Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Qazwsxefv · 16/03/2023 10:20

All this moving employer 4-6monthly also means that your almost never off the “emergency” tax code either which makes massive dents in take home (although I appreciate you do get the tax back in the end and this is t a doctor only issue). But to reiterate we are not paid a yearly salary with the reassurance of knowing what we are being paid each month. Our pay peaks and spikes throughout the year like any other hourly employee.

Qazwsxefv · 16/03/2023 10:14

@nocoolnamesleft sorry paediatrics, anaesthetics and ED excluded from my rant! Have been the peads sho at small DGH about 6 yrs ago (used to be peads before deciding neonates was not for me) and would never have dreamed of calling the consultant out of hours for a cannula (I got pretty good at scalp ones - once getting one in an anaesthetist had failed to do - still a point of pride) but yes the peads consultants were there teaching - actually they were filling gaps in the Reg (senior junior for non medics) rota because were so bloody short of doctors the consultants were having to work as juniors long term (also a reason I jumped ship - no desire to be working as a reg when I’m 70) - thank you for doing so!

@ArdeteiMasazxu we talk about wages in hourly rates becuase that is how we are paid. Our payslips come as x number of hours at y rate (and for an Fy1 y rate between the hours of 7am-9pm is £14.09/hr. We do not receive a yearly salary/12 paid monthly. We are not SALARIED in that sense. We don’t completely have varied hours per month either just to make it complicated. We change posts (and frequently employer) every 4-6months. For each post they add up the predicted hours you will work over the 4-6 months. This is split into hours between 7-9pm and 9-7am multiple that by the day rate and night rate respectively and then add on a “lump sum supplement” if you work frequent weekends. This pay is then averaged out per month. Of course pay months don’t align with the actual months you work in the rotation so you don’t know what you’re going to be paid each month until your payslip turns up. The “ annual salary” quoted is simply 40x52xday rate. It is possible (but I never have heard off it becuase they want maximum hours from everyone) for a “full time” doctor to be paid less than the annual quoted salary if they were for example working 38hrs a week between the hours 7-9 and “only” working 1 weekend in nine

WaitingForEgg · 16/03/2023 10:13

These same people will be complaining they can’t get a GP appointment and the A&E wait is 20 hours. “Sorry mrs smith we don’t have an orthopaedic surgeon to do your hip repair. The British public decided they were all whingers so they left to work in Australia… I could supply you with some poorly sized crutches however…”

WaitingForEgg · 16/03/2023 10:00

aurynne · 16/03/2023 09:59

The UK pays their doctors £14/hour??? A first-year midwife in new Zealand gets £15.93 (NZD$31.17), and NZ is a known low-wage country!

But we just have to accept it! And stop whinging!!

how dare we complain! Don’t we know plenty of people earn less! 🙄

aurynne · 16/03/2023 09:59

The UK pays their doctors £14/hour??? A first-year midwife in new Zealand gets £15.93 (NZD$31.17), and NZ is a known low-wage country!

WaitingForEgg · 16/03/2023 09:40

Our union has changed a lot since the 2016 strikes. They have realised no one cares about “saving the nhs”, they need to ask for something concrete. We will continue to walk out until we are listened to.

WaitingForEgg · 16/03/2023 09:35

SamanthaCaine · 16/03/2023 09:26

@WaitingForEgg

Half of the stuff you've mentioned there is what many non doctors do, like study, work everywhere and learn complex computer systems. Except they don't publicly whinge about it.

The other stuff about pay and respect. Speak to any engineer and they'll tell you that's exactly the same in the UK. Elsewhere, I'd be viewed in a similar category as a doctor and paid accordingly (more closely to doctors in fact). Rates have stagnated for the last 15 years. Not much difference except we don't have issues with pensions where I might be forced to retire early (what a problem to have!).

I've had to set up my own business to earn what I feel I'm worth here but others aren't so fortunate.

BUT I'll give you working conditions for sure and no NHS worker should put up with it. Maximum sympathy and support in this respect. In fact I'm surprised you all put up with it. 13 hours without a toilet break. I'd give your management an option where I'd piss/shit in his/her office or in the toilet like a civilized human being.

What good is a union if they can't fight for this kind of thing. Chocolate teapot springs to mind and I find it odd that in all this, I've never read a bad word said about them. Yet in my lifetime they seem to have done sweet FA.

I also think your exams should be covered as your ongoing costs but that applies to all critical qualifications in society.

You have been forced to move 100s of miles multiple times with no choice whatsoever?!

Apart from the military no I cannot think of jobs that require this. These moves are not optional you realise? I have lived in 4 areas of the uk including the south of England and Scotland.

i don’t think you understand my point. Every ward, department, hospital runs completely differently. How long do you work until you feel settled in a job? We move every 4 months. We often get NO training on these computer systems, and delays in our time cost lives.

Yes we are entitled to “whinge”. I really hope you do not require medical care in the near future, you may struggle to find it

SamanthaCaine · 16/03/2023 09:26

@WaitingForEgg

Half of the stuff you've mentioned there is what many non doctors do, like study, work everywhere and learn complex computer systems. Except they don't publicly whinge about it.

The other stuff about pay and respect. Speak to any engineer and they'll tell you that's exactly the same in the UK. Elsewhere, I'd be viewed in a similar category as a doctor and paid accordingly (more closely to doctors in fact). Rates have stagnated for the last 15 years. Not much difference except we don't have issues with pensions where I might be forced to retire early (what a problem to have!).

I've had to set up my own business to earn what I feel I'm worth here but others aren't so fortunate.

BUT I'll give you working conditions for sure and no NHS worker should put up with it. Maximum sympathy and support in this respect. In fact I'm surprised you all put up with it. 13 hours without a toilet break. I'd give your management an option where I'd piss/shit in his/her office or in the toilet like a civilized human being.

What good is a union if they can't fight for this kind of thing. Chocolate teapot springs to mind and I find it odd that in all this, I've never read a bad word said about them. Yet in my lifetime they seem to have done sweet FA.

I also think your exams should be covered as your ongoing costs but that applies to all critical qualifications in society.

Qazwsxefv · 16/03/2023 09:23

KimmySchmitt · 16/03/2023 00:37

@Qazwsxefv you're proving my point beautifully. No it is not okay to turn up to a professional meeting with your soon-to-be boss in trackies, this is basic! And they stoated onto the ward like this, so yes patients saw them. Also other HCP students do NOT all get uniforms provided, I have always had to buy my own work clothes (student or qualified) as we're not uniformed. Even when covid hit I had to buy my own scrubs as it was suggested we wear those for infection control. And come on, a pair of black trousers and a shirt can cost £20 from Asda, nobody's insisting on suits. And you don't have to be 'unwaged', what's wrong with having a part time job? I know plenty of med students who were at uni the same time as me who could work a Saturday job so don't be giving it 'we're too busy studying'.

you see this has touched a nerve becuase it remeinds me so much of my experience at medical school.

my mum (working class left school at 16) bought me my first “professional outfit” for my medical school interview (when I was 17) that and the train fair to the interview (in London from up north) were a big stretch for her. It was my only smart outfit and I wore it with my slight too small old school shoes from y11 to my interview feeling very proud. I also wore it to my first “clinical day” (when I was 18 and anyway from home in a city for the first time) to find it wasn’t suitable because I couldn’t roll the sleeves up as they didn’t have buttoned cuffs and got well told off buy a nurse on the ward and sent away until I could buy some “suitable” clothing (they also took objection to the length of my skirt)I felt like I had failed some test I didn’t know was a thing.

I also didn’t wear smart clothes my first meeting with my tutor in hospital (an academic consultant)- I wore jeans a t shirt and trainers because as an 18yr old from a background where no one had been to uni or worked in a professional job I had no idea that this would even be a requirement for meeting with a tutor. fortunately he realised that I was completely out of my comfort zone and enquired very gently if I had “work clothes” - sadly he didn’t explain that the “work clothes” needed rollable sleeves and pencil skirts were a no no!

(I worked in medical school (interestingly enough as an barista then waitress) apart from the 6 months before finals because I had to eat. However the medical school told us that employment was recommended against and would not be taken as a mitigating factor if one failed exams or as a reason not to be sent on pheriperal (50 mile away) placements - got fired from the coffee shop due to that. In my first weeks at uni I hadn’t yet found a job however and had had to spend my loan on things like train fairs, halls, textbooks, a laptop!!! (Big deal in 2005) and a stethoscope - I was totally broke for a long time.

Also the consultant is not the students soon to be “boss”. The students is paying £9K/yr for the consultant to teach them. One could well say that the student is the employer of the consultant in this situation. Not saying the consultant actually sees any of that money but a student has paid for the privilege of meeting that consultant - the massive fees mean that this is much more transactional relationship than it was back in the day.

And again we’re not taking junior doctors here we’re taking medical student s - medical school is where teens go to learn how to be doctors/professionals. They are going to mess up and make errors and good tutors and lecturers guide them to improve not judge them for not being the finished article at 18.

and I’m sorry you had to buy your own scrubs for covid (me to) - more evidence that the working conditions are shit - individual HCPs shouldn’t be having to prop up the NHS’s infection control system at their own expense. did you know you can claim the tax back on them and any other work uniform related expenses?

WaitingForEgg · 16/03/2023 09:06

mids2019 · 16/03/2023 06:49

Medics moving to other countries so a 120K ultimate salary can be replaced by 200K and the public are meant to sympathise with the 'brain drain'?.Does anyone have an idea of average earnings in the UK? Why are medics moving if not for what would it in a lot of people's opinions be astronomical salries?

Medics have gotten used to the sort of work life very few people would accept.

You work hard for 6 years, pass your exams and then are randomly allocated a job ANYWHERE in the uk. It doesn’t matter where your family are, it doesn’t matter if you have young children and need family support. These factors are not even considered.

You are given a 2 year job absolutely anywhere in the uk and you take it or you don’t work as a doctor. You are then given 6 jobs in 2 years with little or no induction to any. You are expected to learn multiple new computer systems, job plans with little or no support. While you do this you are paid poorly, working 80 hours per week. You work bank holidays, weekends, night shift. You miss family weddings. If you’re REALLY lucky you may even get rota’d to work YOUR OWN WEDDING day. Because “it’s a night shift… surely you get married earlier in the day?”

You work 13 hour shifts with no toilet breaks. I once gave myself pyelonephritis from not urinating. I was septic and needed intravenous antibiotics, I took 3 days off work and was hassled the entire time when I would be back as the oncall rota was so short.

You get almost no training. Most of the work is pure service provision to prop up the nhs which under staffed and under resourced. You are supposed to get teaching, this is cancelled due to “busy wards”. You have to pay £1000s for your own exams, without which you cannot progress. In order to specialty train you must move around the country.

You handover sat on broken bins, have no food available out of hours and nowhere to rest.

in 2016 junior doctors striked for better working conditions.
what happened? Nothing good. Conditions worsened as did our pay
what have we learnt? Conditions WILL not be improved

why do people go abroad?

you’re paid for EXTRA work you do
you have training
you have somewhere to sit
you’re treated like a human being
you’re paid fairly
people respect you

it isn’t all about pay. But when you leave your children 80 hours a week to work like this, and have paid your £1500 per month childcare bill (or maybe £3000 for 2 children) as you live nowhere near family for help, it’s nice to be able to afford somewhere to live

Alexandra2001 · 16/03/2023 08:40

KimmySchmitt · 16/03/2023 00:37

@Qazwsxefv you're proving my point beautifully. No it is not okay to turn up to a professional meeting with your soon-to-be boss in trackies, this is basic! And they stoated onto the ward like this, so yes patients saw them. Also other HCP students do NOT all get uniforms provided, I have always had to buy my own work clothes (student or qualified) as we're not uniformed. Even when covid hit I had to buy my own scrubs as it was suggested we wear those for infection control. And come on, a pair of black trousers and a shirt can cost £20 from Asda, nobody's insisting on suits. And you don't have to be 'unwaged', what's wrong with having a part time job? I know plenty of med students who were at uni the same time as me who could work a Saturday job so don't be giving it 'we're too busy studying'.

I doubt you ve been anywhere near a Hospital as a HCP.

Just spouting the normal anti nurse/ahp and now junior Doctor crap to denigrate, insult, to promote the Governments pov that these essential workers aren't worth a penny extra & are actually a drain on the NHS, as Coffey put it "dont like it leave, we'll get some overseas workers"

Or as one NHS manager once told me "This place (Hospital) would run just fine if we didn't have all these troublesome staff"

AviMav · 16/03/2023 08:19

Florenz · 16/03/2023 07:32

"Junior Doctor" makes me think of child doctors like Doogie Howser MD. They should be asking for a job title change if they want people to take them seriously.

Nobody uses that term who I work amongst junior doctor what is that? Amongst my colleagues they are know as the on call doctor if we need to bleep them or the SHO. Perhaps some don't realise it doesn't matter how junior they are or not they are the doctor making the decisions. The nurses go to then to escalate NOT the other way round!

Maybebabyno2 · 16/03/2023 08:12

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 23:14

Not really. Pret workers are paid more and haven’t accumulated 5/6 years of student debt. These are highly qualified professionals. Why shouldn’t they demand a higher wage than a barista?

Erm no, a pret manager earns slightly more and that is the limit of their earnings. Its complete bollocks to compare that to someone just starting out in their career after university whose earning potential will just go up and up and up.

DifferenceEngines · 16/03/2023 08:03

KimmySchmitt · 16/03/2023 07:44

I literally said in my previous post 'This is not all FY1s, but I see it in most juniors in my own profession'. It is a bigger issue now than it used to be though.

What is considered "good manners" changes with each generation.

DifferenceEngines · 16/03/2023 08:01

Socrates, 4th century BCE: "The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households. They no longer rise when elders enter the room. They contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up dainties at the table, cross their legs, and tyrannize their teachers."

KimmySchmitt · 16/03/2023 07:44

DifferenceEngines · 16/03/2023 07:04

So one student turned up in unprofessional clothing, therefore all medics are unprofessional?

Medical students can struggle with part time jobs, particularly later in the course. Most part time employers don't really appreciate people disappearing for weeks or months at time for rotations in different towns.

I literally said in my previous post 'This is not all FY1s, but I see it in most juniors in my own profession'. It is a bigger issue now than it used to be though.

Florenz · 16/03/2023 07:32

"Junior Doctor" makes me think of child doctors like Doogie Howser MD. They should be asking for a job title change if they want people to take them seriously.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 16/03/2023 07:10

I voted yanbu but I do think it's unreasonable for junior doctors to talk about an hourly wage as if they were paid per hour. they are in the early stages of a very important profession, they should be putting in plenty of hours, but they should be getting better support in that, with the extra hours being spent genuinely learning from more experienced professionals, not the reality of being left flying virtually solo (with an F2 somewhere in the building theoretically "supervising" but not actually) - extra hours ought to be spent building the experience needed to become experts in their field, and there's loads of professions where the early-years juniors have to put in 60+ hour weeks if they want to be the best and be raking in the 6 figure salaries 10 years later. instead, the extra hours are being spent propping up seriously understaffed and underfunded hospitals, it doesn't give an F1 any useful career-enhancing experience to just do more and more hours without real support.

An F1 starting salary should certainly be over £30kpa though.

DifferenceEngines · 16/03/2023 07:04

KimmySchmitt · 16/03/2023 00:37

@Qazwsxefv you're proving my point beautifully. No it is not okay to turn up to a professional meeting with your soon-to-be boss in trackies, this is basic! And they stoated onto the ward like this, so yes patients saw them. Also other HCP students do NOT all get uniforms provided, I have always had to buy my own work clothes (student or qualified) as we're not uniformed. Even when covid hit I had to buy my own scrubs as it was suggested we wear those for infection control. And come on, a pair of black trousers and a shirt can cost £20 from Asda, nobody's insisting on suits. And you don't have to be 'unwaged', what's wrong with having a part time job? I know plenty of med students who were at uni the same time as me who could work a Saturday job so don't be giving it 'we're too busy studying'.

So one student turned up in unprofessional clothing, therefore all medics are unprofessional?

Medical students can struggle with part time jobs, particularly later in the course. Most part time employers don't really appreciate people disappearing for weeks or months at time for rotations in different towns.

mids2019 · 16/03/2023 06:49

Medics moving to other countries so a 120K ultimate salary can be replaced by 200K and the public are meant to sympathise with the 'brain drain'?.Does anyone have an idea of average earnings in the UK? Why are medics moving if not for what would it in a lot of people's opinions be astronomical salries?

mids2019 · 16/03/2023 06:45

Will the medical profession be happy that the £1000,000 limiting pension pots has been removed? I am sure the public are sympathetic with this dilemma? The limit certainly makes nurses, HCAs and porters relieved about their regiment plans.......(little.hint of sarcasm)

aussiedoctor · 16/03/2023 02:42

HoppingPavlova · 15/03/2023 11:12

@alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 'How much does a Doctor make in Australia? The average doctor salary in Australia is $156,000 per year or $80 per hour. Entry-level positions start at $124,937 per year, while most experienced workers make up to $253,500 per year.'

This is not referring to Juniors and the way you have written it is quite inflammatory. I have worked in both NHS and Aus system and you are not comparing apples with apples.

Juniors are a range skills wise. We’d be stuffed without them as extra hands but equally they are frustrating to train as their knowledge is pretty low and it’s really learning in the job with a steep curve. Given this, they really shouldn’t be paid they much tbh. Yes, they pull (or should pull, but they are trying to dodge this) enormous hours but this is their only learning opportunity essentially. While booksmart they are essentially unskilled labour, through yo skilled while working in the job. It’s really an apprenticeship in a way and apprenticeships are not well paid.

The difference is with expectations these days. Back in the day 6-7 Juniors would have piled into a 3 bed rental on the basis they would only need a bed once every few days for a few hours and would never be ‘at home’, and if so most others would be out so ‘musical beds’. Now Juniors blather on about having to rent a north facing flat for one as essential to ‘decompress’ and barrack to spend less graft on the job hours wise learning. The other difference is that Juniors rarely had families etc previously, now they seem to expect that they should have salaries that support family life rather than delaying families to down the track (and yes, potentially face missing out if you are a woman).

I did not see the issue with apprentice style wages on the basis that after your ‘apprenticeship’ you will be on a really pretty penny at senior and then consultant level if in the hospital system.

Wow essentially unskilled labour hey. Gee that's so weird - I must have hallucinated the fact that junior doctors are the ones who look after hundreds of patients overnight in a hospital and make medical decisions autonomously. I also must have hallucinated all the surgical lists performed by junior doctors on their own, without a consultant physically present. Not to mention all the clinic patients that junior doctors see, assess, and make clinical decisions regarding.

Terrifying that all of this is being done by "unskilled labor". It's almost as if this is literal lies made up by someone who has no idea what they are talking about.

nocoolnamesleft · 16/03/2023 00:41

Qazwsxefv · 15/03/2023 14:07

@HoppingPavlova

I’m assuming you’re a senior in a surgical specialty or anaesthetics? Because you talk about practical skills needing to be learnt and so must mean operating or anaesthesia or cath lab or similar. Uk trained F1s should be competent in all day to day ward practical skills like ivs and ecgs as part of graduating medical school and it would be worrying if they are not and something you should be easing higher. (international grads are not always competent in this stuff because it’s not taught in all international curriculums as I am sure you are aware, but we shouldn’t be claiming uk fy1s don’t have practical expertise just because we are so short of doctors we have to import ones from aboard)

with regard to your comments that all juniors have a lot to learn- are you counting the less junior juniors in this? What wonderful hospital do you work in that has consultants in doing appendix operations or c sections at 2am becuase I’d like to apply to work there!

Btw before this strike week i haven’t seen a consultant where I work as a medical junior for three weeks before they and when I did it was because they wanted me to find something on the electronic records system they didn’t understand. I’m a GP trainee so still a junior-ish junior. I accept I have stuff still to learn about being a GP but don’t think I have much left to learn about being an SHO level doctor in this job. When it comes down to my day to day job which is 100% service provision and no training I’m confident to say I’m competent to undertake it independently- which is what I do after all. I am not being trained by anyone and don’t see why I should be paid an apprenticeship wage when no one is supervising or teaching me.

it’s not just this job- as a psychiatry junior doctor working in an inpatient psychiatric hospital I was expected to provide the medical health care for the 25 elderly inpatients on the ward. The psychiatry consultant was present for half a day a week and informed me they would defer to my option on all medical matters as they had trained outside the uk where psychiatrists did not undertake any physical health training past medical school. I did learn some stuff about old age psychiatry from them as they were very good at this but I certainly was not being supervised or trained in medical healthcare.

the job before this I was the Gynaecology SHO. I was the only doctor on the emergency Gynae clinic from 5pm-9am and all weekend. I would see all referrals and make independent decisions on who to admit and discharge. I would order and interpret the ultrasound scans and blood tests and counsel, consent and prescribe the medical management of miscarriage for these poor ladies, I would also examine (with chaperone) and remove foreign bodies or products as needed . I was taught this admittedly on my first day by another more senior junior (Gynae st3) in the old see one- do one - teach one method (and I of course already knew how to do a speculum and internal exam from medical school as it’s a core competency needed for graduation) If a patient needed theatre then and there it was an ST3 trainee I called and we would then operate together and I also was her sole assistant for c sections. I never saw a consultant in the emergency Gynae clinic - they were on the labour ward in hours, undertaking clinics and performing complex surgeries of course. I’m not claiming to know all there is to know about obstetrics and gynaecology in fact I only know a tiny bit but I am/was competent to do my job as a Gynae sho and did not receive any consultant input into learning to do so. I did assist a lovely consultant to undertake the elective c sections list a few times so I suppose i was being “trained” then but as I’m training to be a GP I’m not sure that’s a skill I have any need of knowing!

Maybe back in the old days when doctors worked in teams with consultants and juniors there was some apprenticeship model learning going on but now days the consultants do clinics and fancy surgeries juniors are not permitted to attend because of “service pressures” and juniors run inpatient medical care and emergencies out of hours. The fact that the outpatient clinics and non urgent operations have all been cancelled so that the consultants are able to work on the wards and admissions units during the strikes shows that the juniors are undertaking patient safety critical work. After all If we were all just standing about watching the consultants do everything as we’re “just learning” then there wouldn’t have been any need for the consultants to come and do our roles on strike days. Yes junior doctors do not know how to the fancy stuff yet but they are independently performing safety critical roles, and not receiving any training in the fancy stuff to make up for the fact their not paid a wage that reflects this

(this probably reads as an attack on consultants - it’s not intended to be one. They are highly trained professionals who generally undertake very necessary specialist clinics and perform complex surgeries and other fancy procedures. But in the UK we have ended up with a healthcare model where the consultants do much of the outpatient and elective care and the juniors do the emergency and inpatient care. )

True for some specialities. But try being a consultant in paediatrics in a small DGH. It's not unusual at all to be in most of the night, having been working the day before, and still be expected to work the day after. And it isn't just being called in because of the acuity of the patients: it isn't that unusual to be called in for a cannula! Some specialities are still relatively consultant led, if not consultant delivered. Which is very clearly part of our job, and how our "juniors" learn.

For the record, I support the strike, and have donated to the strike fund. We have to improve pay and conditions to stem the exodus to other countries of much needed and valuable medical professionals. Though I can't help but think that drastically reducing the crappy portfolio requirements would be one way to improve morale that wouldn't cost much!

KimmySchmitt · 16/03/2023 00:37

@Qazwsxefv you're proving my point beautifully. No it is not okay to turn up to a professional meeting with your soon-to-be boss in trackies, this is basic! And they stoated onto the ward like this, so yes patients saw them. Also other HCP students do NOT all get uniforms provided, I have always had to buy my own work clothes (student or qualified) as we're not uniformed. Even when covid hit I had to buy my own scrubs as it was suggested we wear those for infection control. And come on, a pair of black trousers and a shirt can cost £20 from Asda, nobody's insisting on suits. And you don't have to be 'unwaged', what's wrong with having a part time job? I know plenty of med students who were at uni the same time as me who could work a Saturday job so don't be giving it 'we're too busy studying'.

Qazwsxefv · 16/03/2023 00:12

KimmySchmitt · 15/03/2023 20:14

@juniordoctor you've misunderstood the phrase I fear. 'Paying your dues' doesn't meant you owe the public, it means doing the grunt work and working your way up the ladder within an internal system, as opposed to walking in on day one thinking you can run the place. I'm not speaking as a member of the public, I'm speaking as a fellow HCP. This is not all FY1s, but I see it in most juniors in my own profession. We've had medical students rocking up to meet the consultant prior to their placement in trackies. There just seems to be a lack of professionalism and respect among some young trainees.

We’re talking about junior doctors here not med students. I don’t think that junior doctors should be paid a low wage because some unrelated undergraduate teen once turned up PRIOR to starting placement in a tracksuit.

With regards to the lack of deference I think your putting effect before cause - have you considered that the fact that juniors don’t want to do the grunt work because there no longer being paid a decent wage to do it. Back in the day junior doctors earnt 26% more than they do now per hour so maybe they were more happy to get on with the job as they were being paid more to do it.

Add in that the justification for the low wages juniors get is because we’re apparently being trained but no training ever materialises - yes if a senior tells me I once more can’t have my study leave to actually go to the teaching I’m supposed to go to because of “service needs” I’m probably going to be less than impressed. The low wage is justified because apparently we’re being trained - except we’re not being trained so the wage isn’t justified.

Finally juniors know they have to because there are just too many well publicised cases of seniors throwing juniors under the bus if something goes wrong and the fact that all of the evidence shows that flattened hierarchies have better patient safety outcomes. I know if I see something not being done right I’m supposed to speak up not get on with it because a more senior person told me to. As a HCP I’m sure you’re aware that the evidence all shows that encouraging juniors of all healthcare professions to speak up leads to less adverse patient outcomes. I’ve been a student and junior through an awful lots of healthcare scandals from mid staffs to okendon. When you know the department you work in is currently being investigated for multiple cases of negligence you tend not to value the integrity and knowledge of the people running that department.

(with regards to the undergrad student I would suggest that if not in a patient facing role they (teen with no money) can turn up in any clothing they like as long as it’s clean and decent. I assume when they actually started the placement they were in office clothes or scrubs? Other HCP students get uniforms provided - medical students have to buy their own work approved clothing which when you are in debt and unwaged and not from a background where you have a load of suits your parents bought you it’s a bit expensive to have to buy a suit when your not even going to see a patient)