Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you think junior doctors should be paid per hour

384 replies

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 22:36

you are being unreasonable - they should be paid £14/hr

you are not being unreasonable - they should be paid more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 11:50

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 11:31

WaitingForEgg - Do you know where the stats are for doctors leaving for other professions or work abroad? I can only find stats on those planning to leave or those leaving, without sorting out those retiring from those leaving the NHS/profession. The boomer generation are at retirement age now so lots of retirees should be expected over then next ten years or so.

I think it's a good salary. I work in academia and the vast majority of my contacts at work have a degree, masters (around the same cost as a doctor) and PhD, postgrad work experience. So with around 4 years to get to the end of a masters, 4-5 years of a tiny stipend (12k a year) for a PhD and then maybe 5 years of working they are on about 33-43k pa. These are the scientists developing vaccines etc. lecturers are about 33-43k pa. senior lecturers (probably reach here around 40 years old) 52-55k. Reader about 60 and then professor around 75-95k.

To get more than this they do contracting work - which is also available to medic btw. I know a doctor - who does extra work on the side in an unrelated field - who is fine with his standard NHS pay as a hospital doctor as a comparable job (ie. one that follows his interests and values that he enjoys) would not pay so well.

The issue is yes you have completed a lot of education I agree, but you do not work 80 hours per week including night shifts do you? Half the medical force are women. Many have to go 50% in order to manage childcare/see their children. This means earning £20-25k working 30-40 hours per week. You think that is fair or well paid? It’s below the threshold for universal credit!

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 11:49

Botw1

Supply and demand? If we have 20 applicants for every medical place there is an excessive demand for people to be medics so if you reduce the pay you reduce the demand and the cost to the tax payer? If we paid consultants 60K but had more of them would that help with workload?

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 11:49

@mids2019

'relatively low salaries (though not poverty levels) means more staff and more investment in drugs and equipment for patients'

It doesn't

We have to pay.

1 way or another

Id rather pay hcp decent wages viax a publicly funded system than pay them vastly increased wages through an insurance system where the end goal is not improving pt care but increasing profits

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 11:47

I think this ultimately come down to whether we sustain publically funded health care. At the end of the day the public are paying the salaries of the majority of healthcare workers and therefore through the operation of government have a right to say in salary allocation. If we do not like this system we move to a private on or more of a hybrid model.

Medicine is very well paid over a lifetime but the junior grades are paid less due to the cost of training and sustainably of the NHS economically. I think one thing that is missing from these arguments is that ultimately the NHS too priority theoretically is the patient not the staff and therefore if relatively low salaries (though not poverty levels) means more staff and more investment in drugs and equipment for patients from a patient/taxpayer perspective what is not to like?

One could argue it is not in the taxpayers interests to find expensive medical training and specialist experience for doctors to them work in the private sector. Why should those working in a factory pay tax to find health workers who will then leave or migrate?

I think we have opened a conversation about whether we can run healthcare on an altruistic basis with the idea of vocation or do we have to be hard headed about healthcare and ultimately make access to healthcare a choice depending on market conditions i.e. the ability to pay and what the market feels fit to pay medics.

I don't think striking juniou r doctors elicit a lot of sympathy amongst the general public especially in deprived areas like mine. People are a lot more likely to support nursing strikes simply because people can identify with nurses and health care assistants and know that their salaries are at least around or below the UK average. Middle class professionals taking strike action (potentially delaying procedures for the vunerable) is not a good look in many communities in the UK unfortunatly.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 11:41

@CarmenBizet

I grew up working class

I don't think the wage is paltry

I think it's shit for what they are expected to do.

It's not working in a lab or in academia.

It's actual life and death

The workload and responsibilities are horrendous

They can't get better conditions and more staff without better pay.

Im not sure why people can't grasp that

KimmySchmitt · 14/03/2023 11:40

Takemehomeagain · 14/03/2023 09:10

Starting salary for a pharmacist is 43K.

Junior doctors salary is ridiculously low.

I would say 45k minimum

That's just not true. A pre-reg pharmacist is band 5 so on 27k. An FY1 is provisionally registered, so roughly the same stage. A qualified pharmacist is band 6, so starting salary 33k. Pharmacists can get paid more in e.g. Boots, but you're not comparing like for like there, you need to compare to NHS pay scales.

Junior doctors are not equal. Your life is not in an FY1's hands, any more than it's in a staff nurse's hands. Very responsible job but there's a mechanism for escalation so they need to identify and escalate concerns. ST3+ yes, generally very experienced and good doctors, but by then the pay has increased.

CarmenBizet · 14/03/2023 11:37

I think part of the issue is that medicine has for a long time been very much a profession for the wealthy/privately educated. So these people have never had to live on the breadline or work NMW jobs. They therefore have a distorted idea of money and think a salary of 30k is paltry.

Anyone who grew up working class or who has lived in poverty would feel very insulted at the idea that earning 30k for a year and then getting a pay rise each year thereafter is insufficient.

Strike for better conditions and safe hours, by all means.

CarmenBizet · 14/03/2023 11:32

I support the strikes because I support any worker withdrawing their labour for better conditions.

I will get flamed for this...

DH is a junior doctor (one year away from completing his specialty training) and he reckons that people don't realise a) how much junior doctors are on, which is pretty decent for a first post-uni job, and b) the fact that their wage rises fast, annually, for quite a long while. So even though the pay right out of uni is almost 30k, it doesn't stay there for long. That's a respectable salary.

The whole pret thing is a bit disingenuous. One coffee shop, pret, is offering a better wage, but the vast majority of people who work in coffee shops are on minimum wage. Same with the nurses complaining they'd get more stacking shelves. It's utter nonsense and very clearly evidences that they've never worked a NMW job in their lives, which makes them seem out of touch but makes a good soundbite.

Okay, if stacking shelves is the same cash for less stress, why aren't you leaving nursing to do it?

Back to doctors, you can see what they earn here: www.bma.org.uk/media/5504/bma-junior-doctors-contracts-pay-tables-apr-2022-2023.pdf

newstart1234 · 14/03/2023 11:31

WaitingForEgg - Do you know where the stats are for doctors leaving for other professions or work abroad? I can only find stats on those planning to leave or those leaving, without sorting out those retiring from those leaving the NHS/profession. The boomer generation are at retirement age now so lots of retirees should be expected over then next ten years or so.

I think it's a good salary. I work in academia and the vast majority of my contacts at work have a degree, masters (around the same cost as a doctor) and PhD, postgrad work experience. So with around 4 years to get to the end of a masters, 4-5 years of a tiny stipend (12k a year) for a PhD and then maybe 5 years of working they are on about 33-43k pa. These are the scientists developing vaccines etc. lecturers are about 33-43k pa. senior lecturers (probably reach here around 40 years old) 52-55k. Reader about 60 and then professor around 75-95k.

To get more than this they do contracting work - which is also available to medic btw. I know a doctor - who does extra work on the side in an unrelated field - who is fine with his standard NHS pay as a hospital doctor as a comparable job (ie. one that follows his interests and values that he enjoys) would not pay so well.

America12 · 14/03/2023 11:31

Florenz · 13/03/2023 23:09

They are paid more than enough. Perhaps there should be a limit on how many hours they can work both in a day and in a week. But I am sick of their whinging and misrepresenting of how much they earn, comparing their wage to that of Pret workers is just insulting.

You think a Dr should be paid the same as someone who works in Pret ?
If you had a cardiac arrest would you be happy for someone from Pret to try and save your life?

AviMav · 14/03/2023 11:23

Realistically the NHS are in a shit position because it's pay by banding. There's no way they could decide to give "Band 3" a pay rise without increasing the overall banding.

We all need more money after covid. I think though if money had been left out of it (I know it's a huge issue) and the working patterns had been put over as the main point because this would make a difference.

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 11:09

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 11:02

Can I ask those who think the pay is ok

What do you do? And what do you earn?

I would love to know this too

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 11:09

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

The issue is, with all due respect what you think doesn’t matter a great deal. Doctors do not feel we are paid enough and are leaving. The reason conditions are so poor is because a rota of 10 doctors is staffed by 4. The hospital either cannot fill the gaps and so we have no choice but to work unsafely. The reason it cannot be filled is partly due to pay. At a time when mortgages, food, nursery is increasing, frankly the desire to work as a doctor for the nhs is just not there anymore for most.

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 11:02

Can I ask those who think the pay is ok

What do you do? And what do you earn?

Overworkedwithadog · 14/03/2023 10:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 10:54

Overworkedwithadog · 14/03/2023 10:45

Any doctors on here, us the graph on here correct? ( Upthread on page 2.) So, with allowances, in your first year you're on nearly £40k, and in your fifth year nearly £80k? If so, I think that's plenty although I do agree that having to move around the country is ridiculous and you should have your professional fees and costs covered. But those salaries do look pretty good to me. If you seriously want more than that, why go into medicine when, as another poster has stated, it is taxpayer funded and therefore has to have some limitations. Why not go into banking or similar ( without having done medicine at uni)? There must be plenty of applicants who believe the money is ok, and medicine, and helping society, is what they want to do. Why not leave it to them?

No this is not accurate

fy1 (first year post medical school) I was paid £33k to work 80 hours a week. I worked 48 hours of nights in a row, help multiple cardiac arrest bleeps, dealt with major haemorrhages, and commuted to 3 different hospitals. Fy2 I earnt £46k to also work 80 hours a week including covid wards. I was the only awake person for 60 patients post neurosurgery. St1 and st2 I’ve earnt on average £42-46k per year as my hours have been marginally lighter (56 per week). Still doing nights, weekends and multiple different hospitals.

on top of this I must pay £400 per year for gmc registration, £1600 in exam fees, £100 per month to park my car.

not to mention I have 2 children. Try organising childcare when you get a rota 2 weeks in advance. I have enormous love and respect for the nurses, hcas, porters, pharmacists etc that I work with. But I have £80,000 of student debt despite working while at medical school, and ultimately when you/your child/ your parent is sick, their life is ultimately in a doctors hands

Fifi0000 · 14/03/2023 10:53

Some of the public has become really disrespectful towards HCPs and medics. They think they should be in some kind of indentured servitude not realising that other western countries pay good wages and less workload.

The most important professions are the people who keep you alive , it's time they were respected or they will keep going abroad or refusing to train.

justteanbiscuits · 14/03/2023 10:53

Overworkedwithadog · 14/03/2023 10:45

Any doctors on here, us the graph on here correct? ( Upthread on page 2.) So, with allowances, in your first year you're on nearly £40k, and in your fifth year nearly £80k? If so, I think that's plenty although I do agree that having to move around the country is ridiculous and you should have your professional fees and costs covered. But those salaries do look pretty good to me. If you seriously want more than that, why go into medicine when, as another poster has stated, it is taxpayer funded and therefore has to have some limitations. Why not go into banking or similar ( without having done medicine at uni)? There must be plenty of applicants who believe the money is ok, and medicine, and helping society, is what they want to do. Why not leave it to them?

Sorry, what is tax payer funded? The course? Then surely that makes every single degree out there tax payer funded..

justteanbiscuits · 14/03/2023 10:47

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 10:03

Why if we go to the HE forum on this site are parents actively supporting each other in aiding their offspring acheive places at medical school of the job and pay are so sh*t? Won't people vote with their feet pursue other professions and allow the competitiveness for medicine to decrease as a consequence. Why? The reason is ultimately over a lifetime medicine is lucrative and we can't take away from that and to pretend otherwise may be fairly insulting to the general public. I think more mention needs to be made of salary distributions in the UK.

Because, like my mother in law, you can brag about your grandchild / child the medical student / doctor.

I am actively discouraging my children from doing it! There has been some presumption my eldest would go into medicine, but there is NOT a chance unless he is very very passionate about it (I think we killed any chance of that LOL)

Overworkedwithadog · 14/03/2023 10:45

Any doctors on here, us the graph on here correct? ( Upthread on page 2.) So, with allowances, in your first year you're on nearly £40k, and in your fifth year nearly £80k? If so, I think that's plenty although I do agree that having to move around the country is ridiculous and you should have your professional fees and costs covered. But those salaries do look pretty good to me. If you seriously want more than that, why go into medicine when, as another poster has stated, it is taxpayer funded and therefore has to have some limitations. Why not go into banking or similar ( without having done medicine at uni)? There must be plenty of applicants who believe the money is ok, and medicine, and helping society, is what they want to do. Why not leave it to them?

Jill688 · 14/03/2023 10:44

MissyB1 · 14/03/2023 10:35

@Jill688 I love those stats, and what they want sounds very aciveable to me. Where did you get the figures from?

I looked it up on the BMA website. Doesn’t sound like an unreasonable ask at all to me.

OP posts:
WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 10:44

medical students also have to be taught by doctors in placements. There are not enough doctors to train more.

fUNNYfACE36 · 14/03/2023 10:43

As you state we are dealing with elite professionals and elite candidates.

I think that's a thing of the past.I am not sure that medics are regarded as uniquely 'elite' any more

Botw1 · 14/03/2023 10:38

@mids2019

Its 'oversubscribed' because the govt restrict places

A course being oversubscribed has no baring on the amount of doctors or consultants in the NHS

WaitingForEgg · 14/03/2023 10:38

mids2019 · 14/03/2023 10:31

@WaitingForEgg

As you state we are dealing with elite professionals and elite candidates. However do you realise that from the lens of the general public there may not be not enough to elicit huge public sympathy with the salaries you mention?

Medics can work abroad for more but how many other countries have an NHS like ours frees at the point of delivery? We could always revert to a private model of healthcare in this country where medics essentially become self employed or work in partnerships but that means a major change in political philosophy.

Medics are highly trained and take on huge responsibility but this doesn't negate the fact we have a publicly funded health care system and as easily salaries may be less than the private sector. You could argue teachers are highly trained and have the responsibility of pupils educational opportunities in their hands but they are not well paid compared to medics (and again striking).

I think relatively low starting salaries are the quid pro who for a compassionate health care system; do we want exchange that?

I actually completely agree with you. I think comparing our pay to say the USA is unfair. US healthcare is ridiculously expensive. I wouldn’t feel comfortable working somewhere that I have to deny life saving/prolonging treatment due to someone’s earnings. But 35% is NOT equating us to US pay. I would earn 4-5 x my pay in the US. What we need is something in between (similar to Australia wages).