Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
DifferenceEngines · 14/03/2023 08:47

moveoverye · 14/03/2023 08:40

I feel like everyone forgets that junior doctors are only junior doctors for a couple of years. Yes they work hard but I think as a starting salary that’s really not too bad - they’re still in training really aren't they?

Everyone’s like “Oh but to become a GP takes 6 years of medical school and 10 years of further training” or whatever. Yes, well, most high earning jobs take training and career progression don’t they? 18+ 16 = 34. If I was on a six figure salary by the age of 34 I’d be laughing.

Not many people finish in minimum time. Try pushing 40 and having no control over where you live. Having to find a new job every year.

DifferenceEngines · 14/03/2023 08:41

GP is a specially, by the way, with exams that need to be passed and a training program to completed.

moveoverye · 14/03/2023 08:40

I feel like everyone forgets that junior doctors are only junior doctors for a couple of years. Yes they work hard but I think as a starting salary that’s really not too bad - they’re still in training really aren't they?

Everyone’s like “Oh but to become a GP takes 6 years of medical school and 10 years of further training” or whatever. Yes, well, most high earning jobs take training and career progression don’t they? 18+ 16 = 34. If I was on a six figure salary by the age of 34 I’d be laughing.

clopper · 14/03/2023 08:35

lauriefairycake They should have NO debt, it should be fully funded - they should have to work for NHS for 5 years after qualifying as 'payment'

I think this would be part of the solution.

I also think they should get rid of the title ‘junior’ or only use it for maybe the first 2 years after qualifying, like we do with the renamed Early Career Teacher. After that just call them doctors as it’s very misleading.

I also think that they shouldn’t work such ridiculous hours. But of course this will only happen when we have enough of them to cover the hours there are in a hospital. I would say minimum starting wage for first year should be 35 000. I would pay trainee gps a bit more as that is what we need right now.

The terrible thing is that there are so many really clever and motivated kids trying to get into study medicine, it’s so competitive. We need to open up more training places quickly.

Ideally I would like to see all money from the National Lottery be directed towards the NHS. As people are not motivated to pay extra tax to fund what’s needed, maybe this indirect tax would solve a problem?

DifferenceEngines · 14/03/2023 08:30

JL642 · 14/03/2023 08:19

The only thing I find confusing is that I have a family in law member on a very, very high salary as a part time GP. Not sure when the “jump” to that high salary happens. I’m sure he didn’t qualify that long ago but I could be wrong. However if I was a junior doctor and knew I would be getting this high salary in 4 years (for example) I’d say it’s worth sticking out a lower salary as a junior doctor. As before I don’t know the ins and outs of the profession ie when you move from junior to GP.

Do you know what the salary actually is? "High" is very subjective, and appearances can be decieving. FWIW, where I am, GP takes 6 years of medical school + 3-4 years hospital work, + 4 years GP training, minimum.

cyclamenqueen · 14/03/2023 08:26

Doctors are high achievers from often quite financially stable middle class backgrounds

this is an important point, it is becoming increasingly for difficult for people from low income backgrounds to become doctors . There has been some research that shows that of it is increasingly necessary to have parental financial support just to get through the last two years of medical school let alone the foundation years.

many of my friends are still financially supporting their young doctor dc, either directly or by doing things like standing guarantor for rental ( I have just had to stand guarantor for my ds who is 30 and has 9 years of solid employment and whose income covers the rent) or pay for car insurance , professional exams .

This is really exclusionary , the medical profession should be a viable option for anyone academically able it should not be the reserve of those with financially comfortable backgrounds

JL642 · 14/03/2023 08:19

The only thing I find confusing is that I have a family in law member on a very, very high salary as a part time GP. Not sure when the “jump” to that high salary happens. I’m sure he didn’t qualify that long ago but I could be wrong. However if I was a junior doctor and knew I would be getting this high salary in 4 years (for example) I’d say it’s worth sticking out a lower salary as a junior doctor. As before I don’t know the ins and outs of the profession ie when you move from junior to GP.

Alexandra2001 · 14/03/2023 08:19

Tinner01 · 14/03/2023 08:11

And who is going to fund these magical rises in pay? Not the Mumsnetters claiming ‘work doesn’t pay’ and encouraging everyone to claim as many benefits as they possibly can 🙄

Junior doctors deserve a pay rise, in line with inflation, and better working conditions. To compare their pay with that of pret workers is absolutely ridiculous, taking into account the career progression and extremely generous pension.

Government is funding the building of many new nuclear attack submarines and is wasting 10s of billions on HS2.

A better question is "How will the NHS function without (enough) Junior Doctors?"

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 08:15

@Tinner01

Maybe all those mn whose ohs avoid tax?

Tinner01 · 14/03/2023 08:11

And who is going to fund these magical rises in pay? Not the Mumsnetters claiming ‘work doesn’t pay’ and encouraging everyone to claim as many benefits as they possibly can 🙄

Junior doctors deserve a pay rise, in line with inflation, and better working conditions. To compare their pay with that of pret workers is absolutely ridiculous, taking into account the career progression and extremely generous pension.

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 07:58

I think this is the wrong time to strike.

The timing undermines the very legitimate claims of nursing staff that could only dream of the salaries juniour doctors will eventually earn. The 35% salary increase will just frustrate a public who are fully aware of consultant salaries at a time of a cost of living crisis.

Doctors are high achievers from often quite financially stable middle class backgrounds who have made a choice to enter medicine instead of other lucrative careers. Medics put up with a few years of average pay and poor hours because they are effectively coupling training and practice similar to other professional graduates e.g. accountants and lawyers. At the time when the majority have families and settle down they will be financially set for life. The same does not apply to other staff.

junior doctors should like their consultant peers support pay increased for those that truly needs it in the NHS such as nurses and paramedics and not undermine their efforts through disingenuous claims of poverty and outrageous pay claims.

fizzyfood · 14/03/2023 07:48

£20 per hour sounds reasonable.

Spendonsend · 14/03/2023 07:48

I'm an administrator with an A level, level qualification in my type of admin. I earn £16 an hour in the private sector with a 5% pension contribution and £15.32 in the state sector with a 12% contribution to my pension. Its not particulatly stressful but I suppose my name is accountable for some things publicly. These are not life and death things.

So i think doctors pay is crap. I dont understand why we all argue that everyone should have crap pay all the time.

I do think twice as many doctors would make the job nicer than more pay but the two are linked. So an increase in pay plus more doctors is the answer.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 07:47

I think it's interesting that on any higher earner thread lots of people will argue that they deserve their ridiculous wages because they work hard and will leave if they aren't paid market rate.

Yet when discussing public sector roles the argument is it doesn't matter how hard you work or what you do, just be grateful you have a job

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 07:44

@Tiredoftiers

I was thinking more of a brand new band 7 who definitely won't be operating at St 3/4 level which is why I said bottom. Not all band 7s are prescribes for a start

But then I think nurses should be getting much more than they are

cyclamenqueen · 14/03/2023 07:43

But they are not paid a lot in comparison to the amount of responsibility that they hold in their jobs. These people hold peoples lives in their hands/heads . Of course they should be paid more than people who make coffee .

If someone leaves Pret then they just go out and replace them, a couple of shifts of training and they are off. If a Doctor leaves you can’t just go and get them off the street, it takes at least 7 years to train a doctor . That’s why they should be paid well , because they are highly skilled and carry a huge responsibilities and are essentially a scarce resource.

Alexandra2001 · 14/03/2023 07:33

Florenz · 14/03/2023 07:27

I'd have more respect for doctors if they were just open and said "we're paid a lot already but we're greedy and want even more, otherwise we'll piss off to Australia and let you all die" instead of crying poverty and saying they're paid less than Pret workers which is just insulting people's intelligence. Doctors are intelligent people for the most part but they're treating the general public like idiots at the moment.

Why do you think a Junior Doc today is worth 26% less to the nation than they were in 2005 ?

Alexandra2001 · 14/03/2023 07:31

Florenz · 14/03/2023 07:22

Hourly rate only matters if you're paid at an hourly rate. Doctors aren't, they're salaried.

Thats irrelevant, there is still an hourly rate that they work for but either way....why is it "insulting" ?

fwiw i know a junior Doc, 2 years out from qualified, off sick with stress, she just cannot stomach how many people are dying needlessly, whilst waiting for treatment.
I counted 23 Ambulances waiting outside Derriford's AE dept last Monday afternoon.

She is now actively looking to work abroad, all that time and money to train her.... wasted.

Florenz · 14/03/2023 07:27

I'd have more respect for doctors if they were just open and said "we're paid a lot already but we're greedy and want even more, otherwise we'll piss off to Australia and let you all die" instead of crying poverty and saying they're paid less than Pret workers which is just insulting people's intelligence. Doctors are intelligent people for the most part but they're treating the general public like idiots at the moment.

cyclamenqueen · 14/03/2023 07:25

Florenz · 14/03/2023 07:22

Hourly rate only matters if you're paid at an hourly rate. Doctors aren't, they're salaried.

Actually because if the weird terms and different hourly rates paid according to shift patterns their pay is more akin to an hourly rate than a salary

cyclamenqueen · 14/03/2023 07:23

@wot3va a GP is not a junior doctor . They have completed their specialist training . Also they can only do GO training after doing their FY in hospitals where they would have had to move jobs every 4 months. They have done very well if they managed to stay in the same city, well done them but that is quite difficult to achieve especially if the specialty that you want to pursue has a scarcity of training places which is an increasing problem .

Tiredoftiers · 14/03/2023 07:23

Botw1 · 13/03/2023 23:12

I don't think they're paid enough and think they shouldn't have to pay uni fees as long as they work for the NHS for 10 years say?

They should prob be on the same as a bottom band 7

I agree that they aren’t paid enough and they definitely deserve a rise. Do you mean FY1s should be paid the same as bottom band 7s? A bottom band 7 maybe an ANP in a role described as being allied to ST 3/4 level, so to state they should be sane as a bottom band 7 shows nurses with advanced practice skills little respect or recognition of what they do.

Florenz · 14/03/2023 07:22

Hourly rate only matters if you're paid at an hourly rate. Doctors aren't, they're salaried.

Alexandra2001 · 14/03/2023 07:20

Florenz · 13/03/2023 23:09

They are paid more than enough. Perhaps there should be a limit on how many hours they can work both in a day and in a week. But I am sick of their whinging and misrepresenting of how much they earn, comparing their wage to that of Pret workers is just insulting.

Why is it insulting if its true? though it is the attack line from the Govt too?

Hourly rate is hourly rate..... Plenty of low skilled jobs pay more than £14 ph.

BUT the point here is Dr's are leaving the NHS, so whatever you or i think, they are voting with their feet... putting up with poor conditions... getting experience and then leaving, same with pretty much all HCPs.

Junior Doc's work long hours because there isn't enough of them... how does your thinking get us more Doctors?

wot3va · 14/03/2023 07:13

Why does everyone keep saying that junior doctors move every few months?? A friend of mine is a gP in training and has worked in the same place since graduating 🤷‍♀️

Starting salaries are just that . A start. And I hate how people keep remind us how long it takes to be a consult. I am pleased it takes so long. Making life and death sect, or serious medical decisions should require a lot of training. And most jobs are about 10 years before getting into senior positions.

I think the starting salary should be around 35k ish . But other than that , I don't support the strike