Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Fiona Bruce is not the wrong doer here?

110 replies

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 18:10

She is stepping down as a patron of Refuge (DV charity) after saying Stanley Johnson 'only hit his wife once' on QuestionTime.IMO It was rather a clumsy thing to say - but she clearly wasn't meaning that it was ok- apply a bit of context and she was clearly trying to be impartial /balanced here - which she is week after week even though she must feel like banging her head off the bloody table!
I just feel that another amazing women is vilanised and another arse of a bloke gets away Scott free. Anyone else?

OP posts:
Peterbear · 13/03/2023 21:26

lenaperkins · 13/03/2023 19:58

She was doing her job as a journalist. It's called right to reply and had she not done it, she would have left QT open to being sued by Stanley Johnson. The ignorance of law on here is quite eye-opening.

annawharton.substack.com/p/youre-burning-the-wrong-witch-again

Completely agree with Anna Wharton.

OP posts:
PopGoesTheProsecco · 13/03/2023 21:07

Just a personal view so please don’t flame me!

Am so conflicted about this. Her words really upset me (if you’ve experienced DA it’s never a one off, and I think the majority of abusers are quite skilled in inflicting pain and fear without leaving a mark - think throttling, maximum fear, ‘I can’t breathe properly’, but minimum marks. ‘Allegedly’ Stanley broke her nose (I don’t want to get sued!) so who knows what other abuse this woman could be enduring.

As an ambassador for Refuge FB would have (or should have) understood the pattern of domestic abuse. That marks only happen when the abuser can’t even be arsed to disguise it or hide it any more.

As the chair of Question Time she would have known that this question may come up (it was topical) and should have researched more into what exactly Charlotte said to Tom Bower. She said it happened many times and that Boris witnessed it. First time ever I’ve felt sympathy for Boris Johnson.

I do think that, as a journo, she immediately tried to seek a balance (Stanley has never been on trial for DA) but Question Time is not actually quite live and they could have made her response a lot less clumsy.

BlueLabel · 13/03/2023 21:00

lenaperkins where FB let herself down is on agreeing to deliver that message. As an ambassador of Refuge and as an adult with autonomy she was more than well equipped to challenge the inclusion of the final sentence. "The right to reply" isn't something decided by a team, it's a legal right and that hasnt been enacted here. The contextualisation was in part to remove the likelihood of SJ exercising that right and avoid defamation claims. The content of the statement is something that the BBC production& legal team and FB are all accountable for - its not uncommon for broadcasters to seek clarification or suggest edits to statements.

That the BBC and SJ seem to escape the same level of scrutiny is depressing but this is a case where more than one team or person is at fault.

MavisMcMinty · 13/03/2023 20:46

Of course as well as the allegations of wife-beating and being a really shit father and husband, rancid old Stanley is also accused of being a groper.

As if he wasn’t skin-crawling enough.

lenaperkins · 13/03/2023 20:43

Fiona Bruce didn't need to say it was rumoured to be a one off because of BBC guidelines on right of reply. Ultimately those guidelines simply ensure that the subject of claims of wrongdoing is given a fair opportunity to respond to them.

Had a legal advisor wanted to ensure the BBC was covered under UK defamation laws then all FB needed to comment was that SJ had not commented on the claims, nor had he been convicted of any such crime.

It should have been kept factual. There was no need to quote the "friends" comment at all.

The right to reply would have been decided by the team. Of course it's nonsensical as how would SJ's friends have a clue what happened behind closed doors?

Everyone may think that Fiona had ' no need' to quote 'friends', but ultimately it wouldn't have been her call.

I really hope the wife-beating Stanley doesn't get his fucking knighthood btw, but the fact FB is held up to these nonsensical standards for being a journalist is nauseating. And Yasmin Alibhai-Brown agrees with me.

inews.co.uk/opinion/stanley-johnson-question-time-fiona-bruce-2205823?fbclid=IwAR3hhnGXJ8YgpY_07nm97c9LSlYYMS-0DezNzP4Y_AfgjqGWenHhM_lGGss

EarringsandLipstick · 13/03/2023 20:42

She is stepping down as a patron of Refuge (DV charity) after saying Stanley Johnson 'only hit his wife once' on QuestionTime

You have even put it in quotes - but this is not what she said.

The words were poorly chosen. I don't know enough about her as a presenter to know how representative that is of how she usually performs, whether it's clumsy broadcasting or lack of impartiality.

However, listening to the repeated inaccuracies about what she actually said is very frustrating.

I also agree with a pp who said that while she said the words, she was acting on production guidelines and it most certainly shouldn't be only her that is being blamed.

Womencanlift · 13/03/2023 20:42

Boomboom22 · 13/03/2023 20:34

I can't watch her due to the talking like she's having an orgasm thing. But in general the BBC is so far to the left it's unreal, no balance to be seen in the news, most discussion programmes so I'm surprised to hear people say fb is right wing.

😂😂😂 “BBC is so far to the left…” - didn’t realise it was April Fool’s Day already

MavisMcMinty · 13/03/2023 20:42

I’ve seen the clip of her saying it, but there doesn’t seem to have been any reaction from the audience, or indeed Yasmin Alibhai-Brown, who just took up where she’d left off. Did anyone say anything about it after that, during the show?

Roussette · 13/03/2023 20:38

Boomboom22 · 13/03/2023 20:34

I can't watch her due to the talking like she's having an orgasm thing. But in general the BBC is so far to the left it's unreal, no balance to be seen in the news, most discussion programmes so I'm surprised to hear people say fb is right wing.

Good grief. She always always cuts off panelists who are more on the left before they've finished their sentences, yet lets the likes of Jenrick and others go on and on.

It is very very obvious.

NameThenChange · 13/03/2023 20:37

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:22

I agree with you, but she didn’t actually say he only hit his wife once. She said "Stanley Johnson has not commented publicly on that. Friends of his have said it did happen, it was a one-off." All she’s done is tried to give a balanced account, which is what the BBC are supposed to do.

The fact he did it at all is disgusting and unacceptable. There's no excuse.

There's no reason to tell anyone "it was a one off" unless you are trying to somehow justify it.

Disgusting. She should go. So should he.

DashboardConfessional · 13/03/2023 20:36

Whataretheodds · 13/03/2023 20:20

She didn't have to say 'his friends have accepted it happened but said it's a one-off'.

Indeed.

Perhaps she could have said "His wife said it happened repeatedly and her parents confronted him about it, but according to the Daily Mail Stanley told his friends that it only happened once"? If we want some "balance".

BlueLabel · 13/03/2023 20:34

Though one thing that I think should be given more thought, this was either fed to her at the time or a statement given to her in advance. Whilst FB chose to deliver that message, the decision to include how SJ's friends choose to characterise his domestic abuse was made higher up the pole.

Boomboom22 · 13/03/2023 20:34

I can't watch her due to the talking like she's having an orgasm thing. But in general the BBC is so far to the left it's unreal, no balance to be seen in the news, most discussion programmes so I'm surprised to hear people say fb is right wing.

Callipygion · 13/03/2023 20:31

“.. she was clearly trying to be impartial /balanced here - which she is week after week ..”

you must watch a different version of QT to me then, she’s not impartial at all! So much a Tory mouthpiece it’s totally embarrassing. She should be taken off, she’s insufferable.

Perfect28 · 13/03/2023 20:27

She is right wing and doesn't even try to hide it. She's the opposite of impartial and she's utterly ruined question time. Her comment about it being just the once is inexcusable.

Abraxan · 13/03/2023 20:24

They were only talking about the one particular incident in which her nose was broken. Her comment was only in relation to that, not the other times.

So why was the 'only once' comment added? If the fact that the wife says there were other times was irrelevant then the face that his friends say it only happened once was equally irrelevant. Should ah E just stopped after saying that the friends said it [that incident] did happen.

Whataretheodds · 13/03/2023 20:20

Ttwinkletoes · 13/03/2023 20:18

Waaa waaaa waaaa waaaaa waaaa waaaaa - that’s what many posters hear even when others clearly explain the legal reasons FB had to say what she said - and that’s so that they can then spout bollox condemning another woman just to make them feel like a good little soldier pretending to fight a cause when in fact they are just eejits.

She didn't have to say 'his friends have accepted it happened but said it's a one-off'.

BlueLabel · 13/03/2023 20:20

Fiona Bruce didn't need to say it was rumoured to be a one off because of BBC guidelines on right of reply. Ultimately those guidelines simply ensure that the subject of claims of wrongdoing is given a fair opportunity to respond to them.

Had a legal advisor wanted to ensure the BBC was covered under UK defamation laws then all FB needed to comment was that SJ had not commented on the claims, nor had he been convicted of any such crime.

It should have been kept factual. There was no need to quote the "friends" comment at all.

LizzieSiddal · 13/03/2023 20:19

I disagree with you @Peterbear

Her statement today said “Last week on Question Time, I was required to legally contextualise a question about Stanley Johnson”
As an ambassador for Refuge, she should have known the words she used were minimising DV and because she obviously didn’t know that she’s really not fit to be an ambassador.
Also using “his friends have said” is just unbelievable. Why do his friends need to be quoted? If Stanley Johnson won’t comment they should just say “he refuses to comment”

The fact this controversy has happened will mean more people know Stanley Johnson is a wife beater and I’m very pleased about that.

Ttwinkletoes · 13/03/2023 20:18

Waaa waaaa waaaa waaaaa waaaa waaaaa - that’s what many posters hear even when others clearly explain the legal reasons FB had to say what she said - and that’s so that they can then spout bollox condemning another woman just to make them feel like a good little soldier pretending to fight a cause when in fact they are just eejits.

Notonthestairs · 13/03/2023 20:17

"Saying "He hasn't commented on the allegations," would have sufficed quite nicely. As opposed to adding selective hearsay."

Absolutely.

AlecTrevelyan006 · 13/03/2023 20:17

Rumplestrumpet · 13/03/2023 18:16

Well if she were neutral all the time it would be less bad.

but she bends over backwards to defend the tories, give them more airtime and interrupt left-leaning guests.

So I think her comments were part of a pattern and pretty poor.

this

Dayvi · 13/03/2023 20:15

ClownpantsKate · 13/03/2023 20:12

When is Stanley getting his knighthood ? I want to go and boo him as he goes in and out of Buckingham Palace

Yes. I think that would be a good thing to do. What would be better is that he doesn't get it at all.

Dayvi · 13/03/2023 20:14

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:22

I agree with you, but she didn’t actually say he only hit his wife once. She said "Stanley Johnson has not commented publicly on that. Friends of his have said it did happen, it was a one-off." All she’s done is tried to give a balanced account, which is what the BBC are supposed to do.

That sounds like a reasonable thing to say under the circumstances.

ClownpantsKate · 13/03/2023 20:12

When is Stanley getting his knighthood ? I want to go and boo him as he goes in and out of Buckingham Palace

Swipe left for the next trending thread