do think carers should be much better paid than they are. I worked as a carer before I went to medical school, it’s an extremely difficult job that should be much better paid than it is. It isn’t a race to the bottom.

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 12:56

@Bumpitybumper

Fair point well made. I do have sympathy for nurses as for the majority their career path will not result in the salaries you mention. Additionally I feel there are those on the lowest bands that are in dire conditions due to the cost of living crisis. These deserve priority.

I think conditions do need improving but increased pay does not solve this; more staff will. As you suggest there are plenty willing to embark on careers in medicine despite the onerous conditions and we would be doing ourselves a disservice by not accepting the reason for this is ultimately medicine is a well paid career.

if we do have a socially minded spirit in the NH S do we accept those on the top accept lower pay rises than those at the bottom?

I don't think the medical profession as a whole can carry the argument for more pay to the public; what they want to see is more staff and a better service.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 12:54

@Bumpitybumper

Seems to be a bottomless pit of money for stuff the tories want

@newstart1234

Well, yes.

Thats what is happening

Doctors are leaving and we can't replace them

And then people moan that they can't get treatment.

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 12:49

Care workers should be paid more for the work they do looking after the elderly. OK it's not ontology or surgery but holistically a care worker can add similar levels of life satisfaction to the elderly and infirm. We should look at this that are suffering from the cost of living crisis first and those whose career paths will mean they stay on a relatively static wage. Care workers may not have the luxury of striking depending on how draconian their employers are.

Getting2me · 14/03/2023 12:47

£100

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 12:46

Botw1 - I don't care. You win. However, doctor's will not get public sympathy if they go for 35%. If you don't like it then leave. Work privately or go abroad. There, I said it. I have actually worked 'abroad' aligned to healthcare and no, doctors pay is no better when taken in the round (ie. purchasing power). If WaitingForEgg is still around than I'd still love to know where the stats on doctors leaving are.

Bumpitybumper · 14/03/2023 12:46

I think if we aree not careful then it becomes a bit of a chicken and egg situation.

The NHS is under immense financial strain as we age and become generally less healthy as a society. People talking about it being 'under resourced', ignore the fact that we are now spending in real terms 10x more on the NHS than we were in 1950. There isn't a bottomless pit of taxpayer money available (the burden of taxation in the UK is already extremely high and many families are struggling to cope) so my question is how much would be enough and where do we get the money from?

In this context, I have sympathy with junior doctors who are working very long hours with difficult working conditions for relatively low pay The answer isn't though to just pay them more. Sure, this might help the last part of the conundrum but it may well detract from the other problems they face as money is spent on wages instead on training more much needed doctors and pumping money into improving the facilities and other things that would aid working conditions.

If you had an endless supply of money of course you would tackle all three things, but we need to be realistic and not live in a fantasy world where we blame the mean Tories for not just giving junior doctors and everyone else striking lots of (very limited tax payer) money. Demand for places at medical schools is high and career progression can be lucrative in medicine. Consultants can earn well over £100k and can tout out their services in the private sector for even more money so I would be keen to know whether those who are desperate to write off the student loans of junior doctors think that this is fair when teachers and other vital professions don't have anything like this earning potential and get no such waivers.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 12:40

@newstart1234

I don't need to ask them. I was asking you.

Most carers work for private companies not the NHS.

They absolutely deserve much better pay.

Theyre unlikely to get it in the private sector

Bearpawk · 14/03/2023 12:38

They are paid more than enough. Perhaps there should be a limit on how many hours they can work both in a day and in a week. But I am sick of their whinging and misrepresenting of how much they earn, comparing their wage to that of Pret workers is just insulting.

Cool, I assume you'd be happy for a 'pret worker' to operate on your spinal chord after a car accident then or investigate your cancer symptoms 🙄

dottiedodah · 14/03/2023 12:31

I had no idea the starting salary was so low. Surely about £25.00 at the minimum.Most Doctors enter the profession for altruistic reasons ,but they still have bills to pay.Last evening a young guy says after a frantic 11 hour shift ,he would like a takeaway or ready meal .Cant afford to. Bloody stupid WTF! They will be leaving in their droves at this rate .3 times salary and a shorter week in NZ!

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 12:31

It's a direct reply to the complaints about conditions I've heard from doctors and their representatives themselves. Ask them. I don't know. I think improving pay for carers would be better myself. It's a great job but not a salary you can live on. More carers, less people stuck in hospital, better for doctors :) its a win win win

GrisleyR · 14/03/2023 12:28

Not particularly salary related, but surely there needs to be a look at job titles???

Junior Doctor, Doctor, Senior, Consultant.

The problem with Junior Doctor is that the role is then seen as junior, with salaries to match.
Junior should only apply to the newly qualified. With a proper career and salary progression in place, there would be light at the end of the tunnel for the newly qualified.

Love the idea of their uni fees being paid off for as long as they remain in the NHS - nice one!

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 12:26

@newstart1234

How do you think any of that will help the working conditions?

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 12:24

@WaitingForEgg

I accepted your saying but looking at a number of selective school websites it is still the case that schools boasts about Oxbridge entrants and Medicine entrants. It appears medicine is still a desirable profession to aspire to (discuss?). Will there be a point where schools simply will not suggest medicine as aspirational career and are we teaching that point?

I think the worry from the public point of view is that medics are leaving for other well paid and less onerous careers yet have benefited from tax payer funded training with the expectation the trainee would stay in the NHS to treat the tax payer.

I find it easier to have more sympathy for nurses as the sideways career moved away from front line healthcare are as not as obvious or available so maybe the focus should be there.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 14/03/2023 12:21

Yes! Pension is conveniently forgotten by people saying 14£/h is not enough or when comparing with the famous Pret worker…

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 12:20

Just the ones that have already been mentioned, (parking, hours, exam fees, training areas, on site childcare maybe, hospital accomodation) I also like the 'pay their student loan for as long as they work in the uk' idea.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 12:20

@CornishGem1975

Sure

But pay is definitely part of investing in the NHS

CornishGem1975 · 14/03/2023 12:19

They can't get better conditions and more staff without better pay.

Im not sure why people can't grasp that

Surely better conditions and more staff is about investment into the NHS itself rather than just pay.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 12:18

@newstart1234

Focusing on conditions in what way?

Lcb123 · 14/03/2023 12:16

They should get their students loan paid as long as they work on the Uk. And at least £35k