Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
mids2019 · 14/03/2023 10:36

@Botw1

if there is recruitment crisis how do we squad the circle that is medics is a massively oversubscribed course? I am aware of applicants with superlative academic qualifications being rejected. The reason for the the recruitment crisis is not due to a lack of suitably qualified applicants for medicine but did to a shortage of training places partly due to the cost of training (and salary is a cost). It also benefits a profession to limit numbers as that increases salary in genral.

contrast the situation above with that for nursing where I feel there is a genuine recruitment crisis. People aren't queuing up to do nursing and busting their b@lls to get the grades necessary for courses as at a fundamental level the career isn't as well renumerated.

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 10:36

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 10:27

@WaitingForEgg

Our local trust has lost 8 consultants across various specialities this year to retirement.

They have no applicants for the posts

Frankly why would people bother

”junior” doctors train for 5-15 years
in many specialties there are NO consultants in the hospital at night. The hospital is held up by junior doctors.

There are rota gaps emerging all over the hospital. Thousands on exams, indemnity, car parking. One year on Christmas day we were given a satsuma to say thank you, but had a rota 50% covered.

“most are then consultants” not true now. No one wants to stay in training in the uk. I am a working class doctor who worked my arse off to get into medicine. I am first generation uni let alone medical school. My husband earns well and I am not greedy. However I’m so sick of the way we are treated, by the government and frankly the public opinion that I may well not stay. I’m here because my daughter is happy in school. My parents are elderly and here. But once I finish training I could easily move to Australia/Canada/USA. This is the story over and over again. You pay and train these doctors, and all of them are going to leave.

MissyB1 · 14/03/2023 10:35

Jill688 · 14/03/2023 00:51

On the left what they’re paid, on the right what they want.

£14/hr -> £19/hr
£16/hr -> £22/hr
£19/hr -> £25/hr
£24/hr -> £32/hr
£28/hr -> £38/hr

@Jill688 I love those stats, and what they want sounds very aciveable to me. Where did you get the figures from?

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 10:31

@WaitingForEgg

As you state we are dealing with elite professionals and elite candidates. However do you realise that from the lens of the general public there may not be not enough to elicit huge public sympathy with the salaries you mention?

Medics can work abroad for more but how many other countries have an NHS like ours frees at the point of delivery? We could always revert to a private model of healthcare in this country where medics essentially become self employed or work in partnerships but that means a major change in political philosophy.

Medics are highly trained and take on huge responsibility but this doesn't negate the fact we have a publicly funded health care system and as easily salaries may be less than the private sector. You could argue teachers are highly trained and have the responsibility of pupils educational opportunities in their hands but they are not well paid compared to medics (and again striking).

I think relatively low starting salaries are the quid pro who for a compassionate health care system; do we want exchange that?

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 10:27

@WaitingForEgg

Our local trust has lost 8 consultants across various specialities this year to retirement.

They have no applicants for the posts

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 10:24

@mids2019

You pu do realise the NHS has a massive recruitment and retention crisis?

It can't fill the vacant posts it has right now.

How do you propose we find lots more doctors?

Ylvamoon · 14/03/2023 10:24

I think a 35k stating wage after 5/6 years of training seems fair.

However this should raise quickly... eg you are a junior doctor for a further 3 years (?) - after that, you have the qualifications/ experience to be a Dr. and get paid accordingly.

This could easily be linked to hours worked... eg 3 years full time or 6 years pt.

I also think a cap on weekly hours to 40 should be the norm to ensure patients safety.

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 10:19

The issue is
No matter what the public seem to believe junior doctors should be paid, most are deeply unhappy with conditions and pay. I’m 3.5 years out of medical school and of my cohort of 200, around 80 remain in the uk practicing medicine. Of these a small amount are in training programmes. Many are choosing not to enter training programmes, this gives greater flexibility to relocate to Australia in future. Many of these will also leave. My life would be so much better in most ways if I relocated my family to Australia (better pay, working conditions and respect) but my family are here and so I plod on.

Medics are intelligent highly skilled people. If you don’t offer at least a semi-competitive salary then frankly the difficulties of the job become less and less worth it. To give you some idea many of my colleagues have left to work in consulting in London. Firms offered them £70-80k as a STARTING salary with no experience in that field, purely because of their degree and transferable skills.

And so the issue is, if you want doctors to care for you in your old age. If you want to be able to get a Gp appointment, doctors need to be retained. There is 0 point training more when retention is so poor. The more leaving the worse conditions become and this further fuels the issue. I’m genuinely very very worried about the future of the nhs. Many current consultants and Gps are from a previous generation of no/low student debt and lower house prices. These need to be replaced by a new generation. At the moment I suspect within the next 10 years we are going to be very very short of doctors.

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 10:17

I think working conditions are more important than salary. You could always employ more doctors without increasing salary and therefore essentially have a less onerous workload for a more basic salary. Simple economic theory though states that if you limit entry into profession salaries increase due to the scarcity of workers. Medics have benefited from this model for a number of decades.

Overworkedwithadog · 14/03/2023 10:13

DifferenceEngines, I doubt it. The electricians I know make barely more than junior doctors in their FIRST year before extra allowances even though they're in their early thirties!

elliejjtiny · 14/03/2023 10:11

I think starting salary for a junior dr should be about 30-35k. It's more about the hours than the salary though. Junior drs have a huge responsibility and they need sleep, proper meals and regular toilet breaks.

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 10:11

Paramedics are rightly on strike and they 'literally save lives'. Do we feel we need to displace the public attention front hose hard working NHS staff that aren't on stellar career paths?

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 10:10

And I also think all those you've listed should also be paid more

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 10:09

@mids2019

My ds wants to be a Dr.

Im actively discouraging him

gyl2000 · 14/03/2023 10:08

Here in New Zealand our doctors in their final year of study (6th year, whilst still studying/working in a hospital placement so around age 23) get $70,000 NZD, approx £36,000. First year doctors get $96,000 NZD, approx £49,000. More if they work in a rural area and this goes up every year. Yes they do big hours but definitely not more than the UK, they should 100% be paid more, they are literally saving lives.

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 10:08

No one should work for free but does anyone think that the case of health care assitants, porters, admin staff,, care workers etc. for additional salary is as equally as valid where many ate a near NMW and certainly won't reach a career grade whether they will be driving Jags or Audis🤔

DifferenceEngines · 14/03/2023 10:07

Addictedtocustardcreams · 14/03/2023 09:43

This person with not be a salaried GP. They will be a partner so earnings fluctuate year on year (and are in general going down). Their three days a week will be at least 10 hours a day, likely longer. They will need to devote time to running the practice on top of this. They will be responsible for the business and should it all go wrong they will need to pay redundancies etc. They are definitely not a junior doctor.

This. The money is due to the business risk they take on, and is not guaranteed.

For a lot of people, it would be better financially to do an electrician apprenticeship, rather than medicine.

Artisticpaint · 14/03/2023 10:04

Of course they work for money, ? Di you think they should work for free?

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 10:03

Why if we go to the HE forum on this site are parents actively supporting each other in aiding their offspring acheive places at medical school of the job and pay are so sh*t? Won't people vote with their feet pursue other professions and allow the competitiveness for medicine to decrease as a consequence. Why? The reason is ultimately over a lifetime medicine is lucrative and we can't take away from that and to pretend otherwise may be fairly insulting to the general public. I think more mention needs to be made of salary distributions in the UK.

justteanbiscuits · 14/03/2023 09:59

The £14 per hour is just for their contracted hours remember. Working an additional 20 hours a week is normal - and expected most of the time. Plus writing up notes, additional study (paid for by themselves). And of course coming saddled with massive debt after 5 years at University. Working 48 hours straight isn't unusual - yet these are the people that are meant to save our lives.

My husband works in a hospital pharmacy. They're all doing over time during junior doctor strikes because the consultants, who are covering junior doctors, generally prescribe so very very rarely they need hand holding to do it. That says a lot! Junior Doctors carry the load - and it's a very, horrible, heavy load.

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 09:58

Junior doctors are effectively still learning (although working). Junior doctors benefit from specialist training to become consultants and the vast majority achieve this grade. Doctors can retain as bankers or accountants of they like but one has to question the motivation of doctors if salary is of such paramount importance.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 14/03/2023 09:58

MajorCarolDanvers · 13/03/2023 23:11

I'm fine with them getting a pay rise. Current UK average pay rise is 6.4%. Give them that.

They want a 35% pay rise - which is just ridiculous

35% puts the on parity with their pay in 2008.

Do you think doctors are worth 35% less in 2023 than in 2008? If so, why?

KnittedCardi · 14/03/2023 09:57

Not disputing they should be paid more, though not 35%.

But they don' t get paid per hour. They are salaried with overtime available. So disingenuous to break it down like that.

Also note that junior doctors are paid up to £55k I think, at the top grade. You are looking at starter grade.

Whatnowfgs · 14/03/2023 09:57

"It seems wrong that we're poaching doctors from poorer countries where they're needed, while doctors trained here go to Australia."

Couldn't agree more with this!

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 09:55

Doctors could all get higher salaries of they went into private practice but won't this lead to a system where only the wealthy could afford adequate health care? We could move in that direction but isn't this is real threat to the NHS?

Maybe we should let the market rule healthcare and see where that leads us?