Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To NOT want DH and I to see our respective locations on Find my iPhone?

260 replies

Thisismenow2 · 13/03/2023 10:17

I have always been able to see DH’s location on Find my iPhone (although I rarely bother looking - only if he running late for dinner!) and he’s able to see mine. It’s not that I want to get up to anything untoward but I just think it would be better if we couldn’t see each other’s locations.

AIBU to think most partners DON’T share their locations?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Comefromaway · 14/03/2023 11:35

My husband drives long distances home. If I send a text he won't see it and certainly can't legally reply to it.

Polis · 14/03/2023 10:28

Why not send a text in the first place then if you need to know when partner is going to be home rather than assume the time based on his location?

I usually do. However, my commute is quite long and subject to all sorts of delays. If I’m not home when I say I am going to be, location sharing means that my husband can see at a glance whether I am stuck a mile from work or a mile from home. In theory anyway, as poor mobile coverage does mean that can take a while to update.

And the excuse that you only look occasionally is a poor one; if you have the option of looking whenever you want it's like being watched all the time because you never know when the other person is looking.

So what? I personally don’t have a problem with that. If I did, I wouldn’t share my location. It isn’t compulsory.

LaVitesse2022 · 14/03/2023 09:26

Polis · 13/03/2023 21:30

I would not like to be under the pressure to get home by a particular time and would much prefer to just send a quick text to say I’ll be home a bit later.

Having location sharing turned on doesn’t stop you sending a text. If I am going to be unusually late, or early, I often send a text to say so.

Why not send a text in the first place then if you need to know when partner is going to be home rather than assume the time based on his location?

That's what baffles me. Surely if you want info on your partners whereabouts, ETA you ask him. That's what true communication is about. Like others have said, I'd find it suffocating knowing that my partner could see where I am at any time and assume I'd be home by a specific time based on that. And the excuse that you only look occasionally is a poor one; if you have the option of looking whenever you want it's like being watched all the time because you never know when the other person is looking. It's not about having a need to hide my whereabouts - my life is not that interesting - it's the principle. If he wants to know where I am, when I'll be home, he asks me. And vice versa.

Dawny221 · 14/03/2023 08:17

we use it. I use it to keep and eye on where my daughter is. She’s 9 and has started walking to and from school on her own. I like to see when DP is on his way home too so I can time dinner.
I share my location with him in case I’m abducted during one of my countryside runs. 🤣

Phoebo · 14/03/2023 06:28

I can see it would be handy, but it's not necessary. It doesn't really bother me either way, but then it also seems intrusive but equally I have nothing to hide.

namechangeforthisbleep · 14/03/2023 06:25

We don't but I send mine a lot to him. He always knows where I am; I think that's fair given we have kids and I can't think of a single time I would need to hide my whereabouts

Polis · 13/03/2023 21:30

I would not like to be under the pressure to get home by a particular time and would much prefer to just send a quick text to say I’ll be home a bit later.

Having location sharing turned on doesn’t stop you sending a text. If I am going to be unusually late, or early, I often send a text to say so.

Lonelylonelylonely · 13/03/2023 21:09

Neither approach is wrong. If people are happy to share their location, that's fine, but if people don't want to, that's fine too. Where it goes wrong is if one partner expects it and the other feels obliged to go along with something they are not comfortable with.

My ex-h put a tracker on my car (without my knowledge or consent) and used that to get information about where I'd been when we were in the process of splitting up. Consequently I don't want anybody tracking me. He uses life 360 with the DC and when we split the DC asked me to put it on my phone. I won't do that because I don't know whether or not ex-h will get that information and abuse it.

If I need someone to know where I am I might share my location with them via WhatsApp or FB messenger temporarily, but no way will I put up with being tracked again.

VioletaDelValle · 13/03/2023 21:09

Isuppose · 13/03/2023 20:49

Well it is needy surely? People said they need to know where their DH is because they want to know what time to have dinner ready. Their DH can’t decide to pop into a shop, stop for a coffee with a friend because presumably their DW will be in a panic if he isn’t home by tine it usually takes him to get home or DW puts on said dinner and it’s spoiled because their DH took an extra thirty mins. I would not like to be under the pressure to get home by a particular time and would much prefer to just send a quick text to say I’ll be home a bit later. Just actual communicate I guess.

I’m trying g to figure out why I have such an issue with it because I really do. Growing up my father liked to know where we were and what time we’d be home. I found it nothing less than suffocating.

That's not necessarily needy, for some that's just a very practical use. It might not suit you or your relationship but it doesn't necessarily mean it's needy.
I'm not sure anyone has said they want to know their partner's location ALL of the time have they? It's just there for occasional use.

We started using life 360 when I started to travel internationally for work. Often I'm on my own travelling around India or China getting multiple flights and it's reassuring that DH can see where I am. We kept it but we don't monitor it constantly.
I don't see that as needy.

Elfandwellbeing · 13/03/2023 20:55

i had this on for a while, it caused no end of issues, everywhere I went I was phoned to buy this or that … when the checking up on me started and I deleted it.

Isuppose · 13/03/2023 20:49

Well it is needy surely? People said they need to know where their DH is because they want to know what time to have dinner ready. Their DH can’t decide to pop into a shop, stop for a coffee with a friend because presumably their DW will be in a panic if he isn’t home by tine it usually takes him to get home or DW puts on said dinner and it’s spoiled because their DH took an extra thirty mins. I would not like to be under the pressure to get home by a particular time and would much prefer to just send a quick text to say I’ll be home a bit later. Just actual communicate I guess.

I’m trying g to figure out why I have such an issue with it because I really do. Growing up my father liked to know where we were and what time we’d be home. I found it nothing less than suffocating.

VioletaDelValle · 13/03/2023 20:38

It isn’t about lying. It’s about not feeling the necessity, because it absolutely is not necessary, to share every single thing or every single place you go in your life or to know about every single thing and every single place your partner, your family, your in laws are doing. I’m not a needy person in that way so I will never see the need to do this. We become who we are as the years progress though and maybe when I’m aged and more dependent on others or in poor health this might come in useful if I forget how to answer my phone although when I’m at that stage, I expect I will also forget the phone itself too! .

If you are saying you're going to work and then do something else then that is lying. Your partner might not be bothered and the intentions mights not be malicious but it's not being honest is it?

Pretty much every one of your responses has included you trying to categorise people in a negative way .... this time it's 'needy'.

Most people who have said they share their location have offered up perfectly reasonable reasons, you might not understand those reasons from your own perspective but it doesn't mean you are better than them.

Thelnebriati · 13/03/2023 20:37

It obviously suits some people and not others. One problem would be if you're ok with it now, then the relationship deteriorates and you need to remove it, that could cause issues.
It suits me because if I have a fall when I'm, out, I can't always reach my stupid phone.

BigFatLiar · 13/03/2023 20:36

So if its on is it constantly telling you where they are or do you have to look at the app? He doesn't need to know I'm sitting in the chair across from him but I suspect if I go out on my motorbike if I'm late he may want to know I'm not in a ditch somewhere.

Ladyvgc · 13/03/2023 20:33

We only just recently realised we could share our locations with each other! It’s so much easier to see when he will be home rather than ring him. Or to see if he’s left work yet and can grab something from the shop for me! I doubt he’d ever bother tracking me but he knows I’m either at the school, home or Sainsburys 🤣

Isuppose · 13/03/2023 20:27

VioletaDelValle · 13/03/2023 18:42

I can identify with this and have done the same in the past. I also have my own bank account as well as a joint one.

I didn’t meet my DH until my mid thirties. By then I had travelled, had my own apt, my job, my savings. Perhaps if we had met when younger, I wouldn’t have gained that independence and would have been more comfortable with giving it up. Instead I cling onto what parts I can including my bank account and privacy. I wouldn’t dream of sharing my location any more than I would share my email passwords.

We met when I was in my mid 30's and DH was mid 40's and I'm fiercely independent- I travel alone for pleasure and work, i have my own hobbies and interests, my own bank account, savings and investments.

We share our location and I can't imagine lying to my DH about what I've done or where I've been.
I don't think age has anything to do with it.

It isn’t about lying. It’s about not feeling the necessity, because it absolutely is not necessary, to share every single thing or every single place you go in your life or to know about every single thing and every single place your partner, your family, your in laws are doing. I’m not a needy person in that way so I will never see the need to do this. We become who we are as the years progress though and maybe when I’m aged and more dependent on others or in poor health this might come in useful if I forget how to answer my phone although when I’m at that stage, I expect I will also forget the phone itself too! .

Oakbeam · 13/03/2023 19:59

I find it bizarre that so many people are OK with their partner knowing 24/7 where they are and not seeing an issue with it.

I dare say there are a fair few people who find it equally bizarre that you are seeing an issue with it.

MrsDrSpencerReid · 13/03/2023 19:56

Have always shared our locations, DH & DC (13 & 16)

None of us have any problem with anyone knowing where we are.

DH is diabetic so he likes knowing I can ‘see’ him incase he has a bad hypo.

DD was once in a situation where she felt unsafe and was able to send me a quick text to ask me to watch her until she got to her friends place.

Everyone’s relationship is different, this is what we do in ours. If it’s not what you do in yours that’s fine too 🤷🏼‍♀️

LaVitesse2022 · 13/03/2023 19:39

Absolutely not. I find it bizarre that so many people are OK with their partner knowing 24/7 where they are and not seeing an issue with it. It's an invasion of privacy, regardless of it being useful or not. If I need to know when he's going to be home I ask and vice versa.

gogohmm · 13/03/2023 19:04

I've set dp only last week so I can see where he is after a traffic incident. His car hands free is old without voice recognition so he wanted me to be able to see he's stuck and ring!

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 13/03/2023 18:47

God, we know of a guy that went through a stage of leaving the house for work, then sitting in his work van reading the paper until his wife left, going back home and doing nothing all day.

He got found out when his FIL popped in to pick something up (wife had asked him to, and was expecting the house to be empty) and found him napping on the sofa in his dressing gown 🤣

Quite strange all round

VioletaDelValle · 13/03/2023 18:42

I can identify with this and have done the same in the past. I also have my own bank account as well as a joint one.

I didn’t meet my DH until my mid thirties. By then I had travelled, had my own apt, my job, my savings. Perhaps if we had met when younger, I wouldn’t have gained that independence and would have been more comfortable with giving it up. Instead I cling onto what parts I can including my bank account and privacy. I wouldn’t dream of sharing my location any more than I would share my email passwords.

We met when I was in my mid 30's and DH was mid 40's and I'm fiercely independent- I travel alone for pleasure and work, i have my own hobbies and interests, my own bank account, savings and investments.

We share our location and I can't imagine lying to my DH about what I've done or where I've been.
I don't think age has anything to do with it.

Isuppose · 13/03/2023 18:26

lastapache · 13/03/2023 18:07

In fairness she’s right. I am lying to him. I’m okay with it. We’ve been married 13 years and it seems to be working out just fine. I can tell the difference between lying to get a days peace, and, say, pretending to go to work but meeting a male friend for lunch (or worse).

Personally, I like the innocent subterfuge of it. And not having to explain that, no, I don’t want him to go to the French language film with me, because that takes the good out of it. Perhaps it’s a red flag for some underlying issue that I am unaware of. Or maybe it just is what it is, a day off from work/mothering/partnering.

I can identify with this and have done the same in the past. I also have my own bank account as well as a joint one.

I didn’t meet my DH until my mid thirties. By then I had travelled, had my own apt, my job, my savings. Perhaps if we had met when younger, I wouldn’t have gained that independence and would have been more comfortable with giving it up. Instead I cling onto what parts I can including my bank account and privacy. I wouldn’t dream of sharing my location any more than I would share my email passwords.

Polis · 13/03/2023 18:14

We share locations. There’s no downsides for us that I can think of.

VioletaDelValle · 13/03/2023 18:12

lastapache · 13/03/2023 18:07

In fairness she’s right. I am lying to him. I’m okay with it. We’ve been married 13 years and it seems to be working out just fine. I can tell the difference between lying to get a days peace, and, say, pretending to go to work but meeting a male friend for lunch (or worse).

Personally, I like the innocent subterfuge of it. And not having to explain that, no, I don’t want him to go to the French language film with me, because that takes the good out of it. Perhaps it’s a red flag for some underlying issue that I am unaware of. Or maybe it just is what it is, a day off from work/mothering/partnering.

Hey, if it works for you then fine. If I told my DH i was doing something because wanted time to myself he wouldn't try to muscle in on that, he'd leave me to it!

If my DH lied to me about going to work I think I'd start to worry about what else he was lying about but we have a total honesty policy and we chat a LOT so there's no way I could hide what i'd been up to all day as I'd be desperate to tell him about my day!