Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that many of the people shouting about Gary Lineker's "freedom of speech" are happy to shut women down?

106 replies

Qbish · 13/03/2023 16:36

It's marvelous, isn't it, "freedom of speech". It's marvelous when it's something nice and progressive that you agree with.

But if it's something you deem to be unacceptable... then shut it down! Cancel her! No platform her! Burn her books! Get her sacked! Picket anywhere she's booked to speak! Many of the same types who support Gary wouldn't hesitate to tell a woman to keep quiet, sit down, shut up. And they can't even see that.

OP posts:
BigMacExtraPickles · 13/03/2023 17:28

potniatheron · 13/03/2023 17:14

If you imagine a Venn diagram with the number of TRA and MRA types who want women to shut up, and map them against Lineker's most vocal supporters, you'll get a substantial overlap.

Gary Lineker is not a hero. He's not even a wise or intelligent policial commentator. The Government's migration bill has nothing in common with persecution of Jewish people in the 1930s. Lineker's just showing how ignorant he is of history.

Also, using the Holocaust as a rhetorical tool to own your enemies is pathetic.

When Lineker has paid the £4.9m he owes HMRC, then I might just take him seriously.

it's a big 'might' tho.

Well said

slashlover · 13/03/2023 17:27

However I had a breakthrough moment at the weekend with DD, who is now I think moving towards being GC. Firstly she's a professional scientist, so that helps. But the free speech double standards argument did see a light flicker ever brighter.

By "breakthrough" do you mean she now agrees with your opinion instead of having a different one?

Wingedharpy · 13/03/2023 17:26

Nolongera · 13/03/2023 17:11

Many people conflate freedom of speech with the freedom to agree with their opinions.

If Lineker had said the opposite most of these free speech " campaigners" would have been calling for his head.

So very true.
You're only free to speak if I like what you're saying.

Ahwelltoobad · 13/03/2023 17:18

I hoped it would go without saying, but I obviously don't agree with the comment she made. It was just my understanding that she had to make it for legal reasons, and now she has a shitstorm in social media, after years and years of work FOR the women suffering DV.
You would think they'd go after the perpetrator with the same intensity?

This example aside, my opinion stands, the OP is not BU.

potniatheron · 13/03/2023 17:14

If you imagine a Venn diagram with the number of TRA and MRA types who want women to shut up, and map them against Lineker's most vocal supporters, you'll get a substantial overlap.

Gary Lineker is not a hero. He's not even a wise or intelligent policial commentator. The Government's migration bill has nothing in common with persecution of Jewish people in the 1930s. Lineker's just showing how ignorant he is of history.

Also, using the Holocaust as a rhetorical tool to own your enemies is pathetic.

When Lineker has paid the £4.9m he owes HMRC, then I might just take him seriously.

it's a big 'might' tho.

Nolongera · 13/03/2023 17:11

Many people conflate freedom of speech with the freedom to agree with their opinions.

If Lineker had said the opposite most of these free speech " campaigners" would have been calling for his head.

Merkins · 13/03/2023 17:05

Whiskyinajar · 13/03/2023 16:43

Was she legacy obliged to say it though?

Well, yes. He’s never been convicted of DV so no BBC lawyer is going to allow an accusation to be made without some sort of attempt at balance (even if we all know it’s true).

Merkins · 13/03/2023 17:04

Kathleen Stock who has been in the national press every day for nearly a week, was on Woman’s Hour last week, was on Lorraine a few months ago and even had a book published? The one so tragically silenced that she’s absolutely bloody everywhere? 😂

TooBigForMyBoots · 13/03/2023 17:00

I was disgusted at the Tory party trying to shut down Gary Lineker by reporting him to his employer. I was disgusted at the Tory MP trying to shut down Lisa Townsend for retweeting JKR by reporting her to her employer.

They're skanky bastards who use all means available to them to shut down criticism of Tory policy.Angry

Qbish · 13/03/2023 16:59

I have already, in my mind, moved past the "Oh I wonder if they would support a BBC star spouting something right wing" feeling.

It's all the "progressives" supporting him who have, and will, denigrate women for daring to try to have their precious freedom of speech.

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 13/03/2023 16:59

Qbish · 13/03/2023 16:54

I mean let's look at The Guardian, for a start. Fawning over Gary, silencing their own journalists.

Correct.

faffadoodledo · 13/03/2023 16:59

Qbish · 13/03/2023 16:54

I mean let's look at The Guardian, for a start. Fawning over Gary, silencing their own journalists.

Agree

Turtletumy · 13/03/2023 16:57

Ahwelltoobad · 13/03/2023 16:42

YANBU
Why is FB being hounded for something she was legally obliged to say?
www.theguardian.com/media/2023/mar/13/fiona-bruce-to-step-down-as-refuge-ambassador-over-stanley-johnson-comments

Because she was only legally obliged to say that Stanley Johnson had not commented publicly.
Maybe even to say friends say it did happen.

However the one off comment was the problem.
As an ambassador of Refuge she should have pointed out that this was,

  1. Not what Charlotte Wahl had said.
  2. Even if it was true it was minimising domestic abuse

Womens Aid called the comments unnecessary and irresponsible.
And just for clarity as someone who has been in an abusive relationship the comment was tone deaf and I would have expected her to refuse to say it.

Violetparis · 13/03/2023 16:56

I agree with you OP. I think what Fiona Bruce said is a different issue and domestic abuse should never be minimised.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/03/2023 16:56

This had occurred to me.

However you’ve also got the right wing wanting to shut down Lineker and being quite fine with their supporters saying what they like (not saying the women OP has in mind are part of this group, I’m just saying it’s more complex than that!)

So there’s quite a lot of hypocrisy all around really.

I’m also 100% behind both GL and, for example, gender critical women being allowed their say - and also the less progressive people who I don’t agree with!

Axahooxa · 13/03/2023 16:55

YANBU

Qbish · 13/03/2023 16:54

I mean let's look at The Guardian, for a start. Fawning over Gary, silencing their own journalists.

OP posts:
Qbish · 13/03/2023 16:53

My point is, that many of the people who are so happy with their decision to support Gary Lineker's freedom of speech, do not hesitate to shut down women who they disagree with. And it's infuriating me.

OP posts:
DashboardConfessional · 13/03/2023 16:51

She was not legally obliged to say it was a "one-off". I can't believe anyone, let alone a woman, would say that as if it were relevant.

bellac11 · 13/03/2023 16:46

Ahwelltoobad · 13/03/2023 16:42

YANBU
Why is FB being hounded for something she was legally obliged to say?
www.theguardian.com/media/2023/mar/13/fiona-bruce-to-step-down-as-refuge-ambassador-over-stanley-johnson-comments

In what way was she obliged to say it?

lieselotte · 13/03/2023 16:44

Ahwelltoobad · 13/03/2023 16:42

YANBU
Why is FB being hounded for something she was legally obliged to say?
www.theguardian.com/media/2023/mar/13/fiona-bruce-to-step-down-as-refuge-ambassador-over-stanley-johnson-comments

Because she is disliked by the Twitterati for being a "Tory mouthpiece" (and a woman) and the powers that be pander to it all instead of telling the professionally offended to shut up.

Maybe her wording wasn't the best, but QT is a pressurised environment, and I doubt any her detractors have never made a mistake. Much like the sanctimony that occurs on MN on a regular basis, in fact.

Whiskyinajar · 13/03/2023 16:43

Was she legacy obliged to say it though?

lieselotte · 13/03/2023 16:43

Yes of course. It's one of the reasons Liz Truss was so pilloried. Do you really think the markets would have reacted in quite the same way if Johnson had done the same thing? Her policies were very stupid, but women are assumed incompetent until proven otherwise; it's the opposite with (white) men.

Ahwelltoobad · 13/03/2023 16:42

YANBU
Why is FB being hounded for something she was legally obliged to say?
www.theguardian.com/media/2023/mar/13/fiona-bruce-to-step-down-as-refuge-ambassador-over-stanley-johnson-comments

faffadoodledo · 13/03/2023 16:41

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 13/03/2023 16:39

Do you have a particular woman in mind?

I imagine Op has JKR and Kathleen Stock at the top of her list.

Swipe left for the next trending thread