Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are junior docs really only on £14.09 per hour?

366 replies

yawningmorning · 13/03/2023 06:54

That is so low.

I've seen the headline that you can earn more per hour working in pret.

No wonder they are striking.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Willyoujustbequiet · 13/03/2023 23:59

TreadLight · 13/03/2023 17:20

Just for some perspective, basic pay without any add-ons like unsocial working hours, overtime etc.:
First year (not qualified, still training), doctors earn more than 57% of the population (i.e. most people are earning less than unqualified doctors in the first year)
2nd year - doctors earn more than 67% of the population
3rd and 4th years - 75%
Years 5-7 doctors earn more than 86% of the population
Years 8-10 its 89% of the population

Then they move into consultancy, where the salary is better than between 95% and 97% of the population.

And then there is the problem that the additional benefits like pension contributions are so high that they hit the tax free limits for these benefits.

If I was to describe the salary of doctors in one word, I would use the word "Good".

I agree.

The working conditions need to be improved but the pay no. I find it difficult to have much sympathy when you see it outlined as you have above. I think the general public won't either.

SueVineer · 13/03/2023 23:39

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 23:29

@Florenz the nhs can’t get enough immigrants to come and work as doctors despite massive overseas recruitment drives so I don’t think that’s a concern. I think all doctors would love it if there were more doctors. The shortage of doctors isn’t driving up wages and so filling the vacancies because wages are fixed. So wages stay low, working conditions (and patient outcomes) worsen as you’re always doing the work of 3 people, so more doctors leave the profession/for abroad and it becomes a vicious cycle.

(and before someone calls out the whole “the bma voted to limit medical school
numbers I. 2008” no the bma passed a motion calling for medical school numbers to be tagged to f1 jobs available. As hospitals actually have to supervise f1s (unlike the rest of the junior doctors) f1 places are limited - and since you need to do that provisional registration year in the nhs to get full gmc registration and be able to work anywhere else or as any other sort of doctor the bma lobbied that it was unfair and rather stupid to have loads of qualified doctors that couldnt actually work as they couldnt get gmc registration. Clearly the simple solution would be for the nhs/government to increase the f1 places and so increase the number of medical school places to match but that’s far to sensible, so instead we have a massive shortage of all other grades of junior doctor but the inflow tap (f1) is kept strangled) and now we have a catch 22 where we would struggle to increase f1 and medical school post numbers massively because there simply aren’t enough more senior-juniors left to supervise them. )

Ridiculous isn’t it. We really need more doctors

fUNNYfACE36 · 13/03/2023 23:39

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 17:08

It’s not saying that they should be paid more because they have an at A level in biology here it’s saying they should be paid more because they have a medical degree (and at least when I went to medical school an A level in biology was not an entry requirement)

we are not fully trained consultants or GPs yes, but from F2 on they are fully trained doctors. They are fully qualified and trained to do the job they are doing day to day (hospital ward doctor). We are also training to do another job (consultant/GP) on the side. We would like to be paid a proper wage for the day to day job we do which is complex and requires at least five years undergrad (medical school) and one year probation (f1) of study to do.

The vast majority of science professionals do at least 4 years ( integrated masters at least) or 5 with year industry and such qualifications usually have higher A level requirements eg matural sciences at Bath is A A A and maths at Durham A A* A

Jill688 · 13/03/2023 23:37

It’s disgusting that we pay them the same as a pret barista.

SueVineer · 13/03/2023 23:36

Salverus · 13/03/2023 07:08

The majority of the time.

Dn has just started as a teacher - got poor A levels and has a 2.2 from a low ranked uni and is training while working. It's not really comparable with a junior doctor. She's lovely and I'm sure she'll make a good teacher but on paper there's no reason she should earn as much as someone who spent 7 years in training with a very competitive degree and top A levels.

Absolutely. Ultimately medicine is a higher skilled more competitive job than teaching and the pay should reflect that.

BornBlonde · 13/03/2023 23:36

Tryingtokeepgoing · 13/03/2023 11:00

They might well be on just over £14 an hour when they start in year 1, but in absolute terms their income is nearly £40k and by year 4 nearly £70k. So it seems to me the key issue is one of working conditions not pay. And I don’t doubt the working conditions are tough. Very tough in the first few years when you’re constantly moving around.

I think perhaps they’d get a little
more sympathy if they focussed on conditions, not pay which is, by any reasonable standards, not that bad.

This

Happyvalleyfan · 13/03/2023 23:31

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 13/03/2023 13:20

I have little sympathy for them and don’t think many members of the public will have sympathy either. They have had below inflation pay rises for the past 10 years? So what. So have the vast majority of the working public! They have a job for life. The whole ‘if we don’t pay them more then they’ll move abroad’ is about as ethical as tax-dodging non-doms. We invest so much money in training doctors - £250k per doctor - and there are 15 applicants for every place at medical school. We need to start requiring UK medical students agree to the equivalent of 20 years of NHS service before giving them a place.

Medical staff have been particularly affected with below inflation wage adjustments.

www.ft.com/content/fac8062a-bd83-486b-ac6f-582f1931750b

If the government wants to think about minimum level of service- they should get rid of student grants for medics

twitter.com/DrLucyLu_/status/1635025515903094785?s=20

If you think it’s unethical for our doctors to go abroad - what do you think of NHS having recruited doctors and nurses from developing countries for decades to meet demands? Not sure how attractive NHS is now though 🤔

Some specialities still go abroad to recruit.

Hurrahhurrah · 13/03/2023 23:29

Anybody on a salary is on crap pay once commute/unpaid work etc is taken into account.
I travel 28 hrs per week.
Ex dp used to point out I was on less than £10 per HR after commuting and stopping over. Used to piss me off with his calculations.

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 23:29

@Florenz the nhs can’t get enough immigrants to come and work as doctors despite massive overseas recruitment drives so I don’t think that’s a concern. I think all doctors would love it if there were more doctors. The shortage of doctors isn’t driving up wages and so filling the vacancies because wages are fixed. So wages stay low, working conditions (and patient outcomes) worsen as you’re always doing the work of 3 people, so more doctors leave the profession/for abroad and it becomes a vicious cycle.

(and before someone calls out the whole “the bma voted to limit medical school
numbers I. 2008” no the bma passed a motion calling for medical school numbers to be tagged to f1 jobs available. As hospitals actually have to supervise f1s (unlike the rest of the junior doctors) f1 places are limited - and since you need to do that provisional registration year in the nhs to get full gmc registration and be able to work anywhere else or as any other sort of doctor the bma lobbied that it was unfair and rather stupid to have loads of qualified doctors that couldnt actually work as they couldnt get gmc registration. Clearly the simple solution would be for the nhs/government to increase the f1 places and so increase the number of medical school places to match but that’s far to sensible, so instead we have a massive shortage of all other grades of junior doctor but the inflow tap (f1) is kept strangled) and now we have a catch 22 where we would struggle to increase f1 and medical school post numbers massively because there simply aren’t enough more senior-juniors left to supervise them. )

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 23:13

Postgraduate entry to medical school has been a thing for years. It’s for those with a science undergrad degree (nursing most definitely counts) and then it’s “only” 4 years medical school not five so cuts off a little bit of the debt burden for medicine (but nowadays a student nurse dosent get their tuition fully covered so the total cost would be more or very similar). I don’t think postgrad medical training is really going to reduce costs but agree it does often have more diverse applicants and many are nurses. I have no idea why you would think that anyone would think graduates from these courses are lesser doctors - I honestly have no idea if my colleges did medicine as undergrad or postgraduate unless they volunteer the info.

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 23:05

Hardbackwriter · 13/03/2023 21:09

I have a couple of close friends who are doctors. It's an incredibly tough job and I have huge respect for those who do it. I think their conditions are absolutely appalling, and were even worse when they were earlier in their career. I just don't think any of them would be meaningfully addressed by a pay raise, and I think paying doctors anything close to 35% more would make some of their working conditions worse because of the way it would squeeze wider resources.

I get what you say about a pay rise not fixing the working conditions.

But if there was a pay rise then maybe we could attract enough junior doctors so we weren’t always short staffed so we could finish on time and get breaks and not always be being bullied into overtime.

The other thing is that being payed more allows you to throw money at the multiple issues the terrible working conditions create and so make life more bearable. The issues that the horrid long hours, changing city of work every 4 months to a year, nights, under 6 weeks notice of what your shifts are going to be etc create for your home life

When my daughter was born we could afford a full time nursery place or a nanny and it meant that not knowing what shift I would be working until a few weeks before wasn’t an issue because I had childcare sorted whatever. Now we can’t afford full time childcare so not knowing if im working until a few weeks before is awful as I am always begging the afterschool club to let me move my days etx. I found out on Friday I’m working the Easter weekend - four weeks notice to find bank holiday childcare - not easy.

its possible to work loads of antisocial hours with last minute demands if you have the support structure in place - if you don’t it’s exhausting, and unless your gifted with lots of close by friends and relatives it costs money (the fact you have to move hospitals every year also dosent help with the setting up of local support networks either)

noblegiraffe · 13/03/2023 22:17

"Well of course inequality is terrible and all that but it surely doesn't apply to doctors who need to be paid high wages or they'll bugger off abroad"

So you're a communist and you think that we should build a wall to stop all the doctors from leaving?

Florenz · 13/03/2023 22:12

There's so much snobbery on this thread. "Well of course inequality is terrible and all that but it surely doesn't apply to doctors who need to be paid high wages or they'll bugger off abroad". That way of thinking is why we have so much inequality. The most privileged/highly skilled can travel the world to demand the highest possibly remuneration for their work, meanwhile normal, less skilled people see their wages fall as they are threatened that immigrants/people in poorer countries than do their job cheaper and better than they can.

Hardbackwriter · 13/03/2023 21:09

ADoctorsWife · 13/03/2023 20:24

Really interesting views on this post. Those that think doctors get paid enough probably don’t have close friends or family that work in the profession. The amount of dedication and sacrifice that’s needed to continue through medical school and training is intense. The salary is good when you see it on paper but when you take into account the debts accrued through training, relocation and vast commuting expenses, indemnity insurances etc. it is pittance. Perhaps we need to look at a more Scandinavian model of training our HCP’s where training expenses are covered by the state and thus more equal to those that enter employment straight from college.

I have a couple of close friends who are doctors. It's an incredibly tough job and I have huge respect for those who do it. I think their conditions are absolutely appalling, and were even worse when they were earlier in their career. I just don't think any of them would be meaningfully addressed by a pay raise, and I think paying doctors anything close to 35% more would make some of their working conditions worse because of the way it would squeeze wider resources.

WeAreBorg · 13/03/2023 21:06

Pay them more ffs. I don’t want to get operated on by some crap arse who failed his exams and can’t string a sentence together. Which is what will happen when all the clever kids fuck off and do something where they actually get paid a reasonable wage.

MegaManic · 13/03/2023 21:04

Hardbackwriter · 13/03/2023 07:05

It's comparing the very least a junior doctor can earn, without any of the additional payments and at the very start of their career, with what pret pays their most experienced staff in the most expensive areas. It ignores pensions. It's disingenuous and snobby. There is a reason that while loads of people do quit medicine at some point in training or beyond they don't very often go to work at pret.

In short the answer is no, in the vast majority of cases, they do not earn £14 per hours as stated by the union, explain vert well here by @Hardbackwriter

RedToothBrush · 13/03/2023 21:00

ADoctorsWife · 13/03/2023 20:24

Really interesting views on this post. Those that think doctors get paid enough probably don’t have close friends or family that work in the profession. The amount of dedication and sacrifice that’s needed to continue through medical school and training is intense. The salary is good when you see it on paper but when you take into account the debts accrued through training, relocation and vast commuting expenses, indemnity insurances etc. it is pittance. Perhaps we need to look at a more Scandinavian model of training our HCP’s where training expenses are covered by the state and thus more equal to those that enter employment straight from college.

Bil is a doctor. Sil is a doctor. DS'S godmother is a doctor.

bakebeans · 13/03/2023 20:27

Againstmachine · 13/03/2023 07:02

I don't believe the story most pret staff will be minimum wage or just above.

No it's true! People think that a doctor is on fantastic wages but In reality they don't get the better wages until either consultant/ surgeon or a GP.

I really wish people would listen. This is why nurses, NHS staff and doctors are striking!

ADoctorsWife · 13/03/2023 20:24

Really interesting views on this post. Those that think doctors get paid enough probably don’t have close friends or family that work in the profession. The amount of dedication and sacrifice that’s needed to continue through medical school and training is intense. The salary is good when you see it on paper but when you take into account the debts accrued through training, relocation and vast commuting expenses, indemnity insurances etc. it is pittance. Perhaps we need to look at a more Scandinavian model of training our HCP’s where training expenses are covered by the state and thus more equal to those that enter employment straight from college.

DepartmentOfMysteries · 13/03/2023 20:22

Yes, this is what I get paid. I qualified in 2020.

Artisticpaint · 13/03/2023 19:58

My dc is a junior doctor, her friend just finished GP training, got a job asa GP. six months later was earning twice as much as a management consultant for one of the big five.
there are a lot of Doctors looking at their options

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 13/03/2023 19:52

Sockloon · 13/03/2023 07:04

Yawn, 🥱 if they don't like it retrain find a new job. Plenty of others will do it, the putty party is growing really old now.

Nah, they’ll just move abroad where they get better pay and work life balance.
same with nurses

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 13/03/2023 19:47

I think doctors have also accepted working over hours etc for many years because ultimately they like the private work prize pot at the end. Like others have said the RMT and other unions have been stronger. I feel that Doctors often come from good backgrounds, worked hard and did what they are told. This hasn’t helped then or everyone who uses the NHS.too ready to accept poor conditions and practices!

Qazwsxefv · 13/03/2023 18:55

@TreadLight

f1 is a qualified doctor - they have a medical degree. They are in a provisional registration year yes but that best thought of like having P plates rather than L plates on their car- they have passed there test they just have to not mess up for a year and then they are fully registered - there is no further exam they need to sit.

I’ve said above it’s not like you finish medical school and you get a job for life with the nhs and every year you get a pay rise up the pay scales. You get generally 2-3 year training contracts at certain points on the scale and when they are finished you can take and exam and then apply for a new job at a higher point in the scale. Saying y1 post qualification is paid this and y2 is paid this etc is not true.

It’s a reverse funnel - there are less jobs at each level you go up the scale. The system is designed that some people don’t progress up the levels and end up taking non training jobs at the top level they made it to. This is becuase the nhs needs more junior doctors at the lower levels doing the day to day work in hospitals than it needs consultants doing the fancy high level stuff. You don’t defend judge the wages of a Tesco checkout worker buy the saying well if they worked hard at their job and passed lots of exams and interviewed for a higher portion in the company like store manager they would be paid more. Junior doctor is a role that needs filling for the working of the health service and deserves a wage commiserate with the qualifications it demands and the responsibilities it entails.

Trinity65 · 13/03/2023 18:28

noblegiraffe · 13/03/2023 07:29

What is this bizarre idea that thinking a doctor should be paid more than a barista or a bin man is 'snobbery'? The idea that working incredibly hard over many years to earn demanding qualifications shouldn't mean that you earn any more than someone doing a job you can start straight out of school?

Is it a legacy of Gove's 'people have had enough of experts'? Are the people trotting this out communists? What is going on?

I absolutely agree with this .

I have no degrees, and only got a GCSE English (A for Spoken and B for coursework) when I was lucky enough to take that as part of a intro to Computing course many years ago (cough. 1999).
I have never been to Uni probably because I didn't want too but also I did not sit my A Levels (I went to college instead).
However, imho, I would definitely expect Junior Doctors to earn more per hour than a barista or a dustman. Absolutely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread