Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Fiona Bruce is not the wrong doer here?

110 replies

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 18:10

She is stepping down as a patron of Refuge (DV charity) after saying Stanley Johnson 'only hit his wife once' on QuestionTime.IMO It was rather a clumsy thing to say - but she clearly wasn't meaning that it was ok- apply a bit of context and she was clearly trying to be impartial /balanced here - which she is week after week even though she must feel like banging her head off the bloody table!
I just feel that another amazing women is vilanised and another arse of a bloke gets away Scott free. Anyone else?

OP posts:
DashboardConfessional · 13/03/2023 19:04

You know what the source of the "family friends" who said it was a one-off is?

This article.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8802035/amp/Boris-Johnsons-mother-tells-TOM-BOWER-familys-deepest-secret.html

"Last night, family friends confirmed the story to this newspaper, but insisted that the incident had been a one-off.

The friends said it happened in the 1970s when Charlotte was suffering from Obsessive Compulsive Disorder and had ‘flailed’ at Stanley, who broke her nose when ‘flailing back’.

It is appalling.

Roussette · 13/03/2023 19:03

but surely we should all be massively up in arms about him potentially getting a knighthood

We are
At least I am. And I'm not letting that drop anywhere

BHRK · 13/03/2023 19:02

I think she was trying to show this hasn’t been proven and the man in question wasn’t there to defend himself. If she hadn’t said anything there is a risk that this just becomes fact when the fact hasn’t been “proven” in a court of law.
of course DV is wrong and she absolutely believes that. Her comments were clumsy but not malicious

Schmutter · 13/03/2023 19:00

She did come across as minimising it and I’m glad she stepped down.

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 19:00

Interesting article.....he really is an utter knob- but surely we should all be massively up in arms about him potentially getting a knighthood- that makes me so much more angry than FB saying something stupid/clumsy/that she doesn't actually think or believe?? I just feel as though the anger and outrage is pointed at the wrong person. I find our media coverage so bloody childish and quick to dismantle some (I.e women) but not others (I.e men)....

OP posts:
Forever42 · 13/03/2023 18:59

Sorry, I see he's never confirmed it himself, but as PP have said she could just have referred to the incident as reported by family friends.

Forever42 · 13/03/2023 18:58

I'm not sure why she needed to clarify anything. As far as I understand he has admitted the act himself so what was there anything she needed to clarify for legal purposes. She should just have said nothing. Whatever her reasoning, it came across as minimising domestic violence.

BlueLabel · 13/03/2023 18:56

If she wanted to be balanced she could have completely omitted the "friends have said it did happen, it was a one off". Saying "one off" absolutely is minimising an alleged assault and didnt add balance. Its ridiculous to think that commenting on the frequency of DV could be considered balanced reporting.

Refuge quite rightly commented to that effect.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 13/03/2023 18:56

She said "but". BUT. BUT it was a one-off. This is exactly the same as "However, in his defence, they said it was a one-off"

This in bucket loads! All she needed to say was that he'd refused to comment on it. There was no need for the rest of what she said.

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:52

DashboardConfessional · 13/03/2023 18:49

No!!!

She said "but". BUT. BUT it was a one-off. This is exactly the same as "However, in his defence, they said it was a one-off".

She’s quoting his friends. What’s she supposed to do? Make stuff up they didn’t say?

And don’t you think it paints him and his circle in an even worse light?

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:50

Abraxan · 13/03/2023 18:32

To be balanced she should then have quoted what his wife has said about it.

As an ambassador of that kind of charity she should have been very very clear as to what has been said and by who, and should not have left it as 'it,was only once' even if quoting his friends.

They were only talking about the one particular incident in which her nose was broken. Her comment was only in relation to that, not the other times.

DashboardConfessional · 13/03/2023 18:49

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:46

I think that if you’re representing the BBC and you’re repeating allegations that haven’t been heard in Court and which the alleged perpetrator hasn’t commented on, then yes, you do need to be fairly balanced about it.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not defending him. I think he’s odious and I fully believe his former wife. But Fiona Bruce knew she had to word things in a particular way. I think she did the best she could by stating that his friends had admitted that particular incident had happened. And if his friends have admitted it happened as a ‘one off’ then that’s pretty much tantamount to saying ‘yes, our friend is an abuser’.

No!!!

She said "but". BUT. BUT it was a one-off. This is exactly the same as "However, in his defence, they said it was a one-off".

Redebs · 13/03/2023 18:49

Rumplestrumpet · 13/03/2023 18:16

Well if she were neutral all the time it would be less bad.

but she bends over backwards to defend the tories, give them more airtime and interrupt left-leaning guests.

So I think her comments were part of a pattern and pretty poor.

Absolutely this
And if she wants to be an apologist for the long time violent, abusive, gaslighting bully of Stanley over his breaking his wife's face and nose, then she shouldn't be facing a domestic violence charity.

Bear in mind also the Tory cuts to services supporting women at risk and the stress their policies put struggling single mothers under.

She's a hypocrite

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 13/03/2023 18:49

Nope, she should step down. There was probably other abuse alongside the physical as it rarely comes alone.

Roussette · 13/03/2023 18:48

Why do you think she's brilliant?

She is brilliant on Antiques Roadshow. Not on QT.

And we all know DV is never a 'one off'. It's a pattern of behaviour.

Here ...
In the case of Stanley, his ex-wife, the late artist Charlotte Wahl, kept his abuse secret until four years ago when she told Boris’s biographer, Tom Bower, that their marriage had been “ghastly, terrible”. “I want the truth told,” she said about Stanley’s violence, which was witnessed by Boris. “He hit me many times, over many years.” Early on he resented her seeing her friends “and that’s when he first hit me”. Later, she was deposited in the country, without a car. “To adultery and violence, his family could add deserter.”

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 18:47

Rumplestrumpet · 13/03/2023 18:16

Well if she were neutral all the time it would be less bad.

but she bends over backwards to defend the tories, give them more airtime and interrupt left-leaning guests.

So I think her comments were part of a pattern and pretty poor.

Oh,you see I think she's good at giving people airtime when she clearly doesn't agree with them I.e I.e Tories.

OP posts:
Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:46

Ponoka7 · 13/03/2023 18:29

Should a DV incident be reported in a balanced way? We wouldn't allow it for racism. No-one can confidently say that it was a one off. It's a shocking thing for someone who wants to be highly and publicly involved in a DV charity.

I think that if you’re representing the BBC and you’re repeating allegations that haven’t been heard in Court and which the alleged perpetrator hasn’t commented on, then yes, you do need to be fairly balanced about it.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not defending him. I think he’s odious and I fully believe his former wife. But Fiona Bruce knew she had to word things in a particular way. I think she did the best she could by stating that his friends had admitted that particular incident had happened. And if his friends have admitted it happened as a ‘one off’ then that’s pretty much tantamount to saying ‘yes, our friend is an abuser’.

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 18:45

Hmmm I hear you. I absolutely do not think DV should be minimized- and I don't think she was minimizing things. I think she said something very clumsily but , like I said another brilliant woman (mostly we're all human) demonized whilst noone talks about the hideous nature of Stanley getting away with it. Just feels the balance is all wrong in favour of men,again.

OP posts:
Purplehyena · 13/03/2023 18:43

I’d find it very hard to argue she’s impartial or balanced generally to be honest, plenty of stats and analysis to suggest she very much isn’t.

I think she has done the right thing here, it may well be that case that she didn’t expect her words to have the effect they did, but she messed up and has, to some degree, taken the fall for it. Wish more public figures (politicians mainly) took responsibility in the same way.

The BBC has questions to answer as to why comments from Johnson’s friends were seen as relevant/essential and not the words of the victim herself.

MavisMcMinty · 13/03/2023 18:42

She should step down from BBCQT on the grounds of being incapable of fairly chairing debate. She’s as Tory as the BBC board and her bias on QT is blatant. Antiques Roadshow is within her capabilities, QT isn’t.

Ponoka7 · 13/03/2023 18:39

From Refuge itself,
"These words minimised the seriousness of domestic abuse and this has been retraumatising for survivors"
"Survivors of domestic abuse are, and will always be, Refuge’s priority. Our focus must remain on them"

carriedout · 13/03/2023 18:38

EggyBreads · 13/03/2023 18:31

I saw the program in question and yes it did come across as minimising it. Why on earth are Stanley Johnson's friends being cited as it being a 'one off'?. It was very awkwardly handled.

Same here, I winced when she said it.

Whataretheodds · 13/03/2023 18:34

It's not either/or.

nocoolnamesleft · 13/03/2023 18:32

I agree that it came across as minimising.

Swipe left for the next trending thread