Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have not been effusive when colleague was waving her engagement ring around

440 replies

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 13/03/2023 13:43

Just been taken to task by a colleague for failing to be sufficiently excited when another colleague told us she had just got engaged and was waving a medium-sized rock around the office.

The colleague who has just got engaged has been with her partner for about seven years and on two separate occasions has been in tears at work parties because of his behaviour (on one of these he accused her of going out because she was trying to sleep with other men). She has previously said they usually sleep in separate bedrooms, she has thought of leaving him and he refuses on principle to do anything social with her at all and has no interest in doing anything other than watching rugby. In short, he sounds like a world-class arse and she could certainly do better.

She was showing people the ring and everyone was gushing over it and saying how happy she must be etc. A couple of the other girls made comments along the lines of "wait until I go home and show Bob/John the pictures".

Full disclosure I find the whole business of engagement and engagement rings pointless and utterly embarrassing at the best of times. If you want to get married, get married but this ridiculous charade of having to be asked by the man and having to have an expensive ring to wave around as a badge of honour is just cringe. In the best of situations I find the business naff but I'm very happy to overlook it if the people getting married are happy.

But I know for a fact that this is not a happy relationship and simpering over this was more than I could bear. So I gave a peremptory nod, said "congratulations, very exciting" and wandered off, leaving the rest of them talking about the ring for a further 20 minutes. Much later on someone took me aside and said it had been noted that I was lacking in enthusiasm around the engagement and why had I felt it necessary to be this unpleasant?

I honestly don't understand why it should be mandatory to be interested in the engagements of people you don't know all that well in the first place but particularly when everyone knows they aren't well matched. I won't be rude and I wasn't rude, but why should I pretend to be overjoyed?

OP posts:
BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 15/03/2023 15:07

I’m with you, OP.

Goldenbear · 15/03/2023 15:06

SerafinasGoose · 15/03/2023 11:58

Still find the tone and language of some of OPs posts a bit dismissive and "I'm not like other girls".

This is not the case at all. At least not unless women are viewed as some sort of homogenous monolith, without separate minds and beliefs, who believe in a sisterhood and a nebulous thing called the 'girl code'. Just like men, we don't all adhere to the same tastes, ideologies and personal beliefs.

Culturally, the assumption that an important decision like our whole legal future with our intimate partner needs to rest on the shoulders of only one party - and a clear cultural expectation in some quarters that this is how 'tradition' decrees it - is potentially damaging. But if people want to have this discussion, and then go the whole hog with a demonstrative proposal, knock yourself out. Just because it's not for me doesn't invalidate others' pleasure in it. But what does need reappraising, IMO, is the notion of 'waiting for a ring' from someone who holds the sole power in that decision. Equally so is the silly, erroneous assumption that it must be what all women must want; that we've 'dreamed about our wedding day' since we were small children. We don't. And we haven't.

I was never interested in marriage at all - we're both economically independent - until my mother died young and I realized how difficult it could be to order our affairs in the event of the illness and incapacity of one of us. This was our single most important reason for marriage: very cold, hard and practical, albeit we did have the romantic overseas wedding (eloped) if not The 'Traditional' Proposal. If he'd got down on one knee I'd have laughed; if he'd asked my dad for permission as though trading ownership of a sheep or cow, I'd have been furious. Marriage is an equal agreement and a serious legal covenant.

At least this thread is a cautionary tale that people need to consider very seriously the practicality of their choices. There's also the option of civil partnership, albeit it's no different on paper to marriage. To those who never intend to marry, the least you need is a watertight Will and arrangements to be made relating to enduring power of attorney. To people who marry with all the whistles, bells and traditions, have fun and be happy. Just don't cede over all the power as to this decision, along with legal rights that might have serious implications especially should you fall ill, to another person.

Viewed like this, the 'I'm not like other girls' protestation is really pretty meaningless.

Those in support of the OP are the posters who are unsettled by the colleague not conforming to the idea of the universal woman - the OP by her own admission states she is probably nasty and judgemental. This judgement is of the colleague seemingly basking in the attention from the shiny rock and the proposal! Implicit in the judgemental descriptions is that the colleague is actually a bit thick (despite stating she isn't later on in the thread) for falling for this shoddy representation of 'romance'. The romance undermined by the reality, where the colleague has not once but twice, been in tears over this man! It is a shock to the OP as this woman is rejecting the forced relatability where women have the same political motivations, the same ideas about marriage, children, men, if you are not with us, you're against us mentality and if you are making poor choices like this colleague, you are letting your fellow sex down. If you are doing this you will be judged as you really need to tow the line.

There are fundamentals that most Women agree on like Rape is bad, domestic violence and sexual harassment are bad but areas of personal preference like being proposed to is a choice, as is enjoying being romanced or liking engagement rings, I like jewellery and my own is not a traditional diamond ring, it is a precious stone with a poignant tale from DH's family history associated with it. Women are entitled to make shit choices as well as ones we deem to be good and align with our own moral code. The OP has a choice not to be effusive but she should also realise that the colleague has a choice to make 'bad decisions' or ones that don't align with her political outlook.

dumdididum · 15/03/2023 14:35

Well this is what the world of an autism looks like - being constantly berated for not being two faced. I'm absolutely not suggesting you are of course, its just that I have two autistic boys and stuff like this happens all the time. Personally I think you have a point and perhaps you are the only genuine one - all those gushing are probably now bitching about when she's going to get divorced. But I still feel that if anyone has set you aside you may possibly need to brush up on our acting skills - sometimes it makes our lives easier.

MysteryBelle · 15/03/2023 14:26

Let us all rejoice that the op holds no power because if she did think what a tyrant she would be. Op, have you stopped to notice that nobody cares what you think when it comes to making others bend to your will? You’re not the boss of her. You sound like a stalker and a psycho. Again, you are not the boss of her. The whole reason for equality is so women can make their own decisions and not be oppressed by ANYONE. Including other women. You have an enormous chip on your shoulder acting self righteous, and truly you sound jealous as can be. Look at what you’re saying. Textbook jealousy.

threecupsofteaminimum · 15/03/2023 13:42

YANBU

whoever took you aside needs to wind their neck in.

SerafinasGoose · 15/03/2023 11:58

Still find the tone and language of some of OPs posts a bit dismissive and "I'm not like other girls".

This is not the case at all. At least not unless women are viewed as some sort of homogenous monolith, without separate minds and beliefs, who believe in a sisterhood and a nebulous thing called the 'girl code'. Just like men, we don't all adhere to the same tastes, ideologies and personal beliefs.

Culturally, the assumption that an important decision like our whole legal future with our intimate partner needs to rest on the shoulders of only one party - and a clear cultural expectation in some quarters that this is how 'tradition' decrees it - is potentially damaging. But if people want to have this discussion, and then go the whole hog with a demonstrative proposal, knock yourself out. Just because it's not for me doesn't invalidate others' pleasure in it. But what does need reappraising, IMO, is the notion of 'waiting for a ring' from someone who holds the sole power in that decision. Equally so is the silly, erroneous assumption that it must be what all women must want; that we've 'dreamed about our wedding day' since we were small children. We don't. And we haven't.

I was never interested in marriage at all - we're both economically independent - until my mother died young and I realized how difficult it could be to order our affairs in the event of the illness and incapacity of one of us. This was our single most important reason for marriage: very cold, hard and practical, albeit we did have the romantic overseas wedding (eloped) if not The 'Traditional' Proposal. If he'd got down on one knee I'd have laughed; if he'd asked my dad for permission as though trading ownership of a sheep or cow, I'd have been furious. Marriage is an equal agreement and a serious legal covenant.

At least this thread is a cautionary tale that people need to consider very seriously the practicality of their choices. There's also the option of civil partnership, albeit it's no different on paper to marriage. To those who never intend to marry, the least you need is a watertight Will and arrangements to be made relating to enduring power of attorney. To people who marry with all the whistles, bells and traditions, have fun and be happy. Just don't cede over all the power as to this decision, along with legal rights that might have serious implications especially should you fall ill, to another person.

Viewed like this, the 'I'm not like other girls' protestation is really pretty meaningless.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 21:27

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 21:12

Even if you think Marriage is wholly a contract, it doesn't follow that a 'contract' just exists in the institution of marriage, my response was about other ways to do things as fundamentally a feminist marriage is an oxymoron. I don't have any qualms about marriage in that sense so I don't care as my motivation for getting married was romance. This word appears an affront to most on here as it doesn't fit in to the universal woman mould where the personal has to be the political. I'm not sure where you got the impression the op's views are in the minority, a majority on here are supporting her need to almost be repelled by this woman. No one has answered why it is ok for women to expect others to behave and think like you. Whether this woman is heading for a doomed relationship is irrelevant, it is the the principle of women having the right to choose their own life path that is what is being discussed. Nobody should tell the OP off but equally why act superior, why do you feel you are better than her.

I don’t think it, that’s what marriage is, a legal binding agreement. I can’t understand how you are married and didn’t know this. The point about it being legally binding is what gives the parties defined protections under law. It legalises the relationship.
‘it doesn't follow that a 'contract' just exists in the institution of marriage’ yeah you can have a civil partnership, another legally binding agreement between partners regulating their relationship. You cannot expect to have legal protection in a relationship when you have not subjected the relationship to the rule of law.
‘This word appears an affront to most on here as it doesn't fit in to the universal woman mould where the personal has to be the political’ Sorry but this is nonsense. Just because I know the legal implications of marriage it doesn’t mean that I reject romance and love. Love is inherent in the concept of marriage. The two are not mutually exclusive.
‘I'm not sure where you got the impression the op's views are in the minority’ I didn’t say her views are in a minority. I said she has been pressured in person and online to conform to the prevailing view.
‘it is the the principle of women having the right to choose their own life path’ yes and the OP congratulated her on her decision and continued with her day. She is allowed to think flip me that’s a bad decision. She didn’t vocalise it, she didn’t criticise the woman. She gave a totally appropriate response and then was criticised for not being overly effusive. The issue here is the criticism, the expectation that she must jump for joy and when she doesn’t, as a woman, other women think they have the right to condemn her for it.

Corcomroe · 14/03/2023 21:25

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 21:12

Even if you think Marriage is wholly a contract, it doesn't follow that a 'contract' just exists in the institution of marriage, my response was about other ways to do things as fundamentally a feminist marriage is an oxymoron. I don't have any qualms about marriage in that sense so I don't care as my motivation for getting married was romance. This word appears an affront to most on here as it doesn't fit in to the universal woman mould where the personal has to be the political. I'm not sure where you got the impression the op's views are in the minority, a majority on here are supporting her need to almost be repelled by this woman. No one has answered why it is ok for women to expect others to behave and think like you. Whether this woman is heading for a doomed relationship is irrelevant, it is the the principle of women having the right to choose their own life path that is what is being discussed. Nobody should tell the OP off but equally why act superior, why do you feel you are better than her.

Because to ooh and ah over an engagement ring perpetuates the sexist idea that bagging a chap is the highest pinnacle of female achievement, highlighted in this specific case by the chap in question clearly being a dreadful piece of work, as demonstrated by his long history of making his now-fiancée miserable and accusing her of attending work events only to sleep with other men?

The OP is, in this situation, demonstrably superior because she’s not sleepwalking into a dire marriage despite seven years of obvious unhappiness, nor is she colluding in the simpering collective amnesia which appears to think Bad Guy + Diamond = Prince Charming. It’s that kind of nonsense that causes women like that to think that marriage is an achievement, regardless of whom you marry.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 21:12

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 20:02

Whether it is or isn’t a contract in your mind, it absolutely legally is one! Romance has nothing to do with it. A marriage is a legally binding agreement.
‘Your posts suggest otherwise- the OP is showing upset over this woman not conforming to what she thinks is an acceptable way to think and behave as a woman and you agree with her’ It’s funny you see it like that. What I see is the OP being singled out in her office for not conforming to the expectation she should be super excited by a colleague’s engagement and indeed has been called bitter, jealous, etc. by more women on here for not conforming to that either 🤷‍♀️ The OP has congratulated the woman and that’s STILL not enough to conform. The OP described her views and the context as background and has been castigated for them as the conformist view is that she should be excited and more than that even if she isn’t she should fake it to socially conform.
Its interesting how many people seem personally affronted by a woman saying I think engagement rings and proposals are a load of nonsense.

Even if you think Marriage is wholly a contract, it doesn't follow that a 'contract' just exists in the institution of marriage, my response was about other ways to do things as fundamentally a feminist marriage is an oxymoron. I don't have any qualms about marriage in that sense so I don't care as my motivation for getting married was romance. This word appears an affront to most on here as it doesn't fit in to the universal woman mould where the personal has to be the political. I'm not sure where you got the impression the op's views are in the minority, a majority on here are supporting her need to almost be repelled by this woman. No one has answered why it is ok for women to expect others to behave and think like you. Whether this woman is heading for a doomed relationship is irrelevant, it is the the principle of women having the right to choose their own life path that is what is being discussed. Nobody should tell the OP off but equally why act superior, why do you feel you are better than her.

ThanksItHasPockets · 14/03/2023 21:07

Ha. I’m re-watching Mad Men and have just had the scene when the secretaries are all squealing in one office when two of the men walk past and say ‘sounds like a visit from the stork or De Beers’ before Joan walks out flashing her engagement ring. Plus ça change, etc.

Bamboux · 14/03/2023 21:01

A marriage is not a contract in my mind, you old romantic you!

I mean, a whale is not a mammal... in my mind. France is not a country... in my mind. Water is not a liquid at room temperature... in my mind. It's not March... in my mind.

Unfortunately (or probably fortunately), that has absolutely no bearing on reality. Any more than your bizarre conceit that 'marriage is not a contract'.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 20:49

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 14/03/2023 20:16

I mean we'll have to agree to disagree (if this was directed at me). I possess emotions as well but for me if you're routinely in tears in the office or in a work setting about the state of your relationship that's not normal. I've never done that ever. There's absolutely no way I would let work colleagues know about the state of my relationship. It must be pretty bad for her to have been reduced to tears like that.

And to tell colleagues (as opposed to friends) that your OH has accused you of being unfaithful because you've gone to a near-mandatory work dinner, I really struggle to see how anyone could think was normal or healthy? And to then go on and announce your engagement, all smiles, and expect people to airbrush this incident out. I have every compassion for this woman and quite prepared to not embarrass her by raising it in public but let's not pretend this is a great example of a romantic relationship.

You are completely correct. You can’t expect people to forget everything you said prior to the engagement.

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 14/03/2023 20:16

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 19:50

Really? People cry all the time over relationships as people possess these things called emotions, it shows they have compassion too. Something that some seem to lack on here.

I mean we'll have to agree to disagree (if this was directed at me). I possess emotions as well but for me if you're routinely in tears in the office or in a work setting about the state of your relationship that's not normal. I've never done that ever. There's absolutely no way I would let work colleagues know about the state of my relationship. It must be pretty bad for her to have been reduced to tears like that.

And to tell colleagues (as opposed to friends) that your OH has accused you of being unfaithful because you've gone to a near-mandatory work dinner, I really struggle to see how anyone could think was normal or healthy? And to then go on and announce your engagement, all smiles, and expect people to airbrush this incident out. I have every compassion for this woman and quite prepared to not embarrass her by raising it in public but let's not pretend this is a great example of a romantic relationship.

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 20:02

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 19:47

Your posts suggest otherwise- the OP is showing upset over this woman not conforming to what she thinks is an acceptable way to think and behave as a woman and you agree with her.

A marriage is not a contract in my mind, you old romantic you!

I am not really bothered either way get married/don't get married, I am just failing to understand why the OP gets to be so sanctimonious about it all.

Whether it is or isn’t a contract in your mind, it absolutely legally is one! Romance has nothing to do with it. A marriage is a legally binding agreement.
‘Your posts suggest otherwise- the OP is showing upset over this woman not conforming to what she thinks is an acceptable way to think and behave as a woman and you agree with her’ It’s funny you see it like that. What I see is the OP being singled out in her office for not conforming to the expectation she should be super excited by a colleague’s engagement and indeed has been called bitter, jealous, etc. by more women on here for not conforming to that either 🤷‍♀️ The OP has congratulated the woman and that’s STILL not enough to conform. The OP described her views and the context as background and has been castigated for them as the conformist view is that she should be excited and more than that even if she isn’t she should fake it to socially conform.
Its interesting how many people seem personally affronted by a woman saying I think engagement rings and proposals are a load of nonsense.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 19:50

Really? People cry all the time over relationships as people possess these things called emotions, it shows they have compassion too. Something that some seem to lack on here.

QueSyrahSyrah · 14/03/2023 19:50

@Eyerollcentral Ok fair enough, even I might find that a little too passive-aggressive Grin

Over the years I've perfected the art of either zoning out, or immediately forgetting, any office chat that doesn't spark joy in me. I'm the Marie Kondo of workplace gossip.

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 14/03/2023 19:50

QueSyrahSyrah · 14/03/2023 19:23

You seem to know a lot about her, her relationship and her partner for someone who don't know all that well in the first place 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don't know much about her or her relationship but I know enough. When someone is reduced to tears by her partner because he has called her rude names for going out to a work event, you know he's not a keeper!

I can't for the life of me see what's controversial about that. Leaving my views about marriage and engagement out of it for one moment surely people can agree on that? If you actually think this is normal behaviour between couples there's something wrong.

OP posts:
TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 14/03/2023 19:48

QueSyrahSyrah · 14/03/2023 19:23

You seem to know a lot about her, her relationship and her partner for someone who don't know all that well in the first place 🤷🏻‍♀️

She knows that her fiance makes her cry at work.
That's not "a lot about her", but it's enough.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 14/03/2023 19:47

Member869894 · 14/03/2023 18:24

You were mean and rude.

😂😂😂

How is "congratulations, very exciting" mean & rude?

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 19:47

QueSyrahSyrah · 14/03/2023 19:42

@Sugarfish @Eyerollcentral Noise cancelling headphones are your friend. We have over-sharers at work, but if I don't care to listen then I just block them out and let them blather on to people who are interested.

I mean in my personal office, a separate room not an open plan office. I’m not rude enough to put a big pair of overhead earphones on whilst someone in crying across my desk at me, although I often wish I was! Some people just like to involve the world and their wife in their relationship dramas, same way the new fiancée wanted to involve everyone in her engagement.

Goldenbear · 14/03/2023 19:47

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 18:35

Marriage is a contractual agreement?
‘I don't think you qualify as a feminist if you think we should all conform to the ideas of the universal woman’ I don’t think women should conform to an idea of a universal woman. The reality is that women with young children so the bulk of child care and this has a negative effect on their ability to work and earn which can take years to resolve and they may never catch up.

Your posts suggest otherwise- the OP is showing upset over this woman not conforming to what she thinks is an acceptable way to think and behave as a woman and you agree with her.

A marriage is not a contract in my mind, you old romantic you!

I am not really bothered either way get married/don't get married, I am just failing to understand why the OP gets to be so sanctimonious about it all.

QueSyrahSyrah · 14/03/2023 19:42

@Sugarfish @Eyerollcentral Noise cancelling headphones are your friend. We have over-sharers at work, but if I don't care to listen then I just block them out and let them blather on to people who are interested.

Sugarfish · 14/03/2023 19:34

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 19:27

Tbf some people are drama llamas and totally over share at work. I’ve had people spilling their guts in tears in my office who I barely knew and actually sometimes it’s easier for some people to offload to work colleagues who are at a remove from their lives. Sounds like the woman the OP is describing is one of those who needs zero encouragement to tell you everything

Totally agree with this, you can overhear so much! I work in a large open plan office and I know all the details about one woman’s endometriosis, despite only speaking to her a handful of times. I know that one man was adopted and I know the name of a guy another woman had a one night stand with last weekend. I could not tell you when any of these peoples birthdays are, their favourite foods, what music they’re into.

Eyerollcentral · 14/03/2023 19:27

QueSyrahSyrah · 14/03/2023 19:23

You seem to know a lot about her, her relationship and her partner for someone who don't know all that well in the first place 🤷🏻‍♀️

Tbf some people are drama llamas and totally over share at work. I’ve had people spilling their guts in tears in my office who I barely knew and actually sometimes it’s easier for some people to offload to work colleagues who are at a remove from their lives. Sounds like the woman the OP is describing is one of those who needs zero encouragement to tell you everything

QueSyrahSyrah · 14/03/2023 19:23

You seem to know a lot about her, her relationship and her partner for someone who don't know all that well in the first place 🤷🏻‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread