Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry there is about to be a second 2008 financial crisis

34 replies

Warisocker · 13/03/2023 17:57

Just to warn everyone, bellow is going to be quite a depressing read and this is just my opinion, I hope this will not happen.

The economy generally is absolutely shite compared to what it was the when I was a child and certainly compared to when my boomer parents were coming of age. By every metric out DC will have a worse quality of life on average than us. The benefit of increased life expectancy will most likely begin to reverse over the next decade or so and technological advancements have not been a silver bullet they were sold as, social media has wrecked out DCs mental health and will likely eliminate many potential jobs (chat GPT anyone?)

More recently, the war in Ukraine, the tension in terms of sanctions and the cost of living crisis is creating severe difficulties. For poorer people, a bad situation is being made much much worse. If it was once hard to make ends meet it’s now becoming almost impossible. For middle Britain, living standards are being (possibly irreversibly) decimated. Specifically for our DC moving away for university, getting a car at 17, being able to move out into a flat share with your friends, being able to buy a house in your 20s. These things will continue to go on for some, and good luck to those who can, but for the majority it’s going to become a thing of the past. And I think that’s a crying shame.

Specifically, about the title of my thread, Silicon Valley bank has collapsed. This was how the 2008 financial crisis started - a major bank collapsing. Aibu to worry that, in addition to the current dire situation, we may be headed for another financial crisis.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tomorrowillbeachicken · 13/03/2023 21:37

All are well capitalised until there’s a huge run on them. Usually due to rumours through the markets or brokers. Which is pretty much what happened here

Allmyarseandpeggymartin · 13/03/2023 21:35

Nah op, UK and European banks are much better capitalised than they were in 2008.

The bank HSBC bought were a specialty bank, set up to support Tech companies who have very specific finance requirements. So quite separate to standard retail and commercial banking (which is where the shit hit the fan the last time.

Looks like a good move for HSBC, plenty of profit in Tech. They wouldn’t touch a bad prospect with a barge pole. They were begged by the UK government to take on Northern Rock and refused.

Life is very difficult for a lot of people as it has been in the past, all you can do is take it day by day. No point worrying (pointless waste of brain energy) on something that you can’t control and might not happen 🤷‍♀️

Windingdown · 13/03/2023 21:20

I'm one of those 'boomers' who was born in 1964. Since then I've watched the world go through financial crashes, wars, nuclear war threat, Chernobyl, Aids, the cold war, high unemployment and lately, like all of us, a pandemic. There is always so very much to worry about and yet I am sure most people born the same year as me will have many happy, safe loving times all entirely unrelated to the above. We can spend so much time worry about things that can't happen and then if they do what we realise is that all things can be tolerated.

So much in the news is set to worry us and the news now is everywhere, all the time. Humans aren't designed for this onslaught of horror and bad news.

There are many things that are better about the modern world than in earlier times e.g. infant mortality rates are much lower, cancer is much more treatable. We don't notice these things in the media as they aren't want sells newspapers.

All we can do is vote for the people we think will do the right thing by society, campaign and really work hard to influence those things we can for the better and then to live our lives and try not to worry too much.

Savoury · 13/03/2023 20:48

UK and European banks are well capitalised so can withstand quite significant pressure and financial shocks. While it’s been seen as “hard” to do business in the UK and Europe in recent years compared to the US, we are about to see why it is important to run independent banking entities with boards that personay accountable.
Trump reversed aspects of the financial laws like Dodd Frank and they haven’t had the focus on governance that we have had here.

JackadooJackadee · 13/03/2023 20:36

Worse than 2008 in many ways because there was quite little inflation and plenty of wiggle room to lower rates to encourage borrowing. Now there is ingrained inflation, no real prosects of lowering interest rates without further inflation and GBP destruction. The real kicker is we may have been okay if the past 15 years of borrowing had been invested in productive assets... but nope! Spaffed on houses!

Those with secure jobs should be ok. Everyone else... not so much. I reckon we aren't far off the fabled tenner chicken. And I don't mean the fancy corn fed organic one.

BelleHathor · 13/03/2023 20:34

Good twitter thread on the situation:

"Why US banks are failing🧵

US banks were provided with interest free money by the US Govt / FED for years to prop up the stock markets and to buy Govt bonds. The undocumented rule is that those banks which buy more Govt bonds get preferential treatment to access free money.
The US banking system has become a tool for the US Govt to create the illusion of a strong economy by pumping the markets with Govt printed money and using banks to raise more debt. That only works for a limited time because the more money is printed the higher inflation rises.
When inflation got out of control the US Govt / FED had to stop the interest free flow of printed money to US banks and increase interest rates. Banks which got used to making big profits by manipulating the market with free Govt money started to struggle without the regular fix.
The US Govt bonds that US banks bought, including with depositor funds, to qualify for more free printed money are now toxic assets with the increase in interest rates and the demand for US treasuries drying up globally. That's what created the current crisis for US banks.
In short, US Govt driven market and debt manipulation are to blame. President Biden said today that investors / shareholders of failed US banks will not be compensated because it’s their fault for making bad investments. In reality they are victims of the US Govt Ponzi scheme.
In my opinion the US financial sector is in terrible shape, US markets are highly manipulated, US Govt bonds are now considered a toxic asset with international demand drying up and the future outlook for the US economy couldn’t be more dire. The total collapse is inevitable"

It's extremely pessimistic, but when you add in wider geopolitical issues between the USA and China right now due to Taiwan, sanctions etc. and many other countries choosing to trade in anything but dollars and also offload a lot of their dollar reserves it could get bumpy. The Fed had a choice to make raise interest rates to offset inflation, making long term bonds worth less and putting those 30 regional banks at risk of collapse or stop the hikes, provide a backstop aka print more money which will lead to inflation.

bonzaitree · 13/03/2023 20:33

I try and live day by day OP.

today I’m fine. Tomorrow I’ll probably be fine. I try not to think much beyond that.

Maybe that’s a selfish point of view but I’m also not arrogant enough to think I can change big things either for better or for worse.

It’s mainly self preservation to avoid anxiety. I recommend it.

Partyandbullshit · 13/03/2023 20:20

You have conflated so many disparate issues in your OP that really it just reads as though you’re panicking in the face of a selective reading of bad news. FYI, panic can bring about the very thing you’re worrying about, even if the underlying metrics are sound (they are more sound than they were in 2008). So, first thing to do is calm down.

Secondly, none of us have a God given right to nothing but progress over the course of our lives and into our children’s lives. Who ordained that? Including the car at 17 and home ownership in our 20s? And, specifically, how can we expect this when we are wreaking climate havoc, and consuming so rapaciously (goods and services, including social media seeing as you’ve pointed to that)?

There is so much buck-passing going on, very little holding to account of elected officials or of ourselves. The Tories have never lied about who they are and what they stand for (well, they have, but we should all know better). We get the leaders we deserve. We all use Amazon, Uber eats, Instagram. So distracted by all this rubbish that we don’t pay attention to what matters. This is no accident. It’s pretty pointless complaining at this point. If you want things to change, make it happen 🤷‍♀️

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 13/03/2023 20:18

Svb, silverlink and signature all collapsed

Elieza · 13/03/2023 20:17

1 bank has collapsed in America and 30 banks have had their trading suspended on the stock exchange.

shits hitting the fan in America.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 13/03/2023 20:06

One more collapsed on same day and another over weekend too. I think it might be a domino over there for smaller banks.
from what I’ve seen on financial press though lots of it was caused by the very companies that the us government are bailing out as there were messages going around that it was going to collapse so clients withdrew their money. Which made it collapse.

Starchipenterprise · 13/03/2023 20:04

@llLincslady53
Firstly no need to use the term 'Boomers'.

Secondly, although I agree with the sentiment of your post, the youngest Boomers were born in 1964 (bizarre classification in my view). This means the youngest 'Boomers' would not come of age until 1982.

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 13/03/2023 20:02

It’s overdue, and nothing has been resolved since 2008. It’s worrying. They’ll probably keep kicking the can down the road though (the governments and props) and it won’t all collapse this time. Who knows. We’ll see.

RosaGallica · 13/03/2023 19:54

The global economy is in trouble anyway as there is too much being pulled out by the richest living extreme last bed of luxury and not enough redundancy in the system, aka local sustainability. Ecologies have been buggered and too many have to be told that human societies and economies cannot survive outside of ecology. A financial issue doesn’t concern me more beyond wondering if the public are going to be hoodwinked into more austerity to make bankers rich.

Cloudhoppingdancer · 13/03/2023 19:34

It's true that regulation is much, much tighter now and the consequences of the SV bank collapse are contained - there's no reason to expect a domino effect. Just spookiness which happens so easily.

But lots of money in government bonds, rising interest rates and a run on the banks with a larger bank... That wouldn't be good.

Cloudhoppingdancer · 13/03/2023 19:31

I think we need to know if the bigger banks also have their money in government bonds before taking a position.

maddiemookins16mum · 13/03/2023 19:26

Lincslady53 · 13/03/2023 18:27

If your parents are boomers they would have come of age in the 70s. Rampant inflation, high interest rates, high unemployment. UK bailed out by the IMF. It was shite. Since the 2008 crash rules for banks have tightened so hopefully are more robust against problems.

Totally agree. 1980/81 was horrendous.

RunTowardsTheLight · 13/03/2023 19:19

The banks are much more tightly regulated than in 2008 so I very much doubt we will see a widespread collapse. There's no doubt that there are lots of problems with the economy at the moment though.

dew141 · 13/03/2023 19:17

unconventionalopinion · 13/03/2023 18:49

There was nothing unsurprising about the market activity of SVB; it's been foreseeable for best part of a year.

The concerning (but equally unsurprising) thing is the huge amount of MSM coverage about it inevitably ramping up panic in those who know no better.

Agreed (I work in the financial services sector). I think there will be a rise in retail and commercial bad debts with the hike in interest rates but not enough to threaten the whole banking system.

The panic-inducing posts really don't help.

unconventionalopinion · 13/03/2023 18:49

There was nothing unsurprising about the market activity of SVB; it's been foreseeable for best part of a year.

The concerning (but equally unsurprising) thing is the huge amount of MSM coverage about it inevitably ramping up panic in those who know no better.

weightymatters73 · 13/03/2023 18:43

Financial crises happen / adverse things happen about every decade so YABU....

Life is a series of ups and downs, and it never stops - I think we have had some financial crisis in every decade I have been alive (early 70's, 1992, 1998, 2000 (9/11), 2008)

The current one is from a combination of the fall out from covid /brexit and the Ukraine war, stated in 2020 and is still continuing.

It too will pass.

PandasAreUseless · 13/03/2023 18:37

Yes I think we're heading for another big banking collapse.

FFS 😔

I was in my first proper role when the last one happened. I was at an architecture practice. I was put onto a 4-day week for 6 months, all projects were cancelled, and they made wave after wave of redundancies.

The thing is - this time around we have a national staffing shortage in every single sector - so it's not clear how it will play out in terms of lay offs.

Moredarkchocolateplease · 13/03/2023 18:33

I can assure you that major regulated British banks have enough liquidity to manage this OP.

They have to have enough due to rules put into place after 2008.

TooBigForMyBoots · 13/03/2023 18:31

YANBU OP. The banking sector is experiencing issues. China has already had serious problems.

User3964870654 · 13/03/2023 18:30

It is very concerning but over here we seem more concerned with Gary Lineker, there was hardly any mention of this yesterday in the news