Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS is beyond repair?

157 replies

NHSisfallingapart · 12/03/2023 22:04

DS has been unwell with chickenpox. A couple of the blisters looked like they might be infected. It’s a Sunday and the GP is closed, when I rand their after hours line it just goes dead. I rang 111 for advice at noon and have been waiting for a return pcall ever since. Someone rang me a few hours ago to ask whether I stil want to speak with someone. They could not provide an estimate of when I will receive a return call and told me it’s a 24 hour service and I may be called at any hour.

AIBU to think the standard of care provided by the NHS is inadequate? I suspect DS needs antibiotics and I can’t do anything about it.

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 12:44

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:19

@MarshaMelrose Because the conservatives have been starving the NHS of funding.
I have had excellent care because staff are trying to do their nest in spite of the Tories. Look at how long ambulances are taking because the Tories have fucked up social care.

Social care is messed up because none of the past govts, including Labour have tackled it. As the population lives longer, the strain is greater. It needs a concerted plan from all parties to put something together for the future. Not one party putting forward suggestions like Johnson did only yo have the opposition pull itvdown. Politicians have yo start behaving like grown ups and work tofether for the good of the country. They need yobhave a panel of experts to give them Ll independent advice

You're receiving excellent care that is being funded. If, as you say, they were trying to close down long term care but keep emergency care going, we wouldn't be seeing the nightmare with ambulances because they'd have defunded the care you're receiving and re-allocated it to the paramedics and emergency depts.
How you can be happy with all the care your family is receiving but still criticise the govt for funding it, I just don't understand.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 13/03/2023 12:36

There is currently a strike on due to the government refusing to discuss the appealing working conditions ans pay of doctors. Its mental its not all over the news but.... the government

Swiftbushome · 13/03/2023 12:34

@Kazzyhoward I completely agree with you. The NHS is crap at diagnosis in my experience as well. Sure they may be great once you know what's wrong, but if they take too long to put the jigsaw pieces together and work it out (because they don't listen and keep fobbing you off) it may well be too late.

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 12:27

Pastadanca · 13/03/2023 12:02

The NHS is great at urgent care, but the issue is a lot of the other longer term or emergency issues- the diagnoses and management of is lacking as well as for lesser things but that also effect quality of life. I suspect this is the way we are heading- free at point of use for emergencies etc but for anything else pay a fee.

I agree that the NHS is great but only once they've diagnosed the problem. Getting the diagnosis can be a nightmare.

My OH (who'd never been to the GP for years), had numerous GP appointments over a 2 year period for various ailments which suddenly and randomly started. Including fainting, hyperventilating, various pains in different parts of his body, rib pain, headaches and nausea, etc. GP did a few simple tests such as BP, basic blood tests, ECG, etc., but eventually started to tell him it was just "we're all getting older" and basically fobbing him off. After some excrutiating rib pains (for no reason, i.e. no exercising, heavy lifting, falls, etc), he saw a locum GP who took her own different blood test (didn't want to wait for a nurse appointment a few days later) - result came back next day, and she phoned OH to say she'd arranged an oncology appt the following week. Turned out it was a blood cell cancer - when we looked it up, all the signs were there, but his "normal" GPs didn't put 2+2 together to realise what it was - too busy thinking it was just "normal" ageing! Once he got the diagnosis, the treatment started straight away and is working (incurable but treatable).

Same with FIL who, despite being a fit and healthy 69 year old, stagnated in a hospital ward for months because they couldn't diagnose what was wrong with him. All the symptoms were of a bowel blockage (he'd previously had an operation on his aorta so they thought it could be scar tissue from that blocking the bowel), but they did x-rays and scans and couldn't see anything, so they just left him on the ward, waiting, and just treating the symptoms, i.e. giving him liquid food, treating the hospital acquired infections, all the while he was getting weaker and weaker. There was a definite "waiting to die" sort of attitude from the doctors and nurses because they didn't know what was wrong. Eventually, after 2 or 3 months, they decided to open him up at the site of his aorta operation, and yes, there was a bowel blockage. Then they quickly rectified it, got him back on foods, etc., and eventually he was well enough to come home. So they got there in the end, and once they knew what it was, the treatment all came together, but if they'd left it any longer to open him up, it would have been too late.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:19

@MarshaMelrose Because the conservatives have been starving the NHS of funding.
I have had excellent care because staff are trying to do their nest in spite of the Tories. Look at how long ambulances are taking because the Tories have fucked up social care.

DonttouchthatLarry · 13/03/2023 12:17

Moreorlessmentallystable · 13/03/2023 11:51

Really? Our pharmacist does not prescribe anything that you couldn't get over the counter. It's all done through the GP, which also does not have appointments - you have to phone every day at 8:30am sharp on the hope of getting a call back.

Yes @Moreorlessmentallystable if they've got a prescribing qualification they can. My husband had an infected insect bite so went to the pharmacy to see if they could recommend something to put on it or if he needed to make a GP appointment (very difficult as you say). Pharmacist looked at it and said 'I can give you antibiotics for that' which meant he could start them immediately rather than waiting for an appointment.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 12:13

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:05

@Pastadanca It is what the Tories want. Because people dying in the streets from road traffic accidents for example is not a great look. But people dying from untreated long term conditions is more hidden.

I, my DC and my DH all have long term conditions. We have had brilliant treatment. DH and DC are under a top specialist and get great long-term management of their care. Under your scheme they would just die.

Honestly, you talk such tosh. In 2021 the uk system was rated 4th in the world above countries like Germany, France and Canada. Why do you keep implying the Tories are trying to wreck it.

You say in one paragraph the Tories don't care if you die ftom long term conditions. In the next paragraph you say you've received excellent care.

You just don't make sense.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:05

@Pastadanca It is what the Tories want. Because people dying in the streets from road traffic accidents for example is not a great look. But people dying from untreated long term conditions is more hidden.

I, my DC and my DH all have long term conditions. We have had brilliant treatment. DH and DC are under a top specialist and get great long-term management of their care. Under your scheme they would just die.

Pastadanca · 13/03/2023 12:02

The NHS is great at urgent care, but the issue is a lot of the other longer term or emergency issues- the diagnoses and management of is lacking as well as for lesser things but that also effect quality of life. I suspect this is the way we are heading- free at point of use for emergencies etc but for anything else pay a fee.

Caramelstar · 13/03/2023 11:54

6 weeks ago I’d have agreed with you

I suddenly became unwell 5.5 weeks ago. Was able to see my gp same day after they triaged me online. Referred immediately to hospital seen the next day by a consultant and then every 48 hours for another 10 days even at weekends with a consultant and not made to wait at all . Scanned etc quickly at weekends then given open access to a ward if needed till the issue was resolved. The level of care was amazing and not at all what I was expecting

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:53

Then I would contact your MP maybe to ask if this can be changed.
I have never heard anyone talk about this before and I have had friends and relatives with cancer, including my mother. So it may be a very specific issue that needs tackling.

user40816 · 13/03/2023 11:53

YANBU to this the NHS is beyond repair [without significant reform and overhaul], because it is.

But YABU if you think that based purely on this one experience that you don't find satisfactorily convenient.

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 11:51

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:49

@Kazzyhoward That is strange. Sounds like it is to do with how the drugs are packaged by companies. Maybe the NHS does not have a choice then?

No, it's the pharmacy who "package" them. All individual drugs are separately packed, and the most expensive chemo drug comes in individual tablet packs, so he gets 3 separate packs of a single tablet, so they "could" easily just prescribe 1 or 2, rather than 3 if there was a will to do so.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 11:51

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:31

In 2019 WHO judged the NHS the most efficient healthcare system in the world. The Conservatives then decided they would make the NHS more efficient and would cut "pen pushers". So they decimated the NHS admin staff which has caused it to be inefficient. Appointments do not get sent out in time, paperwork does not happen when it should, results of tests are delayed.
Its as if the government thought the admin staff were sitting around doing nothing, instead of being crucial to the NHS.

Most efficient in 2010 but not the best. That didn't happen til 2014. 😉

purpledalmation · 13/03/2023 11:51

But YANBU to expect a call back in a timely manner

Moreorlessmentallystable · 13/03/2023 11:51

DonttouchthatLarry · 12/03/2023 22:20

You could get antibiotics from a pharmacist tomorrow. 111 probably haven't called back as they're so busy and it's not exactly urgent.

Really? Our pharmacist does not prescribe anything that you couldn't get over the counter. It's all done through the GP, which also does not have appointments - you have to phone every day at 8:30am sharp on the hope of getting a call back.

purpledalmation · 13/03/2023 11:50

It didn't need urgent care last night unless the child was not drinking and dehydrated or showing signs of sepsis. Chicken pox can look awful but it's rarely a serious issue

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 11:49

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:35

@Kazzyhoward That sounds like the oncologist is at fault. I have found Drs and consultants quick to remove medication from prescriptions. But your DH does not need to get the medication. He can give the pharmacist the prescription and say what he needs and not to give him anything else. My DP did this when a repeat prescription had an old medicine wrongly on it that he no longer used.

Anyway, he doesn't "give" the pharmacist the prescription. He has no control. The oncology dept send the prescription to the hospital pharmacy (he's not allowed to pick it up anywhere else due to the controlled chemo drugs), and the pharmacy pick/pack it. All OH does is go in to collect it from the hospital pharmacy (or sometimes, it's handed over by the oncology nurse if he has to go to the oncology dept for blood tests, BP checks etc that month). It's not a case like a GP where you tick to ask for the meds you need and pick up from your local pharmacy!

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:49

@Kazzyhoward That is strange. Sounds like it is to do with how the drugs are packaged by companies. Maybe the NHS does not have a choice then?

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 11:45

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:35

@Kazzyhoward That sounds like the oncologist is at fault. I have found Drs and consultants quick to remove medication from prescriptions. But your DH does not need to get the medication. He can give the pharmacist the prescription and say what he needs and not to give him anything else. My DP did this when a repeat prescription had an old medicine wrongly on it that he no longer used.

Do you think he hasn't tried handing the meds back to the pharmacist? That was the first thing he tried before asking the oncologist to stop issuing the ones he doesn't use. The pharmacists (he's tried several times) insists that because it's a package containing restricted chemo tablets), he has to "hand over" the complete sealed bag, and if OH opens it and hands anything back, then it'll be destroyed as it's been "officially handed over" and they can't reuse anything handed back! Rather than having it destroyed in the pharmacy, OH thinks it's better to keep it just in case he needs to take it in future if the "approval" gets stopped in the future (he'd only do that if the oncologist agrees of course!).

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:35

@Kazzyhoward That sounds like the oncologist is at fault. I have found Drs and consultants quick to remove medication from prescriptions. But your DH does not need to get the medication. He can give the pharmacist the prescription and say what he needs and not to give him anything else. My DP did this when a repeat prescription had an old medicine wrongly on it that he no longer used.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:31

Sorry should say 2010 not 2019.

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 11:31

Pastadanca · 13/03/2023 08:28

What do you means by funding being badly managed? Any examples? (And not T&T which wasn't procured by the NHS). Sure there's some, but they have to adhere to PCR 2015 just like all other public sector spending- so what examples?

My DH has cancer and will be on a package of Chemo tablets until they stop controlling it which could (hopefully) be several more years, he's already been on them over 3 years! He has, literally, thousands of pounds of tablets that he's not taken because he has no control over the prescriptions issued by his oncologist. The oncologist knows he doesn't take all the meds prescribed (literally a carrier bag full every 4 weeks), but won't change the prescription because it's a "package" and he glibly says "it's funded so doesn't come out of my budget!". He gets 3 of one particular chemo tablet that costs over £1k per tablet, but only takes 2 per month (can't tolerate all 3 and it's working anyway). Same with another cancer drug where he gets 21 (3 weeks out of 4 week cycle), but only takes 1 every other day (so 10 or 11 per cycle), and those are around £300 per tablet. Oncologist knows all this as he's the one who suggested cutting down to reduce side effects etc. There's also other drugs he never takes which are a lot cheaper, i.e. anti sickness, anti diarrhoea etc. Oncologist says that if he reduces the numbers prescribed, he may not get "authorisation" to increase them again if needed hence why he wants to keep to the standard "package" which he has authorisation for. But OH had probably £20k of tablets in his cupboard and it's getting fuller!

I'm sure all that is more the fault of "the system" rather than individual doctors or managers, but it's still waste! That kind of thing shouldn't happen, but, ironically, it's probably because of trying to be efficient that it does happen, i.e. oncologists having to get "committee" approval for expensive treatments is fair enough, but not when it has adverse side effects such as oncologists not wanting to change things when they have specific approval for a specific course of treatment!

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 11:31

In 2019 WHO judged the NHS the most efficient healthcare system in the world. The Conservatives then decided they would make the NHS more efficient and would cut "pen pushers". So they decimated the NHS admin staff which has caused it to be inefficient. Appointments do not get sent out in time, paperwork does not happen when it should, results of tests are delayed.
Its as if the government thought the admin staff were sitting around doing nothing, instead of being crucial to the NHS.

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 11:22

blebbleb · 13/03/2023 08:44

Yes. A mix of underfunding and an aging u healthy population. I know people who have gone to a&e for a black finger nail when it was shut in a door! Stuff like that needs no more than a GP or pharmacy visit.

But the problem is that you can't get a GP visit and a lot of the time, pharmacists aren't helpful either and they just refer you to the GP!

Swipe left for the next trending thread