Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
justasking111 · 15/03/2023 09:05

Our health board put out a message on social media yesterday on the increase in attacks on staff in A&E.

Very disturbing

Dente · 15/03/2023 08:59

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 07:58

I think this is the wrong time to strike.

The timing undermines the very legitimate claims of nursing staff that could only dream of the salaries juniour doctors will eventually earn. The 35% salary increase will just frustrate a public who are fully aware of consultant salaries at a time of a cost of living crisis.

Doctors are high achievers from often quite financially stable middle class backgrounds who have made a choice to enter medicine instead of other lucrative careers. Medics put up with a few years of average pay and poor hours because they are effectively coupling training and practice similar to other professional graduates e.g. accountants and lawyers. At the time when the majority have families and settle down they will be financially set for life. The same does not apply to other staff.

junior doctors should like their consultant peers support pay increased for those that truly needs it in the NHS such as nurses and paramedics and not undermine their efforts through disingenuous claims of poverty and outrageous pay claims.

Great, so we should discourage social mobility. “ if you don’t have the financial cushioning of a middle class family, there it’s not financially possible to be a Doctor” is what you are essentially saying.

I’m gobsmacked!

Mummyford · 15/03/2023 08:54

Dente · 15/03/2023 08:27

It’s sounds out of touch?

What percentage of professionals work weekends ? and I’m sorry to say we already work weekends and there are not enough of us to cover this, if you fully staff hospitals at the weekend you would need more staff and more money. There just aren’t enough Doctors, it would take away staff from during the week.

Doctors (mainly) cannot work from home, you could also claim that was out of touch.

The 14ph is based on a 40hr week between the hours of 8-5 or 8-6 or whatever your contract is depending on the nation you’re working in. So you are uplifted due to more hours/unsociable hours. Some if someone works every second or 3rd weekend and by that I mean 3x 12.5 hour shifts Fri, Sat, Sun on top of the hours they work during the week then they are compensated for this by an uplift.

If you were a single Mother working these hours, how much do you think you would pay in childcare? Would childcare actually exist to cover this ? On top of this you have to move every couple of months/years, parking, definitely need a car for most jobs and student debt.

If we don’t value our Junior Doctors they are going to leave, not because they are chasing money, but because this lifestyle is not conducive to having a family, hobbies, buying a home. If juniors leave they won’t come back as Consultant and the hole gets bigger and ofc you can try to fill this by draining other countries of their much needed Doctors, but actually many of them are reconsidering this route too….. and thinking maybe the US or Oz is better ?

What percentage of professionals work weekends ? and I’m sorry to say we already work weekends and there are not enough of us to cover this, if you fully staff hospitals at the weekend you would need more staff and more money. There just aren’t enough Doctors, it would take away staff from during the week.

Doctors (mainly) cannot work from home, you could also claim that was out of touch.

I worked weekends quite a lot, but, yes, could mostly do it from home, when not travelling, even before WFH became the thing. The differences are that my old firm pays newly qualified lawyers over £150,000 their first year, I was always well-supported by plenty of admin staff and co-workers, and while there was an intense mental load, it came in waves and was nothing like a doctor's. My mother's a GP (not in the UK) and I can attest that there's a way in which her mind never fully leaves work/her patients.

I think it's beyond disgusting that anyone could think any of these people from junior doctors to nurses to EMT crews to hospital cooks earns enough, never mind teachers and carers. I'm continually shocked that so many seem to have been turned against the people who educate our children and save our lives.

WaitingForEgg · 15/03/2023 08:36

I’m on several online medical groups. Someone posted on one just yesterday saying they are looking to relocate to the Uk from India. Hugely experienced doctor. Would be a massive asset. 50+ comments underneath from doctors working on the uk, every single one warning them not to come here. Go to Australia/Middle East/US/Canada. ANYWHERE but the UK. Where conditions are awful and even the general public, the people you are sacrificing time with your family to look after, think you are not worth more. Run and save yourself

Dente · 15/03/2023 08:33

Just to add, is it really a coincidence that Medicine is now dominated by females yet we are now paid less than we were when it was a male dominated profession ?

Dente · 15/03/2023 08:27

MarshaMelrose · 14/03/2023 07:06

The problem with doctors pay and the public is that it's just not very transparent to people. They say they get a certain amount and then others say bu that's the basic, on top of that they get certain uplifts, etc. Peole can't figure out the actual truth and it makes doctors look shifty over their pay claims.

I remember seeing a doctor, a union representative talking about striking for improved wages, conditions, etc, being dismissive that the nhs should move to a 7 day week (forgetting the practicalities but thinking of it as the principle and something to aim for) and he pushed back against it strongly because doctors had children and they wouldn't be able to see them if they worked weekends as a normal shift. It sounded out of touch with how the rest of society lives really.

It’s sounds out of touch?

What percentage of professionals work weekends ? and I’m sorry to say we already work weekends and there are not enough of us to cover this, if you fully staff hospitals at the weekend you would need more staff and more money. There just aren’t enough Doctors, it would take away staff from during the week.

Doctors (mainly) cannot work from home, you could also claim that was out of touch.

The 14ph is based on a 40hr week between the hours of 8-5 or 8-6 or whatever your contract is depending on the nation you’re working in. So you are uplifted due to more hours/unsociable hours. Some if someone works every second or 3rd weekend and by that I mean 3x 12.5 hour shifts Fri, Sat, Sun on top of the hours they work during the week then they are compensated for this by an uplift.

If you were a single Mother working these hours, how much do you think you would pay in childcare? Would childcare actually exist to cover this ? On top of this you have to move every couple of months/years, parking, definitely need a car for most jobs and student debt.

If we don’t value our Junior Doctors they are going to leave, not because they are chasing money, but because this lifestyle is not conducive to having a family, hobbies, buying a home. If juniors leave they won’t come back as Consultant and the hole gets bigger and ofc you can try to fill this by draining other countries of their much needed Doctors, but actually many of them are reconsidering this route too….. and thinking maybe the US or Oz is better ?

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 08:14

newstart1234 · 15/03/2023 07:51

It's not that they think they shouldn't be compensated appropriately for what they do... it's that people think they are properly compensated. It's on the ipsos website if you're interested. 37% think newly qualified doctors are paid about right or too much (mostly about right), and a 86% of people think consultants are paid about right or too much, with about half of those thinking 'too much'. This is basically reflected on this thread. Yes, newly qualified should get a decent raise at least as much as inflation (stopping parking charges would benefit the lowest paid doctors more than the better paid for example), but it's acknowledged that the salaries go up quickly in the career to a very nice high. The fact is that Tory decisions have put the uk in a worse position than it would otherwise be and there is not enough money to go round. I totally get that doctors feel undervalued. Totally. I just think everyone feels undervalued right now because they are working harder for less money.

So, taking their hourly wage and considering the years of training, skill required, level of responsibility, even outside of the conditions that they work in, people think they are properly compensated - that’s what I was talking about

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 15/03/2023 08:09

I want them to be disgustingly well paid. These people save my life and that of my loved ones when necessary. I want them driving round in Ferraris, holidaying in the Maldives, unclipping a rolex to get the surgical gloves on. I don't understand how anyone can disagree. All the shite that gets funded, we should prioritise making doctors & nurses the wealthiest in society, as they once were.

WaitingForEgg · 15/03/2023 08:04

newstart1234 · 15/03/2023 07:51

It's not that they think they shouldn't be compensated appropriately for what they do... it's that people think they are properly compensated. It's on the ipsos website if you're interested. 37% think newly qualified doctors are paid about right or too much (mostly about right), and a 86% of people think consultants are paid about right or too much, with about half of those thinking 'too much'. This is basically reflected on this thread. Yes, newly qualified should get a decent raise at least as much as inflation (stopping parking charges would benefit the lowest paid doctors more than the better paid for example), but it's acknowledged that the salaries go up quickly in the career to a very nice high. The fact is that Tory decisions have put the uk in a worse position than it would otherwise be and there is not enough money to go round. I totally get that doctors feel undervalued. Totally. I just think everyone feels undervalued right now because they are working harder for less money.

The issue is whether the public think we are paid enough or not, doctors do not feel we are paid enough. Therefore doctors are leaving. A lot is riding on these strikes. If pay doesn’t get increased I personally know DOZENS of doctors who will leave this year alone. From f2 up until consultant/GP level. Medical students are also supporting the strikes. So that’s the next 5 years of new doctors too, many of which will quit, or immigrate upon graduation. No one will sign an “nhs 10 year” waiver if they are having to pay £100,000 in student debt for the privilege, and often these contracts can be broken if you pay a fee, which they could if moving to Australia and earning more.

This isn’t a recent problem. Doctors have been underpaid for 15 years and it’s getting progressively worse. Unfortunately I do think the timing is bad, as like you say everyone is feeling hard done by currently. But I’m fairly certain that covid has hugely exacerbated this. Watching people work from home or be furloughed at a huge expense to the country while we carried on. That coupled with the rising cost of living, and horrific knock on effect of covid on our hospitals and primary care, the straw has now broke the camels back

DifferenceEngines · 15/03/2023 08:01

Overworkedwithadog · 14/03/2023 20:52

I contributed to this thread earlier, then stepped back. Appreciate doctors don't really care what I think! Fwiw though, I think that professional costs should be covered. I also think parking costs should be covered. Also moving around the country sounds awful and imo that should be looked at. I think salaries seem ok. I know that's probably not popular. Seems like a big problem is vacancy rates, from what I've read on here. But if doctors go to Aus/ retire early, isn't that inevitable? I suppose the pension change may help re the early retirement. But as for going overseas... surely you know what your pay will be before you start medical school? And if you're unhappy, maybe say do economics or something at uni and go into the city? It seems to me a bit wrong to go overseas and leave your colleagues to pick up the slack- which will of course lead to shortages and more difficult conditions for other s. If big money, early on, is your goal, why choose medicine?

Well, first of all, people often choose careers quite young. Less pay and a crazy lifestyle might not seem a barrier to a teenager - reality hits a bit different once you are wanting to settle down.

With going overseas and letting your colleagues pick up the slack - well, once you have a family, what sort of a person would put propping up the system over their children's well-being?

newstart1234 · 15/03/2023 07:51

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 07:38

@aussiedoctor and @juniordoctor and other doctors on here - appreciate your perspective from the inside.

Added to doctors’ woes is the apparent overwhelming ingratitude of a large number of the people they serve who seem to feel that doctors shouldn’t be compensated appropriately for the work they do.

Covid wasn’t that long ago but how quickly people forget.

It's not that they think they shouldn't be compensated appropriately for what they do... it's that people think they are properly compensated. It's on the ipsos website if you're interested. 37% think newly qualified doctors are paid about right or too much (mostly about right), and a 86% of people think consultants are paid about right or too much, with about half of those thinking 'too much'. This is basically reflected on this thread. Yes, newly qualified should get a decent raise at least as much as inflation (stopping parking charges would benefit the lowest paid doctors more than the better paid for example), but it's acknowledged that the salaries go up quickly in the career to a very nice high. The fact is that Tory decisions have put the uk in a worse position than it would otherwise be and there is not enough money to go round. I totally get that doctors feel undervalued. Totally. I just think everyone feels undervalued right now because they are working harder for less money.

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 07:43

OMG12 · 15/03/2023 07:41

Not everyone is grateful for a reason. Do you know how many women are left with PTSD every year often linked to appaling medical care during childbirth? After my experience I wouldn’t trust a doctor as far as I could throw them.

Hopefully you’ll never have to use one ever again then.

OMG12 · 15/03/2023 07:41

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 07:38

@aussiedoctor and @juniordoctor and other doctors on here - appreciate your perspective from the inside.

Added to doctors’ woes is the apparent overwhelming ingratitude of a large number of the people they serve who seem to feel that doctors shouldn’t be compensated appropriately for the work they do.

Covid wasn’t that long ago but how quickly people forget.

Not everyone is grateful for a reason. Do you know how many women are left with PTSD every year often linked to appaling medical care during childbirth? After my experience I wouldn’t trust a doctor as far as I could throw them.

OMG12 · 15/03/2023 07:39

Like most professions, they’re salaried. As a newly qualified tax accountant (3 years uni and 3 years study on top of work) I worked long hours (often it was less than min wage if you worked it out) it’s the promise of higher wages later.

junior doctors start on £29k that’s fine. They need their hours limiting but the pressure on the nhs is something different

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 07:38

@aussiedoctor and @juniordoctor and other doctors on here - appreciate your perspective from the inside.

Added to doctors’ woes is the apparent overwhelming ingratitude of a large number of the people they serve who seem to feel that doctors shouldn’t be compensated appropriately for the work they do.

Covid wasn’t that long ago but how quickly people forget.

WaitingForEgg · 15/03/2023 07:23

aussiedoctor · 15/03/2023 00:24

I have to respond to this utter misinformation about Australia and why we are able to pay our doctors a better wage. I'm an Australian doctor (born in England - moved over here are a child).

Australian doctors who work 100% in the public system (which is most of us) and are paid by the government are paid extremely well. The Australian PUBLIC health system is completely funded by the taxpayer. It does NOT have gap payments. Our public hospital system, which I work for and have for many years, and which provides the vast majority of healthcare in our country, charges patients NOTHING. It is accessible by EVERYONE, and every single Australian will use it (even if they also have private health insurance, as our private system is very limited here to mostly elective procedures).

When you refer to gap payments you are referring to our private system. The way our private system works is that our government contributes some of the money towards private treatment (medicare funded), and the patient and / or their insurer contributes the rest (the gap).

Private insurance is not necessary in Australia (about half of Australians have some level of cover) and is mostly only used for elective, non urgent issues. The vast majority of our healthcare is delivered via our public system, which is again, free at point of access to all Australians (regardless of insurance status or income).

Despite this we still able to pay our PUBLIC doctors (and our nurses) a very good wage. As a registrar (a doctor in specialty training with five years experience) I make more than a UK consultant. Absurd.

When I was an intern (FY1 equivalent) I made the equivalent of 40,000 pounds a year BASE salary. I made approximately another 15,000 pounds on top of that in overtime and penalty rates. I wouldn't get out of bed for what the UK pays its junior doctors.

So please do not spread misinformation. It has nothing to do with funding models. If it did then Australia would not be able to afford to pay its PUBLIC doctors a wage that is considerably more than their counterparts back in the UK.

And I'll be very clear - you can all continue with this toxic tall poppy syndrome behaviour of accusing doctors of being entitled, of implying that they shouldn't go into it for the money, or that they "owe" the public decades of indentured servitude (?why? they go into debt to train as a doctor, and then they work in the NHS providing a service, which is how salaries work. they owe you... nothing), or telling them that the fact that they get a good pension and good salary when they (if they....) ever become a consultant, as if that helps them pay the bills now.

By all means, continue with this. Why? Because that kind of thing is AMAZING for Australia's healthcare system. We will take every British trained doctor you can supply us with - we love them. They are hard workers, they are experienced, they are talented, and best of all we never had to pay to train them. Same for your nurses - we will take them all. So please... keep undervaluing your healthcare professionals, keep training our future doctors and nurses for us - our Australian health system thanks you for it.

Thank you so so much for this. I’d love to know how things are for GPs in Australia if you have time to share by DM? I’m so sick of the population of the UK

newstart1234 · 15/03/2023 07:01

All very good points aussiedoctor but between the nutjobs of putin truss and (I'll add in cameron here) we have a clumped up combination of shite in the uk. The pay will have to come from other budgets or tax rises, meaning other servivces would suffer. It's getting a balance between the losses of everyone in a time when (almost) everyone is losing. And the top 5-10% of earners is not the hill to be dying on. I don't know about Australia's economy is doing right now but it's fair to say the uk is ... er... challenging.

Hdkatznahtw125sgh · 15/03/2023 02:39

@Hollyhead being supernumary wouldn’t change anything. Student Nurses are supposed to be supernumary, I’ve yet to witness it happen.

Hdkatznahtw125sgh · 15/03/2023 02:36

I’m a band 5 nhs nurse.

Junior doctor is too broad a term. FY1 should start on a minimum of 38k, with overtime paid and if breaks aren’t taken (often happens. It should then be an incremental rise as they progress FY2 onwards.

Registrars are grossly underpaid also, and as much as it’s an unpopular view so are consultants.

The UK is haemorrhaging medics to Australia, New Zealand and out of medicine. The lack of Medics and lack of nurses affects the other job role massively. patients are dying as a result of these extreme shortages.

On a night in my hospital, one FY1 is covering up to eight wards, 3 HDUs etc. if one patient has a cardiac arrest on that ward they are the first point of call. Yes there is registrars and some consultants but the FY1 on the ward and their knowledge of that patient is key.

Tonight in my hospital (I’m not in england), 8 medical wards are being covered by 8 Registered Nurses, 10 Health Care Assistants and one FY1 doctor. That’s 260 patients. This is dangerous. Patients lives are at risk

maddening · 15/03/2023 00:41

Hollyhead · 13/03/2023 22:57

First year out of uni 30k for a 36 hour week, take away their responsibility so they’re supernumerary. From then on a pay scale up to about 65/70k before consultant level would feel right. Would also add antisocial hours into this.

Also - free parking for clinical staff, and exams/training/professional insurance fees all covered by the NHS.

I would also potentially allow them to opt out of the nhs pension scheme and opt into nest instead in exchange for higher pay now.

I agree with this, or £35k starting and training paid for subject to working full time in nhs for 10 years.

But definitely cap on hours worked - tired people make mistakes.

aussiedoctor · 15/03/2023 00:24

Bumpitybumper · 14/03/2023 14:01

@mids2019
You make an excellent point and one that is central to the whole debate.

People are trying to benchmark the 'worth' of a doctor by suggesting that because they are paid more elsewhere then the UK is undervaluing them. This completely ignores the fact that other healthcare models are funded completely differently and if we as a country want to 'compete' on doctors' wages then we would need to charge people for health care in much the same way as these other countries do. Australia has 'gap' payments where patients have to fund their care over and above what is covered by Medicare and over half of Australians have private healthcare. To put it frankly, there is more money in the system to pay the doctors and therefore pay is higher. Of course we could do a similar thing here but is that really what people want?

And of course it's worth pointing out that other countries are desperate to poach our doctors as the British taxpayer has effectively subsidised many years of training. We should be putting clauses into training contracts to stop this practice as otherwise it simply isn't a great deal for the tax payer and the UK as a whole. There is a huge demand for places at medical schools so we should only be offering these to people that are prepared to work a number of decades in the NHS. If people don't want to do that then perhaps they should look into alternative career or fund their place completely using their own money without relying on government subsidies.

I have to respond to this utter misinformation about Australia and why we are able to pay our doctors a better wage. I'm an Australian doctor (born in England - moved over here are a child).

Australian doctors who work 100% in the public system (which is most of us) and are paid by the government are paid extremely well. The Australian PUBLIC health system is completely funded by the taxpayer. It does NOT have gap payments. Our public hospital system, which I work for and have for many years, and which provides the vast majority of healthcare in our country, charges patients NOTHING. It is accessible by EVERYONE, and every single Australian will use it (even if they also have private health insurance, as our private system is very limited here to mostly elective procedures).

When you refer to gap payments you are referring to our private system. The way our private system works is that our government contributes some of the money towards private treatment (medicare funded), and the patient and / or their insurer contributes the rest (the gap).

Private insurance is not necessary in Australia (about half of Australians have some level of cover) and is mostly only used for elective, non urgent issues. The vast majority of our healthcare is delivered via our public system, which is again, free at point of access to all Australians (regardless of insurance status or income).

Despite this we still able to pay our PUBLIC doctors (and our nurses) a very good wage. As a registrar (a doctor in specialty training with five years experience) I make more than a UK consultant. Absurd.

When I was an intern (FY1 equivalent) I made the equivalent of 40,000 pounds a year BASE salary. I made approximately another 15,000 pounds on top of that in overtime and penalty rates. I wouldn't get out of bed for what the UK pays its junior doctors.

So please do not spread misinformation. It has nothing to do with funding models. If it did then Australia would not be able to afford to pay its PUBLIC doctors a wage that is considerably more than their counterparts back in the UK.

And I'll be very clear - you can all continue with this toxic tall poppy syndrome behaviour of accusing doctors of being entitled, of implying that they shouldn't go into it for the money, or that they "owe" the public decades of indentured servitude (?why? they go into debt to train as a doctor, and then they work in the NHS providing a service, which is how salaries work. they owe you... nothing), or telling them that the fact that they get a good pension and good salary when they (if they....) ever become a consultant, as if that helps them pay the bills now.

By all means, continue with this. Why? Because that kind of thing is AMAZING for Australia's healthcare system. We will take every British trained doctor you can supply us with - we love them. They are hard workers, they are experienced, they are talented, and best of all we never had to pay to train them. Same for your nurses - we will take them all. So please... keep undervaluing your healthcare professionals, keep training our future doctors and nurses for us - our Australian health system thanks you for it.

jcyclops · 14/03/2023 23:29

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

They had a pay rise in April 2022, another in December 2022 and these are the rates after the forthcoming pay rise in April 2023

Jill688 · 14/03/2023 23:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

jcyclops · 14/03/2023 23:11

Actual Pret a Manger pay rates per hour From April 2023
Team Member £10.60 - £11.90 depending on location & experience
Barista £11.20 - £12.85 depending on location & experience
In addition, all employees in a shop receive a £1.25/hour bonus for one week in which their shop scores above target from a mystery shopper.

This means that the most experienced Barista, in the most expensive location, whose shop scores a maximum from a mystery shopper, can get £14.10/hr for that week.

avocadotofu · 14/03/2023 21:50

Spendonsend · 14/03/2023 07:48

I'm an administrator with an A level, level qualification in my type of admin. I earn £16 an hour in the private sector with a 5% pension contribution and £15.32 in the state sector with a 12% contribution to my pension. Its not particulatly stressful but I suppose my name is accountable for some things publicly. These are not life and death things.

So i think doctors pay is crap. I dont understand why we all argue that everyone should have crap pay all the time.

I do think twice as many doctors would make the job nicer than more pay but the two are linked. So an increase in pay plus more doctors is the answer.

Well said!

Swipe left for the next trending thread