Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Fiona Bruce is not the wrong doer here?

110 replies

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 18:10

She is stepping down as a patron of Refuge (DV charity) after saying Stanley Johnson 'only hit his wife once' on QuestionTime.IMO It was rather a clumsy thing to say - but she clearly wasn't meaning that it was ok- apply a bit of context and she was clearly trying to be impartial /balanced here - which she is week after week even though she must feel like banging her head off the bloody table!
I just feel that another amazing women is vilanised and another arse of a bloke gets away Scott free. Anyone else?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DashboardConfessional · 15/03/2023 19:53

The rest of the paragraph from the article I linked - which is the source of the "friends" quote - says:

"The friends said it happened in the 1970s when Charlotte was suffering from Obsessive Compulsive Disorder and had ‘flailed’ at Stanley, who broke her nose when ‘flailing back’."

No sign of that as "right to reply".

LolaSmiles · 15/03/2023 13:49

But the punishment meted out for her for doing her job is so much worse than all the domestic abusers out there.
She's stepped down from a role at a domestic violence charity after publicly minimising domestic abuse.

Minimising domestic abuse isn't her job.

Excusing abusers isn't her job.

She could have said "SJ has declined to comment on his wife/ex wife's statement" or "SJ has been offered the right to reply and said..."
But she didn't. She chose to minimise it.

Prosecutions and convictions for domestic abusers are low, and it's no wonder when we've got public figures excusing it because what's one broken nose, it's a one off.

Roussette · 15/03/2023 12:53

But the punishment meted out for her for doing her job is so much worse than all the domestic abusers out there

She wasn't sacked? She just distanced herself from Refuge. Nothing else. She still does QT, BBC News and Antiques Roadshow.

lenaperkins · 15/03/2023 12:49

Bullshit. Stanley Johnson isn't going to sue anyone for saying he hit his wife because he did.

You may well be right. But legally he COULD have. Some editors take risks. The famous precedent for this is The Mail's front-page about Stephen Lawrence. They took a risk. It was calculated. But as presenter that wasn't in that position of power.

Honestly, the ignorance of the law here is just gobsmacking.

I get Fiona Bruce is unpopular because she is assumed to be partisan.

But the punishment meted out for her for doing her job is so much worse than all the domestic abusers out there.

Dumpruntime · 14/03/2023 12:23

Contextualising it is fine, but it’s the one off comment that’s the issue. If she had said “and I’ve to point out Stanley claims it was a one off but his wife is not here to confirm “ fine. But the dismissive “and it was a one off” even the way she said it, was really minimising horrendous abuse, the man hospitalised his wife by punching her in the face and breaking her nose .

the only one off Bruce knew was he didn’t break it twice. She’s no idea if he was habitually abusing her. And no lawyer would have asked her to make that claim.

she overstepped her role to minimise violence to women

Blossomtoes · 14/03/2023 10:38

Honestly I can’t believe the number of posters here who are bending over backwards to defend a dv apologist.

Same. No wonder men keep getting away with this shit.

MayThe4th · 14/03/2023 10:10

And then there is what that “just once” shows her as. I now sincerely doubt that she was ever such a supporter of dv survivors as she claimed to be. She’s only ever made one comment to defend and minimise domestic violence, how many more times has she thought what she was prepared to say this one time.

If she was genuinely a supporter of DV survivors there is no way she would have made that comment. She is a senior journalist. She knows the score. She knows what that comment would have looked like, and there absolutely are ways she could have got round having to make it.

Plenty of people would have defended her right not to minimise domestic violence. The bbc was already under the microscope over the GL comments, refusing to quote one sentence wouldn’t even have figured.

Untitledsquatboulder · 14/03/2023 09:49

lenaperkins · 13/03/2023 19:58

She was doing her job as a journalist. It's called right to reply and had she not done it, she would have left QT open to being sued by Stanley Johnson. The ignorance of law on here is quite eye-opening.

annawharton.substack.com/p/youre-burning-the-wrong-witch-again

Bullshit. Stanley Johnson isn't going to sue anyone for saying he hit his wife because he did.

Rosula · 14/03/2023 09:46

Houseplantjungle · 13/03/2023 19:23

I distinctly heard her accurately explaining/ quoting what someone else has said. She has clearly been doing lots to support vulnerable women. She’s been misconstrued and unfairly treated.

The problem is that she was somewhat selective in who she chose to quote. And, quoting or not, the use of the words "one-off" will always come across as dismissive. If someone says, for instance, "Yes, I broke the speed limit, but it was a one-off", the intention obviously is to minimise what they have done. The same applies to the words used about what Stanley Johnson did.

Rosula · 14/03/2023 09:38

Nagado · 13/03/2023 18:22

I agree with you, but she didn’t actually say he only hit his wife once. She said "Stanley Johnson has not commented publicly on that. Friends of his have said it did happen, it was a one-off." All she’s done is tried to give a balanced account, which is what the BBC are supposed to do.

If she wanted to give a balanced comment, she should have said that his wife said he hit her several times.

MayThe4th · 14/03/2023 09:34

Nagado · 13/03/2023 21:50

You do realise that she was quoting what his friends said and not giving her own personal opinion on how bad his wife had it? She wasn’t excusing him or trying to suggest that what he did was ok because it only happened once. What’s disgusting is that he did it and his friends have attempted to minimise it.

And, to be perfectly honest, how many people would be willing to give him the benefit of the doubt if she’d just said that he’d never made any comment on the allegations? How many more people now totally accept his former wife’s claims simply because if even his friends aren’t denying it, then he must have been violent on at least one occasion. And we all know dv is never just a one off. By adding that last sentence she’s shown exactly what sort of people he and his friends are.

And how many people will now think it’s all an overreaction because it was just once.
She’s a journalist. She was an ambassador for a domestic abuse charity. She absolutelyknew what she was saying and the message it sends. Upset my arse. She fucking knew she was a mouthpiece for the minimisation of domestic violence, so let’s not pretend that she was shocked that people were upset. If she actually knew or cared anything about the survivors of domestic violence she would absolutely have known how that comment came across.

Honestly I can’t believe the number of posters here who are bending over backwards to defend a dv apologist.

It’s interesting though because I had a similar thread but from the other side, and while the same FB defenders were out in force on the thread, the vote told a vastly different tale, and only 13% thought I was unreasonable to think she was in the wrong.

Would be interesting to see the vote from the other perspective, but I suspect OP deliberately didn’t enable voting for that reason.

pizzaHeart · 14/03/2023 09:26

Sorry accidentally posted too early. I agree with the following post of @EggyBreads
I saw the program in question and yes it did come across as minimising it. Why on earth are Stanley Johnson's friends being cited as it being a 'one off'?. It was very awkwardly handled.

the last sentence quoting friends was absolutely unnecessary. It was not a fact. Fiona overdid her contribution and her words clearly came across as minimising of the incident like one-off was ok and not too bad.
And I don’t like her apology, I don’t think she genuinely has got what happened and somehow I’m not surprised, it’s just this vibe from her.
I hasn’t commented anything about Stanley Johnson because the question was about Fiona Bruce. My opinion about him is lower than the lowest.

doadeer · 14/03/2023 09:24

She shouldn't be involved with DV charities if she defends DV. It's disgusting to minimise it when so many women will experience it in their life.

Adrelaxzz · 14/03/2023 09:19

Riapia · 13/03/2023 20:01

If only she had been able to kick a ball.

Yes because hosting a political programme and a sports programme demand the same level of impartiality.

NurseCranesRolodex · 14/03/2023 09:11

MavisMcMinty · 13/03/2023 18:42

She should step down from BBCQT on the grounds of being incapable of fairly chairing debate. She’s as Tory as the BBC board and her bias on QT is blatant. Antiques Roadshow is within her capabilities, QT isn’t.

Agree and this incident really highlights it.
Its time for a new genuinely impartial journalist to chair QT.

pizzaHeart · 14/03/2023 09:10

I agree with this^. Everything before the word “friends” was ok.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 14/03/2023 09:09

She handled it badly.

She could have balanced it up in a better way. If she’d said he’d never been convicted, friends of his said it happened once, his wife said it happened multiple times, then she’d have given all sides an airing.

She didn’t. She came across as minimising because she handled it badly.

greenerb · 14/03/2023 09:06

Peterbear · 13/03/2023 18:10

She is stepping down as a patron of Refuge (DV charity) after saying Stanley Johnson 'only hit his wife once' on QuestionTime.IMO It was rather a clumsy thing to say - but she clearly wasn't meaning that it was ok- apply a bit of context and she was clearly trying to be impartial /balanced here - which she is week after week even though she must feel like banging her head off the bloody table!
I just feel that another amazing women is vilanised and another arse of a bloke gets away Scott free. Anyone else?

She wasn’t trying to be impartial or balanced, and she wasn’t a bit clumsy.

She was literally saying what she legally had to say. They weren’t her words. It’s called a right of reply.

There is no intent to be ascribed to it.

The consequent social media storm is ridiculous. Absolutely stupid that she’s been made to stand down.

EsmeShelby · 14/03/2023 09:03

But it wasn't a one off . And as an ambassador for refuge I'd expect her not to parrot the abuser's defence.

Roussette · 14/03/2023 09:00

Because like it or not, she is the face of QT.

As we can see from the Lineker debacle. The BBC considered him speaking out of turn because he is the face of MOTD. (despite him not saying anything on air and expressing an opinion on his personal twitter)

AbuelaGetTheUmbrellas · 14/03/2023 08:52

BlueLabel · 13/03/2023 20:34

Though one thing that I think should be given more thought, this was either fed to her at the time or a statement given to her in advance. Whilst FB chose to deliver that message, the decision to include how SJ's friends choose to characterise his domestic abuse was made higher up the pole.

Exactly this. I’m not a fan of Fiona Bruce but it is obvious that the lines were fed to her by producers, there’s no way she would randomly have such precise quotes to hand. Why is she being penalised and the producer (whose words she is speaking) is getting off Scot free, and the man who was the perpetrator (Stanley Johnson), is not only getting off Scot free, but also being considered for a knighthood?

Roussette · 14/03/2023 08:29

You do realise that she was quoting what his friends said and not giving her own personal opinion on how bad his wife had it? She wasn’t excusing him or trying to suggest that what he did was ok because it only happened once.

You do not talk of 'one off' in a statement about DV. Why didn't she quote his wife then? As opposed to 'friends'.

Dumpruntime · 14/03/2023 08:29

I think she’s wholly in the wrong and should be ashamed. Not as she read out legal context, but that she said “but it was a one off”

she doesn’t know that. It’s mitigating it. And downplaying it. She wasn’t asked to say it was a one-off.

so yes, she should fucking go.

LadyKenya · 14/03/2023 08:26

Womencanlift · 13/03/2023 19:39

She is not a “brilliant woman” in anyway whatsoever. She is not neutral or fair and minimises the arguments that she (or more accurately her husband) don’t like being vocalised.

Have to laugh that she and Laura K get away week after week with their partisan views and Gary Linekar gets thrown to the wolves

Sooner she is off QT and a more balanced facilitator comes on board, hopefully ahead of the next election ramping up, the better

This.

Nagado · 13/03/2023 21:50

NameThenChange · 13/03/2023 20:37

The fact he did it at all is disgusting and unacceptable. There's no excuse.

There's no reason to tell anyone "it was a one off" unless you are trying to somehow justify it.

Disgusting. She should go. So should he.

You do realise that she was quoting what his friends said and not giving her own personal opinion on how bad his wife had it? She wasn’t excusing him or trying to suggest that what he did was ok because it only happened once. What’s disgusting is that he did it and his friends have attempted to minimise it.

And, to be perfectly honest, how many people would be willing to give him the benefit of the doubt if she’d just said that he’d never made any comment on the allegations? How many more people now totally accept his former wife’s claims simply because if even his friends aren’t denying it, then he must have been violent on at least one occasion. And we all know dv is never just a one off. By adding that last sentence she’s shown exactly what sort of people he and his friends are.