Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS is beyond repair?

157 replies

NHSisfallingapart · 12/03/2023 22:04

DS has been unwell with chickenpox. A couple of the blisters looked like they might be infected. It’s a Sunday and the GP is closed, when I rand their after hours line it just goes dead. I rang 111 for advice at noon and have been waiting for a return pcall ever since. Someone rang me a few hours ago to ask whether I stil want to speak with someone. They could not provide an estimate of when I will receive a return call and told me it’s a 24 hour service and I may be called at any hour.

AIBU to think the standard of care provided by the NHS is inadequate? I suspect DS needs antibiotics and I can’t do anything about it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Teder · 14/03/2023 19:52

The NHS is under immense pressure. In the absence of any significant medical concerns, personally, I would not have called 111 for this. You waited a long time because it was low priority not because it’s “broken”. It was only one day until your GP surgery opened. There are other examples of failure of the system (not the individuals within it) but I don’t think there’s anything wrong with waiting such a long time for a phone call for a minor issue.

NHShospuser · 14/03/2023 12:26

I’ve name changed for this.

I am fed up of people saying in an emergency you’ll be rushed through. You won’t always. It happened to me last month.

I am not blaming the individuals in this situation because the care was good but the timescales were something else.

I have a chronic health condition that can deteriorate very fast. I’ve had many intensive care and high dependency admissions. If we can get on top of it quickly, I can prevent such a rapid down slide. Sometimes the meds I have at home to treat a flare up aren’t enough and this was one of those times.

I phoned daily for a GP appointment but I was 87th in the queue on one occasion. They closed the online request system as they’re so busy. I’m lucky, I like my GP surgery. The doctors are good and kind and the receptionists are helpful. They’re just really under pressure.
Due to waiting so long, I ended up in A&E. I spent 14 hours waiting for treatment and admission. They were overcrowded. They have cubicles in majors for each person but they had 3 people in my cubicle. People were vomiting, on oxygen or sharing drip stands. It was horrific.

I needed hourly monitoring which didn’t happen. I went 6 hours without obs and I had rapidly deteriorated by the time I got to the ward. They hadn’t had time to start the meds I needed desperately. I saw them rushing around, they were genuinely too busy to administer medication but I was illler as a result and ended up longer in hospital.

turnthetoiletpaperroundproperly · 13/03/2023 17:33

Having just had my husband rushed in last monday for a pulmonary embolism straight into resus he has been discharged today home I want to say its not easy but I will take whatever system there is cos when we desperately needed them this past week they came through for us.We are very lucky and have nothing but praise for the medics,nurses,ambulance staff,caterers,ward assistants who all worked so hard. I am counting my lucky stars I got my husband home today,still not right but well on his way and so so much better.

Thesharkradar · 13/03/2023 17:21

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 13:32

Obviously, that's part of the problem, but even people who've lived a healthy life with plenty of exercise and healthy eating still get ill, particularly with all the various cancers that have no actual cause other than luck/genetics, and seemingly healthy people still have heart attacks, strokes, etc (look at that footballer who "died" on the pitch - Fabrice Muamba - his heart condition wasn't caused by not exercising was it?). Look at Olivia Newton John who was well known to have a healthy lifestyle, plenty of exercise, no "addictions", etc., who got Breast Cancer aged just 43!

In fact, "healthy" living is a potential cause of the current problems as people are living longer, lots of whom because of healthy lifestyle - as lots get older, their bodies are fine, but their mind is lost to Alzheimers/dementia etc., meaning they could need "care" for a decade or two at a cost far higher than a morbidly obese person or a heavy smoker who would be likely to die at a much younger age, saving not only long term care costs, but also saving from not having pension payments etc!

very true!
what the govt would like is for us to work as hard as we can (so that the rich & powerful can stay that way) until we start to decline and then just drop dead

Moreorlessmentallystable · 13/03/2023 15:03

DonttouchthatLarry · 13/03/2023 12:17

Yes @Moreorlessmentallystable if they've got a prescribing qualification they can. My husband had an infected insect bite so went to the pharmacy to see if they could recommend something to put on it or if he needed to make a GP appointment (very difficult as you say). Pharmacist looked at it and said 'I can give you antibiotics for that' which meant he could start them immediately rather than waiting for an appointment.

That would be great to have at our local pharmacy

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 14:25

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 13:41

@MarshaMelrose Yes local authority homes used to cost more to run. They no longer exist where I live. They were way better. They did not pay staff minimum wage resulting in a rota of low paid, inexperienced young staff rotating through the home.
Nicer furniture does not make a good care home and there have been scandals at lots of private care homes including the BUPA ones.

Yes, our city had 3 large "homes" for convalescence, long term care, etc., which were either council or NHS owned. Trouble was that they were so old, they were falling down (literally) and were riddled with asbestos, so repairs/improvements were incredibly expensive. Repeat that all over the country and you soon see why successive govts have "contracted out" longer term care to the private sector. The three homes in question took years for the developers to clear out the asbestos and either knock them down and/or convert them into housing.

Same happened with the railways. They "had to" be privatised because the trains themselves (as owned by the nationalised BR) were so old, they all needed replacement over a relatively short time period because they weren't compliant with current H&S (disability friendly, sliding doors, tanks under the toilets, containing asbestos, etc) - successive Govt couldn't afford to buy replacement stock (at a cost of billions), so it was privatised to get access to private funding.

Likewise PFI for building new hospitals, etc as lots of older hospitals were unfit for purpose due to age, asbestos, layout, etc.

The international money markets are controlling the UK because of the national debt. For the Govt to build new buildings, buy new trains, etc., it just adds to the deficit and increases national debt, and money markets charge higher interest if we borrow too much. Hence why Govts subcontract out big spending projects so that the debt doesn't land on the Govt balance sheet, so the money markets aren't spooked and don't increase interest!

It's a lot more complex than just a govt saying "nah, we won't bother funding it" - and it's not just the Tories either. Blair/Brown tried all kinds of fudges to try to assure the money markets we weren't borrowing beyond our means, hence the vast amount of new schools/hospitals bought on PFI that the taxpayer will be paying for decades ahead.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 13:52

It used to be nearly all care homes were local authority. Now there are virtually none left. We did not have the number of scandals in the past we now do.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 13:50

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 13:41

@MarshaMelrose Yes local authority homes used to cost more to run. They no longer exist where I live. They were way better. They did not pay staff minimum wage resulting in a rota of low paid, inexperienced young staff rotating through the home.
Nicer furniture does not make a good care home and there have been scandals at lots of private care homes including the BUPA ones.

Of course there are more scandals in private homes, one round us just closed and the manager was charged with manslaughter, but that's because there are so many more of them. We have 6 coincil run in our whole county. Care home wages vary. Its wrong to say that council staff are the best paid. Its also very wrong tobsay that private care homes only employ young staff. The ages are comparable. Council homes are better than some homes and worse than others. I have been round a lot of homes. It's been my life for three months.

When I meant nicer, I wasn't talking about furniture.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 13:44

Also agree that people taking responsibility for their own health leads to more care costs. The biggest risk factor for dementia is age. Most people funded by taxpayers in care homes have dementia. More people who live 90 plus, more people funded by taxpayers in care homes.
People who live unhealthy lifestyles are far less likely to need long term care. They die like my Uncle of a massive heart attack. Or like my step brother of cirrhosis.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 13:41

@MarshaMelrose Yes local authority homes used to cost more to run. They no longer exist where I live. They were way better. They did not pay staff minimum wage resulting in a rota of low paid, inexperienced young staff rotating through the home.
Nicer furniture does not make a good care home and there have been scandals at lots of private care homes including the BUPA ones.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 13:39

@MarshaMelrose Most care is privately funded. There still needs to be carers and and beds. I have personal experience here of a close relative who was in hospital. The discharge team helped set up the care package. But it took several weeks before there were carers available and before the equipment could be delivered.
The equipment is collected. Sorry but you obviously do not realise how it works. The NHS do not do this. The Red Cross provides hospital beds, commodes, etc. But years ago it was easy and quick. A bed delivered within two days IME. They have had major funding cuts and it took a few weeks to get everything. Nothing to do with inefficiency. And they collect them back. Nobody wants to hang onto a hospital bed, commode and similar in their living room.
But I was shocked at the difference over just 7 years time. Same Red Cross Office. First time quick and person seemed pretty relaxed. Second time took a long while and person seemed stressed and had too much work. You make cuts to funding to charities and it has an impact.

Kazzyhoward · 13/03/2023 13:32

Thesharkradar · 13/03/2023 13:08

I think a big part of the problem is the failure of people to take responsibility for their own health, ie not exercising and eating a bad diet etc

Obviously, that's part of the problem, but even people who've lived a healthy life with plenty of exercise and healthy eating still get ill, particularly with all the various cancers that have no actual cause other than luck/genetics, and seemingly healthy people still have heart attacks, strokes, etc (look at that footballer who "died" on the pitch - Fabrice Muamba - his heart condition wasn't caused by not exercising was it?). Look at Olivia Newton John who was well known to have a healthy lifestyle, plenty of exercise, no "addictions", etc., who got Breast Cancer aged just 43!

In fact, "healthy" living is a potential cause of the current problems as people are living longer, lots of whom because of healthy lifestyle - as lots get older, their bodies are fine, but their mind is lost to Alzheimers/dementia etc., meaning they could need "care" for a decade or two at a cost far higher than a morbidly obese person or a heavy smoker who would be likely to die at a much younger age, saving not only long term care costs, but also saving from not having pension payments etc!

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 13:28

@CanOfPop
For old people, as far back as I remember, they had to fund their own care. I don't think council homes are always the best places for eqveryone. And they're often more expensive than many private homes, which often are just nicer places.

Closures of small hospitals and buildings that could have been developed for convalescence care happened under the Tories and continued under Labour. They both wanted showy, shiny hospitals, and there was no forward planning.

Even talking about equipment makes me cross. It can be unpredictable in arriving and almost impossible to give back. The waste of money that happens in that area alone is shocking.

And there's no joined up system between social care and the NHS. It's like they have no idea what the other is doing or does. It's been going on for years. Its the fault of all the parties putting this growing crisis off. And now all the parties need to get-together to make it work.

In my opinion, the Tories are responsible for bad decisions and short-termism. But so is Labour. Tony Blair cut waiting tomescwhen he got in. No doubt about that. I knewcpeoplecwhobad been waiting for years for hip replacements, constantly having operations cancelled. But he also made short-sighted decisions like over pfi.

It's not one side is all wrong and the other is all right. It's so much more complex than that.

Volhhg · 13/03/2023 13:28

Which aibu do I vote for

Is the NHS beyond repair?

Or

Is the standard of care the NHS is offering inadequate?

No I don't think it's beyond repair

Somuchgoo · 13/03/2023 13:26

Sunny= silly

Somuchgoo · 13/03/2023 13:26

I think it's a sunny thing to have sought assistance for on a Sunday, and could have easily waited. Callback shouldn't have been so rubbish, but its probably an indication of how low this is on triage.

The NHS has amazing to my family for serious matters, but frustrating for more everyday things, or routine things like knee replacements.

I cant stand 111 though. They weren't concerned for my toddler, who actually had a brain tumour that required (and received) lifesaving surgery within 24 hours, and a couple of months in hospital, ignoring several official 'red flags'. Thank goodness I researched myself, saw the red flags, ignored 111 and acted on instinct.

In contrast, they massively panicked when my older child complained of chest pain, during the flu, and initially wanted me to rush her to a specialist until 90 mins away, to get there within the hour. They seemed confused when I said that wasn't physically possible, and thankfully I got a callback from someone who was quite sensible.

Thesharkradar · 13/03/2023 13:08

I think a big part of the problem is the failure of people to take responsibility for their own health, ie not exercising and eating a bad diet etc

Hobbitfeet32 · 13/03/2023 13:04

Have you been seen yet or had contact from a clinician @NHSisfallingapart ? Just interested to know how long it takes between your call to 111 and getting contact with a clinician.
Also when they rang you back to check if you still needed care, you could have told them if your child had deteriorated and I suspect they would have increased the priority. As it was, he could wait.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 13:01

I am talking about people who need care after being in hospital. Whether because they have had a major illness like a stroke or a fall, or because they are in hospital because a chronic condition has worsened e.g. cancer. Up to 10% of hospital beds are taken by people like this who should be at home or in a care home, but there is as yet no care package set up. And even if you do the care as a relative, you still need the equipment delivered to your home.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 12:53

So you're talking about old people and those convalescing?

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:51

Social care includes care homes, home carers, and equipment so someone can be at home. All three elements have to work properly. Delays in getting a hospital bed and commode in someone's home can mean a delay in discharge.

MarshaMelrose · 13/03/2023 12:50

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:45

Social care is messed up because the Tories privatised social care and then refused to properly fund it. So there are not enough beds and not enough carers. These staff used to be employed by the local authorities.

What sort of social care are you talking about?

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:49

And the crazy thing is it costs us far more money. Because we end up with lots of people in hospitals who should be at home with carers or in care homes.
Even simple things like equipment at home takes too long now. It used to be an easy quick process through the Red Cross. But now it can take weeks to arrange equipment so someone can leave hospital.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:46

It is the same as they did with dentistry. Fail to properly fund it so that all but the most expensive private care is all that remains in some areas.

CanOfPop · 13/03/2023 12:45

Social care is messed up because the Tories privatised social care and then refused to properly fund it. So there are not enough beds and not enough carers. These staff used to be employed by the local authorities.

Swipe left for the next trending thread