Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS is beyond repair?

157 replies

NHSisfallingapart · 12/03/2023 22:04

DS has been unwell with chickenpox. A couple of the blisters looked like they might be infected. It’s a Sunday and the GP is closed, when I rand their after hours line it just goes dead. I rang 111 for advice at noon and have been waiting for a return pcall ever since. Someone rang me a few hours ago to ask whether I stil want to speak with someone. They could not provide an estimate of when I will receive a return call and told me it’s a 24 hour service and I may be called at any hour.

AIBU to think the standard of care provided by the NHS is inadequate? I suspect DS needs antibiotics and I can’t do anything about it.

OP posts:
Zebedee55 · 13/03/2023 04:52

The NHS needs root and branch reform as much as it needs extra funds.

Even Labour say it needs to change.

labourlist.org/2023/01/labours-plans-to-reform-the-nhs-continue-to-attract-criticism/

EnterChasedByAMemory · 13/03/2023 03:22

XenoBitch · 12/03/2023 22:29

I have called 999 and had an ambulance attend for a panic attack. I didn't know it was one... I literally thought I was going to drop down dead. If I had known what it was, I would have used my coping mechanisms and dealt with it myself.
No one calls an ambulance if they know they are having a panic attack.

@XenoBitch, I have no idea who you are or what your health conditions are but as you are quoting me, I might as well respond.

I was responding to another poster who had mentioned someone calling the ambulance because of a panic attack. So I merely responded on the basis of what I had just read on this thread.

I am glad to hear that you’re fine now. My concerns were more for the lack of funding, possibilities of a privatised healthcare and people needing to have access to mental health services etc. not to mention that ambulances might be more occupied so they won’t be able to respond promptly.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 03:20

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 03:00

2010 NHS was judged the most efficient healthcare system in the world.
An NHS can not by itself make people live healthier lives. Smoking used to be very common. Government laws changed that.

Show me. Because I'm looking at the headline, uk is best performing and it's in 2014, although they might be based on 2013 figures, to be fair.

www.candi.nhs.uk/news/nhs-declared-world%E2%80%99s-best-healthcare-system#:~:text=The%20NHS%20has%20been%20declared,produced%20by%20the%20Commonwealth%20Fund

And if you follow through to the reports you can go back to 2010, where we were 2nd out out of fewer countries. If you go ahead, it reports for 2021. The UK has fallen to 4th, behind Norway, the Netherlands and Australia. But ahead of Germany, NZ, Sweden, France Swizerland, Canada and the US. Not great but hardly dreadful.

EnterChasedByAMemory · 13/03/2023 03:09

EnterChasedByAMemory · 13/03/2023 03:08

The Tories have been in power for over a decade and who knows if that will continue for another decade? What if it’s too little, too late? Sad

I can’t help but think that so much change in the next 2 years by the time we have another general election. I mean I’m not even sure how many people spoke about Rishi Sunak undoing the work of the Labour Party about how they inherited a bunch of formulas where the funding went to poor deprived urban areas in a leaked footage months ago. And last I checked, he’s still the PM and there hasn’t been this massive outrage for him to step down etc.

There needs to be more accountability and checks and balances in place about how much funding goes into each area so all constituents benefit from government funding whether they are in a rich area or a deprived one. I am not sure how much the Opposition party is holding the Tories to account?

Another thing, are salaries being paid to match inflation? People are striking not just for a pay rise, but for their salaries match inflation. Meanwhile, it was recently reported that MPs did get a pay rise. It’s mind-boggling by the amount of daylight robbery.

so much can change*

EnterChasedByAMemory · 13/03/2023 03:08

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:16

The Tories nearly destroyed the NHS last time but did not succeed. It was brought back from life support by Labour. It will be again.

The Tories have been in power for over a decade and who knows if that will continue for another decade? What if it’s too little, too late? Sad

I can’t help but think that so much change in the next 2 years by the time we have another general election. I mean I’m not even sure how many people spoke about Rishi Sunak undoing the work of the Labour Party about how they inherited a bunch of formulas where the funding went to poor deprived urban areas in a leaked footage months ago. And last I checked, he’s still the PM and there hasn’t been this massive outrage for him to step down etc.

There needs to be more accountability and checks and balances in place about how much funding goes into each area so all constituents benefit from government funding whether they are in a rich area or a deprived one. I am not sure how much the Opposition party is holding the Tories to account?

Another thing, are salaries being paid to match inflation? People are striking not just for a pay rise, but for their salaries match inflation. Meanwhile, it was recently reported that MPs did get a pay rise. It’s mind-boggling by the amount of daylight robbery.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 03:04

Yes lots of rich people would make a lot of money out of the sale of the NHS.
And healthcare would become like dentistry. Available mainly to the well off.

Emotionalstorm · 13/03/2023 03:02

They should just sell it off and put it out of its misery. I would be interested in buying some shares if it was publicly listed.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 03:00

2010 NHS was judged the most efficient healthcare system in the world.
An NHS can not by itself make people live healthier lives. Smoking used to be very common. Government laws changed that.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 02:58

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:29

WHO assesses it as the best system. That did not mean it was perfect.
I could always get a GP appointment. And I could get seen quickly by specialists, not like now.

Hmm. In 2010 the UK was ranked 2nd behind Netherlands when comparing 7 countries. Out of the 9 categories judged, it came 1st in 2.

It was in 2014 when the UK was ranked 1st out of 11 countries. Out of the same 9 categories it came 1st in 6, 2nd in 1, 3rd in another. And 10th in another. So second to last. And in fact that last category is most telling. We came 2nd to last in 2010 as well. And it was for healthy lives. And that tells us something about the problems we have with the nhs. We don't live healthy lives which puts strain on the system.

Back to yourvpoint, I'm struggling to remember, but in 2014, who was in power?

Actually I hate any of this being political. The NHS should be taken out of political hands and given to a board of professionals to make decisions. It's funding should be on a formula that all parties agree with and political hands should be kept off.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:33

You have to understand that no system is perfect. When france was judged the best by WHO I had French friends who would complain about their health system.

But the NHS was objectively better under labour. Waiting times were way lower, ambulances were usually sent quickly, and other services like physio were much easier to access. The stats show all this clearly.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:29

WHO assesses it as the best system. That did not mean it was perfect.
I could always get a GP appointment. And I could get seen quickly by specialists, not like now.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 02:26

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:16

The NHS was externally judged the best healthcare system in the world in 2010.

By who? By people who were told to go for follow up appointments in two weeks but receptionists wouldn't give them an appointment because it was outside the two day rule. But when they rang in two weeks they couldn't get a free appointment?
Who voted it the best system in the world?

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 13/03/2023 02:20

Seventytwosunsetstrip · 13/03/2023 02:17

I thought it was 'free speech' - my bad.

who is denying you your free speech?

you can post what you like and people can respond to it as they like.

that's how internet forums usually work.

try not to be so sensitive.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:19

We need to remove the government that are doing their best to kill the NHS.

Seventytwosunsetstrip · 13/03/2023 02:17

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 13/03/2023 02:14

Oh we've got a good little tory spinning the 'akshully it's Labour's fault' line.

any moment now Clavinaoa will be along to take over the second shift with their cut and paste links.

I thought it was 'free speech' - my bad.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:16

The Tories nearly destroyed the NHS last time but did not succeed. It was brought back from life support by Labour. It will be again.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:16

The NHS was externally judged the best healthcare system in the world in 2010.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 02:14

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 01:42

In 2010 it was judged the best health system in the world.

By Tony Blair!! 😅 Wasn't it him that brought in the rule that you had to be seen within two days of making an appointment. But gps didn't have that capacity so if they couldn't give you an appointment within two days, they'd tell you yto ring back next morning.

So everyone went and queued outside the surgery at 8.30 (I saw really elderly people standing in snow once) because they couldn't get through on the phone. And then at some point the receptionist would come out and say no more appointments and they'd all groan and shuffle off home. But it looked great on the figures. This had been going on for a couple of years and remember TB being on an interview show where the audience could ask him questions. Someone brought this up and he was genuinely surprised this was happening. 🤦 How could he not know? To be fair to him, though, I think he did go on to rescind that instruction.

I totally agree that they spent money and brought down waiting lists, some improvements we're still paying for today, but let's not talk like the nhs was functioning fantastically. I mean, how can any health system that is refusing to give sick people an appointment be reasonably voted the best health system in the world!

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 13/03/2023 02:14

Oh we've got a good little tory spinning the 'akshully it's Labour's fault' line.

any moment now Clavinaoa will be along to take over the second shift with their cut and paste links.

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 13/03/2023 02:11

Beyond repair is precisely what the government would like you to think. Their comms team will be pleased.

Seventytwosunsetstrip · 13/03/2023 02:10

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:08

@Seventytwosunsetstrip You are not discussing this in good faith. You are derailing with rubbish and ignoring the stats posted about how the NHS was much better under labour than the tories.

Labour can't run the NHS in Wales it seems;

www.countytimes.co.uk/news/20154194.opinion-labour-breaking-wrong-records-nhs-wales/

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:08

@Seventytwosunsetstrip You are not discussing this in good faith. You are derailing with rubbish and ignoring the stats posted about how the NHS was much better under labour than the tories.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 02:07

People can not have cosmetic surgery unless they have issues like severe burns. Any nose surgery will be medical need.
You have an extremely narrow idea of medical need. Being able to breathe properly by having polyps removed from your nose is not immediatelu life threatening, but untreated it will affect your ability to breathe and this your life. The NHS should not become an emergency service only.

Seventytwosunsetstrip · 13/03/2023 02:06

Blossomtoes · 13/03/2023 01:59

That Guardian piece is 23 years old, printed when the Blair government was still adhering to Tory spending plans. Try my link to show what rubbish you’re talking.

What link?

And why was Blair using Tory spending plans if they were no good?

NHSisfallingapart · 13/03/2023 02:04

@CanOfPop heres the NHS advice to contact a GP straight away if blisters show signs of infection. I’m sure this has always been the case? Again to be clear, I’m not expecting emergency treatment straight away on a Sunday morning, but was seeking out of hours advice, which is what 111 is designed for (and indeed the call handler determined we needed to speak with a GP). It may also be that advice has changed for younger parents as we’ve learned more about secondary bacterial infection turning to sepsis among children with chickenpox - not just any old blisters

www.nhsinform.scot/illnesses-and-conditions/infections-and-poisoning/chickenpox

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread