Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

More of a WWYD re inherited house

221 replies

Pbbananabagel · 12/03/2023 23:05

So my Sibling and I inherited a house from our parents which they have been living in for the last few years.
with the cost of living crisis obviously money is tight for both our families and I am now desperate to either sell to be honest as it would be a life changing amount of money at present.
my sibling obviously has no intention of leaving but says they cannot buy me out at present due to lack of finance herself but this is really impacting on my family of 4 whereas they only have themself and partner to think of as child is significantly older and at Uni now. They pay all bills and maintenance on the house and I’ve never wanted to demand anything more but I feel like I’m being taking my a mug now.

aibu to be really frustrated? I don’t want to piss them off as they’re the only family I have now but I really need to figure out how to move this issue forward.

OP posts:
lunar1 · 13/03/2023 11:06

Your sister has had a few years of having no rent or mortgage at your expense. It's given her ample opportunity to get herself in a better financial position. The house needs to be sold and you are being taken advantage of.

purplevipersgrass · 13/03/2023 11:06

They moved in and provided care for the mother for two months before her death. She died of cancer and would have had a lot of NHS support if she was anything like my friends who've had cancer — carers and nurses and hospice-at-home service with almost constant care in the last few weeks.

I'm one of those with a growing suspicion that the sister and her partner had a plan. They've done well out of it. Nearly five years rent and mortgage free, and all at the OP's expense.

madamovaries · 13/03/2023 11:02

Did they provide care for your mother? just I think that changes things a bit in their favour.

This might not be a popular opinion, but I think it is never worth falling out with family over money if it's at all avoidable.

I think you need to sit down in a neutral place and have a chat with them, though. They need to see this situation is now unfair on you - you've been generous and you love them - but it's time to sell and split the money.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2023 11:00

Yes, I see what you mean, Allthegoodnamesarechosen

Of course, if a solicitor's been involved they'd have started the proper legal processes around probate and the rest, but that's if one's been involved and this isn't certain

OP will probably need one now though ...

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 13/03/2023 11:00

@Puzzledandpissedoff

When my aunt died , my father was joint executor with the bank. He decided not to inform them, as their charges were high and he was perfectly capable of dealing with it. They never knew.

That was some time ago, but even now , the State and financial institutions are reliant on being given information, there isn’t much interchange between different branches of the process. I suppose that OPs mother was not submitting a self assessment form, so the discontinuation of that would not be a trigger.

speculation of course. But oh the arguments for making a will…….

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/03/2023 11:00

I'd ask them how they'd feel about you moving in too.

purplevipersgrass · 13/03/2023 10:56

You don't have to go through probate if things are very straightforward. A single, only child friend of mine had pooled resources with her mother and they had bought a large house together, with my friend paying 70% of the cost. It was owned outright in joint names. Her mother was ill for a couple of years before her death and put all her bank accounts etc in joint names with her daughter for convenience. On her death the mother had an IHT allowance of £650k (her own £325k allowance and her husband's £325k allowance) which far exceeded the value of her estate. The daughter didn't need probate to remove her mother's name from the deeds of the house or to access her savings.

But to sell the house the OP will need to go through probate. It does also beg the question of the rest of the mother's estate. Jewellery, items of value, money in savings accounts or pension drawdown... What about all these things, OP?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 13/03/2023 10:54

Yes, that is legally the case. But as long as the death is registered, and pensions and benefits have been discontinued, I don’t think that the state is necessarily aware that there is an estate to be wound up ( ages since I had to do this, so I may be out of date). The incentive for probate as an individual who is the executor is to finalise the inheritance!
I think that as long as you continue to pay council tax, the State doesn’t necessarily know there is an estate. If one of the beneficiaries was living in the house at the time of the owners death and has continued to do so, I’m not sure that anyone would ‘find out’ - until of course it has to be sold or even rented out when the whole question of title arises.

of course, not declaring the estate is unlawful, as you say.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2023 10:45

I wonder whether the the estate has ever been probated and declared

Surely they'd have been obliged to do that? While no expert I believe the level of assets at which probate becomes necessary is up to £50k, and with a house involved the estate's going to be over that?

SoonToBeQueenCamilla · 13/03/2023 10:44

Sorry posted too soon

For £80 a month. Please tell me the name of your utility suppliers so I can switch to them.

Thatboymum · 13/03/2023 10:42

I’d personally look at it from the perspective of what would I have done if I hadn’t inherited the house like what would my plans have been then. But I also believe they should be paying you half rent if they refuse to sell. Sometimes you have to be selfish put yourself first

SoonToBeQueenCamilla · 13/03/2023 10:42

Soontobe60 · 13/03/2023 08:12

I’ve calculated that the “upkeep” on my mums empty house over the year since she died is about £1000. So just over £80 a month.

Can I ask how your work that out? I don’t know anywhere in the Uk where you can pay

council tax
standing charges on gas and electricity
use of gas and electric (need to keep the place heated in winter )
buildings insurance ( will be more expensive as it’s unoccupied )
garden maintenance ( if a house )
service charges ( if a flat )

Kennykenkencat · 13/03/2023 10:39

Sorry ArcticSkewer & Puzzledandpissedoff I was quoting someone else but my actual reply to the points didn’t post

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 13/03/2023 10:38

Even if there is no will, the OP should be entitled to an equal share of the estate. However, I wonder whether the the estate has ever been probated and declared, I have a nasty feeling that things have just been allowed to continue with any formal disposal, as any executor ( even if it was ‘just’ the sisters) would have had to put the property on a proper footing.

OP, if your mother did die intestate, and you have not declared the estate, you need to do so asap. I think that if the value of the house and any other property is over £325,000, there will be inheritance tax to pay. Failure to do this amounts to tax evasion.

if there is no will, and the property has not been re- registered in the new owners names, you will not be able to sell the house, because you do not have title.

you need to consult a solicitor , because what you would like to do is conditional on what you can do.

Twofurrycats · 13/03/2023 10:38

Take legal advice.
Ideally your sister should buy you out.
If they can't do that the house needs to be sold.
I would avoid the rental route . The pitfalls are myriad.

Kennykenkencat · 13/03/2023 10:37

Sorry half my message didn’t post.

They took care of the mum for 8 weeks/2months
They have had 4 years free of rent and mortgage

I would turn sisters reply about not being able to sell atm as they are struggling round on her and point out that if she is struggling just paying bills and maintenance on the house then obviously they really can’t afford to go on like that.
You are both struggling and the sale of the house will mean that with the money they can find somewhere that doesn’t have such large outgoings.

Selling the house is the obvious answer if you are both struggling for money

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2023 10:35

They don't owe you any rent. You owe them nursing fees if anything

No, they don't "owe" rent as things stand - it's just been suggested as a possible way to move this forward

... and rightly or wrongly, the nursing fees thing was wiped out when the mum left the property 50/50

ArcticSkewer · 13/03/2023 10:32

Kennykenkencat · 13/03/2023 10:30

So they took care of your Mum while she was in the last stages of life (you didn't, but you could have helped

How? they have paid all bills and maintenance on the house since your Mum passed, but can't even have a conversation with them about putting it on the market and moving on*

They don't owe you any rent. You owe them nursing fees if anything.

Who actually owns the house? You need to tell them you want to sell and work out a way forwards.

What nursing fees?

There are no nursing fees to pay in the situation outlined. Ops mum would have had nhs funded carers going in. This was a sad illness and death from cancer. Nursing home fees are not applicable.

CornishTiger · 13/03/2023 10:31

Another point is that property will be seen as a capital asset should you ever need to claim income related benefits.

You both need to seek some legal advice and your sister needs to speak to a financial advisor to look if they can afford a mortgage to buy you out. If she can’t she needs to either rent or buy a smaller property with the proceeds of sale.

However this can’t continue.

Kennykenkencat · 13/03/2023 10:30

So they took care of your Mum while she was in the last stages of life (you didn't, but you could have helped

How? they have paid all bills and maintenance on the house since your Mum passed, but can't even have a conversation with them about putting it on the market and moving on*

They don't owe you any rent. You owe them nursing fees if anything.

Who actually owns the house? You need to tell them you want to sell and work out a way forwards.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2023 10:29

I also agree that it was highly likely this was a premeditated decision by your sister to move in

The thought had occurred to me Sad

If the awkwardness continues and it's down to "I need the money / well so do I", perhaps the only thing left is to outright ask the sister what she plans to do to resolve this. If nothing's forthcoming that might be the time to mention solicitors - not in a "chuck her out" way, but as a suggestion for resolving something that's beyond the two of them

Blort · 13/03/2023 10:27

Advise your sister that the longer it takes before you are "bought out" - the value of the property will continue to rise and you're still entitled to half. The sooner she does it the better all round.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/03/2023 10:22

ACynicalDad · 13/03/2023 09:42

I would speak to a property lawyer and try to get in writing that they pay you 50% minus agreed maintenance (but not nice to haves which they can do themselves or not at all) and an agreement that they need to buy you out within 2 years or the house goes on the market.
To add to that I know somebody who had a half share in a house, the other person offered to buy them out for x which was under what it was worth, he said fine, if that's what it's worth, I will buy you out for that. So the moral is that some sort of method to agree a fair price is probably worthwhile...

Why minus maintenance? If minus maintenance, it should be plus rent. Op would very likely be quids in there. I think that would be messy.

NevieSticks · 13/03/2023 10:22

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2023 10:09

Agree about legal advice being needed as a priority

I do understand the awkwardness here, and your sister's unlikely to make things easier while she's enjoying a free house, but if probate's been granted and it's now officially half yours I'm wondering about possible financial impacts on you

For a start, should your business fail (god forbid) and you need to claim benefits, the asset may kill any entitlement stone dead - so since your DS already knows you're struggling I wonder if that would provide a way to move this forward?

Overall I agree with most PPs that she needs to pay rent less half the maintenance costs, but from what you've said I doubtt that'll be popular either

This is a very good point. @Pbbananabagel you need to lay this out to your sister as you have to us and tell her that you both need to come together and resolve this. Tell her you are also going to ask for advice as to how you both can progress this. It was an asset and should have been sold at the time.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/03/2023 10:19

billy1966 · 13/03/2023 09:29

I also agree that it was highly likely this was a premeditated decision by your sister to move in.

She has gained spectacularly financially and her reluctance to leave is telling.

I try not to be bad minded but your sister sounds calculating and is depending on your being a doormat in this matter.

I would go back to the solicitor first to get legal advice.

Do not rent to her.
Find out the rent amout the house would have garnered and present that figure to her.

The house needs to be sold.

It does seem rather calculated. I’m presuming your sister / bil were renting. Moving in short term would not have warranted giving up a rental.

I can imagine you’d have been fine for your mum to pay for your sister’s rent whilst she was caring for her of money was tight. I understand they were giving your dm care, which she probably preferred to being in a care home and / or hospital. Much as I imagine you’re grateful to them, this really was a choice and as it has already been pointed out that short term end of life care is not chargeable.

As for half the back rent, I’m not sure if op could get it Billy. That would make it very messy. My concern would be adverse possession. If you don’t force the situation op, your sister can try to lay claim to your half of the property after 10 years. She could win.

Swipe left for the next trending thread