Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

45 and desperate for a sibling for Dd

113 replies

Ourtimeisrunningout · 13/03/2023 21:01

Our Dd is nearly 5, we conceived her after years of infertility and losses via ivf. I feel so sad that she doesn’t have a sibling and feel such guilt for her.
We have a frozen embryo left over but I feel such guilt too about being too old…I feel fine and could do it energy wise…I’ve been through much harder things in my life. But I feel worried if we passed early etc and the child having older parents 🥲I wish life had been easier for us in this respect and we’d had kids in our earlier thirties as planned.
Is adopting a slightly older child an option do you think?
What would you do? Really at a vital crossroads…would you make peace with having only one child and no sibling for Dd and let it go or would you push ahead with the embryo/adoption route..and fast?

OP posts:
Sleepless1096 · 14/03/2023 05:46

Your Dd is 5 and will be at least 6 if you have another dc. That’s a big age gap so they won’t have as close a relationship as you hope.

I disagree with this. It will be a different relationship, yes, but the age gap doesn't necessarily mean it won't be close.

Sleepless1096 · 14/03/2023 05:44

Knitterofcrap · 13/03/2023 21:23

Adopting can take years and it’s possible you wouldn’t be accepted.

If you really want another child I would go ahead with your remaining embryo.

I hope things work out for you, whatever you decide.

This. I definitely wouldn't adopt in your position. The focus of adoption should be the child being adopted, not 'completing' your family.

But just as one child is a completely valid choice, I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting another child. I'm very sorry it's been such a hard process for you and you've ended up in this position 💐.

Beezknees · 14/03/2023 05:18

I'm an only child, as is DS and we're both fine, neither of us are bothered that we don't have siblings. People really need to get over this silly "guilt" idea about only children, we really don't care.

I wouldn't be trying to have another baby at that age honestly.

GelPens1 · 14/03/2023 04:51

Ourtimeisrunningout · 13/03/2023 22:20

Sorry just to be clear..my embryo is frozen from my 30’s so not a massive risk of abnormalities etc.

Also, to say this wouldn’t be *Just to have a sibling for Dd and is obviously something We’d love also. I'd never consider it just for this reason, especially adoption.

It is literally just all about my age and the future for that child 😐

There’s still higher risks in pregnancy and childbirth for older women. Especially when IVF is thrown in. You’re also fairly close in age to my parents so I think 45 is too old now for a newborn. Obviously many people in their 40s are fit and healthy, but a PP earlier said she’s in her early 20s and her parents are in their 70s and this is tricky for her now.

Your Dd is 5 and will be at least 6 if you have another dc. That’s a big age gap so they won’t have as close a relationship as you hope. They would never be into the same things at the same time. Just enjoy your Dd. She doesn’t need a sibling because she’ll have lots of friends.

CluelessInThe21st · 14/03/2023 01:06

Op, I know how life just seems to move so quickly and before you know it years have passed. I am sorry about your fertility struggles too. That must have been hard. How would you feel if the transfer wasn't successful? Do you think you'd be able to cope especially maybe considering that with s child you won't have much time or opportunity to fully grieve.

I had my second at almost 43 so I guess I am biased but I would go for it if you really want another one, are willing to take the risk of a potentially stressful journey ahead and if you are in good health at the moment. I do worry about being an older parent and how I'll cope when my two are teenagers but I'm still glad I had them. Late isn't ideal but for me it's still better than never.

Having said thst after having a second I really doubt that only children are somehow worse off. There are a lot of advantages to being an only especially as a child. Mainly full attention from your parents.

I did consider though in my case that if we died early DD would be left with not much family as she doesn't have any cousins either.

As someone has said I'm pretty sure adoption agencies prefer the adopted child to be the youngest in the family and substantially younger than your other kids so that your have got enough time for them. It's not something to be taken on lightly and I doubt that it would be the right decision for you. I also wonder if havinh an existing child that is your own biologically makes it even more complicated.

Best of luck with whatever you decide.

needabetterlife · 14/03/2023 00:58

@Ourtimeisrunningout
I am a similar age and also have these conflicted thoughts about another child. Its so difficult.

I am an only child and I dont feel one bit envious of any of my friends and their siblings - in fact I think there is only one friend with a brilliant relationship with her sister. Ive always had really good female friendships which has been so important to me.
My relationship with my parents is so special (as is theirs with my child) and my memories growing up are all brilliant with so much nurture and support. Think I need to remind myself of all this 🤣

If you do go ahead with the transfer and it's successful look into the Harmony scan which I had.

Good luck with your decision.

intrestedvic · 14/03/2023 00:54

im going to get flamed for this but I'm early twenties and a single mum. However my parents are both 70s due to being older and I have literally zero support not just with childcare but I struggle to just ring mum as my world I live in (social media, interests, Netflix) is not the same world as my mums and it's always been a a huge struggle for me and made me feel lonely. I think that's partly to do with my parents using old parenting styles rather then choosing to learn or try to adapt more then age but my childhood was a lonely time. (I have a older sister who's amazing) but please think of being 70 with a 25 year old who will likely live at home due to the housing issues it's not just a smal child x

congratulations on dd you sound like a loving and caring mum x

Aria999 · 14/03/2023 00:51

If you want it, do it, or you will regret it.

It may not work out anyway.

I had dd2 at 42 and it's fine so far (she's 3).

My dad is 45 years older than me and has always seemed pretty ancient so it's weird in that respect to think I may be an old parent but as pp said I think that's partly my dad's character (he's been a grumpy old man all his life).

Fifi0000 · 14/03/2023 00:50

Don't have another child for your existing child. Each child has their own personalities, some gel more than others. Have a child because you want one.

Rustyhandlebars · 14/03/2023 00:37

Go ahead with your embryo if this is your wish . Only please consider when the child is late teens, you will be in your sixties, still washing and cooking for him/her when your peers will be enjoying occasional visits from grandchildren. Try asking a few people in their sixties how they would feel have a teenager at their time of life. I am 63, my granddaughter is 16 and to be honest, I don't think I could cope with her full time even though I have good health.

Sugarfree23 · 14/03/2023 00:35

Op if you really want another child give the embryo a go.

Regarding adoption, the child has to be younger than the youngest in the family. Depending on the agency they want a maximum of 45 years between the child and youngest parent. So really that's going to make it harder for you to find a suitable match. But you'll get better advice in the adoption board

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 14/03/2023 00:22

I'm so sorry my post was meant to end with a question mark not a !

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 14/03/2023 00:22

At some stage you are going to have to make a difficult decision about what to do with that embryo if you don't use it. Do you think at that point, you'd have regrets about not trying one more time!

FrozenGhost · 14/03/2023 00:16

I don't mean that unkindly, I don't think it's too old personally.

FrozenGhost · 14/03/2023 00:15

In your situation I would try with the embryo, then draw a line under it if it didn't work. Concerns about being an older parent are valid, but thing is you already are one. In for a penny, in for a pound, surely.

Ourtimeisrunningout · 14/03/2023 00:04

@massifcentral Covid came along and it all changed.:.I had long covid after it for just under two years. But you’re right, I’ve had just under a year to push ahead and haven’t…my Dd hasn’t been well with various things and started school etc, life seems to just take over. It’s that thing of it being not simple at all, my clinic is a 3 hr train/car journey there, going through the whole process etc..I’m not sure what the reason is holding me back, I think is age as I wish I’d pushed ahead before

OP posts:
Ourtimeisrunningout · 14/03/2023 00:01

@Aquamarine1029 Ok. I think this is a personal thing to you, quite clearly and I’m not being offensive to only children at all, as others can see. I won’t be engaging further with you.

OP posts:
Pallisers · 13/03/2023 23:35

Don't adopt a child to give your child a sibling. That isn't the purpose of any child. They should be wanted and loved simply for themselves not for adding something to your child's life.

I don't think I'd transfer the embryo at 45 but I can see why someone would do it and take the chance.

But honestly, I live in an area where there are a lot of older mothers and a lot of only children. Many of my children's friends were only children. There is a huge upside to it. At times when we struggled to give each of our 3 the right amount of attention (especially when one child had issues that consumed nearly all the oxygen) I used to look at those parents who could just focus on the one and envy them.

My dh's grandmother was an only child and was almost entirely cousinless too - she was pretty much the only child of her generation and at a time (early 1900s) when most families were big. She was the most fantastic woman, everyone loved her, she went on to have several children and grandchildren and great grandchildren herself. Try to love the life you have with your gorgeous daughter and trust that she will forge an equally good life for herself.

Rosesandstars · 13/03/2023 23:29

It sounds as though you would like to try using the embryo. I would give it a go. You might regret it if you don't and if it doesn't work out then you'll know that that wasn't meant to be and can look into things like adoption going forwards.

RubiesAndRaindrops · 13/03/2023 23:28

In your shoes I'd def transfer the embryo. I had DC1 age 40, was desperate for another (increasingly so as time went on) had DC2 at age 45. Oddly my desire for a baby was stronger after I'd had my first and although I worried about DC1 being a lonely only (as a friend put it - she also told me that only children are selfish citing her dad as an example. She meant well but it really fed into my insecurities) really it was for me. DC1 regularly asked for a sibling but realistically would have been fine as an only - friends are the family that you choose and all that. So for me it would be embryo no question and consider adoption later on if I still felt the same and DH agreed. Good luck.

Palmface · 13/03/2023 23:25

If I were you, I'd have the embryo transferred and see what happens. I don't think at 45 I could go through a full ivf cycle but that's just me (I did it at 36 and found it a lot). It would be wise to have some counselling around it though, as it might not work so you'll need to have the resilience to get through that, particularly when you have a dd to care for.

If I wanted another's dc and had a remaining embryo I'd find it hard to not just go for it. Best of luck, and sorry you're getting a lot of defensive replies from only children. I get their pov but your post is clearly from an infertility context and it's OK to want more than one child.

My dd was lonely af until she had a little brother at 4.5y and they play really well now at 7.5 and 3.

Aquamarine1029 · 13/03/2023 23:25

Ourtimeisrunningout · 13/03/2023 22:58

@Aquamarine1029 I don’t have any attitude about only children 🤷🏻‍♀️
I would just like a sibling for my Dd as Dh and I get older and I would’ve really loved more kids and a bigger family, but I couldn’t, I’d that ok?!

I feel so sad that she doesn’t have a sibling and feel such guilt for her.

Guilt for her? As though she's "lesser than" because she doesn't have a sibling. Sad for someone who doesn't need your pity? Yes, you absolutely do have an attitude about only children. It's fucking weird.

massifcentral · 13/03/2023 23:21

I'd say try the embryo.

But I do slightly wonder why you haven't already done that. I'm an older mother, like many of my friends, and we all tried for much smaller age gaps. (In my case natural conception, and got lucky, so have 2 two years apart.) Was there a reason that you didn't go for the second embryo when you were 41/42? Has that now changed? Without knowing anything more, I would think that the choice not to try for another baby already points to some real ambivalence about having a second.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 13/03/2023 23:19

I felt great at 44. Two years later perimenopause kicked in and I felt urgh. Hrt has helped but be warned those hormones can really change the game, my inclination to nurture took a real hit when the hormones dropped, my kids were a bit older so could have been worse, if they'd been toddler age I might have imploded with the effort of holding myself together. Doesn't mean you can't do it, everyone is different anyway, but have your awareness tuned so you can deal with it if you need to. Good luck whatever you decide.

Fredfro · 13/03/2023 23:17

I'd just try with the embryo. The egg won't be that old- must be from age 39/40? Then, if it's not meant to be, then it's not meant to be, but at least you tried. Had my DD at 42, naturally conceived so the egg would be older. Had GD but DD is unaffected and I'm fine now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread