Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS is beyond repair?

157 replies

NHSisfallingapart · 12/03/2023 22:04

DS has been unwell with chickenpox. A couple of the blisters looked like they might be infected. It’s a Sunday and the GP is closed, when I rand their after hours line it just goes dead. I rang 111 for advice at noon and have been waiting for a return pcall ever since. Someone rang me a few hours ago to ask whether I stil want to speak with someone. They could not provide an estimate of when I will receive a return call and told me it’s a 24 hour service and I may be called at any hour.

AIBU to think the standard of care provided by the NHS is inadequate? I suspect DS needs antibiotics and I can’t do anything about it.

OP posts:
Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 11:20

The waste and inefficiency is the problem, not lack of money (although more money is also needed).

My son has finally got an appointment for a scan of a growth on his neck. He first consulted his GP about it a year ago. GP "referred" him for a scan but said it may be a long wait! After six months, he contacted surgery to chase it up, only to be told that the referral had been rejected, but the receptionist didn't know why. A few days later, a GP rang back to say it had been rejected because the GP hadn't done a blood test and for him to book a blood test! (how long would the GP have left it before they bothered telling DS!). Once blood test done, referred again, another 6 months, still nothing heard, so DS phoned GP surgery again, only to be told it had been rejected again (apparently not even sent to scan dept, both times were "rejected" within the GP surgery by a more senior GP! A few weeks ago, he went for his annual dental check up and the dentist mentioned the growth - DS told her he'd been trying to get it checked out via the GP, but without success - dentist said she'd refer him herself to the maxillofacial dept, he got an appointment quickly and now he's got a scan appointment next month. So finally getting somewhere by going via a different route, not via the GP! The GPs do seem to be the problem by just "fobbing" off which causes more GP appointments needed in the long run!

Blossomtoes · 13/03/2023 10:44

A slightly more red chicken pox spot does not need seen on a Sunday. It's not a weekend GP service.

It doesn’t need to be seen at all. It needs extra calamine lotion.

cornflakegeneration · 13/03/2023 10:20

NHSisfallingapart · 13/03/2023 01:10

Sorry I’ve not been clear. I don’t expect to be seen on a Sunday evening with this. I rang 111 at 11 am on Sunday for advice, after DS woke up pointing out one spot that was larger, redder and more painful than the others, and having taken pictures of the spots that look infected. Was told I needed to speak to a clinician, someone would ring me back but they had “no idea” when. I received a call at 8 pm (nine hours later) asking if I’d still like to wait in the queue, and they still had no idea when someone would ring. Only that it’s a 24 hour service and someone could ring at any hour. Obviously it’s not a life-threatening emergency and I’m not expecting an ambulance at the door or anything.

my hope was that someone could review the picture and provide a prescription for antibiotics, so we wouldn’t have to attend A&E or a GP surgery in person and put others at risk of infection.

But people will be calling 111 on a Sunday because they've got a baby with a sky high temperature, a painful ear infection that is not responding to painkillers and in excruciating pain or if their asthma is playing up and they're struggling to breathe. These are the people they are dealing with and that's why you were waiting so long.

A slightly more red chicken pox spot does not need seen on a Sunday. It's not a weekend GP service.

cornflakegeneration · 13/03/2023 10:16

Rewind20Years · 12/03/2023 23:22

I thought i was having a mild stroke last week
I didnt call an ambulance
Partner drove me there

Major Trauma Hospital (with helipad)
It was very very busy. Nowhere to sit

I was assessed straight away and saw the stroke team within 10 minutes
Within 30 minutes i had seen a stroke nurse, had a CT Scan and had blood tests

Can not fault them…
If it really is an emergency, You do get seen

This.
And I can only assume that 111 have assessed your situation as not being urgent which is why they haven't called back.

blebbleb · 13/03/2023 08:44

Yes. A mix of underfunding and an aging u healthy population. I know people who have gone to a&e for a black finger nail when it was shut in a door! Stuff like that needs no more than a GP or pharmacy visit.

Pastadanca · 13/03/2023 08:28

Bovril2000 · 13/03/2023 07:43

It's completely beyond repair and has been for some time. No amount of funding will fix it now - the waste and the way funds are badly managed are crippling it from the inside.

I waited recently 17 hours for a callback from 111 - by the time the call arrived, I was in A&E which is where I should have gone in the first place. I would never use 111 again. If you can afford it, take out health insurance to cover as much as possible. I just wish there were a private A&E - there's definitely a demand for one!

What do you means by funding being badly managed? Any examples? (And not T&T which wasn't procured by the NHS). Sure there's some, but they have to adhere to PCR 2015 just like all other public sector spending- so what examples?

cptartapp · 13/03/2023 08:10

You could have googled the nearest out of hours pharmacy and gone there. Somethings these things respond better to topical antibiotic cream you can buy over the counter.

Blossomtoes · 13/03/2023 07:50

Seventytwosunsetstrip · 13/03/2023 02:06

What link?

And why was Blair using Tory spending plans if they were no good?

This one

www.kingsfund.org.uk/sites/default/files/summary-high-performing-nhs-progress-review-1997-2010-ruth-thorlby-jo-maybin-kings-fund-april-2010_0.pdf

Blair used Tory spending plans for the first two years because it was in their manifesto in 1997, that’s what they were voted in to do. And, by the way, he never had any inclination to sell off the NHS, he knew it would be electoral suicide - and that man knew how to win elections.

Bovril2000 · 13/03/2023 07:43

It's completely beyond repair and has been for some time. No amount of funding will fix it now - the waste and the way funds are badly managed are crippling it from the inside.

I waited recently 17 hours for a callback from 111 - by the time the call arrived, I was in A&E which is where I should have gone in the first place. I would never use 111 again. If you can afford it, take out health insurance to cover as much as possible. I just wish there were a private A&E - there's definitely a demand for one!

Swiftbushome · 13/03/2023 07:32

I find 111 to be fucking useless personally. I once had to call them because my 3 year old was struggling with breathing over night. He had a viral infection and I was thinking maybe it was just that so didn't want to go nuts and rush him straight to A and E in the middle of the night if I was overreacting and he maybe needed to rest. But I was scared so I rang for advice on whether I should take him. I waited ages and eventually got a call back.from a doctor who asked me loads of questions and eventually said to take him to the GP the next morning. I stayed awake watching him all night then took him to the doctor in the morning. Who called a fucking ambulance and stuck him on a nebuliser while we were waiting for it to arrive. He also asked me why I hadn't taken him to A&E last night. When we got to hospital I was asked accusingly by 5 different staff members as to why I hadn't taken him in before since he was in such a bad way. He is fine now (thank god) but it was traumatic. Especially with everyone apparently thinking I was negligent for not bringing him in earlier. BUT IM NOT MEDICAL!! I just don't know this stuff. I realise I have a tendency to panic and I don't trust my judgement so I got advice from a doctor and acted on it. So the PP with the rat bite got good service from 111 which is great but I cam tell you they were worse than useless for us. I would have taken him in if it wasn't for 111 telling me he didn't need to go. And we're so used to having "don't just go to A&E" drummed into us 24/7.

Emotionalstorm · 13/03/2023 07:32

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 06:44

If the Tories are running it into the ground why is it rated higher than, France, Germany, Canada, Sweden, etc?

Because it's not true but Mumsnet is full if left wing communist fans.

Pastadanca · 13/03/2023 06:56

iloveeverykindofcat · 13/03/2023 06:29

@Pastadanca That's exactly what happened to me though? A doctor phoned me back within twenty minutes, and sent me to an appointment at a minor injuries clinic. I don't know if it was because it was an animal bite and they were worried about disease control or what, but I couldn't have asked for prompter service.

Goof for you? Do you not believe the many people who have not had that experience? It should always work as you found it, but it absolutely doesn't. This isn't the fault of the call handlers, its because many areas don't have the appointments to give out or the HCPs to call back in a reasonable time frame.

Florissant · 13/03/2023 06:45

Enthrallingstoryofstillnessandlight · 13/03/2023 01:20

Totally agree 👍

Another who agrees.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 06:44

If the Tories are running it into the ground why is it rated higher than, France, Germany, Canada, Sweden, etc?

ladyofshertonabbas · 13/03/2023 06:41

yabu. Why were you ringing, you literally diagnosed the problem in your post. If anything, go and speak to a pharmacist.

MarshaBradyo · 13/03/2023 06:36

We’ve had good service with ABs on a Saturday, not sure about Sunday though

A few things going on, massive advances so we live longer with complex needs, even stuff like knee and hip replacements going up (look at the projected stats it’s eye watering). Age related plus social care causes back logs so money needed there. Plus unhealthy population that could improve.

If people want to pay more that’s ok, it’s tax payers after all that fund it.

Apricotlemonade · 13/03/2023 06:30

Sorry I don’t understand why the op couldn’t wait until the next day ie Monday for infected chickenpox blisters. What do you think is going to happen between Sunday night and Monday that needs an immediate response.

I agree with a lot of what has been said on hear re the Tories running it into the ground and Labour absolutely being able to rebuild it again however we do need to take some responsibility re expectations.

iloveeverykindofcat · 13/03/2023 06:29

@Pastadanca That's exactly what happened to me though? A doctor phoned me back within twenty minutes, and sent me to an appointment at a minor injuries clinic. I don't know if it was because it was an animal bite and they were worried about disease control or what, but I couldn't have asked for prompter service.

Pastadanca · 13/03/2023 06:21

People keep saying about funding, yes some areas are undoubtedly inefficient, but the demands on the NHS are greater than ever before, and equipment is more expensive than ever. An MRI machine for example is amazing but bloody expensive to buy and run, same with other equipment that's being rolled out. Agency pay takes up a lot of money, but they're only used if desperate.

Until they sort out staffing it'll continue to be below par. 111 for example should be an excellent tool, but as is its pointless! If you could phone it and speak to a clinical fairly quickly, or even better if there were actually appointments they could sign post you to ie out of hours then it'd be great; but there's not the infrastructure behind it to allow that which redness it largely pointless. Had to go to minor injuries the other week, the wait was 6 hours (DS had split his head open)- the nurse said she was the only nurse in and there was 1 doctor and a HCA; madness.

It could be saved but the tories won't.

iloveeverykindofcat · 13/03/2023 06:14

I found 111 to go above and beyond. A while ago I got bitten by a rat that I was trying to help escape my home before my cat got it. I wasn't worried, but I was so surprised when it screamed, flew into my hands and bit me 3 times that I texted my friend in a 'ha ha you won't believe what just happened' and they immediately told me to call 111 because they carry diseases. So I did, and 111 called me back within 20 minutes and sent me to a clinic 15 minutes away for antibiotics and a tetanus shot. All done and dusted within an hour, couldn't ask for more.

beezlebubnicky · 13/03/2023 06:01

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 12/03/2023 22:15

The system is definitely broken, but I voted yabu because I don't agree that it is beyond repair. I believe that the problems could be sorted out with sufficient investment and political will to do so. That might mean all of us being willing to pay in a bit more/ change the way we interact with it.

I hope that your ds gets better soon.

YABU, I agree with this.

The only trouble is a lot of people in this country think very short-term politically. Even with proper investment if Labour got in, it would take years to recover and I can see people complaining at a future election about the state of the NHS as it still hasn't yet improved enough, forgetting that it was the Tories that fucked it in the first place. And potentially voting them back in.

Brits are turkeys who vote for Christmas.

Dyslexicwonder · 13/03/2023 05:47

They should also manufacture their own drugs rather than buying them in from over expensive private companies which would all save billions.

I agree there are huge savings to be had. Manufacturing our own drugs isn't one of them. The NHS with NICE effectively operates a monopoly around procurement, it's the major stumbling block in obtaining a free trade arrangement with the US. Most prescribed drugs are off patent and amazingly cheap.

rwalker · 13/03/2023 05:23

The problem is people are that stupid and thick that they think all it needs is more money

YES YES it does need more funding but we are breaking it by not taking responsibility for out health and creating unnecessary demands on the service

we are one of the fattest unhealthy nations no wonder our health service has unprecedented demand

in our entitled society everything is someone else problem and responsibility

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 13/03/2023 05:06

I've known things were bad for a while, but this week I saw the NHS falling around around its ears. Buckle up- this is a long post (I apologise):

After four lots of antibiotics in four weeks for a chest infection that hasn't cleared I phoned my GP on Tuesday morning. I originally had covid and it had gone to my chest. My symptoms were tightness and heaviness of chest, fever of 39.4, a terrible cough and blood-flecked mucus. I also had a very painful left ear Was told there were no appointments to be had (after waiting on hold from when they opened at 8am to 9.15) and I should wait until the out of hours service opened at 5pm.

Phoned them at 5, was on hold for 1hr 45mins and when I got through was told there were no OOH appointments and to phone 111.

Phoned 111 at 6.45pm and got through quite quickly, by around 7pm. Was told I would be phoned back by a doctor based on my symptoms within six hours.

At 1am I received a phone call from 111 saying this wasn't my call back, it was to inform me my callback had been delayed but would be within the next six hours.

At 4.30am I received the call from a doctor. He was very concerned based on my symptoms and the fact four lots of antibiotics haven't worked. He sent a referral to my local A&E and told me to go now. Told me he would say in the referral that I need a chest X-ray, blood tests to check for infection markers, a swab and likely IV antibiotics but that I should tell the doctor this too.

Got to my local hospital at 5am. It's a large, London teaching hospital. Absolute war zone. 43 trolleys with ambulance crews sat with the patients (almost all extremely elderly people) in the corridor leading down to A&E.

I waited four hours to see a doctor, who listened to my chest and took my temperature and looked like I was boring her to death. It was all she could do to touch me, I think if she could have got away with not examining me she would have. Explained everything the 111 doc had said and she snapped and said “yes o can read all of that here”. She said there was a wheeze on my left lung but that I had no fever- and said that like I was a fantasist. Her exact words were “you told the 111 doctor that you had a fever but you don’t”. I explained that I’d taken some codeine about an hour prior for the ear pain which had likely taken it down and she literally scoffed. I then asked her to look in my painful ear and she refused saying “you’ve had a chest infection, not an ear infection!”

She then said that as four lots of antibiotics hadn’t worked there was no point giving me anymore. I asked how that worked as I still very clearly had signs of infection. She shrugged and said “you’ll just become antibiotic resistant” and that I should go home and contact my GP in a week if I was no better. I then said- very politely- that that wasn’t good enough and I wanted the tests the other doctor had recommended. She huffed and puffed, went out to talk to someone else for a while and came back in with a form which she wrote my name on and said “fine, you can have a chest x ray” like she was really doing me a favour.

Chest x-ray done around 10am and I went back to wait for the doctor. By this time I’m tripping balls as I feel so ill and have been up all night. I see the doctor again at 11am who says that I have pneumonia that “looks bacterial” on my left lung but it looks like “it’s clearing up” and that he hospital can’t facilitate further tests or IV antibiotics so I should go home and ring my GP for another course. She also says I should ask for a referral to the long covid clinic. I explain that not being able to see my GP 27hrs ago was what landed me here. I also said that clearly, I don’t have long covid, I have pneumonia. She shrugged and said “well you say you’re tired, that’s probably long covid”(!!!) I asked if she could prescribe the antibiotics. She said she couldn’t as “this is A&E”. I was sent off totally flabbergasted but clear that I was getting no further help from her.

I was with my mum and she drove me to the GP where we went in and explained the situation. Luckily we got the one nice receptionist- or she was just so shocked by the story- who said there were no appointments but if we sat and waited I could see someone after morning surgery finished.

At 1.30pm I eventually got a prescription for 21 months days of further antibiotics from one of the GPs. He said it was a terrible story but he “wasn’t surprised”.

I’ve got no doubt that- probably- if your heart packs in or you’re in a bad accident or something similar the NHS would help. It was brilliant when I had my kids and suffered PPHs. It can probably cope with limited crises and react accordingly. But for someone like me with something that won’t imminently kill them but for whom is ill and could end up quite seriously poorly if left alone, they’re now next to useless. I’ve never felt so helpless. I literally did not know who to turn to after being in A&E. I felt like the safety net that I had believed in all my life was well and truly gone.

RunTowardsTheLight · 13/03/2023 05:00

The NHS needs to be overhauled - it can't cope with the ageing population. I would support the system in some European countries where some things are charged for.