Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are junior docs really only on £14.09 per hour?

366 replies

yawningmorning · 13/03/2023 06:54

That is so low.

I've seen the headline that you can earn more per hour working in pret.

No wonder they are striking.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:26

Lookwhostalking99 · 13/03/2023 09:21

Personally you couldn't pay me enough to have to deal with the whinging, entitled British public.

So why are you on a british public forum then? complaining about a 120K per year salary.

Bye bye.

What a strange comment. We are hugely chippy as a nation as this thread proves. Until some of the posters here actually get seriously ill, when I'm sure they'll take full advantage of their free health care and be pathetically grateful for the education and training of their doctor.

medicmumma · 13/03/2023 09:26

£100k is not silly money when you factor in 5/6 years for medical school, multiple degrees + exams (that we pay for - I don't get where this myth comes from that the 'taxpayer' pays), spending our free time doing extra projects/publications (for free!) and literally being responsible for peoples' lives (remember that next time your child gets sick).

Lookwhostalking99 · 13/03/2023 09:21

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:17

Don't be ridiculous. That's after almost 20 years of making life and death decisions for the benefit of ungrateful people like you. Personally you couldn't pay me enough to have to deal with the whinging, entitled British public.

Personally you couldn't pay me enough to have to deal with the whinging, entitled British public.

So why are you on a british public forum then? complaining about a 120K per year salary.

Bye bye.

Sirzy · 13/03/2023 09:20

KnittedCardi · 13/03/2023 09:18

Yes but an awful lot do private work on top. All the specialists I have seen privately are also NHS consultants. Most of my GP practice is part time, and the rest of the week they do private too.

But if they were properly paid for the nhs work, and had better working conditions then they wouldn’t need to do private practise.

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:20

KnittedCardi · 13/03/2023 09:18

Yes but an awful lot do private work on top. All the specialists I have seen privately are also NHS consultants. Most of my GP practice is part time, and the rest of the week they do private too.

Yes, that's fair enough isn't it - not tax payers money?

Cloudhoppingdancer · 13/03/2023 09:19

medicmumma · 13/03/2023 09:17

Because the intelligence, qualifications and dedication needed to be a doctor, as well as the responsibility far outweighs that of being a teacher and a barrister. Both are important jobs in society but do not compare to being responsible for peoples lives.

And with regards to investment banking - they work incredibly hard and yes while their pay per hour is low (not as low as doctors) they have a good gross pay + many other benefits (paid work trips abroad, able to expense meals/travel, an actual desk to work on rather than a bin next to a computer...)

Not necessarily at all.

KnittedCardi · 13/03/2023 09:18

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:10

NHS consultants earn a max of 120k a year. It's hardly tech company levels.

Yes but an awful lot do private work on top. All the specialists I have seen privately are also NHS consultants. Most of my GP practice is part time, and the rest of the week they do private too.

Cloudhoppingdancer · 13/03/2023 09:18

Teddybear120 · 13/03/2023 09:07

The pension arrangements for the current junior doctors are already different to those close to retirement now. It is the pay erosion and change in conditions which is a factor in this strike. However it is also patient saftey but this cannot be the ballot reason for strike, nor can pension rules.

I’m junior doctor.
The pay is worth 25-30% less than 10 years ago, this is the same for many public sector workers with pay freezes and below inflation rises but this can only be swallowed for a certain about of time. Now with inflation being around 10% it has become a real struggle. If rises had been at inflation or closer to it for the last 10 years people wouldn’t be asking for such big rises. This is the same for teachers, police, firefighters, (who have agreed 12% over 2 years), paramedics, nurses, civil servant workers (the list goes on). Each of those have pressures, poor conditions etc. I do not compare my job to my teacher friends etc, of course they deserve pay rises. It isn’t a race to the bottom- in an ideal world we would all have pay restored. Also asking for this high amount is because we are talking about 23/24 (we got 2% in 22/23 which will be not rediscussed) while the nurses etc are all striking over last years pay and pay moving forward so headline figures for settlements in the end may look different but over multiple years may look more similar. Secondly it’s an opening demand- the government are refusing to even sit down with us. I and many of my colleagues will settle for less but you have to start somewhere.

There are conditions to my work that people don’t even realise. I move post every 6 months- working in different teams, different specialities and even different hospitals with different systems I have to learn on my feet. I’ve had friends move 200 miles with no choice and only 8 weeks notice as that is where they are told to go. I regularly get called on my day off asking me to come in and cover and even had an argument with an administrator for 20 minutes that I wasn’t coming in on my day off as I had no childcare options- I was then told my childcare arrangements were not robust enough and I really needed to think about how I could meet the needs of the ward in the future. I already pay a premium for flexible childcare and extra care as I can never guarantee my finish time. For a 9 hour shift- I pay for 11 hours of care in the hospital nursery. This is the norm from my experience. I’ve missed funerals, struggled to plan my wedding as I couldn’t get my rota that far in advance to ensure I had time off. This doesn’t even cover my conditions during my actual working hours short staffed, no breaks etc.

Ive been told to leave if I don’t like the conditions. We already are and even if you increase training places etc. you won’t be able to plug the gap quickly. As a society we seem to say well it was worse for me in my job etc. so suck it up. As I said it isn’t a race to the bottom, we should be striving for better for everyone, no dragging everyone down.

I stay in the profession as I care for my patients, there are days I really enjoy my job and I feel like I make a difference. Unfortunately those days are becoming less frequent due to the conditions.

Full disclosure I am not striking as I don’t agree with the 72 hour strike of full withdraw of care but I do support my striking colleagues.

I have huge sympathy with how difficult it is but I don't think there is any wage packet that could fix the problems you're describing. They're problems inherent in the NHS and our childcare system that need to be addressed by the government, not problems to do with not being paid enough.

With respect, each time you're training and moving, you're being invested in and starting out in a new role that you're able to contribute very little to at the start. Any nurse knows when to avoid having an operation as things can be chaos while the junior doctors learn the ropes. In the period of your job progression they you're describing, if you were wanting to be a GP, you would have to sign decisions off with another doctor and ask their advice frequently. This is training, not just working. More experienced doctors are doing their job in training you but it makes sense that they are paid much more.

medicmumma · 13/03/2023 09:17

Because the intelligence, qualifications and dedication needed to be a doctor, as well as the responsibility far outweighs that of being a teacher and a barrister. Both are important jobs in society but do not compare to being responsible for peoples lives.

And with regards to investment banking - they work incredibly hard and yes while their pay per hour is low (not as low as doctors) they have a good gross pay + many other benefits (paid work trips abroad, able to expense meals/travel, an actual desk to work on rather than a bin next to a computer...)

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:17

Lookwhostalking99 · 13/03/2023 09:15

Well if you complaining about an earning potential of 120K per year before topping it up, say soo and see how much support you get. Total and utter greed!

Don't be ridiculous. That's after almost 20 years of making life and death decisions for the benefit of ungrateful people like you. Personally you couldn't pay me enough to have to deal with the whinging, entitled British public.

rookiemere · 13/03/2023 09:16

£120k is a more than healthy annual salary coupled with a generous pension.

Junior doctors pay is a real anomaly, as most other public professionals don't get that huge pay bump in their careers.

I'm not saying it's right that junior doctors get low salaries for the work they do, but I do have concerns that upping that salary means that those on £120k will get even more when it's 3-3 times the average salary in the UK.

Lookwhostalking99 · 13/03/2023 09:15

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:13

Yes. The point being that it isn't hundreds of thousands as the PP said. Of course they can bump it up with private work.

Well if you complaining about an earning potential of 120K per year before topping it up, say soo and see how much support you get. Total and utter greed!

TortolaParadise · 13/03/2023 09:15

Salverus · 13/03/2023 07:08

The majority of the time.

Dn has just started as a teacher - got poor A levels and has a 2.2 from a low ranked uni and is training while working. It's not really comparable with a junior doctor. She's lovely and I'm sure she'll make a good teacher but on paper there's no reason she should earn as much as someone who spent 7 years in training with a very competitive degree and top A levels.

I hear your perspective but high grade/lower grades have little bearing on the quality of practitioner you are/become once in post.

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:13

Lookwhostalking99 · 13/03/2023 09:11

Duh Tech company's make money, NHS spend tax payer money. 🙄

Yes. The point being that it isn't hundreds of thousands as the PP said. Of course they can bump it up with private work.

Lookwhostalking99 · 13/03/2023 09:11

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:10

NHS consultants earn a max of 120k a year. It's hardly tech company levels.

Duh Tech company's make money, NHS spend tax payer money. 🙄

vivainsomnia · 13/03/2023 09:10

Yawn, 🥱 if they don't like it retrain find a new job. Plenty of others will do it, the putty party is growing really old now
Indeed! And then we will have yet another thread about how bad posters' experience was at the hospital, how outrageous it is that they had to wait X hours, how they can get to see a GP, and wondering why they can't train more doctors and what are their taxes paying for....

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:10

x2boys · 13/03/2023 09:08

I guess it's a reward for all the training and exams they have had ti.do and once Drs reach consultant level ,they will be very experienced and i
knowledgeable, it's an incentive to carry on?

NHS consultants earn a max of 120k a year. It's hardly tech company levels.

Cloudhoppingdancer · 13/03/2023 09:09

pico1 · 13/03/2023 09:02

Also, this is nonsense. The “junior” doctor is the first person you meet in the A&E Dept, at the outpatient clinic or on the ward if you become acutely unwell. They are under very indirect supervision for the majority of their training and carry a huge amount of responsibility, particularly out of hours. They are not being minded and mollycoddled through their training as you suggest.

'Junior' covers a wide range of levels of expertise. If you are a doctor, you will know that this is an accurate description of what the job is like at the beginning and for quite some time after that. As they advance, they become better paid and handle more responsibility. They are called junior at stage too, but their pay at that point is not being highlighted today, hence my talking about the initial stages.

Salverus · 13/03/2023 09:08

Lookwhostalking99 · 13/03/2023 09:08

Another day another WWwwaaaaa from the over paid over privileged. All we see is pay this pay that, your winning zero support.

It's all about money, every single thread is started with moaning about we want more money.

Never get ill then?

x2boys · 13/03/2023 09:08

emmylousings · 13/03/2023 09:02

Why can't we level out doctors earnings more evenly across their careers? Seems daft that they are treated like crap and paid relatively poorly for the 1st 10 years, then they become consultants and earn silly money. Noone really needs hundreds of thousands of pounds per annum. I don't think the public sector should pay any salaries that high, in any sector (e.g local govt / universities)

I guess it's a reward for all the training and exams they have had ti.do and once Drs reach consultant level ,they will be very experienced and i
knowledgeable, it's an incentive to carry on?

SamanthaCaine · 13/03/2023 09:08

JeimeHonfUcoim · 13/03/2023 08:48

It's not totally unreasonable to be comparing the junior doctor starting wage with the experienced barista wage.

The starting salary for a junior doctor in their forst post is £29.4ish kpa (don't have the exact figure to hand but definitely below 30) but that's after 7 years in university with a gruelling workload requiring a lot more than 40 hours a week of studying.

If they hadn't bothered with the medical degree and had put that 7 years of dedicated, single minded effort and commitment to excellence into being the best barista they could, then yes they would be on the top rate that pret offers after those 7 years.

However the analogy does then break down, because 14 years later the medical doctor will have at least doubled that salary, and in the cases of the top consultants will have much higher multiples of that, whereas the talented barista might possibly hope to have moved into pret store management but will likely still be under £40k.

Also, the £14.09 per hour is accurate if calculated on the assumption of working just a 45 hour week. In reality many will end up working a lot more than this, but there are attached enhancements for those which would make for maths too complicated to use in a campaigning slogan.

It's totally unreasonable and the BMA should be ashamed for coming up with such an unintelligent, base level advert.

By all means, compare it to the NMW but ultimately what's the point? The public aren't responsible for pay. We pay the required taxes, can vote parties in/out but that's it. I'll support anyone's right to strike but public knowledge of pay doesn't really achieve a lot. I don't know why the public sector has such an obsession with it TBH.

Also a 40 hour/week degree is not gruelling. Hard, yes but lots of non medical undergraduates do 40 hours/week. I did.

Lookwhostalking99 · 13/03/2023 09:08

Another day another WWwwaaaaa from the over paid over privileged. All we see is pay this pay that, your winning zero support.

It's all about money, every single thread is started with moaning about we want more money.

Teddybear120 · 13/03/2023 09:07

rookiemere · 13/03/2023 08:28

I wonder if there is any scope to change/reduce pension arrangements and use that money to pay junior doctors more.

It does seem an odd situation where many doctors retire very early because their pension pot is greater than £1MM, but the starting salary for a number of years is low for a highly skilled profession.

The pension arrangements for the current junior doctors are already different to those close to retirement now. It is the pay erosion and change in conditions which is a factor in this strike. However it is also patient saftey but this cannot be the ballot reason for strike, nor can pension rules.

I’m junior doctor.
The pay is worth 25-30% less than 10 years ago, this is the same for many public sector workers with pay freezes and below inflation rises but this can only be swallowed for a certain about of time. Now with inflation being around 10% it has become a real struggle. If rises had been at inflation or closer to it for the last 10 years people wouldn’t be asking for such big rises. This is the same for teachers, police, firefighters, (who have agreed 12% over 2 years), paramedics, nurses, civil servant workers (the list goes on). Each of those have pressures, poor conditions etc. I do not compare my job to my teacher friends etc, of course they deserve pay rises. It isn’t a race to the bottom- in an ideal world we would all have pay restored. Also asking for this high amount is because we are talking about 23/24 (we got 2% in 22/23 which will be not rediscussed) while the nurses etc are all striking over last years pay and pay moving forward so headline figures for settlements in the end may look different but over multiple years may look more similar. Secondly it’s an opening demand- the government are refusing to even sit down with us. I and many of my colleagues will settle for less but you have to start somewhere.

There are conditions to my work that people don’t even realise. I move post every 6 months- working in different teams, different specialities and even different hospitals with different systems I have to learn on my feet. I’ve had friends move 200 miles with no choice and only 8 weeks notice as that is where they are told to go. I regularly get called on my day off asking me to come in and cover and even had an argument with an administrator for 20 minutes that I wasn’t coming in on my day off as I had no childcare options- I was then told my childcare arrangements were not robust enough and I really needed to think about how I could meet the needs of the ward in the future. I already pay a premium for flexible childcare and extra care as I can never guarantee my finish time. For a 9 hour shift- I pay for 11 hours of care in the hospital nursery. This is the norm from my experience. I’ve missed funerals, struggled to plan my wedding as I couldn’t get my rota that far in advance to ensure I had time off. This doesn’t even cover my conditions during my actual working hours short staffed, no breaks etc.

Ive been told to leave if I don’t like the conditions. We already are and even if you increase training places etc. you won’t be able to plug the gap quickly. As a society we seem to say well it was worse for me in my job etc. so suck it up. As I said it isn’t a race to the bottom, we should be striving for better for everyone, no dragging everyone down.

I stay in the profession as I care for my patients, there are days I really enjoy my job and I feel like I make a difference. Unfortunately those days are becoming less frequent due to the conditions.

Full disclosure I am not striking as I don’t agree with the 72 hour strike of full withdraw of care but I do support my striking colleagues.

rookiemere · 13/03/2023 09:06

emmylousings · 13/03/2023 09:02

Why can't we level out doctors earnings more evenly across their careers? Seems daft that they are treated like crap and paid relatively poorly for the 1st 10 years, then they become consultants and earn silly money. Noone really needs hundreds of thousands of pounds per annum. I don't think the public sector should pay any salaries that high, in any sector (e.g local govt / universities)

I very much agree with this.

Also the hours expected from junior doctors are ludicrous. I know it's just a book, but does seem to chime with some real live experiences in 'This is going to Hurt' where senior consultants are pushing the responsibility and hours on to the junior doctors.

avocadotofu · 13/03/2023 09:04

I think junior doctor pay is truly shocking. I'm a teacher and I think junior doctors should absolutely be paid more. I don't think comparing teacher and doctor pay is particularly helpful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread