Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
KimmySchmitt · 15/03/2023 20:14

@juniordoctor you've misunderstood the phrase I fear. 'Paying your dues' doesn't meant you owe the public, it means doing the grunt work and working your way up the ladder within an internal system, as opposed to walking in on day one thinking you can run the place. I'm not speaking as a member of the public, I'm speaking as a fellow HCP. This is not all FY1s, but I see it in most juniors in my own profession. We've had medical students rocking up to meet the consultant prior to their placement in trackies. There just seems to be a lack of professionalism and respect among some young trainees.

juniordoctor · 15/03/2023 17:22

KimmySchmitt · 15/03/2023 11:41

@Bearpawk But there's a middle ground, the juniors don't seem willing to pay their dues at all. You see it in all professions in healthcare (and probably outwith healthcare too). They want it all and they want it now. I think @HoppingPavlova 's post was very balanced and made really good points.

What "dues" do you think are owed by us to the public exactly? What value do we owe you, and how have you calculated the cost? What interest is payable? What rate is it paid off at? What happens if someone can't work as a doctor any more due to their health? What happens if they leave the country? What happens if they go and volunteer for a charity? Do we commit to paying the same to the countries who we poach junior doctors from?

What about nurses who go on to train to be doctors? Do they owe you twice? Are they to work into their 90s to pay this back, or do you propose just taking it from their children instead?

I accept medicine likely costs the taxpayer more than the £36k my tuition fees were, but how much more? Lets not forget, I owe over £80k for my education, which is looking like it will grow to somewhere in the region of £250k before it's written off as I won't pay it off with my salary as it is in the next 30 years. If you're wondering why I don't feel I owe you anything perhaps start there.

There's a reason the only Tory talking rubbish like this is 30p Lee. In short, it is because you're proposing 16 year olds sign up for some form of regressive indentured servitude.

juniordoctor · 15/03/2023 16:51

Artisticpaint · 15/03/2023 11:37

Can you tell us what role you have?

We’d be stuffed without them as extra hands but equally they are frustrating to train as their knowledge is pretty low and it’s really learning in the job with a steep curve.
Let's ignore how offensive this remark is and focus on the substance (or lack thereof). Presumably you're an end-of-career or retired consultant or GP. How much has medical science advanced in your career? Back when the BNF could have been copied out on a few sheets of A4? When cheese and onion covered everything a houseman needed to know and was what, 150 pages? When the treatment for an MI was an aspirin, a cup of tea, and crossing your fingers?

You've presumably specialised in something, and had a career learning it and keeping up to date with the developments in it. But your juniors are feckless because they don't know your specialty in the depth you do because they've spent five years learning yours and everyone else's, and then carry on rotating through various jobs. Seems a bit odd and entirely devoid of insight to me.

Yes, they pull (or should pull, but they are trying to dodge this) enormous hours but this is their only learning opportunity essentially.
Sorry, when have junior doctors tried to dodge the working hours? The new deal (which was negotiated when I was about five years old, I believe) was to bring the profession into compliance with the European working time directive and many of us are expected to opt out regardless. My work schedule states my rostered hourly average is 48 hours. I frequently work 72 hour weeks, and I never leave on time.

I'm sick and tired of old-school GPs bleating on about how bad they had it with their hundred hour weeks as the houseman and we're all so soft, while conveniently forgetting to mention that when they were on-call they were expected to sleep in their rooms and be woken up only by the sister infrequently. Medical science has advanced, the population is older and sicker - and the intensity for juniors has too. Management have decided the nurses can't use their professional initiative any more and must bleep us for everything so we now spend our lives on-call running around desperately trying to firefight.

And if the ward is our only learning, why am I saving for thousands of pounds in fees to start taking the MRCP next year?

Back in the day 6-7 Juniors would have piled into a 3 bed rental on the basis they would only need a bed once every few days for a few hours and would never be ‘at home’, and if so most others would be out so ‘musical beds’.
If this was ever true (giving strong Monty Python's Four Yorkshiremen vibes), it would be a breach of every tenancy agreement now and the landlord would probably be breaking the law around HMOs. And there's one key thing you've forgotten to mention - your generation had free (as a house officer) or subsidised hospital accomodation on-site and free meals provided 24/7. I can't even buy a £5 sandwich out of hours now. You could buy a house as you finished as an SHO - good like finding an SHO who can do that now without help from their parents.

So what was the house you rented with it's 'musical beds' for? A break away from the hospital? But we don't deserve that, according to you.

Now Juniors blather on about having to rent a north facing flat for one as essential to ‘decompress’
Yes, we need to decompress from work. You might have missed it but much of the last three years have been rather focused on something called COVID, and the system is collapsing around us because of underfunding and a demographic bomb as the boomers are becoming increasingly frail and unwell.

You can harken back to the 'good old days' all you like. Some of our consultants bought coffee to the picket line, and they really didn't enjoy being on-call on Monday night as much as they thought you would. What else in our profession's "fine" history would you like to bring back - lobotomies for troublesome housewives? Blood-letting?

Don't worry, we're all back at work tomorrow so you can get back to screaming at your talentless, procedurally weak post-nights FY1 on the post-take ward round for not ordering the serum rhubarb when they clerked the twelfth patient of their fourth night shift in.

Qazwsxefv · 15/03/2023 14:07

@HoppingPavlova

I’m assuming you’re a senior in a surgical specialty or anaesthetics? Because you talk about practical skills needing to be learnt and so must mean operating or anaesthesia or cath lab or similar. Uk trained F1s should be competent in all day to day ward practical skills like ivs and ecgs as part of graduating medical school and it would be worrying if they are not and something you should be easing higher. (international grads are not always competent in this stuff because it’s not taught in all international curriculums as I am sure you are aware, but we shouldn’t be claiming uk fy1s don’t have practical expertise just because we are so short of doctors we have to import ones from aboard)

with regard to your comments that all juniors have a lot to learn- are you counting the less junior juniors in this? What wonderful hospital do you work in that has consultants in doing appendix operations or c sections at 2am becuase I’d like to apply to work there!

Btw before this strike week i haven’t seen a consultant where I work as a medical junior for three weeks before they and when I did it was because they wanted me to find something on the electronic records system they didn’t understand. I’m a GP trainee so still a junior-ish junior. I accept I have stuff still to learn about being a GP but don’t think I have much left to learn about being an SHO level doctor in this job. When it comes down to my day to day job which is 100% service provision and no training I’m confident to say I’m competent to undertake it independently- which is what I do after all. I am not being trained by anyone and don’t see why I should be paid an apprenticeship wage when no one is supervising or teaching me.

it’s not just this job- as a psychiatry junior doctor working in an inpatient psychiatric hospital I was expected to provide the medical health care for the 25 elderly inpatients on the ward. The psychiatry consultant was present for half a day a week and informed me they would defer to my option on all medical matters as they had trained outside the uk where psychiatrists did not undertake any physical health training past medical school. I did learn some stuff about old age psychiatry from them as they were very good at this but I certainly was not being supervised or trained in medical healthcare.

the job before this I was the Gynaecology SHO. I was the only doctor on the emergency Gynae clinic from 5pm-9am and all weekend. I would see all referrals and make independent decisions on who to admit and discharge. I would order and interpret the ultrasound scans and blood tests and counsel, consent and prescribe the medical management of miscarriage for these poor ladies, I would also examine (with chaperone) and remove foreign bodies or products as needed . I was taught this admittedly on my first day by another more senior junior (Gynae st3) in the old see one- do one - teach one method (and I of course already knew how to do a speculum and internal exam from medical school as it’s a core competency needed for graduation) If a patient needed theatre then and there it was an ST3 trainee I called and we would then operate together and I also was her sole assistant for c sections. I never saw a consultant in the emergency Gynae clinic - they were on the labour ward in hours, undertaking clinics and performing complex surgeries of course. I’m not claiming to know all there is to know about obstetrics and gynaecology in fact I only know a tiny bit but I am/was competent to do my job as a Gynae sho and did not receive any consultant input into learning to do so. I did assist a lovely consultant to undertake the elective c sections list a few times so I suppose i was being “trained” then but as I’m training to be a GP I’m not sure that’s a skill I have any need of knowing!

Maybe back in the old days when doctors worked in teams with consultants and juniors there was some apprenticeship model learning going on but now days the consultants do clinics and fancy surgeries juniors are not permitted to attend because of “service pressures” and juniors run inpatient medical care and emergencies out of hours. The fact that the outpatient clinics and non urgent operations have all been cancelled so that the consultants are able to work on the wards and admissions units during the strikes shows that the juniors are undertaking patient safety critical work. After all If we were all just standing about watching the consultants do everything as we’re “just learning” then there wouldn’t have been any need for the consultants to come and do our roles on strike days. Yes junior doctors do not know how to the fancy stuff yet but they are independently performing safety critical roles, and not receiving any training in the fancy stuff to make up for the fact their not paid a wage that reflects this

(this probably reads as an attack on consultants - it’s not intended to be one. They are highly trained professionals who generally undertake very necessary specialist clinics and perform complex surgeries and other fancy procedures. But in the UK we have ended up with a healthcare model where the consultants do much of the outpatient and elective care and the juniors do the emergency and inpatient care. )

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 12:49

amp.theguardian.com/society/2015/nov/13/hundreds-consultants-jeremy-hunt-support-junior-doctors-back-strike

Good that some that have reached the top support the others.

Dente · 15/03/2023 12:39

Also….. Consultants are also being balloted for strike action.

Dente · 15/03/2023 12:37

HoppingPavlova · 15/03/2023 11:12

@alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 'How much does a Doctor make in Australia? The average doctor salary in Australia is $156,000 per year or $80 per hour. Entry-level positions start at $124,937 per year, while most experienced workers make up to $253,500 per year.'

This is not referring to Juniors and the way you have written it is quite inflammatory. I have worked in both NHS and Aus system and you are not comparing apples with apples.

Juniors are a range skills wise. We’d be stuffed without them as extra hands but equally they are frustrating to train as their knowledge is pretty low and it’s really learning in the job with a steep curve. Given this, they really shouldn’t be paid they much tbh. Yes, they pull (or should pull, but they are trying to dodge this) enormous hours but this is their only learning opportunity essentially. While booksmart they are essentially unskilled labour, through yo skilled while working in the job. It’s really an apprenticeship in a way and apprenticeships are not well paid.

The difference is with expectations these days. Back in the day 6-7 Juniors would have piled into a 3 bed rental on the basis they would only need a bed once every few days for a few hours and would never be ‘at home’, and if so most others would be out so ‘musical beds’. Now Juniors blather on about having to rent a north facing flat for one as essential to ‘decompress’ and barrack to spend less graft on the job hours wise learning. The other difference is that Juniors rarely had families etc previously, now they seem to expect that they should have salaries that support family life rather than delaying families to down the track (and yes, potentially face missing out if you are a woman).

I did not see the issue with apprentice style wages on the basis that after your ‘apprenticeship’ you will be on a really pretty penny at senior and then consultant level if in the hospital system.

You sound rather unprogressive and I suspect you no longer work in the NHS or are past retirement age.

They are not striking for a payrise, they are striking for pay restoration.

Are junior Dr worth less now than they were previously ?

justasking111 · 15/03/2023 12:30

They should change the name and grade their pay. I know one he's thirty, two children. His wife earned more. He's done all the exams for a consultancy position is looking for an opening

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 12:29

Artisticpaint · 15/03/2023 12:18

no wonder the doctors are fl
ee the NHS if your attitude towards them is representative of management and patients

Yep, and then we despair that we can’t get the care we’d like….

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 12:27

KimmySchmitt · 15/03/2023 11:41

@Bearpawk But there's a middle ground, the juniors don't seem willing to pay their dues at all. You see it in all professions in healthcare (and probably outwith healthcare too). They want it all and they want it now. I think @HoppingPavlova 's post was very balanced and made really good points.

You mean these ‘juniors’, many of whom will have been juniors for many years, probably settled down and have family and responsibility - they want it all and want it now?

Artisticpaint · 15/03/2023 12:18

*fleeing

Artisticpaint · 15/03/2023 12:18

no wonder the doctors are fl
ee the NHS if your attitude towards them is representative of management and patients

KimmySchmitt · 15/03/2023 11:41

@Bearpawk But there's a middle ground, the juniors don't seem willing to pay their dues at all. You see it in all professions in healthcare (and probably outwith healthcare too). They want it all and they want it now. I think @HoppingPavlova 's post was very balanced and made really good points.

Artisticpaint · 15/03/2023 11:37

HoppingPavlova · 15/03/2023 11:12

@alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 'How much does a Doctor make in Australia? The average doctor salary in Australia is $156,000 per year or $80 per hour. Entry-level positions start at $124,937 per year, while most experienced workers make up to $253,500 per year.'

This is not referring to Juniors and the way you have written it is quite inflammatory. I have worked in both NHS and Aus system and you are not comparing apples with apples.

Juniors are a range skills wise. We’d be stuffed without them as extra hands but equally they are frustrating to train as their knowledge is pretty low and it’s really learning in the job with a steep curve. Given this, they really shouldn’t be paid they much tbh. Yes, they pull (or should pull, but they are trying to dodge this) enormous hours but this is their only learning opportunity essentially. While booksmart they are essentially unskilled labour, through yo skilled while working in the job. It’s really an apprenticeship in a way and apprenticeships are not well paid.

The difference is with expectations these days. Back in the day 6-7 Juniors would have piled into a 3 bed rental on the basis they would only need a bed once every few days for a few hours and would never be ‘at home’, and if so most others would be out so ‘musical beds’. Now Juniors blather on about having to rent a north facing flat for one as essential to ‘decompress’ and barrack to spend less graft on the job hours wise learning. The other difference is that Juniors rarely had families etc previously, now they seem to expect that they should have salaries that support family life rather than delaying families to down the track (and yes, potentially face missing out if you are a woman).

I did not see the issue with apprentice style wages on the basis that after your ‘apprenticeship’ you will be on a really pretty penny at senior and then consultant level if in the hospital system.

Can you tell us what role you have?

Bearpawk · 15/03/2023 11:19

Back in the day 6-7 Juniors would have piled into a 3 bed rental on the basis they would only need a bed once every few days for a few hours and would never be ‘at home’, and if so most others would be out so ‘musical beds’. Now Juniors blather on about having to rent a north facing flat for one as essential to ‘decompress’

Gosh what snowflakes, imagine wanting your own bed to come home to after a 14 hour shift Hmm

HoppingPavlova · 15/03/2023 11:17

to reiterate Junior Doctors are not students they are extremely highly qualified professionals, god knows why they call themselves such a demeaning name.

Because they have a LOT to learn. I have personal experience of this.

smellyflowers · 15/03/2023 11:13

£20

HoppingPavlova · 15/03/2023 11:12

@alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 'How much does a Doctor make in Australia? The average doctor salary in Australia is $156,000 per year or $80 per hour. Entry-level positions start at $124,937 per year, while most experienced workers make up to $253,500 per year.'

This is not referring to Juniors and the way you have written it is quite inflammatory. I have worked in both NHS and Aus system and you are not comparing apples with apples.

Juniors are a range skills wise. We’d be stuffed without them as extra hands but equally they are frustrating to train as their knowledge is pretty low and it’s really learning in the job with a steep curve. Given this, they really shouldn’t be paid they much tbh. Yes, they pull (or should pull, but they are trying to dodge this) enormous hours but this is their only learning opportunity essentially. While booksmart they are essentially unskilled labour, through yo skilled while working in the job. It’s really an apprenticeship in a way and apprenticeships are not well paid.

The difference is with expectations these days. Back in the day 6-7 Juniors would have piled into a 3 bed rental on the basis they would only need a bed once every few days for a few hours and would never be ‘at home’, and if so most others would be out so ‘musical beds’. Now Juniors blather on about having to rent a north facing flat for one as essential to ‘decompress’ and barrack to spend less graft on the job hours wise learning. The other difference is that Juniors rarely had families etc previously, now they seem to expect that they should have salaries that support family life rather than delaying families to down the track (and yes, potentially face missing out if you are a woman).

I did not see the issue with apprentice style wages on the basis that after your ‘apprenticeship’ you will be on a really pretty penny at senior and then consultant level if in the hospital system.

OMG12 · 15/03/2023 10:50

Maggiethecat · 15/03/2023 07:43

Hopefully you’ll never have to use one ever again then.

I really really go out of my way to ensure I don’t. My main contact with them has been when they nearly killed my son and I through negligence they then falsified my notes to try and cover up, giving up on my Dad who then survived 30 years. Putting me through months of tests and an operation to then tell me what I had told them and been dismissed months earlier. They’re useful in that they can dispense drugs but other than that they’re generally a bunch of uncaring fools who think they’re god. I’m sure there are good ones in there, unfortunately I’ve never actually met one. Thinking back to the med students at uni, I’m not surprised though.

nolongersurprised · 15/03/2023 10:31

Another advantage of the GP (or other private practitioner) system in Australia is access to private labs and imaging:

The government subsidises the cost of the usual investigations so most/all of the basic investigations are free.

For example, I am having periodic very heavy periods, prob because I’m perimenopausal but worth getting checked out. My GP may refer me for bloods/scan which I can get done within a day or so and which will be reported and back to fhe GP within 24 hours. There are “free” scanning places but I’ll choose one where there’s a small fee because I prefer them.

I could of course, not do any of this and ask for a gynae appt at the hospital where everything would be just like the NHS, just to emphasise that the public hospital system here is the same.

Pragmatically it means that GPs have a lot more autonomy with less gate keeping around basic investigations.

aussiedoctor · 15/03/2023 10:17

WaitingForEgg · 15/03/2023 07:23

Thank you so so much for this. I’d love to know how things are for GPs in Australia if you have time to share by DM? I’m so sick of the population of the UK

No problem at all - very happy to help if you want to DM me 🙂

Tl;Dr we have a shortage of GPs especially in regional areas so we need more.

GPs in Australia are mostly private practitioners and are paid per encounter- with the highest remuneration being for procedural work. Basically the government will reimburse you for a given item number (eg skin cancer removal will have its own number, mental health assessment another etc) and then most GPs will charge a gap over and above that which the patient has to pay. Often GPs won't charge a gap to children and pensioners but it's their own choice.

So because you're paid according to billing and not hours worked, and the amount each item is billed for varies widely (procedural stuff attracts $$$, non procedural not so much), this means the salary varies widely but it also gives you a huge amount of control over what kind of work you can do / let's you play to your skills/ interest areas.

Especially as patients aren't registered to a clinic here, they can go where they like. So if you've got a good rep for (for example) palliative medicine or women's health then you'll build up that kind of patient cohort over time, along with just your bog standard usual variety of GP presentations.

eg there are GPs who love procedures and will have a whole day of skin biopsies etc, vasectomies, mirena implants etc. Others who love women's health and work in female only patient practices. Others who just do cosmetic medicine eg botox, fillers etc.

If you live outside of the main cities and are are least somewhat procedural you can make half a million a year full time. FYI if you work regionally you see far more complicated stuff and a lot of these GPs also do shifts in the local EDs. There's a special rural generalist scheme where some of our GPs even do c sections, do appys and choles, provide procedural sedation etc, run neonatal resus etc. But this is all optional, you don't have to do that stuff.

If you work in a main city and are mostly non procedural (this would be the least lucrative method) you cant bill as highly but you can still expect to make 150-200K a year full time. The patients are also far less complex/comorbid and city GPs refer earlier generally speaking.

There are certainly issues w GP here in Australia (mostly the government defunding it which means the GPs have to pass the cost onto the patient....and also the unequal compensation for procedural vs non procedural) but it's still a thousand times better than the UK.

That turned out to be rather long haha but please DM me with any questions.

Dente · 15/03/2023 10:16

nolongersurprised · 15/03/2023 10:06

Well said. I’m an Australian consultant (working public/private) and it’s always overlooked on here that the public hospital system is also free at the point of use, just like the UK.

There are aspects of the private system I also have really come to appreciate (I didn't train in Australia) apart from my private income 😀 but that’s for another thread.

Here. Here. I’ll come 😄

nolongersurprised · 15/03/2023 10:06

aussiedoctor · 15/03/2023 00:24

I have to respond to this utter misinformation about Australia and why we are able to pay our doctors a better wage. I'm an Australian doctor (born in England - moved over here are a child).

Australian doctors who work 100% in the public system (which is most of us) and are paid by the government are paid extremely well. The Australian PUBLIC health system is completely funded by the taxpayer. It does NOT have gap payments. Our public hospital system, which I work for and have for many years, and which provides the vast majority of healthcare in our country, charges patients NOTHING. It is accessible by EVERYONE, and every single Australian will use it (even if they also have private health insurance, as our private system is very limited here to mostly elective procedures).

When you refer to gap payments you are referring to our private system. The way our private system works is that our government contributes some of the money towards private treatment (medicare funded), and the patient and / or their insurer contributes the rest (the gap).

Private insurance is not necessary in Australia (about half of Australians have some level of cover) and is mostly only used for elective, non urgent issues. The vast majority of our healthcare is delivered via our public system, which is again, free at point of access to all Australians (regardless of insurance status or income).

Despite this we still able to pay our PUBLIC doctors (and our nurses) a very good wage. As a registrar (a doctor in specialty training with five years experience) I make more than a UK consultant. Absurd.

When I was an intern (FY1 equivalent) I made the equivalent of 40,000 pounds a year BASE salary. I made approximately another 15,000 pounds on top of that in overtime and penalty rates. I wouldn't get out of bed for what the UK pays its junior doctors.

So please do not spread misinformation. It has nothing to do with funding models. If it did then Australia would not be able to afford to pay its PUBLIC doctors a wage that is considerably more than their counterparts back in the UK.

And I'll be very clear - you can all continue with this toxic tall poppy syndrome behaviour of accusing doctors of being entitled, of implying that they shouldn't go into it for the money, or that they "owe" the public decades of indentured servitude (?why? they go into debt to train as a doctor, and then they work in the NHS providing a service, which is how salaries work. they owe you... nothing), or telling them that the fact that they get a good pension and good salary when they (if they....) ever become a consultant, as if that helps them pay the bills now.

By all means, continue with this. Why? Because that kind of thing is AMAZING for Australia's healthcare system. We will take every British trained doctor you can supply us with - we love them. They are hard workers, they are experienced, they are talented, and best of all we never had to pay to train them. Same for your nurses - we will take them all. So please... keep undervaluing your healthcare professionals, keep training our future doctors and nurses for us - our Australian health system thanks you for it.

Well said. I’m an Australian consultant (working public/private) and it’s always overlooked on here that the public hospital system is also free at the point of use, just like the UK.

There are aspects of the private system I also have really come to appreciate (I didn't train in Australia) apart from my private income 😀 but that’s for another thread.

WaitingForEgg · 15/03/2023 09:13

A GP position in Australia. One of hundreds currently advertising. I get constant recruitment messages on LinkedIn and I haven’t even completed training yet (almost!). My husband thinks I’m utterly mad to want to continue to practice in the UK. He knows what a thankless job it is here and the sort of life we could have elsewhere. Im not expecting uk doctors to remotely match this. But what we are paid is simply not enough. The uk public for some reason seem to dislike doctors. Not the elderly vulnerable generation, the boomers and younger. I suspect I do need to get out but struggle with the concept of living away from my family. However what is likely to happen is I will finally have had enough and eventually go. Those without ties have already left. It is now reaching the point that people actually assume you may “CCT and flee” (complete training and move abroad). We will soon just create doctors for other countries

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour
How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour
Artisticpaint · 15/03/2023 09:05

Here are some examples of adverts at attracting doctors out of the NHS and over to New Zealand and Australia. The doctors get many of these every day and many are moving overseas.

to reiterate Junior Doctors are not students they are extremely highly qualified professionals, god knows why they call themselves such a demeaning name.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour
How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour
How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour