Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of being skint?

69 replies

SnappyTheCrocodile · 13/03/2023 09:15

DH and I make fairly decent money. Nothing to write home about but we’re not on the breadline either. We bring in about £65000pa pre-tax (I work pt, DH runs a business). I drive a 13 year old hatchback on its last legs. DH has a work van that is similarly iffy. We have a lovely but very tiny house with a mortgage just over £1000pm. Two DCs in nursery (eldest gets 30 hours funding so doesn’t cost too much). We have pets that don’t cost a great deal. We have potentially expensive hobbies but do them ‘on the cheap’ (DH’s business is in a related area so this helps). We don’t have massive debts - a couple of thousand in overdrafts/credit cards.

Why do we struggle so much?! I don’t get paid for ten days and I’m counting change to buy sugar!

We don’t have masses of subscription services (no Netflix, or Disney, or Spotify anymore), we don’t eat out, we don’t buy clothes or anything. I don’t understand what we are doing wrong.

OP posts:
1AngelicFruitCake · 13/03/2023 22:09

You sound quite dismissive of your debt and I wonder what your approach is with money?

uncomfortablydumb53 · 13/03/2023 14:29

Can you transfer your credit card debt to a 0% interest card to pay it down?

CatOnTheChair · 13/03/2023 12:24

You've got 2 kids with a fairly small age gap. Things will sort themselves out as nursery fees drop.
Our income has sat around your level (between 55 and 70) for the past 3 years, and without childcare fees we are comfortable right now. Hold on in there.

monsterradeliciosa · 13/03/2023 11:56

Use a spreadsheet with a running balance and plot income/outgoings on this to show where you will be in weeks' or months' time.

I use this and it's invaluable otherwise I'd find myself suddenly out of money.

I bring in £1,680/month for me and my child and two cats.

We are often skint but only for a few days as I have multiple paydays due to being self-employed.

Our rent is extremely low though, less than half yours. And I think a car takes a lot of money, hence why I've never got one. We probably spend about £40/month on taxis with practically zero public transport costs as right now I don't do much outside the local area.

Just put every single thing on a spreadsheet. I can't imagine being in the dark about my finances, and it's usually people with a high income who are. I'm sure your situation is better than mine but it's really easily solved.

3WildOnes · 13/03/2023 11:56

Can you list your income and outgoing?

latetothefisting · 13/03/2023 11:55

You're not skint because you have things that are luxuries that you could cut back on if you desperately needed to save money.

Also it depends who you are comparing yourself against - you earn roughly the average salary but if your comparing yourself against a colleague who doesn't have kids or pets, although those costs are comparatively low (for you, I understand nursery fees can be extortionate for others) they all add up. Even if pet food is "only" a fiver a week and insurance "only" 70quid a year that's over £300 a year that someone without pets isn't paying, so (everything else hypothetically being similar) they might not be worrying about paying for groceries at the end of the month, and might be able to afford a meal out or new clothes now and again.

Even if you are "only" paying £100 a month for nursery that's £1200 more a year than colleague who isn't paying for childcare- that's not just the difference between struggling to buy sugar at the end of the month, that's a holiday!

I'm not suggesting giving up your pets or hobbies just saying small things add up and can make the difference between "managing OK with a few small treats" and "barely getting by". Neither of which are the same as "skint" which is struggling to pay for essentials even after cutting all luxuries.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 13/03/2023 11:46

We are on a bit more than you, combined £68k , our mortgage is low because we have moved up the ladder by renovating and moving up. We live very frugally though, only a handful of nights out a year, no takeaways but we do host a fair bit at our home. No masses of clothes, and always buy on the sales. Make a spreadsheet of your expenses and see where you can cut back to have some savings...

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:43

Our household income is half of yours. But we can only afford to run one car and use public transport as needed. We have also worked hard to never get into debt.

Dixiechickonhols · 13/03/2023 11:39

I suspect it will be the mortgage plus childcare. What is that? If it’s say £2500 out of net a month for those you’ll not have much disposable income even on a decent income.

TheGoogleMum · 13/03/2023 11:35

It'll be the 2 kids in nursery + mortgage I expect.
Our combined income is a little less (maybe just under 60k) but we have 1 child in nursery (2nd on the way but 1st will be in school by the time 2nd starts nursery) and our mortgage is less - though we've had to do it over a long term to keep the costs down so over 30 years left!
We have just 1 car between us and don't have much money for hobbies.
We manage but we don't really have money for holidays and only really buy big ticket items by paying monthly for them for a while, always feels like money is a bit tight.

TheNinny · 13/03/2023 11:31

We are on the same, prob just a bit more now with some recent pay rises but my first thought was that your mortgage seems quite high for a small property. This last year with the energy hikes was the first time I would say we have felt stretched and I felt nervous
financially, on the same amount.

We live in a cheap, rural area though and mortgage is around £450 for a 3 bed semi. Most it has been thought was £570 in a house bought in 2014 ( it was a tired ex council property so didn’t pay huge for it). Also childcare, we only have 1 child and just recently started getting the free hours which has made a huge difference and such a relief. Switching to term time only nursery soon so cost will drop further. While we were paying full fees it was quite tight sometimes, though I’d never say struggling and we could still afford 2 newish cars (within 5 yrs), holiday and some modest savings.

I think with having to pay childcare for two children and the mortgage would be the main thing. Hopefully childcare will come down in the not too distant future for you. I also monitor my finances religiously (perhaps a bit too much ) and make an effort not to fritter £30 away every week on shite (not saying you do but I know I will if I let me). We have had family help with regard to childcare which may be our saving grace as we didn’t have to pay for full time. So I guess it depends on the specifics. Had I had to pay full time I would have forgone holidays until free hours/starting school. I don’t really do clothes either. I mean I buy something new if I need it but nothing designer etc.

We also have a log burner and dramatically reduced our electric use so could keep the DD a lot lower than the recommended.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 13/03/2023 11:29

It's miserable working 40 hours a week in a career you've spent years building to have nothing to enjoy after you've paid your bills.

It is indeed, but plenty of people include as part of their bills things that others consider a treat. Coffee being one. It used to be and still is for some that a coffee stop was a rare treat on a special shopping trip, such as a day Xmas shopping or out buying a new outfit or something. Nowadays its often an extension of the supermarket trip. The supermarket I work in has both a Greggs and a Maccys inside. Both very well used. Considering there is a time limit in the car park, people are not spending huge amounts of time to justify needing to eat and drink but they do it anyway. Which is fine but the problem is people don't class it as a treat they class it as part of their shopping and feel hard done by if they don't get another treat.

Not saying this is the case for OP but most people have to make certain choices and the only way to do that is write down exactly what you spend and what is essential and non essential then make your decision as to what non essential you could cut.

alwayscheery · 13/03/2023 11:28

BarbaraofSeville · 13/03/2023 09:44

The information in your OP doesn't tie up with running out of money mid month, so my guess would be that you're not accounting for all your annual/irregular essentials (how do you pay for things like Christmas, insurance, car repairs/servicing/MOT etc, white goods replacement, dentist/opticians/hair cuts etc etc) or you spend more than you think on non essentials like lunches, beauty treatments, days out.

It's all very well people saying how shit it is and blaming the government, but for middle income people who have enough money on paper, you can make a huge difference to how far your money goes by managing it well and making the effort to cut costs where possible.

You need to have a thorough review of your budget and spending to see where your money is going and identify areas where you can cut back - TV, mobiles, broadband are places where you can often get a deal. Also for the credit cards (and any overdrafts) can you switch to a 0% deal so you don't pay any interest while you pay it off).

Have a look at:

www.moneysavingexpert.com/family/money-help/

Yes, This.

I read an article "think like a millionaire"
and it said similar.

Someone said the comment made them sad , does it make them sad if we called it millionaire mentality?

TheWayTheLightFalls · 13/03/2023 11:19

You haven't really given enough detail to advise but my initial suggestion would be to temporarily cut back on the hobby and throw that money at the credit cards/loans so that burden eases sooner; up your working hours if you can around the DC, to the same end; and look in detail at your (food especially) spending - have one or two cheaper meals a week and actively put that saved money towards debt.

Massive caveat because of gaps in info of course.

polkadotdinosaur · 13/03/2023 11:18

YANBU, at all. It’s really crap and difficult at the moment. Things cost so much! Is there any way you’re able to move to a cheaper area? Appreciate not always a possibility for most.

Jazz12 · 13/03/2023 11:14

Crumpetdisappointment · 13/03/2023 10:55

whatever your earnings you either need to earn more or spend less.

THIS 🏆

Jazz12 · 13/03/2023 11:13

And did you say couple of thousands on credit cards!??

Jazz12 · 13/03/2023 11:12

Small bits add up.
Pets cost money. Vet bills, food, insurance, accessories - all add up!

Expensive hobbies, pets etc cost WAY more than Netflix subscription 😂

you need to put things on paper to see where your money is going.

PositiveLife · 13/03/2023 11:11

Apologies @BarbaraofSeville I didn't read your post as you intended it. Flowers

Wakeywake · 13/03/2023 11:02

Mortgage 1000, nursery 1000, household bills at least 600, that leaves you with what, about 1000? Car insurance, pet insurance, fuel, phones, food, nappies, dentist, hobbies + servicing your debt. Of course you're skint.

Sundaefraise · 13/03/2023 10:57

Crumpetdisappointment · 13/03/2023 09:26

you are not really skint though
it is subjective

stop your hobbies
eat cheaper

I think its probably childcare. Will make a huge difference when not paying this. If you work say 3 days and pay £45 a day for nursery then that's over £500 a month right there.

Crumpetdisappointment · 13/03/2023 10:55

whatever your earnings you either need to earn more or spend less.

Overthebow · 13/03/2023 10:53

65k joint fund become is not huge for living in an expensive area. Your mortgage is big for a tiny house (so I’ve assumed expensive area), and your childcare costs are high. You’ll be better off once your second DC gets the free hours, but if you want more money before then have you considered going full time?

BarbaraofSeville · 13/03/2023 10:53

PositiveLife · 13/03/2023 10:23

Posts like this make me really sad.

Of course I can blame the government. And whilst I could cut back on some things, that too has a huge knock on effect. If all of us "with enough money on paper" cut back on every 'treat' or non-essential, what happens to all those businesses and the people working for them?

It's miserable working 40 hours a week in a career you've spent years building to have nothing to enjoy after you've paid your bills.

But I', not talking about 'cutting back on treats' or 'having nothing to enjoy', far from it.

The OP mentions credit card debt and an overdraft. If she's paying interest on it, she could be paying tens of pounds a month needlessly which can be saved by transferring to a 0% deal.

There are people who buy the same things from the same supermarket every week without considering a different supermarket or buying only when on offer. Why buy one tin of soup every week when you could buy a 4 pack every month and save a good percentage? Expand that to all your groceries and you can easily save 20/30% without changing what you buy.

A lot of people pay £40+ pm for their mobile phone, get a new one every 2 years and leave the old one in a drawer. So why not go SIM only, keep your old phone, and save at least half the cost?

Likewise insurance, broadband, TV etc. If you never shop around you're likely to be paying 50/100%+ more than you need to.

Doing all that can free up a significant sum each month, to give you more money to spend on treats, or free up money to save for bigger purchases or for an emergency fund so you can pay things like insurance in one go, or get the car repaired without worrying about it and has little or no effect on what essentials you have, only reduces what you pay for them.

Comedycook · 13/03/2023 10:49

How much is your childcare bill? You said you have two DC in nursery but only the eldest gets free hours? Are they in nursery full time.

Honestly I am not surprised you're skint. 65k might seem like a lot but it's not really. I think your mortgage is highish. Running two cars with tax, insurance, petrol adds up . Utility bills. Food. Life is really expensive.

Wages in this country are an absolute disgrace. Hope things improve for you soon.