Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Fiona Bruce is not the wrong doer here?

110 replies

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 18:10

She is stepping down as a patron of Refuge (DV charity) after saying Stanley Johnson 'only hit his wife once' on QuestionTime.IMO It was rather a clumsy thing to say - but she clearly wasn't meaning that it was ok- apply a bit of context and she was clearly trying to be impartial /balanced here - which she is week after week even though she must feel like banging her head off the bloody table!
I just feel that another amazing women is vilanised and another arse of a bloke gets away Scott free. Anyone else?

OP posts:
Abraxan · 13/03/2023 18:32

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:22

I agree with you, but she didn’t actually say he only hit his wife once. She said "Stanley Johnson has not commented publicly on that. Friends of his have said it did happen, it was a one-off." All she’s done is tried to give a balanced account, which is what the BBC are supposed to do.

To be balanced she should then have quoted what his wife has said about it.

As an ambassador of that kind of charity she should have been very very clear as to what has been said and by who, and should not have left it as 'it,was only once' even if quoting his friends.

EggyBreads · 13/03/2023 18:31

I saw the program in question and yes it did come across as minimising it. Why on earth are Stanley Johnson's friends being cited as it being a 'one off'?. It was very awkwardly handled.

Ponoka7 · 13/03/2023 18:29

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:22

I agree with you, but she didn’t actually say he only hit his wife once. She said "Stanley Johnson has not commented publicly on that. Friends of his have said it did happen, it was a one-off." All she’s done is tried to give a balanced account, which is what the BBC are supposed to do.

Should a DV incident be reported in a balanced way? We wouldn't allow it for racism. No-one can confidently say that it was a one off. It's a shocking thing for someone who wants to be highly and publicly involved in a DV charity.

Ponoka7 · 13/03/2023 18:26

Other DV charities, women's aid being one, had real issue with her choice of language. Refuge has said that her statement goes against their knowledge of DV. They felt that she minimised DV. There was no way that she could remain an ambassador, she minimised a woman's nose being broken and chose to ignore what else would have been going on. She fucked up and showed that she'd throw the vulnerable under the bus to defend abuse as long as the perpetrator was a Tory. How many women have suffered over the centuries because their abuser had a higher status? She's figuratively smacked them in the face.

DashboardConfessional · 13/03/2023 18:23

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 18:10

She is stepping down as a patron of Refuge (DV charity) after saying Stanley Johnson 'only hit his wife once' on QuestionTime.IMO It was rather a clumsy thing to say - but she clearly wasn't meaning that it was ok- apply a bit of context and she was clearly trying to be impartial /balanced here - which she is week after week even though she must feel like banging her head off the bloody table!
I just feel that another amazing women is vilanised and another arse of a bloke gets away Scott free. Anyone else?

"Clearly"? It's not "clear" that she was trying to be impartial at all. Why would she say that at all, in any context?

""Friends of his have said it did happen but it was a one-off.”

How the hell would these "friends" know? Were they lodgers?

Would we be ok if she was talking about Saatchi grabbing Nigella by the throat during lunch, and she said "The staff say it did happen but it was a one-off"?

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:22

I agree with you, but she didn’t actually say he only hit his wife once. She said "Stanley Johnson has not commented publicly on that. Friends of his have said it did happen, it was a one-off." All she’s done is tried to give a balanced account, which is what the BBC are supposed to do.

UnfinishedBusiness · 13/03/2023 18:22

She merrily quoted his friends, who said it yes it happened, it was a one off. Why didn’t she quote his wife who said “ he hit me many times, over many years”. That would have been balanced.

bellac11 · 13/03/2023 18:17

Well yes and no. Its not her crime but I cant help but wonder why she chose that particular piece of information to share, when she could have just said something similar (his friends dismissed it, or his friends recognised it happened) or not said anything at all.

Yes it was clumsy. I think we need to stop punishing people for making mistakes with their language like this, but in order to feel more comfortable about it I would have preferred that she explained why she said it. Im aware she was mortified if it had been misconstrued but thats not the same thing (unless Ive missed it)

Rumplestrumpet · 13/03/2023 18:16

Well if she were neutral all the time it would be less bad.

but she bends over backwards to defend the tories, give them more airtime and interrupt left-leaning guests.

So I think her comments were part of a pattern and pretty poor.

cupofteaandabiccyplease · 13/03/2023 18:14

Hitting anyone male or female is wrong in my book. But the Johnsons are hardly good role models for anyone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread