Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this gym policy makes no sense

94 replies

redskylight · 13/03/2023 09:56

My gym has a policy that if you book a class/activity in advance and don't turn up you get charged a £4 no-show fee.

This makes sense for people on contracts - clearly they don't want people booking up loads of classes and then not coming, and depriving other people of the spaces.

However, I don't have a gym membership, I pay on a PAYG basis. I recently paid online to attend a class and then attended the class. It appears that my attendance wasn't registered because I've been told I have to pay the £4 no-show fee. However, I'm not sure of the validity of this even if I hadn't attended? I paid for a specific service (attending the class) and even if I hadn't turned up the gym still got my money for this. They surely then can't charge me more money for not using the service I'd paid for? If anything, this is great for the gym -if lots of people pay for classes on a PAYG basis and don't turn up, they are raking in money for nothing.

(I should also say, in case it matters, that the class was only about 1/4 full, so in no way did this affect anyone else).

OP posts:
ancientgran · 13/03/2023 11:25

ChristmasKraken · 13/03/2023 11:22

Yes, you might be asked to pay for the appointment itself even though you didn't turn up for it, but you wouldn't be asked to pay an extra fine on top of the cost of the appointment, which is what we're talking about here.

No I paid for the appointment and a fine so it is exactly what we are talking about here. I think it is the same for the dentist but I've never missed an appointment so not 100% sure.

drspouse · 13/03/2023 11:23

zurala · 13/03/2023 10:16

My gym does a three strikes policy. Don't she for three classes in a set period and you can't book any for a certain period. I think that's better.

I go to one class at one gym regularly and another at a second gym so I'm PAYG and one of them does this - I think this is in addition to the no refund for PAYG if you don't show up.

Once I got stuck in traffic and couldn't find the gym number to call while driving, and they took me off the three strikes list. Once I did go but didn't get registered on entry and ditto once I told them. It expires anyway so the non-registration was before Christmas, then I was ill and then didn't go back for a month and they'd expired that issue anway.

ChristmasKraken · 13/03/2023 11:22

ancientgran · 13/03/2023 11:02

Happens to me if I book a hygienist appointment at dentist's and then don't turn up. Happened to me once when I had a migraine and wouldn't have been safe driving. You have to book up well in advance but you can cancel with 24 hrs notice.

Yes, you might be asked to pay for the appointment itself even though you didn't turn up for it, but you wouldn't be asked to pay an extra fine on top of the cost of the appointment, which is what we're talking about here.

pontipinemum · 13/03/2023 11:03

I think it is a very strange policy! I agree with the fine for gym members to stop them booking lots of classes and only showing up to some of them since the cost of the class is inc in their membership fee anyway.

I'm glad they are refunding you the fine (as they should) I don't think I'd press them on their policy but it is a weird one.

ArcticSkewer · 13/03/2023 11:03

It's a stupid policy.
Imagine if the rest of the country ran that way.

Pay for train ticket then pay a fine if you miss the train, pay for your takeaway then pay a fine if you forget to collect it, pay for your parking then pay a fine if you get stuck in traffic on the way there. The non attendance and waste if money is punishment enough!

Ridiculous.
And yes, just pay on the door in future

museumum · 13/03/2023 11:03

I wouldn't think of it as a charge, it's more a fine - to discourage unwanted behaviour. My dh often can't get a place and ends up on the waiting list, and then still doesn't get in. He used to assume it was because the class was jam-packed full. Fair enough.
But when he did get a place he noticed that there are maybe 5/6 empty mats. People just didn't bother cancelling. It's very frustrating that people are missing out because others can't be bothered cancelling. A fine for no-shows is an attempt to stop this.

ancientgran · 13/03/2023 11:02

redskylight · 13/03/2023 10:02

Is the policy fine? I can't think of any other example, where I would pay for something, and then had to pay even more for not using it.

For example, if I booked a party at a soft play centre, paid for it and then didn't turn up, it would be very odd if they'd then expected me to pay even more money for it?

Happens to me if I book a hygienist appointment at dentist's and then don't turn up. Happened to me once when I had a migraine and wouldn't have been safe driving. You have to book up well in advance but you can cancel with 24 hrs notice.

Pootles34 · 13/03/2023 10:59

Its a bit daft if the class isn't full. Ours doesn't charge, but they have a cancellation policy whereby is you cancel 3 times then you get in the 'sin bin' and can't book in advance for 1 week. The cancellation only counts if the class was full.

spelunky · 13/03/2023 10:56

It probably is an oversight by the gym.

They obviously want to make sure they don't lose money through people not attending classes, but they have not been very intelligent in the way they have implemented it.

You need to point out their error.

redskylight · 13/03/2023 10:49

Leftbutcameback · 13/03/2023 10:43

So @redskylight - how late can you cancel with no penalty? Surely if it’s to allow others to attend you could cancel right up to start time, maybe lose your fee, but not get the penalty. Is it literally only if you don’t tell them you’re not coming?

My local council gym lets you cancel quite late for PAYG, and you get the money as a credit in your account, which seems really reasonable.

You can cancel up to 2 hours before the class.
Ironically I only booked this one about 50 minutes before the class as I like to be sure that nothing last minute will come up to stop me attending :)

The gym has now agreed to remove the charge, but not commented on my comments on their overall policy.

OP posts:
Amoreena · 13/03/2023 10:43

redskylight · 13/03/2023 10:02

Is the policy fine? I can't think of any other example, where I would pay for something, and then had to pay even more for not using it.

For example, if I booked a party at a soft play centre, paid for it and then didn't turn up, it would be very odd if they'd then expected me to pay even more money for it?

Yes you're right. It's fine for them to fine people on a contract who don't pay extra for the class for blocking a space they don't use, but makes less sense to charge people twice for the same space

Leftbutcameback · 13/03/2023 10:43

So @redskylight - how late can you cancel with no penalty? Surely if it’s to allow others to attend you could cancel right up to start time, maybe lose your fee, but not get the penalty. Is it literally only if you don’t tell them you’re not coming?

My local council gym lets you cancel quite late for PAYG, and you get the money as a credit in your account, which seems really reasonable.

budgiegirl · 13/03/2023 10:41

But I suppose the logic is the same- if people cancel their contract because there's never any availability for classes and they're only half full it's a good business decision to impose a penalty on no shows

This. I know it sounds unfair on the face of it, but when you consider the longer term repercussions to the gym, it perhaps starts to make sense. I appreciate that this particular class is never full, but it's probably easier and fairer to just have a blanket policy that applies to all gym users (both members and non-members) - it reduces the risk of any complaints of discrimination or unfairness.

BellePeppa · 13/03/2023 10:40

It seems very strange to me. As long as you’ve paid the fee to attend what does it matter to them that you didn’t? You wouldn’t get charged for not going to the cinema or if you’d booked and paid for a train seat but didn’t travel etc?

PARunnerGirl · 13/03/2023 10:39

It could be an admin oversight but if it’s not, I kind of see what they might be trying to do, in terms of incentivising people to show up. Yes they’ve got your cash, but if you don’t show you block someone else from attending should the class be full.

The other (and probably fairer) way to do this is through a three-strikes-and-you’re-out type of approach someone else has mentioned, where if you do pay and don’t show up two/ three times in a month, they block your booking privileges for a month.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/03/2023 10:39

RudsyFarmer · 13/03/2023 10:27

Yes the PAYG customer has already paid for each and every class so her attendance is neither here nor there, she’s paid up! The membership person might have block booked 14 classes. but has paid a monthly charge covering gym, swimming and classes. Just those classes alone might be more than the monthly fee. It’s clearly not the same. .

I totally agree with this post and you op.

If you pay to block book and due to unexpected circumstances, you have to cancel all classes, you are unlikely to get your money back. If you don’t cancel and are just a no show, they’ll charge you double! A member otoh can block book and cancel all classes, then block book another set of classes with no penalty.

TheOverlord · 13/03/2023 10:33

RudsyFarmer · 13/03/2023 10:27

Yes the PAYG customer has already paid for each and every class so her attendance is neither here nor there, she’s paid up! The membership person might have block booked 14 classes. but has paid a monthly charge covering gym, swimming and classes. Just those classes alone might be more than the monthly fee. It’s clearly not the same. .

Re-read what I said and you’ll see the many reasons that I listed as to why it’s bad for PAYG members to do that. It’s already been stated so I’m not sure why you’re now feigning ignorance and saying “her attendance is neither here nor there”.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 10:30

Is the policy fine? I can't think of any other example, where I would pay for something, and then had to pay even more for not using it.

Yes, that's totally unreasonable. That's like paying for a flight, not showing up and being charged £100 for missing the plane.

RudsyFarmer · 13/03/2023 10:27

TheOverlord · 13/03/2023 10:22

PAYG customers have just as much ability to block book. They just have to pay per class to do so.

Yes the PAYG customer has already paid for each and every class so her attendance is neither here nor there, she’s paid up! The membership person might have block booked 14 classes. but has paid a monthly charge covering gym, swimming and classes. Just those classes alone might be more than the monthly fee. It’s clearly not the same. .

redskylight · 13/03/2023 10:24

cstaff · 13/03/2023 10:10

So what you are saying OP is that you pay at the time you book so you should be covered and then if you don't show up they charge you a second time. Am I reading this right. Is so that is insane - they can't charge you twice for the same class whether you attend or not.

yes, exactly that.

OP posts:
TheOverlord · 13/03/2023 10:22

RudsyFarmer · 13/03/2023 10:19

I’m not sure I agree with that.

The reason those with memberships are treated differently or should be treated differently are that most memberships have the ability to prebook unlimited classes. Most gyms I’ve attended have allowed you to book a week ahead.

So you’re going to have many people block booking classes at least a week ahead without having to pay for each class. I completely agree that a ‘fine’ should be implemented in the case of a no show to make sure you don’t get persistent offenders preventing PAYG people like OP being able to access the class.

PAYG customers have just as much ability to block book. They just have to pay per class to do so.

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 13/03/2023 10:20

It's an admin oversight that you can clear up quickly. The policy seems a bit harsh, but the company obviously have their reasons. As others said its probably to stop members wasting places by block booking and not turning up. As long as it was stated in the contract when you joined or renewed, then its fair.

redskylight · 13/03/2023 10:20

Thanks all - to clarify, I've already raised and it's being "looked into".

I understand the need for a blanket policy, but this is particularly odd in that I go to the same class every week, and it's never full (or even half full - actually I keep waiting for them to decide to cancel it due to lack of numbers!).

The policy has been there for a while, but I assumed it only applied to people with memberships. And clearly I've never fallen foul of it before!

In my case, depending on what the gym comes back with, I'm thinking I'm going to start just paying on the door as I know there is no issue with getting a space, and I don't want the hassle of this potentially happening again.

I don't suppose the gym charge people with membership any more if they haven't been to the gym at all over a month which would seem to be the analagous case for those with gym memberships?

OP posts:
RudsyFarmer · 13/03/2023 10:19

TheOverlord · 13/03/2023 10:14

They surely then can't charge me more money for not using the service I'd paid for?

Of course they can. Why do you think you’re any different from those with a membership? They’re also paying, you know.

They don’t want people booking classes and not turning up to them. They don’t want members booking classes and not turning up to them. They don’t want non-members booking classes and not turning up. It means that people miss out on attending and, if classes are always full then they’ll go to other gyms. It means that classes are less enjoyable for the people who do attend. It makes it hard for the gym to establish which classes are actually popular and to decide which classes to increase or decrease in frequency or capacity. That’s all the case whether you’re a member or not.

You’re not an exception to the rule and there’s no reason why you should be an exception to the rule. Obviously, you haven’t broken the rule this time so you shouldn’t have to pay but the rule itself should apply to you as much as anyone else.

I’m not sure I agree with that.

The reason those with memberships are treated differently or should be treated differently are that most memberships have the ability to prebook unlimited classes. Most gyms I’ve attended have allowed you to book a week ahead.

So you’re going to have many people block booking classes at least a week ahead without having to pay for each class. I completely agree that a ‘fine’ should be implemented in the case of a no show to make sure you don’t get persistent offenders preventing PAYG people like OP being able to access the class.

zurala · 13/03/2023 10:16

My gym does a three strikes policy. Don't she for three classes in a set period and you can't book any for a certain period. I think that's better.