Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have not been effusive when colleague was waving her engagement ring around

440 replies

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 13/03/2023 13:43

Just been taken to task by a colleague for failing to be sufficiently excited when another colleague told us she had just got engaged and was waving a medium-sized rock around the office.

The colleague who has just got engaged has been with her partner for about seven years and on two separate occasions has been in tears at work parties because of his behaviour (on one of these he accused her of going out because she was trying to sleep with other men). She has previously said they usually sleep in separate bedrooms, she has thought of leaving him and he refuses on principle to do anything social with her at all and has no interest in doing anything other than watching rugby. In short, he sounds like a world-class arse and she could certainly do better.

She was showing people the ring and everyone was gushing over it and saying how happy she must be etc. A couple of the other girls made comments along the lines of "wait until I go home and show Bob/John the pictures".

Full disclosure I find the whole business of engagement and engagement rings pointless and utterly embarrassing at the best of times. If you want to get married, get married but this ridiculous charade of having to be asked by the man and having to have an expensive ring to wave around as a badge of honour is just cringe. In the best of situations I find the business naff but I'm very happy to overlook it if the people getting married are happy.

But I know for a fact that this is not a happy relationship and simpering over this was more than I could bear. So I gave a peremptory nod, said "congratulations, very exciting" and wandered off, leaving the rest of them talking about the ring for a further 20 minutes. Much later on someone took me aside and said it had been noted that I was lacking in enthusiasm around the engagement and why had I felt it necessary to be this unpleasant?

I honestly don't understand why it should be mandatory to be interested in the engagements of people you don't know all that well in the first place but particularly when everyone knows they aren't well matched. I won't be rude and I wasn't rude, but why should I pretend to be overjoyed?

OP posts:
BellePeppa · 14/03/2023 19:08

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 14:37

Why do women need to be told what to do though and how to act? I don't understand how this is being a feminist. I think the description is embellished as it is just not plausible that every other woman was stood around, fawning over this woman who was vulgarly (of course) brandishing her engagement ring.

Some Men have also been known to collectively cheer and swear when watching sports for instance. I'm sure some men even feign it as most of us do not have the courage of our convictions all of the time!

Yes of course we’ve all done it. My son said he was at a concert recently he wasn’t particularly enjoying but joined in all the arm swaying etc because he didn’t want to be a douche in front of his friends. That’s understandable as he’d gone with a friend group and you don’t want to be the only one standing stoney faced and complaining. But if someone he didn’t know particularly well was in the group and told him off for not being ‘effusive’ enough he’d have probably had a few choice words to say.

Sugarfish · 14/03/2023 19:00

Some of the responses on this thread are mental. I was starting to think the dictionary obsessed poster was the engaged woman from the story, or the colleague that pulled the op aside!

@Thelaughingtonepoliceman I don’t think you did anything wrong. I wouldn’t be able to conjure up that much enthusiasm for someone I don’t know that well. I don’t think you sounded rude either.

I’ve had a manager in the past who totally would have pulled someone up for not reacting the way she deemed correct. She was a total control freak!

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 18:35

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 16:29

A contractual agreement isn't marriage.

Being cynical about people's behaviour and habits is all very well for commenting on but what about solutions.

I don't think you qualify as a feminist if you think we should all conform to the ideas of the universal woman. I honestly don't see what the colleague's choices have to do with the OP. If you think it will fuck up, the stats are probably on your side but if/when that happens are you going to withhold your compassion as you knew this would happen all along!

Marriage is a contractual agreement?
‘I don't think you qualify as a feminist if you think we should all conform to the ideas of the universal woman’ I don’t think women should conform to an idea of a universal woman. The reality is that women with young children so the bulk of child care and this has a negative effect on their ability to work and earn which can take years to resolve and they may never catch up.

Member869894 · 14/03/2023 18:24

You were mean and rude.

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 18:20

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 16:29

A contractual agreement isn't marriage.

Being cynical about people's behaviour and habits is all very well for commenting on but what about solutions.

I don't think you qualify as a feminist if you think we should all conform to the ideas of the universal woman. I honestly don't see what the colleague's choices have to do with the OP. If you think it will fuck up, the stats are probably on your side but if/when that happens are you going to withhold your compassion as you knew this would happen all along!

A contractual agreement isn't marriage.

That's literally exactly what it is.

burnoutbabe · 14/03/2023 16:52

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 14/03/2023 08:34

I have never, in my middle-aged adult life, been spoken to by another adult about my tone or enthusiasm for a situation. I have never spoken about the same to another adult. I really did not think that this was unusual. Some pp are giving the impression that this is a fairly frequent occurrence and they might want to consider if in fact they are the common denominator.

Agree! i think about the only person who could get away with saying that to me maybe be my mum, if say my sister got engaged.

But not a work colleague!

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 16:29

A contractual agreement isn't marriage.

Being cynical about people's behaviour and habits is all very well for commenting on but what about solutions.

I don't think you qualify as a feminist if you think we should all conform to the ideas of the universal woman. I honestly don't see what the colleague's choices have to do with the OP. If you think it will fuck up, the stats are probably on your side but if/when that happens are you going to withhold your compassion as you knew this would happen all along!

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 16:14

Ladyofthesea · 14/03/2023 16:02

I was once booted off of someones facebook when I didn't congratulated her on her engagement (as in: if you can't say something kind then say nothing). They broke up a few months later, which anyone with half a brain could see coming.

This is so hilariously petty, imagine actually scrolling your friends list to cross check who has congratulated you!!! Some people go bonkers when the engagement klaxon goes off.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 16:12

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 15:58

Eyerollcentral, dismiss it as 6th form level debating all you like but belittling that argument does not by default make your argument correct. Besides, 6th formers often have more radical ground breaking beliefs and are more inclined to strive for the 'ideal' rather than have their views informed by life experience that gets weighted down with a hefty dose of cynicism. The cynicism being the end on itself.

What is wrong with wanting to achieve the economic protection without entering marriage, developing original ways to govern rather than patching up broken patriarchal systems as that's what your proposal is based on the rational that's all we have to work with!

‘…rather than have their views informed by life experience that gets weighted down with a hefty dose of cynicism. The cynicism being the end on itself’ or as I see it they don’t have the benefit of knowing what the real world is like and how people actually tend to operate in it. It’s important to aim for high ideals, I agree with you, but schemes built upon them often falter because they fail to take in to account how people really are and really behave.
‘What is wrong with wanting to achieve the economic protection without entering marriage, developing original ways to govern’ I suppose civil partnerships are an example. I would be intrigued as to how anyone could be economically protected without requiring another party to bear responsibility to them and how that could be achieved without establishing some kind of contractual arrangement between them.

Ladyofthesea · 14/03/2023 16:02

I was once booted off of someones facebook when I didn't congratulated her on her engagement (as in: if you can't say something kind then say nothing). They broke up a few months later, which anyone with half a brain could see coming.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 15:58

Eyerollcentral, dismiss it as 6th form level debating all you like but belittling that argument does not by default make your argument correct. Besides, 6th formers often have more radical ground breaking beliefs and are more inclined to strive for the 'ideal' rather than have their views informed by life experience that gets weighted down with a hefty dose of cynicism. The cynicism being the end on itself.

What is wrong with wanting to achieve the economic protection without entering marriage, developing original ways to govern rather than patching up broken patriarchal systems as that's what your proposal is based on the rational that's all we have to work with!

Blossomtoes · 14/03/2023 15:49

But you’re both saying the same thing @Eyerollcentral.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 15:36

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 15:27

I have absolutely explained why it is an oxymoron, if you can't understand my explanation or read between the lines then I suggest you read up on the meaning of marriage!

If you are in a partnership why should you as a woman have to enter a marriage for economic protection, why is the State involved in your romantic relationships by indirectly affording people who are married an economic advantage? Marriage has roots in the patriarchy those don't change because you as a 'feminist' have got married! I am married and I mostly married for romantic reasons, but it was also to ensure my economic security but I'm not kidding myself that it is a feminist marriage as that is a contradiction in itself in my mind.

Name me an institution in the modern world that has not arisen as a result of the patriarchy??? Every single one of them has because patriarchy to date has been the dominant force in our society. It is sixth form level debating to say a feminist marriage is an oxymoron. There are very good arguments as a feminist especially one with children to marry as it enshrines your rights against your husband in law. Particularly as the state has resolved historical disadvantages to the female in married couples. Marriage should be promoted to women with children. The current trend for having a family outside marriage is incredibly regressive as it leaves the mother and children generally disproportionately vulnerable in the event of relationship breakdown, it does not recognise contribution to the family of a non working or part time working mother and leaves the man free of any legal responsibility bar the absolute minimum financial contribution required by the state.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 15:27

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 14:58

Er, you can't just go around 'asserting your right' to not pay inheritance tax, for example, or to be entitled to half of the assets of a relationship, or to benefit from all of the other legal, financial and economic protections of marriage.

I mean, you could try 'asserting it', but it's not going to get you very far.

It's very much in men's interests to say that marriage is meaningless, as it's mostly women who get the shitty end of the stick if an unmarried relationship breaks down.

I asked you why a 'feminist marriage' is an oxymoron and you haven't answered.

Marriage is a legal contract, and the roots of marriage are economic and familial security. There is nothing unfeminist about my marriage.

I have absolutely explained why it is an oxymoron, if you can't understand my explanation or read between the lines then I suggest you read up on the meaning of marriage!

If you are in a partnership why should you as a woman have to enter a marriage for economic protection, why is the State involved in your romantic relationships by indirectly affording people who are married an economic advantage? Marriage has roots in the patriarchy those don't change because you as a 'feminist' have got married! I am married and I mostly married for romantic reasons, but it was also to ensure my economic security but I'm not kidding myself that it is a feminist marriage as that is a contradiction in itself in my mind.

LLMS2022 · 14/03/2023 15:01

Wow, you sound like you think you know an awful lot about their relationship, but it isn't really any of your business to decide who she should or shouldnt marry? You have probably only heard negative things because people dont tend to gush everyday about how amazing their relationship is.You must have come across quite rude for your colleague to say something to you, I am going to assume this is a running theme with you and people have noticed it before and they have finally been spurred on to say something.
Your posts sound a bit bitter and jealous.

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 14:58

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 14:44

Bamboux because the very roots of the institution of marriage are not something that can be forgotten about, why do you have to marry in the first instance to reap the benefits that you reference. Shouldn't a feminist be asserting the right to that protection without entering marriage?

Er, you can't just go around 'asserting your right' to not pay inheritance tax, for example, or to be entitled to half of the assets of a relationship, or to benefit from all of the other legal, financial and economic protections of marriage.

I mean, you could try 'asserting it', but it's not going to get you very far.

It's very much in men's interests to say that marriage is meaningless, as it's mostly women who get the shitty end of the stick if an unmarried relationship breaks down.

I asked you why a 'feminist marriage' is an oxymoron and you haven't answered.

Marriage is a legal contract, and the roots of marriage are economic and familial security. There is nothing unfeminist about my marriage.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 14:53

In fact if you want it to be more about equality, really marriage should wholly be about romance, the commitment to each other should just be about love, the financial security should already be available to women with children to use your example.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 14:44

Bamboux because the very roots of the institution of marriage are not something that can be forgotten about, why do you have to marry in the first instance to reap the benefits that you reference. Shouldn't a feminist be asserting the right to that protection without entering marriage?

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 14:37

Why do women need to be told what to do though and how to act? I don't understand how this is being a feminist. I think the description is embellished as it is just not plausible that every other woman was stood around, fawning over this woman who was vulgarly (of course) brandishing her engagement ring.

Some Men have also been known to collectively cheer and swear when watching sports for instance. I'm sure some men even feign it as most of us do not have the courage of our convictions all of the time!

Mochinated · 14/03/2023 14:36

Toxic femininity in action!

YANBU OP and your colleague/boss are toxic twats.

As pp have said, did anyone take the men aside and bollock them for not being more enthusiastic?

Pure sexism

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 14:28

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 14:16

Sorry, I've obviously not been clear. I'm talking about the sexist expectations of society as a whole and how it's perhaps better to challenge them rather than mocking those who end up being victims of those expectations (ie women)

Society places certain expectations on women about engagement/marriage/babies. Perhaps it would be better to criticise those expectations in the first place rather than be a bit condescending about the reactions women have to engagement/marriage/babies etc.

Tbh I don't really have an answer to the bigger question of challenging society's expectations. I mean in my own engagement / marriage it was a mutual discussion, we both bought rings and I haven't changed my surname. Ive been really open with my own daughters about all of that and how you don't have to follow traditions. Hardly changing the world, but then again neither is blaming women's behaviour.

I've done the same as you

(this bit . I mean in my own engagement / marriage it was a mutual discussion, we both bought rings and I haven't changed my surname. Ive been really open with my own daughters about all of that and how you don't have to follow traditions. except that neither of us wear rings.)

I don't think there's anything wrong with a bit of mockery or refusing to participate in this sexist bullshit. And I think that mild mockery/refusal to participate IS a way of criticising those expectations. As is doing things differently yourself.

I'm not going to join in with the valorisation and fake excitement about something which I think is actively damaging to women.

@Goldenbear

Marriage is an institution with deep rooted inequality, it seems to me that a 'feminist marriage' is an oxymoron!

Why is it? I'm married and a feminist, in a marriage of equals (which benefits me more, on balance, given that I had to stop working for periods of time to have children). What's oxymoronic about that?

BellePeppa · 14/03/2023 14:19

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 14:16

Sorry, I've obviously not been clear. I'm talking about the sexist expectations of society as a whole and how it's perhaps better to challenge them rather than mocking those who end up being victims of those expectations (ie women)

Society places certain expectations on women about engagement/marriage/babies. Perhaps it would be better to criticise those expectations in the first place rather than be a bit condescending about the reactions women have to engagement/marriage/babies etc.

Tbh I don't really have an answer to the bigger question of challenging society's expectations. I mean in my own engagement / marriage it was a mutual discussion, we both bought rings and I haven't changed my surname. Ive been really open with my own daughters about all of that and how you don't have to follow traditions. Hardly changing the world, but then again neither is blaming women's behaviour.

What is this society you speak of? To quote Maggie Thatcher (if I dare 😁), “there’s no such thing as society”. Personally I’ve never felt any outside pressures to get engaged or married or have children. The only person putting that on me was me.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 14:19

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 13:48

You weren’t rude. I agree with your views on engagements and the fuss around rings. I love jewellery but i find the hysteria around engagement rings childish, especially when you are being forced to oooo and aaa at a boring ring with a piddling diamond in it. You can see from this thread the anger many women have towards other women for having a view different from theirs, it’s the extension of the #bekind banality which really is just another way of getting women to shut up and as you can see is rigorously enforced by other women. Getting engaged is wonderful for happy couples. I too have had to feign congratulations where the match was ill made and indeed on one occasion where I knew the groom to be was abusive. In that particular case I do wish I had said to the bride to be are you sure you know what you are doing, but it took another two years of torture and him leaving her humiliated just before their wedding for her to realise this was not the man for her. The thread also shows so many women still see engagement and marriage as a prize, a reward that shows you are a marriageable woman and therefore worthy as a man has chosen you. Not as a decision taken by equals to move forward together through life. The insults thrown at the OP for expressing completely reasonable feminist views are shocking. You weren’t rude and the woman who said you should have stood for longer congratulating your colleague was massively crossing a line. Would a man be pulled up by anyone ever for simply saying congratulations and good luck? Never in a million years.

I would say the anger is very much being exuded by the OP and other PP on here, angry that some of us won't be the acceptable universal woman, how dare a woman not comply with the forced relatability- does every single woman not want the same thing! Marriage is an institution with deep rooted inequality, it seems to me that a 'feminist marriage' is an oxymoron!

BellePeppa · 14/03/2023 14:16

RampantIvy · 14/03/2023 07:36

No she doesn't. I'm with the OP on this. I might try and fake a little more enthusiasm but it has disaster written all over it.

I can't get excited about engagement rings either as rings are just not my thing.

Maybe it’s an age thing? When I was younger (late teens, early to mid twenties) I would have feigned a more enthusiastic response than I might have felt but as I’ve got older the feigning over stuff I’m not that invested in has significantly reduced. I’m not rude but, like the OP, I’ll give a polite acknowledgement (that’s a lovely ring, what a cute baby etc ) but I won’t be huddled in a group excitedly going over all the details.

DistantSkye · 14/03/2023 14:16

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 14:08

I was responding to you saying to the OP:

You've not really been as critical with men,

But why would she, when men don't perform the behaviours that she's criticising?

How would you prefer to challenge the sexist expectations around reactions to engagements etc.? What OP did was to do the bare minimum polite thing, and then come here to express her feelings more truthfully. The reality is that this behaviour IS damaging to women, not least because they see getting engaged to an abusive wanker as something to jump around getting excited about. How would you tackle it?

Sorry, I've obviously not been clear. I'm talking about the sexist expectations of society as a whole and how it's perhaps better to challenge them rather than mocking those who end up being victims of those expectations (ie women)

Society places certain expectations on women about engagement/marriage/babies. Perhaps it would be better to criticise those expectations in the first place rather than be a bit condescending about the reactions women have to engagement/marriage/babies etc.

Tbh I don't really have an answer to the bigger question of challenging society's expectations. I mean in my own engagement / marriage it was a mutual discussion, we both bought rings and I haven't changed my surname. Ive been really open with my own daughters about all of that and how you don't have to follow traditions. Hardly changing the world, but then again neither is blaming women's behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread