Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are junior docs really only on £14.09 per hour?

366 replies

yawningmorning · 13/03/2023 06:54

That is so low.

I've seen the headline that you can earn more per hour working in pret.

No wonder they are striking.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
bengalcat · 13/03/2023 13:27

As I was driving past the Chelsea and Westminster picket line today majority of cars honked their horns in support

FrodisCapering · 13/03/2023 13:22

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Carriemac · 13/03/2023 13:22

I fullly support the junior doctors . All lot of the NHS current problems are are due to staff shortages and they will get worse as junior doctors vote with h their feet and leave , and senior ones stop working as the ridiculous pension rules cost them to stay on even if they want to

AngeloMysterioso · 13/03/2023 13:21

2023ttc · 13/03/2023 11:13

@AngeloMysterioso I'm not sure when you went to uni.

Most (UK) doctors today paid 9k for tuition and probably similar accomodation/living expenses per year. Thats at least 15-18k/year depending where in the UK. Multiplied by 5-7 years and thats £75,000-126,000.

Especially when compared to peers who didnt achieve as high grades etc, who've enjoyed stability and becoming a homeowner and probably earning similar to that of a junior doctor while more able to hold down a relationship/start a family etc. This is before we even talk about the kind of stress and responsibilities at work at often quite young ages. It is a lot.

The £9k tuition fees started in 2012, so the first cohort of doctors who paid those fees will have graduated and started working less than 6 years ago. I don’t think that applies to most Uk doctors working today.

Also, plenty of people achieve very high grades who go on to not become doctors.

it’s not like you can say none of them went into this career with their eyes open… nobody forces them!

FarmGirl78 · 13/03/2023 13:20

My first job in the NHS, as a Biomedical Scientist with a BSc Hons in Biomedical Sciences was LESS than I'd have got working a supermarket at the time. It was also below minimum wage, which payroll only realised when I complained. My pay went up from £7,200 to £9,100 from memory so was still a pittance. This was "only" 24 years ago.

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 13/03/2023 13:20

I have little sympathy for them and don’t think many members of the public will have sympathy either. They have had below inflation pay rises for the past 10 years? So what. So have the vast majority of the working public! They have a job for life. The whole ‘if we don’t pay them more then they’ll move abroad’ is about as ethical as tax-dodging non-doms. We invest so much money in training doctors - £250k per doctor - and there are 15 applicants for every place at medical school. We need to start requiring UK medical students agree to the equivalent of 20 years of NHS service before giving them a place.

Salverus · 13/03/2023 13:13

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

This thread isn't about teachers (for once).

I'm sure there are some very highly qualified teachers. It is also possible to become a teacher with the bare minimum of qualifications. That isn't the case with doctors.

FrodisCapering · 13/03/2023 13:10

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

mathsgirl12 · 13/03/2023 13:00

SamanthaCaine · 13/03/2023 12:33

I completely sympathise with the horrendous working conditions that your management, union and government can't seem to solve. It really is a disgrace and noone should have to put up with it.

But taking over 20 years to arrive at six figures is not a complaint that anyone is going to take seriously. Like many experience based fields, there's no quick route to a decent salary as you need to gain the knowledge and experience. But six figures is a very good salary, especially when you factor in the pension etc.

I'm not saying it is. It's on the back of a quote where someone said you quickly reach 6 figures. I don't think 20 plus years is quick. I'd personally, like to have conditions improved. More time with family etc. I honestly wouldn't do the job again and having seen my working life, none of my children wish to become doctors. When I started, there was lots of children of doctors in my year. The personal sacrifice has been too big for the renumeration. The contempt some posters have for HCPs is awful too. Pay erosion is real regardless of an individuals thoughts about it and if you want to continue to recruit bright, capable individuals, pay will need to keep up with fellow professionals. It was relatively unheard of for juniors to leave the profession after the registration year. It's now common. If we want a good quality healthcare system then, we cannot allow that to happen.

SamanthaCaine · 13/03/2023 12:33

mathsgirl12 · 13/03/2023 11:06

I think you're totally missing the point. I said well over 20 years and I have less than 20 years before I retire anyway. In reality with working conditions and morale in the profession, I'll be lucky to make another 5 years.

I completely sympathise with the horrendous working conditions that your management, union and government can't seem to solve. It really is a disgrace and noone should have to put up with it.

But taking over 20 years to arrive at six figures is not a complaint that anyone is going to take seriously. Like many experience based fields, there's no quick route to a decent salary as you need to gain the knowledge and experience. But six figures is a very good salary, especially when you factor in the pension etc.

Sockloon · 13/03/2023 12:29

burblish · 13/03/2023 11:52

Doctors have to make life or death decisions. If they make a mistake, a person can die. The level of responsibility they bear is extraordinary. This isn’t just about who works more hours, or harder. People in other professions may put in even more hours than a doctor, of gruelling physical labour. But the skill and knowledge that a doctor has to employ, and the potential consequences of them making a mistake while doing so, just don’t compare with any other profession.

There is so much reverse snobbery on this thread, with people simply refusing to acknowledge that there are genuine reasons doctors are (or should be!) highly valued. It isn’t about who might have done better in their A-levels or works more than 40 hours a week - it’s about the levels of skill and responsibility the job actually entails.

I'm afraid you knowledge is pretty limited if you believe that doctors are the only ones with these types of decisions and consequences. 🙄

Before the inevitable benign quoting of my post do your own research.

KnittedCardi · 13/03/2023 12:25

Hesperatum · 13/03/2023 09:45

I fully support the Junior Doctors. The title Junior is misleading - these are all doctors before consultant level. The public forget that on top of huge student loans they have to pay for registration and exams. Working conditions are generally poor. Compare this with the very cushioned position the MPs enjoy whilst spouting untruths about the NHS and its employees.

Agreed. However the OP's title and point only applies to newly qualified. As a "junior" progresses so does their pay.

SamanthaCaine · 13/03/2023 12:24

Sirzy · 13/03/2023 11:52

But we need medicine to be open to everyone not just the elite who have parents who can pay.

But we do. A friend of mine has recently become a junior doctor, having been a nurse for years. She's come from a very modest background and studied incredibly hard. This route is open to all I believe.

I'm sure someone will come along and tell me she's not a real junior doctor and that the scheme is rubbish though.

Workerbeep · 13/03/2023 12:10

In 2008 the BMA voted to limit the number of medical students.

randomsabreuse · 13/03/2023 11:57

Do we really want becoming a doctor to be limited to children of the well off? Just because doctors were well off, doesn't mean they are now.

I know doctors coming up to retirement (but younger than my parents) who live in massive country houses, my own generation have managed to stretch to a new build house on a reasonable estate with a not too horrid commute but definitely won't have the £££ to help their kids avoid uni fees (or send kids private like our parents did). This seems to be true to for all non city professionals - current salaries don't cover anywhere near as much as they used to and the commuting costs have increased as parking used to be free - fuel costs are massively more and public transport is more expensive while services have been cut...

burblish · 13/03/2023 11:52

Doctors have to make life or death decisions. If they make a mistake, a person can die. The level of responsibility they bear is extraordinary. This isn’t just about who works more hours, or harder. People in other professions may put in even more hours than a doctor, of gruelling physical labour. But the skill and knowledge that a doctor has to employ, and the potential consequences of them making a mistake while doing so, just don’t compare with any other profession.

There is so much reverse snobbery on this thread, with people simply refusing to acknowledge that there are genuine reasons doctors are (or should be!) highly valued. It isn’t about who might have done better in their A-levels or works more than 40 hours a week - it’s about the levels of skill and responsibility the job actually entails.

Sirzy · 13/03/2023 11:52

AngeloMysterioso · 13/03/2023 11:05

Not all doctors have a shitload of student debt to pay… I know several who, being the children of wealthy doctors themselves, didn’t need a student or tuition fee loan as it was covered by their trust funds. And within five years of graduating (so whilst still junior doctors) their salaries were in the mid £60k region. That was the norm among many of the medics I went to uni with.

But we need medicine to be open to everyone not just the elite who have parents who can pay.

Househare · 13/03/2023 11:13

AngeloMysterioso · 13/03/2023 11:05

Not all doctors have a shitload of student debt to pay… I know several who, being the children of wealthy doctors themselves, didn’t need a student or tuition fee loan as it was covered by their trust funds. And within five years of graduating (so whilst still junior doctors) their salaries were in the mid £60k region. That was the norm among many of the medics I went to uni with.

So you know several who don't have student debt. What does that tell us about junior doctors as a whole? NOTHING

2023ttc · 13/03/2023 11:13

@AngeloMysterioso I'm not sure when you went to uni.

Most (UK) doctors today paid 9k for tuition and probably similar accomodation/living expenses per year. Thats at least 15-18k/year depending where in the UK. Multiplied by 5-7 years and thats £75,000-126,000.

Especially when compared to peers who didnt achieve as high grades etc, who've enjoyed stability and becoming a homeowner and probably earning similar to that of a junior doctor while more able to hold down a relationship/start a family etc. This is before we even talk about the kind of stress and responsibilities at work at often quite young ages. It is a lot.

wiffin · 13/03/2023 11:08

What a vile thread.

If your salary had been eroded by 35% or so over 15 years (give or take) I bet you would strike if you could.

At the end of the day, doesn't matter how much I think a Dr should be paid. The point is they can get paid double for half the work elsewhere. We have a Dr shortage because of rising demand and people voting with their feet.

Treat people like shit they will leave.

mathsgirl12 · 13/03/2023 11:06

Tinner01 · 13/03/2023 10:46

So you’re what in your 40s? So will be earning six figures for another 20 years? You’ll be fine

I think you're totally missing the point. I said well over 20 years and I have less than 20 years before I retire anyway. In reality with working conditions and morale in the profession, I'll be lucky to make another 5 years.

AngeloMysterioso · 13/03/2023 11:05

Not all doctors have a shitload of student debt to pay… I know several who, being the children of wealthy doctors themselves, didn’t need a student or tuition fee loan as it was covered by their trust funds. And within five years of graduating (so whilst still junior doctors) their salaries were in the mid £60k region. That was the norm among many of the medics I went to uni with.

2023ttc · 13/03/2023 11:04

@umpaumpajumps Not sure what that is supposed to mean.

I have experience working in healthcare but also in a different sector that involves travelling abroad and therefore have experience of healthcare in other countries.

I have thankfully never needed emergency care but expect, like most, that I probably will at some point in my lifetime. I know where I would prefer to for example, have a heart attack. There have been reports of waiting over 24 hours for an ambulance for a heart attack in the UK, and dying while waiting. It is absolutely not the fault of the paramedic/ambulance service nor the burnt out on A&E doctors. But from a patient perspective, care is almost undeniable better in other developed countries.

I have no children but many of my friends do, children often get unwell and as parents have been advised by the GP that the wait for an ambulance is so long that if able then to take their child in to children's A&E themselves. Some of the first hand stories I have heard are harrowing. So yes, I do think we as the general public need doctors so much more in general than the doctors need their careers. Obviously some may be tied down to the UK but many aren't, and many have already left for countries like Australia. On this thread alone we have seen ex NHS doctors now working elsewhere. Whether they want to work in medicine or in a different industry, these are highly qualified intelligent individuals who are "still studying" in medicine so not the greatest leap to completely change careers and retrain - they excel at studying. As a country though, the NHS is definitely crumbling, its in the publics interest to retain doctors.

Pay is just one aspect of it, but yes of course doctors deserve so much more pay. I think in the past they had expenses - accomodation, commute etc taken care of. Now when rent is at an all time high, and forced to move around the country - often leaving kids/spouse behind in another part of the UK while the medic lives alone in their working week home with the current cost of living, morale is so low. Work is tough physically and mentally, going home to nobody is tough, missing their family/children, still having huge amounts of debt. Not everyone does private work (most probably dont) and as far as I am aware you cant do private work while still in training i.e as a "junior doctor".

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 11:00

They might well be on just over £14 an hour when they start in year 1, but in absolute terms their income is nearly £40k and by year 4 nearly £70k. So it seems to me the key issue is one of working conditions not pay. And I don’t doubt the working conditions are tough. Very tough in the first few years when you’re constantly moving around.

I think perhaps they’d get a little
more sympathy if they focussed on conditions, not pay which is, by any reasonable standards, not that bad.

Are junior docs really only on £14.09 per hour?
AlecTrevelyan006 · 13/03/2023 10:52

uk.indeed.com/q-pret-a-manger-jobs.html

unlikely to earn £14ph at Pret

Swipe left for the next trending thread