Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have not been effusive when colleague was waving her engagement ring around

440 replies

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 13/03/2023 13:43

Just been taken to task by a colleague for failing to be sufficiently excited when another colleague told us she had just got engaged and was waving a medium-sized rock around the office.

The colleague who has just got engaged has been with her partner for about seven years and on two separate occasions has been in tears at work parties because of his behaviour (on one of these he accused her of going out because she was trying to sleep with other men). She has previously said they usually sleep in separate bedrooms, she has thought of leaving him and he refuses on principle to do anything social with her at all and has no interest in doing anything other than watching rugby. In short, he sounds like a world-class arse and she could certainly do better.

She was showing people the ring and everyone was gushing over it and saying how happy she must be etc. A couple of the other girls made comments along the lines of "wait until I go home and show Bob/John the pictures".

Full disclosure I find the whole business of engagement and engagement rings pointless and utterly embarrassing at the best of times. If you want to get married, get married but this ridiculous charade of having to be asked by the man and having to have an expensive ring to wave around as a badge of honour is just cringe. In the best of situations I find the business naff but I'm very happy to overlook it if the people getting married are happy.

But I know for a fact that this is not a happy relationship and simpering over this was more than I could bear. So I gave a peremptory nod, said "congratulations, very exciting" and wandered off, leaving the rest of them talking about the ring for a further 20 minutes. Much later on someone took me aside and said it had been noted that I was lacking in enthusiasm around the engagement and why had I felt it necessary to be this unpleasant?

I honestly don't understand why it should be mandatory to be interested in the engagements of people you don't know all that well in the first place but particularly when everyone knows they aren't well matched. I won't be rude and I wasn't rude, but why should I pretend to be overjoyed?

OP posts:
YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 14/03/2023 14:14

@eirlaw Understood! Apologies. It is quite a combative thread and I misread your post Smile

eirlaw · 14/03/2023 14:08

@YippieKayakOtherBuckets I wasn't trying to contradict you at all.

I was agreeing that it's like there is a common denominator - I thought you'd made it was a very pertinent point - one that was relevant to my own life's experiences. .

I just suggested a different solution you think more fake being enthusiastic

  • OP says she was socially polite (either she was or isnt able to be ) - I'm suggesting being more a forceful in future so people don't put you in these situations where they think they can tell you off.

I just think being more enthusiastic may just make the problem worse - in my babysitting example it would have made that more likely not less to happen again but I should have been more forceful to prevent it at all. I didn't project confidence and self assurance so some did try and take advantage.

I'm suggesting the OP should think about being considered more forceful/confident/self assured so that nobody feels able to take a grown adult to task is another behavioral modification she should consider.

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 14:08

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 14:04

No I haven't (as I suspect you know). But I'm aware that the expected (and actual) reaction of women to engagements and babies is largely because of society's rather sexist expectations, so I don't add to that by mocking or laughing, or acting superior to women 🤷

I was responding to you saying to the OP:

You've not really been as critical with men,

But why would she, when men don't perform the behaviours that she's criticising?

How would you prefer to challenge the sexist expectations around reactions to engagements etc.? What OP did was to do the bare minimum polite thing, and then come here to express her feelings more truthfully. The reality is that this behaviour IS damaging to women, not least because they see getting engaged to an abusive wanker as something to jump around getting excited about. How would you tackle it?

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 14:07

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 14/03/2023 14:01

I know your post wasn't to me but it resonated.

I wouldn't say a word about 1) because she's an adult and it's nobody's business but hers. Once she makes the decision to marry, all but nearest and dearest are best keeping quiet.

  1. I just used the word 'gushing' in my post. It fits, it describes the behaviour of some women and the huge expectation they have for other women to behave in a comparable way. It's neither fair nor relevant for people to police others' responses (talking about OP's insufferable colleague here), by 'taking this up with OP'. That colleague would have got (and deserved) short shrift.

Why are women not allowed to feel the way they do? Engaged lady feels how she does, OP has the right to feel and behave in the way that suits her best as she wasn't rude or dismissive that I can see?

I doubt that men second-guess themselves to this extent - or would have so many people so definitely asserting that OP was x, y, z <not good enough> in tone.

OP can feel and react however she wants. I wouldn't have policed her reaction and I don't necessarily think she should have been told off by a colleague.
Still find the tone and language of some of OPs posts a bit dismissive and "I'm not like other girls".

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 14:04

potniatheron · 14/03/2023 12:59

I like you OP. You've got your head screwed on right.

I'm flabbergsted that MN, which you would think would be a woman-centred place, is taking a women to task because she didn't fake paroxysms of joy at the news that her colleague is to marry an abusive partner.

A few years ago I had a colleague who announced that he was going to marry his boyfriend. I happened to know that the relationship was a very volatile one and not especially happy. But I hid my doubts and fawned and faked gushing smiles so I could 'be kind' and all the other crap PPs on here are saying you should have done. Less than 6 month after the wedding my colleague ended up in hospital after a domestic violence situation. I wish I had been more vocal with my concerns rather than indirectly enabling an abusive relationship in the name of 'being polite'.

You are quite clearly stating that if you had let your colleague know your concerns and not been so polite it may have made them pause for thought, not marry this person, ensuring the abuse was never committed. You've also thrown in a patronising, insult with the 'be kind' comments presumably because like her colleagues, you think that anyone who opposes that view, can't quite follow the profound points the OP is making.

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 14:04

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 14:00

I've never in my life known a man to come into a workplace or similar flashing an engagement ring and excitedly babbling about it to all of his colleagues. Have you?

No I haven't (as I suspect you know). But I'm aware that the expected (and actual) reaction of women to engagements and babies is largely because of society's rather sexist expectations, so I don't add to that by mocking or laughing, or acting superior to women 🤷

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 14/03/2023 14:01

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 13:34

Sounds to me like there are two separate issues here.

  1. If your colleague's partner really is abusive/nasty then you're not wrong to be concerned. But if you genuinely think he's bad enough to intervene then intervene, don't just passively look a bit uninterested.

  2. To me, some of your posts read as a little misogynistic. Using words like simpering/charade/gushing etc just comes across like you're lumping everything to do with weddings and engagements into one and using it as an issue to berate women with. You've not really been as critical with men, or been as emotive with your discussions about the patriarchal roots of marriage which may be why some posters feel you've come across as a bit judgemental.

I know your post wasn't to me but it resonated.

I wouldn't say a word about 1) because she's an adult and it's nobody's business but hers. Once she makes the decision to marry, all but nearest and dearest are best keeping quiet.

  1. I just used the word 'gushing' in my post. It fits, it describes the behaviour of some women and the huge expectation they have for other women to behave in a comparable way. It's neither fair nor relevant for people to police others' responses (talking about OP's insufferable colleague here), by 'taking this up with OP'. That colleague would have got (and deserved) short shrift.

Why are women not allowed to feel the way they do? Engaged lady feels how she does, OP has the right to feel and behave in the way that suits her best as she wasn't rude or dismissive that I can see?

I doubt that men second-guess themselves to this extent - or would have so many people so definitely asserting that OP was x, y, z <not good enough> in tone.

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 14:00

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 13:34

Sounds to me like there are two separate issues here.

  1. If your colleague's partner really is abusive/nasty then you're not wrong to be concerned. But if you genuinely think he's bad enough to intervene then intervene, don't just passively look a bit uninterested.

  2. To me, some of your posts read as a little misogynistic. Using words like simpering/charade/gushing etc just comes across like you're lumping everything to do with weddings and engagements into one and using it as an issue to berate women with. You've not really been as critical with men, or been as emotive with your discussions about the patriarchal roots of marriage which may be why some posters feel you've come across as a bit judgemental.

I've never in my life known a man to come into a workplace or similar flashing an engagement ring and excitedly babbling about it to all of his colleagues. Have you?

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 14/03/2023 13:53

Did all males colleagues in the officer gather around and gush at the sight of the engagement ring too? Or is that just the expectation that any woman must do exactly that?

OP said 'Congratulations' and 'how exciting!'. What more is there to say, really?

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 13:48

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 13/03/2023 15:15

Depends on your definition of "joy" I suppose. I don't associate "joy" with having a woman marry a meat-headed, semi-illiterate bloke who thinks she is going out looking for sex every time she steps outside the house. Horses for courses though.

You weren’t rude. I agree with your views on engagements and the fuss around rings. I love jewellery but i find the hysteria around engagement rings childish, especially when you are being forced to oooo and aaa at a boring ring with a piddling diamond in it. You can see from this thread the anger many women have towards other women for having a view different from theirs, it’s the extension of the #bekind banality which really is just another way of getting women to shut up and as you can see is rigorously enforced by other women. Getting engaged is wonderful for happy couples. I too have had to feign congratulations where the match was ill made and indeed on one occasion where I knew the groom to be was abusive. In that particular case I do wish I had said to the bride to be are you sure you know what you are doing, but it took another two years of torture and him leaving her humiliated just before their wedding for her to realise this was not the man for her. The thread also shows so many women still see engagement and marriage as a prize, a reward that shows you are a marriageable woman and therefore worthy as a man has chosen you. Not as a decision taken by equals to move forward together through life. The insults thrown at the OP for expressing completely reasonable feminist views are shocking. You weren’t rude and the woman who said you should have stood for longer congratulating your colleague was massively crossing a line. Would a man be pulled up by anyone ever for simply saying congratulations and good luck? Never in a million years.

potniatheron · 14/03/2023 13:38

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 13:18

potniatheron, how do you entertain the idea that you were somehow responsible for this colleague being a victim of domestic violence. Are women now also to blame for the things we don't say as well the things we do say? I find the whole notion of telling women how to behave, who to see, who to marry as anti-feminist as when the patriarchy do it!

I do not entertain the idea that I am responsible, as you would know if you'd bothered to read my post before galumphing in to tell me off with all the grace and insight of a sledgehammer.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 14/03/2023 13:35

eirlaw · 14/03/2023 13:14

In my 20s - head of another department left his two primary aged kids with me - never told me what he was doing just has expectation I would entertain them. I was working to a very tight deadline as well so not a great day and I had little experience of kids and was very shy and quiet.

I was rescued by lovely guy in managers department taking pity on us all - but the manager publicly in front of entire office told me off for not being enthusiastic about teaching his daughters about tech careers - my team leader came over with noise and defended me.

I've also been told off about lack of enthusiasm about Christmas parties - I hate them people get drunk and are jerks and one I got stuck with a large unexpected bill. I've also been told off about lack of enthusiasm about evening compulsory social events in my own time.

I'm not sure if it's motherhood or age but I do seem to have developed a don't fucking dare expression and people don't try this any more.

As far as I can see Op you were socially polite - so I can only assume you need to cultivate a don't fuck with me attitude with this colleague who was telling you off.

I am not sure if it was your intention to refute my post but you have absolutely supported my point. In all of the situations you describe the common denominator is that you were indeed entirely uninterested or unenthusiastic! It also sounds like the expectation of enthusiasm in each case was unreasonable but that is, I would suggest, a separate issue.

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 13:34

Sounds to me like there are two separate issues here.

  1. If your colleague's partner really is abusive/nasty then you're not wrong to be concerned. But if you genuinely think he's bad enough to intervene then intervene, don't just passively look a bit uninterested.

  2. To me, some of your posts read as a little misogynistic. Using words like simpering/charade/gushing etc just comes across like you're lumping everything to do with weddings and engagements into one and using it as an issue to berate women with. You've not really been as critical with men, or been as emotive with your discussions about the patriarchal roots of marriage which may be why some posters feel you've come across as a bit judgemental.

Xant · 14/03/2023 13:26

Normally I’d say YABU, but since the guy is such an arse and this is clearly going to be an unhappy marriage, YANBU. If everyone was leas enthusiastic when women get engaged to idiots maybe there would be fewer unhappy marriages.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 13:18

potniatheron, how do you entertain the idea that you were somehow responsible for this colleague being a victim of domestic violence. Are women now also to blame for the things we don't say as well the things we do say? I find the whole notion of telling women how to behave, who to see, who to marry as anti-feminist as when the patriarchy do it!

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 13:15

RampantIvy · 14/03/2023 12:32

and there wouldn't ever be a proposal.

But surely, even saying "let's get married" is a proposal? It doesn't have to be a performance proposal, just a quick question.

A lot of adults in equal relationships have a discussion and agree to get married (or not), rather than one person proposing to the other.

eirlaw · 14/03/2023 13:14

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 14/03/2023 08:34

I have never, in my middle-aged adult life, been spoken to by another adult about my tone or enthusiasm for a situation. I have never spoken about the same to another adult. I really did not think that this was unusual. Some pp are giving the impression that this is a fairly frequent occurrence and they might want to consider if in fact they are the common denominator.

In my 20s - head of another department left his two primary aged kids with me - never told me what he was doing just has expectation I would entertain them. I was working to a very tight deadline as well so not a great day and I had little experience of kids and was very shy and quiet.

I was rescued by lovely guy in managers department taking pity on us all - but the manager publicly in front of entire office told me off for not being enthusiastic about teaching his daughters about tech careers - my team leader came over with noise and defended me.

I've also been told off about lack of enthusiasm about Christmas parties - I hate them people get drunk and are jerks and one I got stuck with a large unexpected bill. I've also been told off about lack of enthusiasm about evening compulsory social events in my own time.

I'm not sure if it's motherhood or age but I do seem to have developed a don't fucking dare expression and people don't try this any more.

As far as I can see Op you were socially polite - so I can only assume you need to cultivate a don't fuck with me attitude with this colleague who was telling you off.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 14/03/2023 13:13

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

What a sanctimonious & ignorant comment. You clearly associate a lack of enthusiasm for marriage with some kind of man-hating stance.

OP's in a happy relationship. She just doesn't want to marry.

Galatine · 14/03/2023 13:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

pasta56 · 14/03/2023 13:07

And also, this kind of shit reminds me why WFH is so appealing!

pasta56 · 14/03/2023 13:02

fairycakes1234 · 13/03/2023 15:11

takes a second to smile and say congrats and your ring is lovely, doesn't matter if you dont agree with it all, its called being nice.

But it sounds like that's basically what OP did? Congratulations, brief positive comment and then getting on with her work. Sounds a perfectly polite and appropriate response to a colleague with some personal news.

As described, I don't see what the problem is.

potniatheron · 14/03/2023 12:59

I like you OP. You've got your head screwed on right.

I'm flabbergsted that MN, which you would think would be a woman-centred place, is taking a women to task because she didn't fake paroxysms of joy at the news that her colleague is to marry an abusive partner.

A few years ago I had a colleague who announced that he was going to marry his boyfriend. I happened to know that the relationship was a very volatile one and not especially happy. But I hid my doubts and fawned and faked gushing smiles so I could 'be kind' and all the other crap PPs on here are saying you should have done. Less than 6 month after the wedding my colleague ended up in hospital after a domestic violence situation. I wish I had been more vocal with my concerns rather than indirectly enabling an abusive relationship in the name of 'being polite'.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 14/03/2023 12:46

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 12:30

How can you possibly know that from reading a thread and from the word of the OP who seems to only be a colleague. Equally, not being happy makes it about the OP, if she genuinely cared, she'd show compassion for her colleague, not the obvious disdain she feels towards her because the colleague doesn't live up to her notion of an acceptable woman in thoughts and actions.

It's hardly a mystery, it;'s right there in the very second paragraph -
The colleague who has just got engaged has been with her partner for about seven years and on two separate occasions has been in tears at work parties because of his behaviour (on one of these he accused her of going out because she was trying to sleep with other men). She has previously said they usually sleep in separate bedrooms, she has thought of leaving him and he refuses on principle to do anything social with her at all and has no interest in doing anything other than watching rugby. In short, he sounds like a world-class arse and she could certainly do better.

How did you fail to see it?

The person who doesn't live up to OP's notion of an acceptable human is the colleague's partner. She's expressed concern about her, not disdain toward her.

RampantIvy · 14/03/2023 12:32

and there wouldn't ever be a proposal.

But surely, even saying "let's get married" is a proposal? It doesn't have to be a performance proposal, just a quick question.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 12:30

How can you possibly know that from reading a thread and from the word of the OP who seems to only be a colleague. Equally, not being happy makes it about the OP, if she genuinely cared, she'd show compassion for her colleague, not the obvious disdain she feels towards her because the colleague doesn't live up to her notion of an acceptable woman in thoughts and actions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread