Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
KimmySchmitt · 16/03/2023 23:18

@Alexandra2001 *Why put them on a system which you ought to know is a discredited system?

Bottom line is a JD does many more years training and needs far more qualifications than a AHP/Nurse yet starting pay is, as an hourly comparison far less*

I said the payrise should be in line with AfC, as in their pay should increase the same as those on similar pay on the AfC payscale.

That's not really true. Nurse starting pay is less than FY1 starting pay for a kick-off. An FY1 hasn't done 'many more years training' than an ANP or other AHP with postgrads and prescribing.

Maggiethecat · 16/03/2023 21:53

@SamanthaCaine - but it’s cumulative the issues that they are dealing with. If they had to deal with moving around often, but had decent working conditions and decent pay I hardly think they’d be striking.

Raising public awareness about what they face as doctors is a good thing so that people can understand the circumstances in which they deliver service.

To talk about them “whingeing” about one aspect of their professional duty does trivialise their action.

SamanthaCaine · 16/03/2023 21:17

DifferenceEngines · 16/03/2023 20:24

There is a massive difference between moving every 12-18 months and moving every 4 months. No comparison at all, really. Also, as a contractor, I presume you had some sort of choice as to whether you wanted to accept the contract, or whether you waited for the next one offered. In medicine, it's accept or not work at all. I am aware that the military does that kind of thing, but... that's the military!

Also, theoretically it was about education, and it probably once was, but these days, it's about service requirements.

Rubbish. I could just as easily move about every 4 months as I have 12. It actually makes very little difference and even less once you've become accustomed to change. Yes I made a choice as I like moving about. Doctors also make a choice, unless they're sleepwalking into these positions.

As I said I'm not just talking about my own experience but other industries/sectors have employees moving about regularly.

WaitingForEgg · 16/03/2023 20:43

Maggiethecat · 16/03/2023 20:32

@DifferenceEngines - what are you on about? Doctors should put up and shut up and be grateful for the privilege of serving the NHS and the great British public.

Many posters on this thread have made me feel soooooo grateful 🤣

DifferenceEngines · 16/03/2023 20:43

SamanthaCaine · 16/03/2023 12:14

No I've not moved hundreds of miles but I've moved about quite a lot and know what it's like to be the new person in a completely different company every 12-18 months. I did this over 10 years as a contractor. I just crack on and actually, it's something that you get used to and should make you better at dealing with new/uncomfortable surroundings. I'm guessing this is something that is designed to improve your ability in this area but you see it as negative.

I guess we're all different but I'm not necessarily talking about myself but lots of other jobs where people move about or work away a lot as required.

Software training is often a myth. I've not been trained much in my entire career as most employers call this 'on the job training'.

Yes we are entitled to “whinge”. I really hope you do not require medical care in the near future, you may struggle to find it

Classy. As I said, you have an absolutely valid complaint about working conditions but the rest just sounds like a whinge and normal for other industries.

Also, I'm in Australia, and medical staff do get software training here. Why? Because medical software can be quite complex and very different from one location to the next, and because errors in using it can result in serious repercussions. It's a patient safety issue.

Maggiethecat · 16/03/2023 20:32

DifferenceEngines · 16/03/2023 20:24

There is a massive difference between moving every 12-18 months and moving every 4 months. No comparison at all, really. Also, as a contractor, I presume you had some sort of choice as to whether you wanted to accept the contract, or whether you waited for the next one offered. In medicine, it's accept or not work at all. I am aware that the military does that kind of thing, but... that's the military!

Also, theoretically it was about education, and it probably once was, but these days, it's about service requirements.

@DifferenceEngines - what are you on about? Doctors should put up and shut up and be grateful for the privilege of serving the NHS and the great British public.

DifferenceEngines · 16/03/2023 20:24

SamanthaCaine · 16/03/2023 12:14

No I've not moved hundreds of miles but I've moved about quite a lot and know what it's like to be the new person in a completely different company every 12-18 months. I did this over 10 years as a contractor. I just crack on and actually, it's something that you get used to and should make you better at dealing with new/uncomfortable surroundings. I'm guessing this is something that is designed to improve your ability in this area but you see it as negative.

I guess we're all different but I'm not necessarily talking about myself but lots of other jobs where people move about or work away a lot as required.

Software training is often a myth. I've not been trained much in my entire career as most employers call this 'on the job training'.

Yes we are entitled to “whinge”. I really hope you do not require medical care in the near future, you may struggle to find it

Classy. As I said, you have an absolutely valid complaint about working conditions but the rest just sounds like a whinge and normal for other industries.

There is a massive difference between moving every 12-18 months and moving every 4 months. No comparison at all, really. Also, as a contractor, I presume you had some sort of choice as to whether you wanted to accept the contract, or whether you waited for the next one offered. In medicine, it's accept or not work at all. I am aware that the military does that kind of thing, but... that's the military!

Also, theoretically it was about education, and it probably once was, but these days, it's about service requirements.

Clavinova · 16/03/2023 20:06

'How much does a Doctor make in Australia? The average doctor salary in Australia is $156,000 per year or $80 per hour. Entry-level positions start at $124,937 per year...

Entry-level positions start at $70,470 here?

medrecruit.medworld.com/jobs/listing/resident-medical-officer?workType=Permanent&location=Australian+Capital+Territory%3BNew+South+Wales%3BNorthern+Territory%3BQueensland%3BSouth+Australia%3BVictoria%3BTasmania%3BWestern+Australia&page=1&locationName=Australia

Clavinova · 16/03/2023 19:49

Wasn't meant to be in bold text;
Looks like £32,000 to me (Probationer)

Clavinova · 16/03/2023 19:47

pigalow27
After all the proposed salary rises are implemented teachers in Scotland will have a starting salary of 38k

Looks like £32,000 to me (Probationer)

www.nasuwt.org.uk/advice/pay-pensions/pay-scales/scotland-pay-scales.html

Alexandra2001 · 16/03/2023 18:45

I'm not saying doctors don't work hard, they do. But I think their pay rises should be in line with AfC

Why put them on a system which you ought to know is a discredited system?

Bottom line is a JD does many more years training and needs far more qualifications than a AHP/Nurse yet starting pay is, as an hourly comparison far less.

But as i ve said on many of these types of threads, folk are leaving, what you think they should be happy with is neither here nor there

Plus as we can all see today, strikes work.... just a short while ago, above 3.5% was inflationary and unaffordable... today its affordable, isn't inflationary and wont come out of existing budgets.

I personally think the Unions should have held out for more but maybe its a decent compromise for all?

Florenz · 16/03/2023 18:17

justasking111 · 16/03/2023 12:20

Maybe these young doctors should have pips on a lanyard denoting years of experience. Their pay should increase each year also. They deserve more respect from patients and administration.

They should have badges with stars on, with the more experienced doctors having more stars.

MintTeaAndChocolate · 16/03/2023 18:14

Florenz · 13/03/2023 23:09

They are paid more than enough. Perhaps there should be a limit on how many hours they can work both in a day and in a week. But I am sick of their whinging and misrepresenting of how much they earn, comparing their wage to that of Pret workers is just insulting.

Well I pay my cleaner £15phr
As much as I LOVE her, she's not saving any lives.

Qazwsxefv · 16/03/2023 14:27

@HoppingPavlova

so to be clear:

  1. you last worked in Australia where juniors earn much more for less hours in the uk
  2. junior doctor working conditions and pay were better in the uk in what the 1980s-1990s?
  3. you left the country you trained in in search of a better life elsewhere I

all the juniors on this thread would probably agree that the uk working conditions and were better 20 years ago. They were better 5 years ago. They were pretty decent when I started working in the nhs 11 years ago. The whole fact of the campaign we want to go back to how it was. it’s a campaign for pay restoration to previous levels not a pay rise.

we want those very conditions you left aus for the uk for back in the day.

since you haven’t worked in the nhs for a while listen to the juniors currently working in it when they say it’s not good right now. I first worked in the nhs as an sho grade junior 10 years ago and I still do now. My pay was acceptable, my working conditions reasonable 10 years ago. It’s got worse way way worse recently.

and as for putting up and shutting up and doing the long hours you did “apprentice style” firstly your saying you didn’t do just l that - you left for pastures greener and secondly since covid the apprentice style training system that was slowly dying with the 2016 contract has completely collapsed. I haven’t seen a consultant in weeks in my work as it’s a junior run service - there isn’t allocated a consultant to supervise it. No one is supervising us day to day. 100-200 patients a week go through our service with no consultant being aware they exist (we’re an admission avoidance team so as the patients haven’t been admitted yet they haven’t been allocated a named consultant yet (clever how hospital management gets round the rules about supervision for juniors isn’t it) I have sometimes called the consultant on call for my speciality to be told no-one is available that day - unfilled roster gaps. My named clinical supervisor dosent work in the same hospital as me so she’s not providing any hands on supervsion either - not that she could give it since their not her patients)

In the last three years I have only worked in two departments/Gp practices the cqc (the hospital inspector incase they were past your day) considers good. Most places I am allocated
to work like my current one are “inadequate and unsafe” (grades gained before I started there). I’ve given evidence just this week to the ockenden inquiry about just how very very bad things were on my obs and Gynae job a year ago. Do you really think that I am receiving anything that might be considered to be “training” in departments that don’t provide safe care? Would you listen to anything you were “taught” by departments that have just been found responsible for causing deaths
due to their poor practice. I would say I’m better off doing the near exact opposite of what such departments do and teach. Rotating juniors were told by trust management that we were responsible for bringing in and showing the departments we rotate into good practice in documentation and team working. Specific junior doctor level posts called “patient safety fellows” were created to try and bring about postive change and were expected to create and Enact improvement projects to fix the issues. When the juniors are the ones being allocated the job of fixing the department issues the claim we’re apprentices falls down quite spectacularly.

You retired pre covid. Pre covid /pre Brexit the system was creaking but just about holding. Juniors weren’t on strike then (although we were in 2016). The system has since broken. I’d love to return to the nhs I worked in 10 or even five years ago - the one you worked in. It’s gone now so please stop saying we need to just put up with things becuase things used to be worse - they didn’t they were better and juniors are trying to get back to that.

Artisticpaint · 16/03/2023 14:19

HoppingPavlova · 16/03/2023 13:35

@juniordoctor If this was ever true (giving strong Monty Python's Four Yorkshiremen vibes), it would be a breach of every tenancy agreement now and the landlord would probably be breaking the law around HMOs. And there's one key thing you've forgotten to mention - your generation had free (as a house officer) or subsidised hospital accomodation on-site and free meals provided 24/7

Where to start. Yes, I do love MP, what a crime but all I wrote was true. Yes, I am ‘retired’, have been for a few years, pretty much immediately preCovid, which means I now work a desk job out of the system as opposed to a clinical facing role. Was Consultant hospital staff. Thanks for insisting I’m out of touch, not so as all my friends (Consultant level hospital) are still just hanging in there treading the boards and we catch up frequently. I’m also still in contact with many of those I used to work with in the UK.

I am in Aus and the ironic fact is that our conditions were so bad starting out that we were dying to get across to the UK which was utopia in comparison, and which I did at a point and worked there for many years. All your diatribe above with free accom and food doesn’t apply as we didn’t get that in Aus, that was UK. We did have one room with bunk beds at major hospitals where we would kip if we got lucky enough, nothing as flash at smaller rural as we also had to cycle around. As for all your bulldust about tenancy agreements, hilarious. Tenancy agreements back then were nothing like today, zero rules re sub letting and a simple case of visiting the real estate with that weeks rent and a form to state tenancy was swapping from one person to someone else (no approvals or fuss needed back then).

As for your 72hour week and overtime, I use that to demonstrate the gulf in expectations. We often worked around 72hours straight, hopeful of a tiny kip here and there in a bunk but more often than not didn’t get it. We were lucky to get 24hrs before returning for next shift and did it all again, on repeat, endlessly. And yes, very well aware this is no longer theoretically permitted. We did it without complaint or whinging as that’s just the way it was. People did have the odd quick bonk in the bunks though🤣. We accepted we had zero lives outside of this and wouldn’t have even dreamed of being able to attend family weddings etc.

In general people left it later to marry, there was not the expectation of having a domestic life as early as people expect this now. Most women didn’t have kids as it wasn’t considered compatible with the working conditions until you climbed out and progressed on. Was especially hard for women as had to work harder to prove yourself with basically all male consultants. People these days don’t think like that, they feel entitled to houses, kids etc although how with being shifted around I don’t know, but then it’s crying hard done by. I’m rare in that I have kids, left it late but no issues, most (not all) women of my gen I know didn’t have kids or slipped in one at a ripe age via ivf. I don’t know one man in my circles who married and started a family until early middle age once they were set up. It wasn’t practical to have them young when choosing this line of work and people accepted this but now the choice seems to be have it all much earlier or whinge.

I’ve not stated it’s just about money, I understand it’s not just the money but conditions but am pointing out that there is also an enormous gulf with expectations now as well and that’s the aspect I question.

So you’re slagging off UK doctors and you are Australian

justasking111 · 16/03/2023 14:00

Something odd on Google before Xmas found four GPs I know that were listed as private. That's been removed.

I'm not sure how the private GP system works if it's online only I could be talking to a doctor between John o groats and lands end. So the GPs I know personally could be covering calls nationwide. They're seemingly too bashful to advertise locally.

WaitingForEgg · 16/03/2023 13:37

SamanthaCaine · 16/03/2023 12:14

No I've not moved hundreds of miles but I've moved about quite a lot and know what it's like to be the new person in a completely different company every 12-18 months. I did this over 10 years as a contractor. I just crack on and actually, it's something that you get used to and should make you better at dealing with new/uncomfortable surroundings. I'm guessing this is something that is designed to improve your ability in this area but you see it as negative.

I guess we're all different but I'm not necessarily talking about myself but lots of other jobs where people move about or work away a lot as required.

Software training is often a myth. I've not been trained much in my entire career as most employers call this 'on the job training'.

Yes we are entitled to “whinge”. I really hope you do not require medical care in the near future, you may struggle to find it

Classy. As I said, you have an absolutely valid complaint about working conditions but the rest just sounds like a whinge and normal for other industries.

There is a very big difference between moving jobs every 12-18 months and every 4 months I assure you. Medicine is not my first job. I worked other jobs beforehand and am not the snowflake you seem to think I am.

You think that calling half broken, fed up professionals who are fighting for fairness to keep our health service function “whingers” Is classy?! At the rate things are going there will NOT be a doctor to see you if you are unwell. This is a fact. The health service is crumbling and the public have absolutely no idea how bad it is.

If I’m honest threads like this one have just made me more sure I will not remain in the Uk long term. Democracy is not “whinging”, fighting for fair pay to enable women to stay in medicine is not “whinging”. Keeping pay low makes it more difficult for working class people to enter and remain in medicine. It should not be that you can only do specialty training if you have parents to help you pay your bills. You think that keeping pay down helps equality. It doesn’t. It makes medicine a career for the wealthy. People leave because they can’t afford exams to progress. People leave because they cannot afford their childcare bill.

We do not do a variety of jobs to make us better. You simply have no idea what you are talking about. You have never been a medic. You have never done our training, you have no idea

HoppingPavlova · 16/03/2023 13:35

@juniordoctor If this was ever true (giving strong Monty Python's Four Yorkshiremen vibes), it would be a breach of every tenancy agreement now and the landlord would probably be breaking the law around HMOs. And there's one key thing you've forgotten to mention - your generation had free (as a house officer) or subsidised hospital accomodation on-site and free meals provided 24/7

Where to start. Yes, I do love MP, what a crime but all I wrote was true. Yes, I am ‘retired’, have been for a few years, pretty much immediately preCovid, which means I now work a desk job out of the system as opposed to a clinical facing role. Was Consultant hospital staff. Thanks for insisting I’m out of touch, not so as all my friends (Consultant level hospital) are still just hanging in there treading the boards and we catch up frequently. I’m also still in contact with many of those I used to work with in the UK.

I am in Aus and the ironic fact is that our conditions were so bad starting out that we were dying to get across to the UK which was utopia in comparison, and which I did at a point and worked there for many years. All your diatribe above with free accom and food doesn’t apply as we didn’t get that in Aus, that was UK. We did have one room with bunk beds at major hospitals where we would kip if we got lucky enough, nothing as flash at smaller rural as we also had to cycle around. As for all your bulldust about tenancy agreements, hilarious. Tenancy agreements back then were nothing like today, zero rules re sub letting and a simple case of visiting the real estate with that weeks rent and a form to state tenancy was swapping from one person to someone else (no approvals or fuss needed back then).

As for your 72hour week and overtime, I use that to demonstrate the gulf in expectations. We often worked around 72hours straight, hopeful of a tiny kip here and there in a bunk but more often than not didn’t get it. We were lucky to get 24hrs before returning for next shift and did it all again, on repeat, endlessly. And yes, very well aware this is no longer theoretically permitted. We did it without complaint or whinging as that’s just the way it was. People did have the odd quick bonk in the bunks though🤣. We accepted we had zero lives outside of this and wouldn’t have even dreamed of being able to attend family weddings etc.

In general people left it later to marry, there was not the expectation of having a domestic life as early as people expect this now. Most women didn’t have kids as it wasn’t considered compatible with the working conditions until you climbed out and progressed on. Was especially hard for women as had to work harder to prove yourself with basically all male consultants. People these days don’t think like that, they feel entitled to houses, kids etc although how with being shifted around I don’t know, but then it’s crying hard done by. I’m rare in that I have kids, left it late but no issues, most (not all) women of my gen I know didn’t have kids or slipped in one at a ripe age via ivf. I don’t know one man in my circles who married and started a family until early middle age once they were set up. It wasn’t practical to have them young when choosing this line of work and people accepted this but now the choice seems to be have it all much earlier or whinge.

I’ve not stated it’s just about money, I understand it’s not just the money but conditions but am pointing out that there is also an enormous gulf with expectations now as well and that’s the aspect I question.

pigalow27 · 16/03/2023 12:44

After all the proposed salary rises are implemented teachers in Scotland will have a starting salary of 38k. I think that is right and do 1st year junior doctors should probably start on 43-44k

justasking111 · 16/03/2023 12:20

Maybe these young doctors should have pips on a lanyard denoting years of experience. Their pay should increase each year also. They deserve more respect from patients and administration.

Quisquam · 16/03/2023 12:17

Our union has changed a lot since the 2016 strikes. They have realised no one cares about “saving the nhs”, they need to ask for something concrete. We will continue to walk out until we are listened to.

Imo, that should say the government doesn’t care about saving the NHS, because they are a wealthy elite, who can afford private medical care; and are leaving the NHS to fail, so the population cries out for a change - then they and their mates can make a killing, because they are sitting on the boards of private providers (Americans) poised to take over; and get their hands on the NHS data on patients for free!

Anyone else, especially the poor stand to lose out in an American system, and should care about the NHS - because that’s where we are heading, not a European mutual insurance system! However, until there is a general election, what can the population do about it?

SamanthaCaine · 16/03/2023 12:14

WaitingForEgg · 16/03/2023 09:35

You have been forced to move 100s of miles multiple times with no choice whatsoever?!

Apart from the military no I cannot think of jobs that require this. These moves are not optional you realise? I have lived in 4 areas of the uk including the south of England and Scotland.

i don’t think you understand my point. Every ward, department, hospital runs completely differently. How long do you work until you feel settled in a job? We move every 4 months. We often get NO training on these computer systems, and delays in our time cost lives.

Yes we are entitled to “whinge”. I really hope you do not require medical care in the near future, you may struggle to find it

No I've not moved hundreds of miles but I've moved about quite a lot and know what it's like to be the new person in a completely different company every 12-18 months. I did this over 10 years as a contractor. I just crack on and actually, it's something that you get used to and should make you better at dealing with new/uncomfortable surroundings. I'm guessing this is something that is designed to improve your ability in this area but you see it as negative.

I guess we're all different but I'm not necessarily talking about myself but lots of other jobs where people move about or work away a lot as required.

Software training is often a myth. I've not been trained much in my entire career as most employers call this 'on the job training'.

Yes we are entitled to “whinge”. I really hope you do not require medical care in the near future, you may struggle to find it

Classy. As I said, you have an absolutely valid complaint about working conditions but the rest just sounds like a whinge and normal for other industries.

KimmySchmitt · 16/03/2023 11:03

@Qazwsxefv . When they work out the average hours for the 4-6months they don’t work out your individual hours if you are a full timer (they do for less than full timers) but the average hours of all the doctors on that roster. So you may well work 6 weekends but only be paid for five (and the other way round). The clever rota coordinator can manipulate these averages in such a way that everyone feels they are hard done

I didn't know this, I thought the banding generally benefited people. See, this is the sort of thing the strikes should be publicising. Focusing on (starting, minimum) hourly rate just winds people up.

@Alexandra2001 I doubt you ve been anywhere near a Hospital as a HCP.

Doubt it all you like, I have 10 years service and a DP who's a staff nurse, so plenty real life experience of working in the NHS. Absolutely no anti-nurse sentiment from me, the real scandal is ANPs prescribing and managing episodes of clinical care independently for a band 6! Doctors work under direction of a consultant (legally), other HCPs are independent practitioners. I found out a few years ago that my indemnity insurance is more expensive than a registrar's.

I'm not saying doctors don't work hard, they do. But I think their pay rises should be in line with AfC.

Suzi888 · 16/03/2023 10:44

EsmeT · 13/03/2023 23:23

We all have to start from the bottom... Doctors included.

Their ‘bottom’ is after 5/6 years studying.

I would say 40k start, rising incrementally year by year. The more experienced they get, the more money and an 8 hour shift.

Qazwsxefv · 16/03/2023 10:38

@ArdeteiMasazxu sorry for going on. Realised I had forgot an important point. When they work out the average hours for the 4-6months they don’t work out your individual hours if you are a full timer (they do for less than full timers) but the average hours of all the doctors on that roster. So you may well work 6 weekends but only be paid for five (and the other way round). The clever rota coordinator can manipulate these averages in such a way that everyone feels they are hard done by by tricks such as arranging when mandatory off days are taken. They can also change the roster to cut hours and so pay with just six weeks notice - if you end up making a fuss about working conditions then this may well be done to you!

Swipe left for the next trending thread