Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable - me or window cleaner?

738 replies

HugATwat · 13/03/2023 10:51

My dog is petrified of the window cleaner.

The reason I started using my current window cleaner is because he always texts so I know in advance when he's coming.

On Friday evening, WC text to say he was coming on Saturday morning. But I was going to be out Saturday morning so I texted him back and said to leave it for this month because the dog would be home alone and wouldn't cope. I said I'd still be happy to pay but please don't clean the windows.

No reply.

I texted again first thing on Saturday morning. No reply.

I called him on Saturday morning. He didn't answer. I left a message. No reply.

I texted him again before we went out saying please don't clean my windows today.

I went out because I couldn't avoid it. I'd asked a couple of friends if they could sit with the dog but they couldn't, far too short notice. When I came back, the windows had been cleaned. The dog was in a right state and had pissed and shit all over the floor.

So I spent an hour or so calming the dog down. Then another couple of hours cleaning everything up. And the living room carpet will need a professional because the piddle has stained quite badly.

I texted the WC to tell him I wouldn't be paying because I'd specifically asked him not to clean the windows.
This time, he texted back. Quelle fucking surprise.

I'm holding firm and not paying. Needless to say I've told him to take me off his books for the future.

It's a weird situation because I was actually willing to pay him for NOT doing the work. But I'm not willing to pay for work that he's done that I specifically asked him not to do.

Am I being unreasonable here? I'm still so pissed off.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
fenwoman123 · 19/03/2023 19:01

BaroldFromEastenders · 19/03/2023 06:37

I guess because her “method” of teaching her dog not to be scared of something involved flooding it with the experience it found terrifying. Not a behaviourist I’d use or anyone whose advice I would take!

It doesn't involve flooding at all. Reward based training is nothing like flooding'. Obviously you don't have a clue, which is fair enough. A behaviorist isn't a trainer. As I replied already, I retired because of age and infirmity.
before you start throwing accusations and slurs around, perhaps you should at least learn something. But I guess ignorance is as good as any qualification lol.

fenwoman123 · 19/03/2023 18:56

"So you're no longer a dog behaviourist........ because?"
Because I am nearly 70 years old and in poor health. Satisfied? Is that a reasonable excuse?

HugATwat · 19/03/2023 08:47

@WiddlinDiddlin Thanks for your explanation. This resonates with my dog and other nervous rescues I've had in the past. I really have tried my absolute best to do counter conditioning with everything that caused her stress when I first had her. We just can't crack the WC.

Or, weirdly, houseplants on the fire hearth 🤔I haven't particularly bothered with that one, easier to just not put plants there!

OP posts:
DizzyLizzyKizzy · 19/03/2023 07:36

@BaroldFromEastenders my thoughts exactly!

WiddlinDiddlin · 19/03/2023 06:55

BadNomad · 17/03/2023 20:17

Of course you can't train a dog when you're not there. No one suggested that. But can you seriously say the OP hasn't made her dog's fear worse by herding it around the house to get away from the window cleaner? And that there is zero point in trying to associate the window cleaner's arrival with a positive treat?

I absolutely can, yes - in fact avoiding the dog experiencing that level of fear is vital to modifying emotional responses, via classical conditioning (in this context usually called counter conditioning as we're working to alter a conditioned response, rather than create a brand new one to a previously unconditioned stimulus).

Once you get past a certain threshold for fear, and stress hormone levels get too high, the subject cannot learn anything positive - thats a normal function of the brain.

To put it into laymans terms - if you could be distracted and diverted from dealing with something aversive, by something positively reinforcing - ie:

you could forget about running away from a tiger, because you've just spotted a pile of your favourite chocolate bars...

Then you would not survive long in the wild.

In fact the brain would stop you finding an appetitive reinforcer in any way reinforcing in that situation - hence in high stress situations many people find food has no flavour and they've little or no desire for it.

So we have to make sure dogs are below threshold when we seek to desensitize or counter condition - or it simply will not work.

Some people use flooding to try to fix problems, believing that everyone needs to 'face their fears' to overcome them. This doesn't work well even in a species who can choose to subject themselves to it, and understand how it works.

People often think flooding has worked, when the animal produces a frozen or subdued response - exhibits learned helplessness - this absence of the unwanted behaviour is deemed a positive result, but it will be temporary and the animal is almost certainly (we know, we can test for stress hormone levels!) experiencing extreme stress.

Even where counter conditioning and altering emotional responses has been successful, once anyone has been seriously frightened of something, a particular event or context, they are much more likely to be frightened of it again without some effort being put into avoiding unnecessary exposure to the trigger, and also efforts put into mitigating the stress caused by unavoidable exposure.

Again, that is a normal function of the brain. It's how we learn and stay safe.

BaroldFromEastenders · 19/03/2023 06:37

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 18/03/2023 23:39

So you're no longer a dog behaviourist........ because?

I guess because her “method” of teaching her dog not to be scared of something involved flooding it with the experience it found terrifying. Not a behaviourist I’d use or anyone whose advice I would take!

Rosula · 18/03/2023 23:47

@fenwoman123 , @WiddlinDiddlin , who is still a dog behaviourist, has spelt out chapter and verse on how you cannot.genuinely teach a dog not to be afraid of which they have ingrained fear. Given that her post is backed by explanation whereas yours is backed by one anecdote, it does sound rather more convincing.

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 18/03/2023 23:39

fenwoman123 · 18/03/2023 12:54

I used to be a behaviourist and wonder what steps you have taken to help the dog? Feeling this afraid is horrible for him and isn't necessary if only you would seek professional help. How much better to put in some effort and teach the dog that callers aren't dangerous and scary? You should be able to find a behaviourist near to you.
Here's an example. I once took in a Shih-tzu who was so terrified of loud bangs, she would try to dig through walls to escape. She'd tear her nails and blood was everywhere.
I live very rural so if the local farmers aren't out shooting pheasants, there are loud crow scarers, and of course, thunder. I wouldn't let any dog of mine suffer like this so, whenever there was shooting, or banging, or thunder, I'd go outside with the rest of the dogs and her and leap about like a lunatic, shouting "yippee yippee" throwing treats, bits of cheese, and anything they only got very rarely and was therefore of high value. I never fussed or petted her during these times. The rest of the dogs and I carried on with our 'party'.
By the end of 6 months , the dog got excited at the first gunshot or rumble of thunder and was with all the other dogs, at the back door, waiting for the party to start because they knew that a loud bang, was the starting signal.
It can be done, and it will help your dog, but be prepared that the behaviourist trains you more than the dog because humans are generally the ones who encouraged or started the behaviour in the first place.
I lost 'Dibs' in 2009. She was well into her teens and had lived a happy and fear free life. Here she is in her usual sleeping position, the little hussy.

So you're no longer a dog behaviourist........ because?

HugATwat · 18/03/2023 21:05

My dog is my absolute life. Before me she had an unimaginably awful life. When I adopted her, she was petrified of basically everything. I've worked hard, with and without a behaviourist.

I've rescued really nervous dogs before so have lots of experience.

We've (me, the dog, the behaviour lady I had some sessions with, friends) cracked basically all her fears. But she can't get past the WC so we manage it by getting out of his way and doing noisy playing while he's around.

I was heartbroken to leave her alone when the WC was potentially going to come. I was as quick as possible. But I wasn't 100% sure if he'd come or not because of the lack of communication. But I had no choice. I had to go out and there was no-one to sit with her. I still well up to think about it.

And, no, of course I haven't made this up. What a fucking boring story to make up!!

OP posts:
fenwoman123 · 18/03/2023 12:54

I used to be a behaviourist and wonder what steps you have taken to help the dog? Feeling this afraid is horrible for him and isn't necessary if only you would seek professional help. How much better to put in some effort and teach the dog that callers aren't dangerous and scary? You should be able to find a behaviourist near to you.
Here's an example. I once took in a Shih-tzu who was so terrified of loud bangs, she would try to dig through walls to escape. She'd tear her nails and blood was everywhere.
I live very rural so if the local farmers aren't out shooting pheasants, there are loud crow scarers, and of course, thunder. I wouldn't let any dog of mine suffer like this so, whenever there was shooting, or banging, or thunder, I'd go outside with the rest of the dogs and her and leap about like a lunatic, shouting "yippee yippee" throwing treats, bits of cheese, and anything they only got very rarely and was therefore of high value. I never fussed or petted her during these times. The rest of the dogs and I carried on with our 'party'.
By the end of 6 months , the dog got excited at the first gunshot or rumble of thunder and was with all the other dogs, at the back door, waiting for the party to start because they knew that a loud bang, was the starting signal.
It can be done, and it will help your dog, but be prepared that the behaviourist trains you more than the dog because humans are generally the ones who encouraged or started the behaviour in the first place.
I lost 'Dibs' in 2009. She was well into her teens and had lived a happy and fear free life. Here she is in her usual sleeping position, the little hussy.

Rosula · 18/03/2023 00:29

. But can you seriously say the OP hasn't made her dog's fear worse by herding it around the house to get away from the window cleaner?

She either takes the dog out, or simply takes him to a back room when the window cleaner is at the front and vice versa. Why on earth would any of that make the dog's fear worse? The point is that, that way, he doesn't hear and see the things that make him scared.

Rosula · 18/03/2023 00:21

BadNomad · 17/03/2023 18:56

Just because people have a different perspective and opinion on things, doesn't make them dense.

And people who love their dogs wouldn't put them in this position.

Having a different perspective doesn't make people dense. But it doesn't make them immune from being dense, either. It is certainly pretty dense to keep pushing the angle that a trader who relies on his phone to communicate with his customers has no need to check his phone for replies and should expect to get paid when he's done work he's explicitly been told not to do.

adriftindenofvipers · 17/03/2023 22:12

BadNomad · 17/03/2023 20:55

I'm heartless for thinking there was no need for a poor dog to be left to run loose around the house in fear? Or heartless because I'm not sympathising with the OP over her carpets? Well, I don't care about the carpets. I do care about a dog who was left to get into that state because her owner did nothing to prevent this other than send a text and make a phone call.

Heartless for your lack of consideration towards the poor dog and you know fine well what I meant.

BadNomad · 17/03/2023 20:55

adriftindenofvipers · 17/03/2023 20:39

@BadNomad - "There is a lot about this that doesn't make sense."

There sure is, a lot of it coming from posters like you.

Did you miss the bit where the dog is a rescue who had been poor treated by a previous owner, and this is the last vestige of the things that caused her fear? So heartless.

I'm heartless for thinking there was no need for a poor dog to be left to run loose around the house in fear? Or heartless because I'm not sympathising with the OP over her carpets? Well, I don't care about the carpets. I do care about a dog who was left to get into that state because her owner did nothing to prevent this other than send a text and make a phone call.

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 17/03/2023 20:41

adriftindenofvipers · 17/03/2023 20:39

@BadNomad - "There is a lot about this that doesn't make sense."

There sure is, a lot of it coming from posters like you.

Did you miss the bit where the dog is a rescue who had been poor treated by a previous owner, and this is the last vestige of the things that caused her fear? So heartless.

Spot on.

adriftindenofvipers · 17/03/2023 20:39

@BadNomad - "There is a lot about this that doesn't make sense."

There sure is, a lot of it coming from posters like you.

Did you miss the bit where the dog is a rescue who had been poor treated by a previous owner, and this is the last vestige of the things that caused her fear? So heartless.

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 17/03/2023 20:31

Crumpetdisappointment · 17/03/2023 20:14

so you say @DizzyLizzyKizzy
we have no idea, but it seems unlikely

What seems unlikely??

UndertheCedartree · 17/03/2023 20:21

JustRingJoeDuffy · 13/03/2023 11:45

Not at all the point - but do UK windows not open inwards for cleaning them?!

I was reading thinking, YANBU, this is like those car window cleaning guys that lurk at traffic lights and dash out to 'clean' your windscreen and expect you to pay even though you didnt want them to.
But surely the obvious thing with a nervy dog is clean your own - I do my own windows, its a pretty quick job.

But then read there was no way you could do your own outside ones. I'm in a third floor appt, its fine - they open in. Do yours open outwards - or is there another issue (apart from just not wanting to - which is totally fine!!!).

I have sash windows, they slide up!

BadNomad · 17/03/2023 20:17

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/03/2023 19:57

I am a dog behaviourist...

Teaching/training a dog to not be scared of a thing they're already scared of, when you're not present..

Isn't actually possible. We can't 'train' anyone not to be scared, we can only train them to suppress an outwardly fearful reaction, and we can only do that if we are there, and we shouldn't do it, because its really bad for anyone to be taught to suppress fear (and the way you'd do it would be to use aversives, again, unkind and not safe).

You can modify behaviour, using desensitization, classical conditioning etc, when you're present, to change the underlying emotional response to the trigger for the fearful reaction.

But you do need to be there to do that, and you need some predictability of the trigger, and then you need to do this often enough that the dogs emotional response changes.

There is no guarantee however that once you're not there, the dog won't be scared.

You could set up situations with ladders/pole etc and perhaps a camera system that delivers treats or a remote controlled treat delivery system (Treat n Train/Pet Tutor/Manners minder) so you could watch and pair reinforcer with sound, however:

Such devices are unreliable:
Such devices are very expensive:
Such devices tend to use small dry treats that are not all that reinforcing for most dogs.

They also don't work at a particularly long range so you'd still need to be right there.

During ALL this training you'd need to ensure the WC did not attend without you present, or they'd undo the work you'd done.

And... even if you did all that, you still have a dog who is likely to back-slide to square one or worse, should the window cleaner startle them, drop a ladder, etc, when you're really not there.

Of course you can't train a dog when you're not there. No one suggested that. But can you seriously say the OP hasn't made her dog's fear worse by herding it around the house to get away from the window cleaner? And that there is zero point in trying to associate the window cleaner's arrival with a positive treat?

Crumpetdisappointment · 17/03/2023 20:14

so you say @DizzyLizzyKizzy
we have no idea, but it seems unlikely

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 17/03/2023 20:03

Crumpetdisappointment · 17/03/2023 19:27

i should hope the op hasnt slandered him on a public forum

And slander is a false statement, which this is not!

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 17/03/2023 20:00

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/03/2023 19:57

I am a dog behaviourist...

Teaching/training a dog to not be scared of a thing they're already scared of, when you're not present..

Isn't actually possible. We can't 'train' anyone not to be scared, we can only train them to suppress an outwardly fearful reaction, and we can only do that if we are there, and we shouldn't do it, because its really bad for anyone to be taught to suppress fear (and the way you'd do it would be to use aversives, again, unkind and not safe).

You can modify behaviour, using desensitization, classical conditioning etc, when you're present, to change the underlying emotional response to the trigger for the fearful reaction.

But you do need to be there to do that, and you need some predictability of the trigger, and then you need to do this often enough that the dogs emotional response changes.

There is no guarantee however that once you're not there, the dog won't be scared.

You could set up situations with ladders/pole etc and perhaps a camera system that delivers treats or a remote controlled treat delivery system (Treat n Train/Pet Tutor/Manners minder) so you could watch and pair reinforcer with sound, however:

Such devices are unreliable:
Such devices are very expensive:
Such devices tend to use small dry treats that are not all that reinforcing for most dogs.

They also don't work at a particularly long range so you'd still need to be right there.

During ALL this training you'd need to ensure the WC did not attend without you present, or they'd undo the work you'd done.

And... even if you did all that, you still have a dog who is likely to back-slide to square one or worse, should the window cleaner startle them, drop a ladder, etc, when you're really not there.

👏 👏 👏

The voice of reason.

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/03/2023 19:57

I am a dog behaviourist...

Teaching/training a dog to not be scared of a thing they're already scared of, when you're not present..

Isn't actually possible. We can't 'train' anyone not to be scared, we can only train them to suppress an outwardly fearful reaction, and we can only do that if we are there, and we shouldn't do it, because its really bad for anyone to be taught to suppress fear (and the way you'd do it would be to use aversives, again, unkind and not safe).

You can modify behaviour, using desensitization, classical conditioning etc, when you're present, to change the underlying emotional response to the trigger for the fearful reaction.

But you do need to be there to do that, and you need some predictability of the trigger, and then you need to do this often enough that the dogs emotional response changes.

There is no guarantee however that once you're not there, the dog won't be scared.

You could set up situations with ladders/pole etc and perhaps a camera system that delivers treats or a remote controlled treat delivery system (Treat n Train/Pet Tutor/Manners minder) so you could watch and pair reinforcer with sound, however:

Such devices are unreliable:
Such devices are very expensive:
Such devices tend to use small dry treats that are not all that reinforcing for most dogs.

They also don't work at a particularly long range so you'd still need to be right there.

During ALL this training you'd need to ensure the WC did not attend without you present, or they'd undo the work you'd done.

And... even if you did all that, you still have a dog who is likely to back-slide to square one or worse, should the window cleaner startle them, drop a ladder, etc, when you're really not there.

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 17/03/2023 19:34

Crumpetdisappointment · 17/03/2023 19:27

i should hope the op hasnt slandered him on a public forum

I bloody hope she has!!

If people ask opinions, they deserve answers!

If everyone that had shit service kept quiet, then people would use them and have more shit service.

A "totally lacks communication skills, which ended with my dog being traumatised and me having to spend a lot of time and money to deal with this" would be true and honest.

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 17/03/2023 19:32

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 17/03/2023 19:31

@JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain because @BadNomad is a telepathic dog behaviourist!

But don't rely on contact with her, because she owns an "unreliable" mobile ...

😂😂😂