Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are junior docs really only on £14.09 per hour?

366 replies

yawningmorning · 13/03/2023 06:54

That is so low.

I've seen the headline that you can earn more per hour working in pret.

No wonder they are striking.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
2023ttc · 13/03/2023 17:32

@TreadLight This does not take into account debt that doctors have (correct me if I'm wrong but most other healthcare degrees are funded). Neither does it take into account the hours actually worked. Doctors don't work 9-5 like they are contracted to. If there is a sick patient (there almost always is) they stay until they sort that out and hand over appropriately. They then go home and study for exams that they have to pay thousands to sit which is a requirement for their job. The study is all-consuming, they miss important life events such as best friends weddings (sometimes their own) because of out of hours on calls and/or studying commitments. They are also paying for indemnity, paying back debts etc and also parking. They commute to work and often pay for parking both at their hospital and street parking where they live. They also give up events like Christmas due to shift work. They come home still thinking about sick patients. They don't have protected "breaks" they eat and pee as the opportunity arises. Sometimes there is no time, they come home starving. They carry a bleep at all times, if that means they've finally had the chance to go to the toilet or sit down with their sandwich/coffee but the crash bleep goes off they drop everything and run. Every single doctor has experienced this, often. They then drive home having worked all night and carry that risk on that commute because very often where they live/their child goes to school etc is not where they work. The very nature of "junior doctor training" is rotating all around. As often as 3 months. It isnt feasible to move your whole life that frequently.

eastegg · 13/03/2023 17:29

follyfoot37 · 13/03/2023 07:03

I think you'll find that barristers are not public servants. Sure, they earn peanuts as pupils, but once called to the bar, have unlimited earning potential particularly if in good chambers

The barristers on strike last summer are paid entirely from public funds though ie criminal barristers. They also most definitely do not have unlimited earning potential; it’s limited (many would say extremely limited) by the graduated fee scheme.

Househare · 13/03/2023 17:27

*outearned

Househare · 13/03/2023 17:27

@TreadLight and what you are spectacularly missing is that the calibre of the doctor is well within the top few percent of the population too. They would most likely have gone on to earn more in alternative professions. They could all have chosen different paths to medicine and outlearned most of the population because of their brains and attitude to work. PS I am not a doctor before you start accusing me of arrogance.

2023ttc · 13/03/2023 17:24

@Qazwsxefv Well said.

TreadLight · 13/03/2023 17:20

Just for some perspective, basic pay without any add-ons like unsocial working hours, overtime etc.:
First year (not qualified, still training), doctors earn more than 57% of the population (i.e. most people are earning less than unqualified doctors in the first year)
2nd year - doctors earn more than 67% of the population
3rd and 4th years - 75%
Years 5-7 doctors earn more than 86% of the population
Years 8-10 its 89% of the population

Then they move into consultancy, where the salary is better than between 95% and 97% of the population.

And then there is the problem that the additional benefits like pension contributions are so high that they hit the tax free limits for these benefits.

If I was to describe the salary of doctors in one word, I would use the word "Good".

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 17:08

It’s not saying that they should be paid more because they have an at A level in biology here it’s saying they should be paid more because they have a medical degree (and at least when I went to medical school an A level in biology was not an entry requirement)

we are not fully trained consultants or GPs yes, but from F2 on they are fully trained doctors. They are fully qualified and trained to do the job they are doing day to day (hospital ward doctor). We are also training to do another job (consultant/GP) on the side. We would like to be paid a proper wage for the day to day job we do which is complex and requires at least five years undergrad (medical school) and one year probation (f1) of study to do.

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 17:01

no it’s not an automatic pay rise per year worked nor is it guaranteed progression from medical school to consulstant hood.

It’s pay nodal points not years worked. You don’t go up a pay scale point per year worked automatically. You either have to apply for a new job to move up or if in a longer contract pass exams and appraisals.

You Pass medical school and apply for foundation - you get a two year nhs training contract
then get paid at point one is f1
if you pass f1 year (appraisal, portfolio of work) of you go do indeed go to point two for a year

your employment contract then ends. No automatic progression anywhere

You can then apply for a training or non training post in a certain speciality. Both you are paid at point three (though some places pay non training at point two). You then stay at point 3 for at least two years after which your contract often ends with no automatic progression (but in a few specialitys continues)

For those whoes contract ends after point two you to get to point four you must then apply for a new job for which you must have passed a new set of exams. For those lucky enough to be on a run through contract to get to point four you still need to pass exams and yearly appraisals - if you don’t pass them you are usually given an extra six months at point three to try again and if not you don’t get to stay where you are at point three, nope your fired.

if at any point you don’t pass an exam (or can’t afford an exam because they cost about 1k a pop and their not paid for) you get 6 months more employment at your current level to try and fix it and then your out. You can then take a non training job at whatever level pay you have made it to but you will then never progress up the pay scale - many training contracts have a “no second chances rule” so if you fail or can’t afford to sit you can never come back to training and your wages will not progress ever

Beyondtired123 · 13/03/2023 16:54

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 16:30

You’re conflating taking risks in a job, which whether you’re in tech, medicine, flying or pretty much any sector, could lead to negative consequences (and it’s not just doctors dealing with lives - pilots, train drivers, bus drivers all have 50/100/300/500 people’s lives in their hands) with sector risks. Tech is renowned for boom
and bust….there’s a real chance of restructure or worse periodically. The same is true across most of the private sector. It’s not true in medicine. If you don’t take risks in the job, the sector itself is pretty much recession and economy proof in the short/medium term.

You’re also not helping the cause by painting anyone who disagrees with your opinion as wilfully ignorant. And being terrified of someone who disagrees with you really isn’t healthy!!

My late husband was chronically ill for over 20 hearts before he died. I saw first hand the dedication some medical staff had, and I’m grateful for what they did in difficult working conditions. They are not messiahs though. They could learn a lot from the airline industries transparency around accidents. They could learn a lot from the other professions about communication. And, dare I say it, making a stand about working conditions. The BMA has failed miserably there compared to the pilots or rai workers unions.

We are at two different ends of the spectrum and I imagine there is no hope to meet in the middle.

I work in a high risk, high reward job in finance which is remunerated accordingly to factor in the risk of messing up in a decision (as you mention). However, I would not want to undertake a role in medicine as I would not want to make treatment decisions on a daily basis that could affect someone's life for years to come.

You also say train drivers and pilots have people's lives in their hands which is also true but once again they are not making the same kind of life, death or life changing decisions on a daily basis as a medic.

I also do not think doctors are infallible or 'the messiah'. The same with any industry, there are poor quality drs and those that need to be put out to pasture. However, there are very few people who are able or would want to be put in situations where you are faced with making decisions about the best form of treatment for a dying patient and do that everyday. You are attempting to compare apples and oranges......healthcare is a unique work environment and all staff involved deserve pay restoration at the very least.

The doctors need to dig deep, be brave and stay the course because unfortunately they are not getting the support and understanding they deserve.

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 16:40

The thing is Not every junior doctors will become a consultant, not all juniors are on training contracts. That dosent mean that those who will not become consultants of GPs are rubbish doctors and deserve to be paid rubbish. We need junior doctors (or non consultant/GP grade doctors) to run the hospital wards - to examine and provide initial treatment of the unwell patient, to put the iv lines in, interpret the chest x rays, take and read the ecgs, to prescribe the medications and fluids, to be on the crash team providing cpr, to talk to relatives and patients, to complete the mounds of paperwork, to write the sick notes, ask about the care provision at home etc…. to Being a non consultant hospital doctor who provides good day to day care of patients is a responsible job in itself and should be recognised as such.

What a consultant in a particular speciality does day in day out has often very little to do with what the juniors working in their team do. For example A junior doctor working on a surgical ward is providing medical care of the patient not operating, the junior doctor in a psychiatric ward is providing GP style services to the patients not doing psychiatry . The consultant surgeon or consultant psychiatrist isn’t providing training or supervision to the junior doctor in how to care for the day to day medical care of the patient. The junior doctor is fully qualified for providing this already (it’s what medical school was for, f1s should have some supervision however ). Last week juniors all over the country were teaching/refreshing their consultants how to prescribe drugs on the computer systems, how to work the ecg machines and in some places crash courses on how to obtain IV acsess in preparation for the strike.

being a hospital doctor- being responsible for the day to day health of a ward of patients is something that should be recognised by pay considerably above £16.03 an hour (that’s the f2 wage so when you are no longer being technically supervised in your basic work, £14.09 is for f1). It dosent matter what the f2 may go on to earn in a different job one day because the job they are doing now needs doing well and needs high quality people doing it. There are loads and loads of vacancies across the nhs at this (sho) level Showing that the job itself isn’t paid enough to make it worth peoples while. The nhs recruits massively into the non training junior roles from abroad as they can’t get uk grads to do it for the wage.
89k (consultant entry pay) for the work an ward doctor does would be ridiculous but the nhs does need f1s and other grades of ward doctor to function. Places that don’t have enough ward doctors have started to employ PA (physician assistants) for more than they pay the f1s and many of them can’t prescribe and need a qualified doctor to supervise them.

there is a whole argument to fully reorganise medical training which would be imo a v good idea if they government weren’t likely to f it up.

superplumb · 13/03/2023 16:38

Dr in hospitals also work 24/7 shift pattern including days like Xmas etc . Most graduates,szp teachers do not, not to mention risks involved. I wish people would stop lining drs up woth other grads. They're a world apart. 7 years training for a start.

noblegiraffe · 13/03/2023 16:34

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 13/03/2023 13:54

Absolutely. In the private sector if your employer is doing badly you don’t get a pay rise. Guess what drs? Your employer is doing badly.

Idiotic short term thinking that led us to this mess in the first place.

The insistence on austerity that is now 13 years of underfunding has resulted in crisis. There are areas of the public sector that need investment in order to protect the economy and the government has failed to understand that for over a decade now.

noblegiraffe · 13/03/2023 16:31

When people talk about the need for society to be more equal and the mega rich hording all the wealth, it’s not normally junior doctors on £30-£40k that people are thinking of. Bizarre that people are trying to peg them as extremely well-off.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 16:30

Beyondtired123 · 13/03/2023 15:34

When your not dealing with someone else's life I am sure you are more likely to have a risk taking attitude. It's a daft comparison.

The wilful ignorance of people is terrifying, and also how little they seem to care about the treatment and care they will inevitably need to access at some point in their life when they are frail, vulnerable and potentially dying.

You’re conflating taking risks in a job, which whether you’re in tech, medicine, flying or pretty much any sector, could lead to negative consequences (and it’s not just doctors dealing with lives - pilots, train drivers, bus drivers all have 50/100/300/500 people’s lives in their hands) with sector risks. Tech is renowned for boom
and bust….there’s a real chance of restructure or worse periodically. The same is true across most of the private sector. It’s not true in medicine. If you don’t take risks in the job, the sector itself is pretty much recession and economy proof in the short/medium term.

You’re also not helping the cause by painting anyone who disagrees with your opinion as wilfully ignorant. And being terrified of someone who disagrees with you really isn’t healthy!!

My late husband was chronically ill for over 20 hearts before he died. I saw first hand the dedication some medical staff had, and I’m grateful for what they did in difficult working conditions. They are not messiahs though. They could learn a lot from the airline industries transparency around accidents. They could learn a lot from the other professions about communication. And, dare I say it, making a stand about working conditions. The BMA has failed miserably there compared to the pilots or rai workers unions.

Househare · 13/03/2023 16:23

RedToothBrush · 13/03/2023 15:57

People complaining about rich people:
Society should be more equal. People shouldn't earn huge amounts more than others. We should value everyone even those who work in menial jobs.

The same people:
Junior doctors arent paid enough. They should be paid more from the day they start. They are paid the same as people who are unskilled and unqualified in lowly service industry jobs. It's outrageous.

Which is it? I'm kinda fed up of it.

It's right that you progress in your career if you gain experience. If you are a junior doctor you are still training. Having an a level in biology compared to someone who doesn't have any doesn't make you more worthwhile to society. It's the experience on the job which is of added value to society. Equally that unqualified staffer at pret, might go on to catering and work their way up to being a top chef if they take the right options.

I do think there's absolute nonsense and cognitive dissonance on this subject where you've got these ultra lefties advocating for magic thinking.

The problem junior doctors face isn't pay. It's working conditions.

Such absolute rubbish. Doctors are not rich. Footballers and Investment Bankers are rich. Doctors are professionals whose skillset and the responsibility they carry right from when they start as F1s mean they merit a decent salary. An A level in Biology doesn't mean that you are more useful to society. Well, get your barista (who may or may not go on to be a top chef) to do your quadruple bypass then.

Salverus · 13/03/2023 16:08

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 15:17

Insightful comment. And who said doctors were poor communicators ;) I’m

I'm not a doctor.

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 16:01

250k for training is just a nonsense figure that no one can ever really show the workings for (and if unis are giving that much to the nhs for training med students it’s not ring fenced for training and ends up being spent on patient care anyway).

university of Buckingham (as in the fully private one) charges 175k for a 5 year medical degree so that is likely near actual cost (and the uni makes a profit so probably over cost)

so current Fy1 doctors who have paid 90k in fees have paid more than half of the cost of their training at least.

postgraduate training costs often quoted are pretty much only consisting of the wage bill of the doctors in training. As in the numbers flung about for the money spent on post grad training by the nhs is actually the wages of the junior doctors themselves - no actual training going on for that money, it’s just what we’re paid to go to work. The “training bits” are paid by the doctors themselves - the courses, exams, overly expensive online portfolio thing to record case studies and courses, membership of a royal college, gmc and professional insurance. We do have a few hours a week where we go for local “teaching” but this is peer teaching - we take turns to teach each other something - no great expense to anyone especially as now post covid it’s on teams so they don’t even have to pay for a room for us to use.

RedToothBrush · 13/03/2023 15:57

People complaining about rich people:
Society should be more equal. People shouldn't earn huge amounts more than others. We should value everyone even those who work in menial jobs.

The same people:
Junior doctors arent paid enough. They should be paid more from the day they start. They are paid the same as people who are unskilled and unqualified in lowly service industry jobs. It's outrageous.

Which is it? I'm kinda fed up of it.

It's right that you progress in your career if you gain experience. If you are a junior doctor you are still training. Having an a level in biology compared to someone who doesn't have any doesn't make you more worthwhile to society. It's the experience on the job which is of added value to society. Equally that unqualified staffer at pret, might go on to catering and work their way up to being a top chef if they take the right options.

I do think there's absolute nonsense and cognitive dissonance on this subject where you've got these ultra lefties advocating for magic thinking.

The problem junior doctors face isn't pay. It's working conditions.

Beyondtired123 · 13/03/2023 15:34

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 15:11

@Salverus they’re also not taking tech company levels of risk. They’re effectively in a job for life if they’re competent. That’s not the case for those in the private sector. Who also don’t get the pensions that doctors get.

Late 40s to be earning 6 figures isn’t that dissimilar to many jobs outside the City, and is also a very secure job unlike most private sector roles… all of which is known at the beginning of any professional career. Medicine is a relatively low risk way of earning well above average for an entire career.

When your not dealing with someone else's life I am sure you are more likely to have a risk taking attitude. It's a daft comparison.

The wilful ignorance of people is terrifying, and also how little they seem to care about the treatment and care they will inevitably need to access at some point in their life when they are frail, vulnerable and potentially dying.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 15:17

Salverus · 13/03/2023 15:14

Just wow.

Insightful comment. And who said doctors were poor communicators ;) I’m

Salverus · 13/03/2023 15:14

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 15:11

@Salverus they’re also not taking tech company levels of risk. They’re effectively in a job for life if they’re competent. That’s not the case for those in the private sector. Who also don’t get the pensions that doctors get.

Late 40s to be earning 6 figures isn’t that dissimilar to many jobs outside the City, and is also a very secure job unlike most private sector roles… all of which is known at the beginning of any professional career. Medicine is a relatively low risk way of earning well above average for an entire career.

Just wow.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 15:11

Lapland123 · 13/03/2023 13:52

£119k when you have been a consultant for 20 years

so usually we’ll into your 50s at that stage

what nonsense some posters have said, talking about ‘hundreds of thousands’. A new consultant is paid £84k. And it’s not comparable to other countries, no- that’s why we have so many vacant posts here.

@Salverus they’re also not taking tech company levels of risk. They’re effectively in a job for life if they’re competent. That’s not the case for those in the private sector. Who also don’t get the pensions that doctors get.

Late 40s to be earning 6 figures isn’t that dissimilar to many jobs outside the City, and is also a very secure job unlike most private sector roles… all of which is known at the beginning of any professional career. Medicine is a relatively low risk way of earning well above average for an entire career.

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 13/03/2023 13:54

SamanthaCaine · 13/03/2023 13:36

I agree. Pay erosion is real but isn't exclusive to HCP's and civil servants in general.

The economy has been pretty dire since 2008 and coupled with a useless government, most of the UK has seen their pay eroded over the last 15 years. This isn't a race to the bottom but in the private sector, if your business isn't profitable, you're either made redundant, lose your pension pot or have a pay freeze. That's the reality for the rest of us that most civil servants just don't understand because you're completely insulated.

Obviously the upshot of a poor economy and stagnant wages is lower tax receipts, which impacts directly on civil servant salaries. I think this is what divides public opinion generally. Asking for a pay rise isn't unreasonable but complaining because doctors think they're owed 30% or more is. And especially after the pandemic when billions have been lost from the public purse.

You're right that we need good salaries to attract the best, but that's idealism. This applies to the private sector too but we sadly don't live in an ideal world and a great many industries can no longer pay the best salaries. If/when our economy is booming again (I live and hope!) I'd expect things to be different but we're a long way from that.

Absolutely. In the private sector if your employer is doing badly you don’t get a pay rise. Guess what drs? Your employer is doing badly.

Lapland123 · 13/03/2023 13:52

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:10

NHS consultants earn a max of 120k a year. It's hardly tech company levels.

£119k when you have been a consultant for 20 years

so usually we’ll into your 50s at that stage

what nonsense some posters have said, talking about ‘hundreds of thousands’. A new consultant is paid £84k. And it’s not comparable to other countries, no- that’s why we have so many vacant posts here.

SamanthaCaine · 13/03/2023 13:36

mathsgirl12 · 13/03/2023 13:00

I'm not saying it is. It's on the back of a quote where someone said you quickly reach 6 figures. I don't think 20 plus years is quick. I'd personally, like to have conditions improved. More time with family etc. I honestly wouldn't do the job again and having seen my working life, none of my children wish to become doctors. When I started, there was lots of children of doctors in my year. The personal sacrifice has been too big for the renumeration. The contempt some posters have for HCPs is awful too. Pay erosion is real regardless of an individuals thoughts about it and if you want to continue to recruit bright, capable individuals, pay will need to keep up with fellow professionals. It was relatively unheard of for juniors to leave the profession after the registration year. It's now common. If we want a good quality healthcare system then, we cannot allow that to happen.

I agree. Pay erosion is real but isn't exclusive to HCP's and civil servants in general.

The economy has been pretty dire since 2008 and coupled with a useless government, most of the UK has seen their pay eroded over the last 15 years. This isn't a race to the bottom but in the private sector, if your business isn't profitable, you're either made redundant, lose your pension pot or have a pay freeze. That's the reality for the rest of us that most civil servants just don't understand because you're completely insulated.

Obviously the upshot of a poor economy and stagnant wages is lower tax receipts, which impacts directly on civil servant salaries. I think this is what divides public opinion generally. Asking for a pay rise isn't unreasonable but complaining because doctors think they're owed 30% or more is. And especially after the pandemic when billions have been lost from the public purse.

You're right that we need good salaries to attract the best, but that's idealism. This applies to the private sector too but we sadly don't live in an ideal world and a great many industries can no longer pay the best salaries. If/when our economy is booming again (I live and hope!) I'd expect things to be different but we're a long way from that.