Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is insensitively worded, to say the least?

141 replies

KimberleyClark · 13/03/2023 22:00

From the website of the Royal Osteoporosis Society

theros.org.uk/latest-news/international-women-s-day-let-s-end-the-ageist-stereotypes-that-fuel-the-most-insidious-women-s-health-condition/?_gl=114hsiyd_up*MQ..&gclid=Cj0KCQjwk7ugBhDIARIsAGuvgPboftpiYL9EHStxq48v0H5lLUXvpcznG4Nt93uHDTN9RmPFxGS6j2QaAqj8EALw_wcB

“Most are surprised to hear it affects a half of all women over 50. That’s every other mother. Every other grandmother. And it’s serious. More so than people think: as many people die from its complications as from lung cancer or diabetes. So why is nobody talking about it?“

Do women with osteoporosis who aren’t mothers or grandmothers not count?

OP posts:
Summerfun54321 · 13/03/2023 23:13

Couldn't get worked up over this even if I tried.

backoftheplane · 13/03/2023 23:12

This is incredibly insensitive and badly written. Sure, it’s trying to get you to think about your own mother or grandmother - but it also reads as these people (ie. women who have given birth) are somehow more worthy of concern than childless/child free women. They need to seriously relook at how they are positioning this message. 100% with OP on this.

AwayWithTheFairiesAgain · 13/03/2023 23:12

Aren’t they just trying to humanise a statistic? Like when people say 10% (or whatever it is) of school kids have asthma. “That’s around 3 in every class.”
It doesn’t mean kids who don’t go to school don’t have asthma,

EmmaEmerald · 13/03/2023 23:05

Zwicky · 13/03/2023 22:54

I don’t love it, although everyone does have a mother - even if those mothers are long dead on non contact or you were raised by dads. There’s a risk that if you don’t read it properly and think about it for a minute then you could think that you are off the hook with osteoporosis if you don’t have kids. Loads of women’s health is tied to reproduction, contraception, breastfeeding and if those things aren’t really relevant then it’s best to stay clear so you don’t muddy the waters - “one in every two mothers? Well I’m all right, I’m not a mother!” - skips off and fractures wrist in mis-timed twirl.

On the one hand I see your point

on the other, I feel a bit despairing about general knowledge on health.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 13/03/2023 23:05

purplevipersgrass · 13/03/2023 22:45

It's a medical article. It should be fact-based and accurate and you don't have to have a medical degree to know that not all women are mothers or grandmothers.

Not all women are fertile or want to be mothers. An increasing number of us choose to be childfree and it's either sheer thoughtlessness or prejudice that allowed that inaccuracy to go through. Childfree women are women. We count. Even though some of you here obviously don't think so.

I respectfully disagree with you on a number of points.

It is not a medical article. It is a PR media release to raise awareness of a medical condition.

This article does not demonstrate thoughtlessness or prejudice to women who are not mothers. It seeks to emotionally engage readers and demonstrate the scale of the problem by making all readers, male and female, think of their mothers. Everyone born has a mother (whether you like her or not).

I write this as someone who spent the majority of my life ‘childfree’.

Inkblue · 13/03/2023 22:56

Zwicky · 13/03/2023 22:54

I don’t love it, although everyone does have a mother - even if those mothers are long dead on non contact or you were raised by dads. There’s a risk that if you don’t read it properly and think about it for a minute then you could think that you are off the hook with osteoporosis if you don’t have kids. Loads of women’s health is tied to reproduction, contraception, breastfeeding and if those things aren’t really relevant then it’s best to stay clear so you don’t muddy the waters - “one in every two mothers? Well I’m all right, I’m not a mother!” - skips off and fractures wrist in mis-timed twirl.

A very good point.

Zwicky · 13/03/2023 22:54

I don’t love it, although everyone does have a mother - even if those mothers are long dead on non contact or you were raised by dads. There’s a risk that if you don’t read it properly and think about it for a minute then you could think that you are off the hook with osteoporosis if you don’t have kids. Loads of women’s health is tied to reproduction, contraception, breastfeeding and if those things aren’t really relevant then it’s best to stay clear so you don’t muddy the waters - “one in every two mothers? Well I’m all right, I’m not a mother!” - skips off and fractures wrist in mis-timed twirl.

Jonesthebones · 13/03/2023 22:54

But they would be different numbers @ItWorriesMeThisKindofThing

EmmaEmerald · 13/03/2023 22:51

I can't imagine a website talking about prostate or testicular cancer in terms of men being fathers but maybe I've just not come across it.

I have osteoporosis on both sides of my family, with my dad having suffered spontaneous fractures. I don't think he ever got sent for DEXA scan before that, but mum did.

ItWorriesMeThisKindofThing · 13/03/2023 22:47

Jonesthebones · 13/03/2023 22:39

One of the statistics they quote must be wrong - it's either half of all women, or every other mother and grandmother, but it can't be both as that doesn't take childless women into account. That's why I find it annoying!

I think both can be true as half is a proportion?

half of all women
half of all mothers
half of all grandmothers
half of all child free women

all the statements are true?

Corrag · 13/03/2023 22:47

Jonesthebones · 13/03/2023 22:39

One of the statistics they quote must be wrong - it's either half of all women, or every other mother and grandmother, but it can't be both as that doesn't take childless women into account. That's why I find it annoying!

If depends how you interpret it I guess. If it affects half of all women over 50 then in theory it affects half of all mothers over the age of 50. And half of all grandmothers over 50. And half of all child free women over 50. And half of all [insert subcategory] over 50.

That's assuming each subcategory is equally affected which is unlikely.

At best it's a clumsily worded statement.

AmyDudley · 13/03/2023 22:46

As others have said it is referring to your mother or grandmother as almost everyone will have one of those , to make people aware of this illness which affects a lot of older women, as in one of your older relatives may have it even though you are as yet too young. It is to increase public awareness and not just have it dismissed as an 'old person' disease.
It would be nice if people could just take the message as it is intended rather than being offended because they have chosen to read it in the wrong way. The message is be aware of this disease at it affects a lot of women. Why are you offended by that ? It doesn't in any way suggest women who aren't mothers or grandmothers don't count. Men can also get it and obviously they count too. But the ad is trying to get people to care by getting them to imagine their own family. Sadly people don't respond well to bare facts - they need a story.

A someone who was diagnosed with osteoporosis in my mid fifties, and currently sporting a broken wrist which just occurred on its own, I'm glad of anything which make people aware and leads to more research and treatment, and earlier diagnosis.

CrosswordConundrum · 13/03/2023 22:46

Are you normally professionally offended OP? I find it hard to get wound up about the wording of things like this which on balance have the right intent. There’s so much that doesn’t have I tend to focus my angst there.

purplevipersgrass · 13/03/2023 22:45

DifficultBloodyWoman · 13/03/2023 22:14

This. Please don’t look for offence where none is intended.

The purpose of phrasing it that way is to highlight that it may not affect you but everyone who has been born has a mother and at least two grandmothers. The chances are that someone close to you is affected.

It's a medical article. It should be fact-based and accurate and you don't have to have a medical degree to know that not all women are mothers or grandmothers.

Not all women are fertile or want to be mothers. An increasing number of us choose to be childfree and it's either sheer thoughtlessness or prejudice that allowed that inaccuracy to go through. Childfree women are women. We count. Even though some of you here obviously don't think so.

Fireyflies · 13/03/2023 22:43

I don't like the wording as it's not taking direct to the women over 50 who need to hear it. So it's implying her children or grandchildren need to be making sure she looks after herself. Can't women over 50 be assumed to read and take care of their own health? And I can see why that's upset women without children, as there's no children looking out for them as mum.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 13/03/2023 22:43

They can't say "your sister" because not everyone has one of those; some people don't have an aunt or even a female neighbour they care about.
By the same logic they can;t say "your mother" or "your grandmother" because not everybody has one of those either.

Although I'm letting you off for this superb piece of snark alone 😂
if there's an awkward implicit assumption, it is that everyone likes their mom/gran & wouldn't like to dance on their brittle bones.

CascaChan · 13/03/2023 22:42

lljkk · 13/03/2023 22:13

It doesn't exclude women who don't have kids/G.kids, it just tries to prompt you to think of your own mom & gran (because everyone has those, even if NC or you'd eagerly dance on their brittle bones).

They can't say "your sister" because not everyone has one of those; some people don't have an aunt or even a female neighbour they care about.

if there's an awkward implicit assumption, it is that everyone likes their mom/gran & wouldn't like to dance on their brittle bones.

You are right and also funny.

Jonesthebones · 13/03/2023 22:39

One of the statistics they quote must be wrong - it's either half of all women, or every other mother and grandmother, but it can't be both as that doesn't take childless women into account. That's why I find it annoying!

KnittingNeedles · 13/03/2023 22:36

HotPenguin · 13/03/2023 22:10

They are trying to personalise it by saying it could be your mother or grandmother.

Exactly. It's about trying to bring it home and get through the "won't affect me" barrier. If it's not affecting your mum, it might be affecting your friend's mum.

NewNameNigel · 13/03/2023 22:35

I think it's the age old thing where women don't have intrinsic value as people. Only as mothers/grandmothers etc. It actually comes up a lot.

EmmaEmerald · 13/03/2023 22:35

This para is also bizarre

"I can empathise, of course. In my youth I didn’t think much – if at all - about bone health. Like most people, I worried about my skin, heart, blood pressure. Bones were just ‘dead’ things that appeared at Halloween."

I don't know what the stats are but surely a lot of people break bones, or know a frkend or family member who has, long before they think about heart or blood pressure?

MrsDoylesDoily · 13/03/2023 22:34

HotPenguin · 13/03/2023 22:10

They are trying to personalise it by saying it could be your mother or grandmother.

Yep.

BrioNotBiro · 13/03/2023 22:34

I'm an older woman. whose mother died 30 years ago and whose grandmothers died before I was born. In view of my age, osteoporosis is an important issue for me personally, but is of no concern to me in regard to my mother or grandmothers.

So I'm with the OP on this. It reads to me as if childfree women don't count. I don't think that was the author's intention, it's just badly phrased.

JenniferBarkley · 13/03/2023 22:33

Isn't it more likely in mothers and grandmothers as pregnancy increases the risk? Might be wrong on that.

They're trying to give an emotional punch to raise awareness. I don't think they're saying that women who haven't had children don't count.

EmmaEmerald · 13/03/2023 22:31

ChildminderMum · 13/03/2023 22:17

I agree it's weird phrasing. They are trying to make women seem valuable by describing them as mothers/grandmothers.

This.