Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Botw1 · 14/03/2023 14:06

I don't think it's relevant what other countries pay doctors (outside it being a reason why they leave)

I think we sshould pay them more because they are worth more

If people don't want a well staffed and funded NHS that's fine.

We can introduce a private model

Still going to cost ya though

Bumpitybumper · 14/03/2023 14:01

@mids2019
You make an excellent point and one that is central to the whole debate.

People are trying to benchmark the 'worth' of a doctor by suggesting that because they are paid more elsewhere then the UK is undervaluing them. This completely ignores the fact that other healthcare models are funded completely differently and if we as a country want to 'compete' on doctors' wages then we would need to charge people for health care in much the same way as these other countries do. Australia has 'gap' payments where patients have to fund their care over and above what is covered by Medicare and over half of Australians have private healthcare. To put it frankly, there is more money in the system to pay the doctors and therefore pay is higher. Of course we could do a similar thing here but is that really what people want?

And of course it's worth pointing out that other countries are desperate to poach our doctors as the British taxpayer has effectively subsidised many years of training. We should be putting clauses into training contracts to stop this practice as otherwise it simply isn't a great deal for the tax payer and the UK as a whole. There is a huge demand for places at medical schools so we should only be offering these to people that are prepared to work a number of decades in the NHS. If people don't want to do that then perhaps they should look into alternative career or fund their place completely using their own money without relying on government subsidies.

lieselotte · 14/03/2023 14:01

Although £35K and no repayment of student loans might be a way forward.

lieselotte · 14/03/2023 13:59

OK compared with Australia £35K isn't enough even for the first year. And you'd need to pay more in London and the south-east.

Although I'd take issue with the fact that house prices in Perth are low! They certainly didn't use to be.

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 13:58

Botw1 - It is in fact very important to have public support for a strike. If people don't support the strikers the government will get a boost from standing their ground. Terse communication is not going to help. The good news is that a pension change has just been announced, with doctors specifically in mind, meaning that they can save more (1million plus) in pension without extra taxes and up to 60k per year into their pension (up from 40k) without extra cost. I'm sure average joe on 30k will breathe a sign of relief :) ( - Yes I know it's to stop doctors retiring early --)

lieselotte · 14/03/2023 13:57

£35K sounds like a realistic starting point with rapid increases for experience. A 10 year post-qualification doctor should be on a high salary - whether or not they are a consultant is a bit of a red herring, as they are still incredibly well qualified and experienced professionals.

And we need to stop calling them junior doctors after about the first two years!

Pret workers have paid £250k for each doctor to qualify though do you mean the taxpayer has? Surely it is in the interests of the country to pay for people to learn the skills the jobs we need? Although that goes to the heart of the tuition fee debate and is for another thread.

Qazwsxefv · 14/03/2023 13:53

the junior doctors on strike and the are the ones who feel some loyalty to the country and the nhs and have a vocation. Those that don’t have already gone aboard/quit medical field entirely/quit clinical work for working in research or pharma or aesthetics.

we have a healthcare crisis or perhaps a healthcare death spiral . As older people on average need more healthcare than young people and with the shape of the uk population as it is we’re at a place where we need lots of healthcare for our elderly population but from a smaller pool of working age people. Anyone with half a brain could have foreseen that this was coming and 10-20 years ago increased training numbers of medical students and nurses and pharmacists etc. But governments haven’t - they limit the number of pre reg posts and so limit the number of medical students and they in their great wisdom had that little fiasco about charging student nurses for the privilege of taking people to the toilet etc.

since we don’t train enough medical students we rely on imported doctors usually from less economically developed countries (we did also used to have a decent number of EU docs but brexit did for that).m but however isn’t enough to recruit the numbers we need (and there’s a massive culture shock for international doctors coming from countries where doctors are respected to come to the uk where the working conditions are awful and they face so much racism) so we don’t have enough doctors

there was junior doctor strike in 2016 if you remember. A lot of it was about hours and conditons. Promises were made such as giving you eight weeks notice of having to move to another area, six weeks notice of the times of the shifts you have to work and promising to pay for overtime and limiting maximum hours worked in a row. None of this has come to pass.

on paper now I can’t do more than 13hrs at work but if I’m at work for a 13 hour shift (0900-2200) and there is a gap on the rota for the night shift (2130-0930) and so no one turns up to replace me at 10pm the GMC says I can’t leave with no replacement in place so I have to stay. I can then try and claim overtime at least but that has to be approved by a manager who isn’t usually available to approve it at 10pm. Got notification last week that I am working the Easter bank holiday (so four weeks notice to find childcare)

so now there aren’t enough doctors or nurses so there more gaps meaning longer hours and less breaks and less training and so more people leave and on and on. The only way to improve conditons in the short term is to pay enough to attract some international graduates (and actually be nice to them so they stay) and then use that breathing gap to train enough homegrown doctors (and then treat them half decently so they also stay)

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 13:41

@Onstrikein2016

Doctors are leaving for higher salaries and better working conditions and that is the free market. The issue is we do not have a market driven NHS in that we are aiming to supply a range of care free at the point of delivery. I suspect that sustainability of this model will ultimately be to give wages less than the equivalent in the private sector. You could argue if you value social medicine this may be a given.

Possibly medics being intelligent with highly desirable skills can migrate relatively elsewhere to other lucrative roles but is this ultimately a problem with our system or as a result of the ambition of our medics? If the high achievers move on do we take the slightly less high achieving and hope there is more durability (and value for the tax payer)?

Maggiethecat · 14/03/2023 13:32

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 14/03/2023 00:01

I'm in Australia, and a quick google shows what they are paid here.

'How much does a Doctor make in Australia? The average doctor salary in Australia is $156,000 per year or $80 per hour. Entry-level positions start at $124,937 per year, while most experienced workers make up to $253,500 per year.'

At today's exchange rate that puts junior doctors on approx. 68k STG. You can't really blame them for moving over here if they are doubling their wages. I'm in Perth where houses are cheap too, its no wonder the hospitals are packed with UK and Irish doctors and nurses!

Yep, they’ll go where they’re valued rather than being paid the pittance that some on here seem to think is sufficient

Onstrikein2016 · 14/03/2023 13:27

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 13:20

@Onstrikein2016

Isn't the really harsh economic reality though that if someone wouldn't want the current pay and conditions of being a medic there would be someone else that would actually jump at the chance? I made the point about the completion for medical school places and it would seem even if a few high achievers decided not to enter the profession there would still be many that would. I think this a different situation to nurses. No one would argue that are many challenges to being a medic or doubt their professionalism but from a very basic point of view it is still realised that medicine is a lucrative career compared to many especially from a population basis.

I think the problem is getting sympathy from the public (tax payers) when although they are sympathetic to the problems in working conditions they are still acutely aware medics are well paid. Indeed in my circle of friends few know medics as they tend to live in a lot more desirable areas. Getting Joe Public to fully throw themselves behind juniors medics is a real challenge.

not all doctors are privately educated, very true, but there are a disproportionate number. I would suggest then that medicine is still a desirable middle class.career even with all the problems.

The harsh economic reality is doctors are leaving. It doesn’t matter if more people are happy to take their places. They leave too. They are highly trained professionals, who find out their worth is multiple times what they are paid in other parts of the world. It also applies to nurses.
you can’t choose to apply market forces to everything else then be upset when doctors and nurses leave for better pay and conditions.

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 13:23

I genuinely think it may just reach a point of “walk out until we are listened to”. In reality this is already happening as people immigrate

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 13:21

@mids2019

Strike action doesmt need public sympathy

@Bumpitybumper

No. It won't make sense to someone with your values. I doubt there is much point trying

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 13:21

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 13:14

No I haven't ever worked in a hospital. I nearly went for medicine under family pressure but I knew I couldn't take the night shifts. It was slightly tongue in cheek, I know waiting ambulances are a big problem and 1 in 10 people in hospital don't need to be there but in a care setting. The impression I get is that the doctors right now are in the trenches and struggling to see the bigger picture. Sorry :/ Doesn't help that lots can get a GP appointment (NO not the doctors fault At all) but it doesn't help the sympathy vote.

They can’t get an appointment as there are no doctors to see them! Part of the reason many are leaving is because we want to provide a good service. We don’t want people sat in corridors, or waiting days to see you to then walk in absolutely furious (and rightly so). We want to provide a good health service. But when you are 3 GPs and have 500 requests what do you do? You can only stretch yourself to a certain level. In my area at the moment if I refer someone to neurology, they will wait eighteen months to see a neurologist. 18 months to find out you may have MS. This is partly due to covid backlog, partly due to several consultant neurologists leaving. I have worked in such poor staffing that entire departments have had to close and divert patients to other hospitals as we do not have safe levels of staffing. The nhs is a ticking time bomb and brain drain is a huge component of that. Every other week I hear of another colleague who is moving to Australia

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 13:20

@Onstrikein2016

Isn't the really harsh economic reality though that if someone wouldn't want the current pay and conditions of being a medic there would be someone else that would actually jump at the chance? I made the point about the completion for medical school places and it would seem even if a few high achievers decided not to enter the profession there would still be many that would. I think this a different situation to nurses. No one would argue that are many challenges to being a medic or doubt their professionalism but from a very basic point of view it is still realised that medicine is a lucrative career compared to many especially from a population basis.

I think the problem is getting sympathy from the public (tax payers) when although they are sympathetic to the problems in working conditions they are still acutely aware medics are well paid. Indeed in my circle of friends few know medics as they tend to live in a lot more desirable areas. Getting Joe Public to fully throw themselves behind juniors medics is a real challenge.

not all doctors are privately educated, very true, but there are a disproportionate number. I would suggest then that medicine is still a desirable middle class.career even with all the problems.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 13:19

@newstart1234

You don't think it helps that people can't see a GP but you're answer to their not being enough GPS is for doctors to leave?

Thats logic for you.

Bumpitybumper · 14/03/2023 13:19

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 13:05

@Bumpitybumper

The economy is nothing like a household budget.

And yes. If we want decent public services and a decent society then we need to pay for it.

That includes tackling wealth inequality via taxation

People are already being subjected to the highest level of taxation since the 1940s and we should be very cautious about raising it further still without getting to grips with where the money should be going and what we are trying to achieve. The economy is like a household budgets in some ways and without economic growth (that unchecked wage inflation will not promote) then increasing taxation is the main way the government can raise more money.

If you want to tackle wealth inequality then junior doctors are nowhere near the least wealthy in society so wouldn't be helped by such policies. Also not to mention the huge irony, that you can subsidise junior doctors for the first decade of their career to find they then enter the top 5% of earners as consultants and become the very wealthy people that you are desperately trying to tax into submission. Make it make sense.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 13:16

@mids2019

if we trained more medics

But we're not.

And even if we did then those doctors being in jobs is 10 plus years away.

I mean you can keep denying the facts but it's not really achieving anything

Bucketheadbucketbum · 14/03/2023 13:15

My cleaner is on more than that

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 13:14

No I haven't ever worked in a hospital. I nearly went for medicine under family pressure but I knew I couldn't take the night shifts. It was slightly tongue in cheek, I know waiting ambulances are a big problem and 1 in 10 people in hospital don't need to be there but in a care setting. The impression I get is that the doctors right now are in the trenches and struggling to see the bigger picture. Sorry :/ Doesn't help that lots can get a GP appointment (NO not the doctors fault At all) but it doesn't help the sympathy vote.

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 13:13

Onstrikein2016 · 14/03/2023 13:06

Name changed for this as you can see!

I’m now a consultant and I support the juniors in their industrial action. There are a few points that come up repeatedly on threads like this.

it’s a vocation so you should just get on with it. Well this is the stick that is used repeatedly to beat us, persuade us to work extra hours, accept below average pay rise for the last 14 years. If you go into it just for money then you won’t last long but the goodwill that has kept things going for years is eroding. Rapidly. There comes a point you can’t push people further and I think for the juniors that this is it.

Junior doctor is a slightly misleading term. I was a junior doctor for 13 years. I would be the one operating on you in the middle of the night. With a junior doctor anaesthetist after you’d been seen by a junior doctor in A and E.

the cost of training often used as justification of tax payers expense includes junior doctors salaries while they are in training. A lot of their studying is done in their own time.

finally the expenses. You have to do exams to continue your job or you get failed. The exams are expensive at £500-1500 each. I had to do 4 over the years. And pay £800 for access to an online portfolio to prove I was learning while working. And pay the GMC £400 a year, £800 to become a consultant. £400 a year indemnity. These are all mandatory. My parking at the moment is £600 a year.

and it’s not a guaranteed progression. Contracts are typically 2-6 years depending on stage and are a competitive process. It’s national recruitment so you could be offered a place in Newcastle. But you live in Oxford. If you don’t take that place you can’t have any job on that training scheme that year. It’s hugely disruptive. And Deaneries cover huge areas. You can work in Dover for a year then get sent to Guildford for a year. You have no say and get about 2 months notice if you are lucky.

so I understand why they are striking and that’s before we look at the conditions they are working under. I came so close to leaving so many times and would be off to Canada if I didn’t have commitments here. I’m also first generation to university from a state school, we aren’t all public school educated.

Absolutely this

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 13:10

I think the other issue is that the people who are now junior doctors has changed a great deal.

Gone are the wealthy whose parents could put them through medical school. Help with house deposits and financially prop them up. Many medical students are now women (over 50%). From a wider spectrum of socioeconomic backgrounds. Doctor pay has been too low for a long time, but doctors used to feel valued and appreciated by the public. And this did make up for a great deal. As we can see very clearly this is no longer the case.

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 13:09

@Botw1

I agree with nursing staff there is a crisis but as I have said previously there is enough supply of would be medics if we fund the training places. We could train more medics but we have to accept without a limitless budget there may be consequences for overall salary; it will be up to the medical profession to make a judgment on that. I just can't square a crisis in recruitment for medics with the fact many brilliant applicants are being rejected from medical school. The bottle neck is training places which need to be paid for; prioritising the training numbers may mean there is less in the pot for salary increases for medics early on in their career.

Onstrikein2016 · 14/03/2023 13:09

Final note. The new contract I went on strike for in 2016 was acknowledged to be detrimental to those who worked part time ie mainly women and those with caring commitments or disabilities. But it was imposed anyway and that was deemed acceptable collateral damage.

Onstrikein2016 · 14/03/2023 13:06

Name changed for this as you can see!

I’m now a consultant and I support the juniors in their industrial action. There are a few points that come up repeatedly on threads like this.

it’s a vocation so you should just get on with it. Well this is the stick that is used repeatedly to beat us, persuade us to work extra hours, accept below average pay rise for the last 14 years. If you go into it just for money then you won’t last long but the goodwill that has kept things going for years is eroding. Rapidly. There comes a point you can’t push people further and I think for the juniors that this is it.

Junior doctor is a slightly misleading term. I was a junior doctor for 13 years. I would be the one operating on you in the middle of the night. With a junior doctor anaesthetist after you’d been seen by a junior doctor in A and E.

the cost of training often used as justification of tax payers expense includes junior doctors salaries while they are in training. A lot of their studying is done in their own time.

finally the expenses. You have to do exams to continue your job or you get failed. The exams are expensive at £500-1500 each. I had to do 4 over the years. And pay £800 for access to an online portfolio to prove I was learning while working. And pay the GMC £400 a year, £800 to become a consultant. £400 a year indemnity. These are all mandatory. My parking at the moment is £600 a year.

and it’s not a guaranteed progression. Contracts are typically 2-6 years depending on stage and are a competitive process. It’s national recruitment so you could be offered a place in Newcastle. But you live in Oxford. If you don’t take that place you can’t have any job on that training scheme that year. It’s hugely disruptive. And Deaneries cover huge areas. You can work in Dover for a year then get sent to Guildford for a year. You have no say and get about 2 months notice if you are lucky.

so I understand why they are striking and that’s before we look at the conditions they are working under. I came so close to leaving so many times and would be off to Canada if I didn’t have commitments here. I’m also first generation to university from a state school, we aren’t all public school educated.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 13:05

@Bumpitybumper

The economy is nothing like a household budget.

And yes. If we want decent public services and a decent society then we need to pay for it.

That includes tackling wealth inequality via taxation