Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

More of a WWYD re inherited house

221 replies

Pbbananabagel · 12/03/2023 23:05

So my Sibling and I inherited a house from our parents which they have been living in for the last few years.
with the cost of living crisis obviously money is tight for both our families and I am now desperate to either sell to be honest as it would be a life changing amount of money at present.
my sibling obviously has no intention of leaving but says they cannot buy me out at present due to lack of finance herself but this is really impacting on my family of 4 whereas they only have themself and partner to think of as child is significantly older and at Uni now. They pay all bills and maintenance on the house and I’ve never wanted to demand anything more but I feel like I’m being taking my a mug now.

aibu to be really frustrated? I don’t want to piss them off as they’re the only family I have now but I really need to figure out how to move this issue forward.

OP posts:
AnotherEmma · 13/03/2023 13:16

YANBU, obviously. You need to talk to your sister, get an estate agent to view the property and provide a valuation, and then reach an agreement about whether to sell, or alternatively for her to pay you rent, but that's messy so I think selling would be better. If she won't talk to you or agree, you'll need a solicitor specialising in property disputes. See if you can find a collaborative one so it can be resolved with minimum conflict and expense. If you can use mediation or ADR that would help. Obviously court would be a last resort.

Do also be aware that if you are otherwise eligible for Universal Credit (or other means-tested benefit), owning half a property that you don't live in would potentially wipe out any benefit entitlement.

Pheasantplucker2 · 13/03/2023 13:12

Sorry, I missed the years bit! Definitely send the above and include how long they've been living there rent free. Perhaps add in something to say

As you are aware you've been living there without paying rent for x years. A quick look on rightmove shows that similar properties are renting out for £x a month, so in essence you've had (£x x number of months/2) out of the inheritance. However, I'm willing to move forward from this providing you start paying me rent and we have an agreed date by which time you will put the house on the market or buy me out.

Pheasantplucker2 · 13/03/2023 13:06

I'd say something along the following lines.

Dear sis I really don't want to fall out over this. However, the house belongs to us 50:50 and I have given you six month's grace in view of all the help you gave you mum, but I now need to access my half of the inheritance.

Going forward from 1 April (or whenever you think is fair) and until we reach a long term agreement, we need agree what the current market rate of the monthly rental value is and split the cost - in effect, so you pay me half of what it's worth. We should get three estate agents round to value it for both rental and sale. As with any standard rental, you are liable for all bills whilst you're living there, and we will split any maintenance costs.

The options are obviously either we sell the house and split the value or you buy me out. Please talk it over with [your partner] and let me know what your thoughts are.

Love you

sis

Kennykenkencat · 13/03/2023 13:06

JemimaTiggywinkles · 13/03/2023 12:01

Can't they get a mortgage for half the value of the house and buy you out? That way they can stay in the property and you have a chunk to pay off your own mortgage.

They are already stretched just paying bills and maintenance although I would use that to get them to sell as they are clearly struggling in a house that they can’t afford.

Knitterofcrap · 13/03/2023 12:56

Sorry OP but you have already let this situation drag on for years! Why?

Speak to her again and say if she hasn’t vacated by (three months time) you will have to instruct solicitors. Who were the executors and why have they failed to enact the provisions of the will?

Honeyroar · 13/03/2023 12:53

Ps, I think I’d move in with your sister and live in your half of the house - see if that spurs her into selling it! Let your house out.

eirlaw · 13/03/2023 12:53

You need to be firmer in discussing this - and if they won't then see a solicitor and maybe get them to write a letter to see if that focuses their minds to find a way forward.

Honeyroar · 13/03/2023 12:51

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2023 11:51

They have suspended council tax on my dad’s house and are paying his winter fuel payments until probate goes through

I didn't know they continued to pay the winter fuel help, but thought council tax was still levied on empty houses - though possibly at a reduced rate depending on area?

Once probate has gone through and the house belongs to someone again, even if it’s empty the council tax will have to be paid, but until probate has gone through it’s kind of in limbo, so nobody officially owns it to pay it..

I was surprised when they wrote to me to say they would still pay my late father’s winter fuel payment, and also delighted as it’s meant we could put a little heat into the house over winter - we were wondering how to afford that when we’re already stretched to the max paying our own bills. And obviously we can’t sell anything to fund the bills until probate goes through..

user1492757084 · 13/03/2023 12:34

Foremost is that you keep the relationship nice.
Family is your most valuable asset.
Suggest that both you and your sister sit down with a mediator to brainstorm an acceptable and fair solution.

Perhaps do that once a fortnight two or three times until all partners also agree and then set it in place with a lawyer.
What is happening now is unfair. The current arrangement has gone on long enough for your sister's kindness to your mother to have been repaid.
Options -
Selling house and splitting proceeds.
All living in house and all contributing to all costs.
Sister staying in house and paying 1/2 rent, 1/2 maintenence and rates costs and all utilities.
Renting house to another entity, sister and you share costs and income.
Short term - lodger or two in two rooms of the house and lodger pays income to you and pays 1/2 utilities, you pay 1/2 rates and maintenence.

Viviennemary · 13/03/2023 12:21

Who is dealing with the will. And has the house and other assets been through probate which is legally requiired. At some point the ownership of the house will need to be transferred to the new owners. You usually get six months suspension of council tax on an empty house after a death.

BlackFriday · 13/03/2023 12:17

They've been living in it for a few years now? Rent free?
Crikey. Lucky them.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2023 12:15

Can't they get a mortgage for half the value of the house and buy you out?

OP said her sister couldn't afford to do this, though whether she really can't or just prefers not to while she's enjoying a free ride is unknowable

Stupidly I only just realised this has been going on for ages - like a fool I read that she'd moved in 2 months before the mum died but didn't twig that was years ago

Nice work if you can get it Hmm

Monster80 · 13/03/2023 12:13

Equity release should allow them to release your interest/share of the property and would leave them to pay a mortgage to the bank on the released amount, which seems fair enough? Often happens in divorce cases where one party wants to be bought out, but the other wants to remain at the house.

billy1966 · 13/03/2023 12:04

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/03/2023 10:19

It does seem rather calculated. I’m presuming your sister / bil were renting. Moving in short term would not have warranted giving up a rental.

I can imagine you’d have been fine for your mum to pay for your sister’s rent whilst she was caring for her of money was tight. I understand they were giving your dm care, which she probably preferred to being in a care home and / or hospital. Much as I imagine you’re grateful to them, this really was a choice and as it has already been pointed out that short term end of life care is not chargeable.

As for half the back rent, I’m not sure if op could get it Billy. That would make it very messy. My concern would be adverse possession. If you don’t force the situation op, your sister can try to lay claim to your half of the property after 10 years. She could win.

Gosh no, I'm not suggesting she go for backnrent at all, but having the figure would be helpful as it has gone on for several years and she is still claiming things are tough.

Living rent/morgage free is a very lucky position to be in and she has done this for several years now.

I suggested it to give the OP a fuller picture.

She moved home for a couple of months?
2 or 3 months?
So a six month period would have been a very reasonable stay to gather herself and to prepare for the houses selling.

Renting as a couple is hugely easier to do than for a family IMO.

I think it is important your mum's solicitor is contacted.

As @Mummyoflittledragon rightly points out, the longer this is allowed to continue, the more difficult it may become.

I think a paper trail is import to create to indicate previous conversations where you have asked that this situation be resolved.

Your sister may hope her persistent refusal to leave causes you to give up!

JemimaTiggywinkles · 13/03/2023 12:01

Can't they get a mortgage for half the value of the house and buy you out? That way they can stay in the property and you have a chunk to pay off your own mortgage.

Kennykenkencat · 13/03/2023 11:54

SoonToBeQueenCamilla · 13/03/2023 10:42

Can I ask how your work that out? I don’t know anywhere in the Uk where you can pay

council tax
standing charges on gas and electricity
use of gas and electric (need to keep the place heated in winter )
buildings insurance ( will be more expensive as it’s unoccupied )
garden maintenance ( if a house )
service charges ( if a flat )

I think Soontobe60 was meaning maintaining the house. Stuff that goes wrong like a leaky tap or clearing the guttering.
Bills are something else but things were paid a year in advance before Soontobe60 took over the house

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2023 11:51

They have suspended council tax on my dad’s house and are paying his winter fuel payments until probate goes through

I didn't know they continued to pay the winter fuel help, but thought council tax was still levied on empty houses - though possibly at a reduced rate depending on area?

HowdoIgetbacktothe80s · 13/03/2023 11:48

I am pretty certain my sister and dad have this ‘plan’. She and her bf rent and can not afford their own home. My parents Will is split between my dsis and I. My mum has Alzheimer’s and dad doesn’t cope very well, even at these earlier stages of the disease. He keeps hinting to my sister that she and her bf are welcome to come and live with them and they should give up renting. My sister has said to me that dad wants to move them in and they will probably do so (she will still expect me to go in and help my parents the 5 days a week that I currently do, as she works FT). If this scenario occurs and my parents eventually pass I know my dsis and partner will never move out. I don’t know what the answer is op but I think you should get legal advice.

Honeyroar · 13/03/2023 11:44

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 13/03/2023 10:54

Yes, that is legally the case. But as long as the death is registered, and pensions and benefits have been discontinued, I don’t think that the state is necessarily aware that there is an estate to be wound up ( ages since I had to do this, so I may be out of date). The incentive for probate as an individual who is the executor is to finalise the inheritance!
I think that as long as you continue to pay council tax, the State doesn’t necessarily know there is an estate. If one of the beneficiaries was living in the house at the time of the owners death and has continued to do so, I’m not sure that anyone would ‘find out’ - until of course it has to be sold or even rented out when the whole question of title arises.

of course, not declaring the estate is unlawful, as you say.

Nowadays when someone dies and you go to get the death certificate you are registered for “say it once” or “tell it once” which means that all things linked to government are notified, such as pensions, driving licences, council tax etc. So usually they will be aware at the local council. They have suspended council tax on my dad’s house and are paying his winter fuel payments until probate goes through. So in this case the sister could be doing very well out of living in the house!

OP I think you need to take legal advice- tell your sister that you are going to, and that it might cost her money financially too if she continues to sit in your share of the house refusing to sell or buy out. Life doesn’t work like that. She will have to buy something else with her share of the proceeds. That may mean living in a smaller property, but that’s life. (and hello from another coffee van owner!)

GettingStuffed · 13/03/2023 11:41

Who was the executor? It's this job to make sure that wishes in the will are carried out. We're in a similar position with MiL's house but DD is living rent few as they'll be clearing the house and doing any DIY that needs doing.

poetryandwine · 13/03/2023 11:38

OP,

When I suggested seeing a solicitor on p1 if this thread, most of the reason was because of what I wrote but I did also wonder about probate.

I have just done some searching and it appears that if your DM was the only living person on the title of her house then her estate is required to go through probate. Please don’t take my word, or blindly follow anyone who says probate is unnecessary. A solicitor can tell you for sure.

The executor of your DM’s will should be administering the settlement of the estate, including making sure you have access to your share. If your sister or her DH is the executor, your solicitor can advise you about conflict of interest which will interest the court very much in this case.

I know money is tight but you are entitled to half a house! Many solicitors will give a free 30 minute consultation and a number will take payment after settlement. You really need one.

SoonToBeQueenCamilla · 13/03/2023 11:29

As Pp said , you need legal advice so you know the options. Then you need a discussion with your sister.

you may also need other advice , eg an accountant or a letting agent.

For example , Pp have said “ you might get £500 / month for rent “. But you will have to pay half of all repairs and maintenance , insurance etc . And you will have to pay tax on any profit you make.

£6,000 a year might sounds a lot, but costs will be high. If your sister wants a new kitchen, how will you decide if the budget is £5k or £10k?

What is she wants the place redecorated but you think it’s fine ?

Do you know the legal duties that you would have as a landlord ? Do things like annual gas safety checks, PAT tests, EICR apply if your tenant is also a part owner ? Whose job will it be to deal with these things? Who will pay for the legal documents that will be required ?

what will you do if your Sister stops paying rent ? Perhaps for a genuine reason like she loses her job?

What if she stops paying because you refuse to replace her carpets or the gas bills are too high ? Tenants stop paying for reasons like this all the time.

Do you really want to go down that route ? Because if your sister was going to be reasonable , you wouldn't be where you are today .

People think that being a landlord is money for old rope but it can be a nightmare, especially with difficult tenants. So you need to information so you can consider each option carefully before you offer it to her.

In your situation I would want it sold , either to your sister ( at market value) or to a third party.

Bollindger · 13/03/2023 11:25

I think You need to sit down with them and remind them you own half the house, say you need them to realise while it is a join assset, so long as you also own half then your also going to be repeating equity as the house price rises.
That if they get a mortgage they will own the house in full, and as they would be paying the same in rent why would they not want to own all of the house .

Btrsun10 · 13/03/2023 11:24

So, I was this sibling. Parent very ill, I was renting so moved back home.
When parent died, my siblings did not want to sell and so I stayed in the house and paid the bills etc. I also paid for a heating upgrade along with a new roof.
Siblings thought they were doing me a good turn and at first we were all very happy with the arrangement.
The whole time I lived there after parent died, I felt most uncomfortable although my siblings insisted they were delighted with the arrangement and wanted me to stay. Eventually, after much persistence on my part, we decided to sell.
I knew all along that we would eventually have to sell and with the market rising and rising I was going to be left in a situation where I'd be priced out of ever buying my own home again.
In fact, I did very badly on the deal. What I put into the house was much more than I would have paid on rent and any rise in the value on the house was wiped out when it was divided equally.
However, I would say that I have an excellent relationship with my siblings and we are very close. I can see how this could have ended in tears if I'd allowed it to.
Best to get it sorted ASAP and save your relationship.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 13/03/2023 11:08

Oof. I think you need a (ideally in writing) exchange with your sister which is explicitly about the future of the house / your plans and hers. Because otherwise this can easily roll into decades of "same old" and then an explosive family break-up, in the worst case scenario. I'd also echo PP's suggestions of getting legal advice.