Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is insensitively worded, to say the least?

141 replies

KimberleyClark · 13/03/2023 22:00

From the website of the Royal Osteoporosis Society

theros.org.uk/latest-news/international-women-s-day-let-s-end-the-ageist-stereotypes-that-fuel-the-most-insidious-women-s-health-condition/?_gl=114hsiyd_up*MQ..&gclid=Cj0KCQjwk7ugBhDIARIsAGuvgPboftpiYL9EHStxq48v0H5lLUXvpcznG4Nt93uHDTN9RmPFxGS6j2QaAqj8EALw_wcB

“Most are surprised to hear it affects a half of all women over 50. That’s every other mother. Every other grandmother. And it’s serious. More so than people think: as many people die from its complications as from lung cancer or diabetes. So why is nobody talking about it?“

Do women with osteoporosis who aren’t mothers or grandmothers not count?

OP posts:
Testina · 14/03/2023 02:23

“And I don’t have any children or grandchildren to be impacted if I get osteoporosis. So it does feel as though my getting osteoporosis is somehow irrelevant.”

That’s a highly personal interpretation. It’s factually incorrect and badly worded. But it’s obviously they were trying to personalise it as almost everyone has/has had a mother or mother figure. I don’t agree with how they chosen to do that, but that’s all it is. No-one is saying your osteoporosis would be irrelevant - that’s your own issue driving your interpretation.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 02:16

@Eyerollcentral but it is being discussed on other Internet forums. This isn’t the only Internet forum thread on this particular subject thread. Which has to be good for a wider audience to be educated on bone loss.
Personally I can’t really get upset about an educational leaflet that is doing exactly what it’s intended to do. Which is excellent. Reaching as many people as it can to do so. The wording could have been better… but meh.

oh, I don’t overlook the misogyny of a society which ignores older women..and childless ones - I am both much older and childless, and often feel totally invisible and not heard, but this leaflet wording is not a ‘hill to die on’. (Imo)

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 02:06

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 01:55

But apparently it does mention/include men, according to a pp (7eleven) on here? So the campaign is being inclusive of those biologically unable to carry children - granted not specifically women who haven’t given birth.

As I said, given this specific topic is being discussed elsewhere on the internet - it is hopefully going to educate a lot wider audience and that must be a positive thing?
(Super Cynical me wonders if the wording might have been deliberate to achieve just that).

I think your super cynical side overlooks the entrenched misogyny in our society which ignores older women in general and childless older women in particular. That’s the much more likely explanation than an incredibly well thought out campaign to stimulate debate - this point won’t be picked on anywhere else but this thread and no campaign would be based on that niche exposure.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 01:55

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 01:44

That could easily have been achieved by being inclusive of all older women. This is a campaign aimed at women, not everyone.

But apparently it does mention/include men, according to a pp (7eleven) on here? So the campaign is being inclusive of those biologically unable to carry children - granted not specifically women who haven’t given birth.

As I said, given this specific topic is being discussed elsewhere on the internet - it is hopefully going to educate a lot wider audience and that must be a positive thing?
(Super Cynical me wonders if the wording might have been deliberate to achieve just that).

WandaWonder · 14/03/2023 01:46

Inkblue · 13/03/2023 22:15

Yes I agree but they could just as easily include sister or aunt.

Not everyone has a sister or aunt but every one has or had a mother or grandmother

Why does everything have to offend someone? Or are people looking deliberately to be offended as it's a slow news day? Boredom?

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 01:44

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 01:09

Another valid point. But at least this literature has got the internet and BOTH men and women discussing it, (for whatever reason). That must surely be a good thing in raising awareness.

That could easily have been achieved by being inclusive of all older women. This is a campaign aimed at women, not everyone.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 01:09

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:56

Osteoporosis disproportionately effects women. With elderly women now particularly there is a wider story to be told about nutrition and the under feeding of female children vs male children in times past.

Another valid point. But at least this literature has got the internet and BOTH men and women discussing it, (for whatever reason). That must surely be a good thing in raising awareness.

TessoftheDubonnet · 14/03/2023 01:05

I think you are overthinking this.

But at least it seems to have women talking about something that is really important but is often overlooked.

Osteoporosis is often diagnosed too late.
Many women do not know enough about the risks of developing osteoporosis.
Or how to prevent it.

Possible options:
HRT
Healthy diet
Limit alcohol and do not smoke

And, most importantly, EXERCISE.
Especially weight bearing exercise.
Lots of workouts on YouTube - Caroline Girvan, Growingannanas, Heather Robertson, Sydney Cummings, Rebecca Louise........
All you need is a mat and some dumbbells

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:56

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 00:37

That’s also a good point. But the disease does not distinguish between male/female/ mother/non mother, which was the direction that particular poster went with.

Osteoporosis disproportionately effects women. With elderly women now particularly there is a wider story to be told about nutrition and the under feeding of female children vs male children in times past.

DahliaMacNamara · 14/03/2023 00:54

I think people are getting irate about the wrong thing here, if I'm honest.

Osteoporosis is a disease mostly affecting older women. It can be painful, disabling and disfiguring, even fatal. Yet it's so common that it's frequently seen as a normal part of the female ageing process, ie something that's just hard luck and to be accepted rather than treated. Let's even make gentle fun of the little old ladies shrinking. Shouldn't we be saying 'fuck that for a game of soldiers'? Because to me it's on the cards for a good many of us.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 00:37

ShrinkingItOut · 14/03/2023 00:26

Well women who have had children are more prone to osteoporosis. Women who were teen mothers are especially prone.

That’s also a good point. But the disease does not distinguish between male/female/ mother/non mother, which was the direction that particular poster went with.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 00:30

7eleven · 14/03/2023 00:16

Given that as well as 90% of the article based around increasing age, the fact that men are also mentioned, suggests that you’d have to be a bit daft to conclude that it only applies to mothers.

Yep I agree - but people don’t seem to always read past the first paragraph or two before making a judgement as to the rest of the leaflet/information/article etc. Rest assured the post was swiftly (re) educated!

My view is that it is written in a manner which captures the reader and gets them to read more of the literature at hand. It’s certainly getting discussed across the internet - which could be a good thing for awareness.

ShrinkingItOut · 14/03/2023 00:26

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 00:12

On another forum, a poster said it made them think it was a disease that only affected those who had become mothers/born children.

Perhaps it could have been written a better /clearer way.

Well women who have had children are more prone to osteoporosis. Women who were teen mothers are especially prone.

7eleven · 14/03/2023 00:25

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:24

The only female roles mentioned by name are mothers though. That infers a value. As I said would it have killed to add an ‘aunt’ in there?

Yeah, I see that point.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:24

7eleven · 14/03/2023 00:21

I don’t think it does only value mothers. The message that stands clearly out to me is about age.

We all see things things differently, of course.

The only female roles mentioned by name are mothers though. That infers a value. As I said would it have killed to add an ‘aunt’ in there?

7eleven · 14/03/2023 00:24

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:21

Loads of people are daft though.

😀

As it interested me, I went off looking for comparisons to adverts about testicular cancer. I found one that was focused around women’s breasts 😳🙄🙀

7eleven · 14/03/2023 00:21

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:18

But it could be more helpful if you even included the word ‘aunt’, which would hardly have ruined the scheme. Who is taking offence? It’s excluding women who aren’t mothers. People still care about relatives who haven’t had children themselves. I find it incredible the women lining up to say yeah what’s wrong with valuing only mothers - as you say it’s a health message so your reproductive status is irrelevant, your sex and age is though. Do you think there are endless budgets to fund health campaigns?

I don’t think it does only value mothers. The message that stands clearly out to me is about age.

We all see things things differently, of course.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:21

7eleven · 14/03/2023 00:16

Given that as well as 90% of the article based around increasing age, the fact that men are also mentioned, suggests that you’d have to be a bit daft to conclude that it only applies to mothers.

Loads of people are daft though.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:18

7eleven · 13/03/2023 23:52

Sometimes I think it’s preferable to focus on what’s helpful rather than what’s true.

Perhaps it can be interpreted that way (it isn’t to me, but we’re all different) but how does it support your happiness to take offence to it? Does it really matter?

it’s a health message about a serious condition. Good to bring awareness to it, even if not done perfectly.

But it could be more helpful if you even included the word ‘aunt’, which would hardly have ruined the scheme. Who is taking offence? It’s excluding women who aren’t mothers. People still care about relatives who haven’t had children themselves. I find it incredible the women lining up to say yeah what’s wrong with valuing only mothers - as you say it’s a health message so your reproductive status is irrelevant, your sex and age is though. Do you think there are endless budgets to fund health campaigns?

7eleven · 14/03/2023 00:16

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 00:12

On another forum, a poster said it made them think it was a disease that only affected those who had become mothers/born children.

Perhaps it could have been written a better /clearer way.

Given that as well as 90% of the article based around increasing age, the fact that men are also mentioned, suggests that you’d have to be a bit daft to conclude that it only applies to mothers.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 14/03/2023 00:12

On another forum, a poster said it made them think it was a disease that only affected those who had become mothers/born children.

Perhaps it could have been written a better /clearer way.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 00:11

AmyDudley · 13/03/2023 23:44

It could easily have included any woman.

It does, it says it affects half of ALL women over 50 before there is any mention of mothers or grandmothers.

And then goes on to highlight only mothers as worth a special mention.

TwoHedgehogs · 14/03/2023 00:10

I mean I'm just glad they managed to use the word women and actually write mothers and grandmothers without some weird bullshit inclusive language.

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 14/03/2023 00:09

I am not a grandmother, and do not have any living grandmothers.

Can confirm that I felt zero offence when reading that statement.

7eleven · 14/03/2023 00:08

The vast majority of the article is focused on age. You have taken one tiny snippet that mentions mothers and grandmothers. The rest is about increasing age.

Nothing wrong with it, in my opinion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread