Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is boys football unnecessarily competetive?

62 replies

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 19:59

My 2 boys 9&7 love football. Playing, watching, talking. They have been part of a club that started out very community based but subsequently the person who set it up has now made it his living.
They are average players, not bad at all but not noticeably brilliant.
There are some players who are better and the club has created like an additional elite squad from the age range who play up an age as well as their usual team and this then trickles into the usual teams because it's his income they accept any new joiners and thus there are a fair few subs each game competing for match time.
It's all just so competetive and serious and not what i signed up for, i've spoken to the manager and explained the atmosphere i think is being created, but he's not interested he wants to join the JPL next year and become an established team with their own grounds etc, and i'm conscious of being 'that mum'.
There are obviously a lot of 9 year olds who want to play football in the area and all teams are full otherwise i would move. Stopping isn't an option because the boys love it.
IABU - it's not that intense just ignore it
IANBU - kids football is too competetive

OP posts:
Travelationjubilation · 12/03/2023 21:30

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 20:42

I would say that's true post 13, 7-9 years olds haven't a clue, there is no league - there is no recording of scores. Parents seek it out

League here starts from the U6

Travelationjubilation · 12/03/2023 21:28

Honestly OP kids football is like nothing I’ve ever experienced. Eldest played from 7 and is still playing at uni. It’s competitive to the extreme for certain parents; the politics of who gets picked each week, the parents getting busy with it all, the blaming each other for when things go wrong. And the girls teams are just as bad. Then each season, the trials, who they’re playing for next season, the bad mood when it doesn’t go their way, the nepotism…..

thank goodness it finally ended at 18 and I’m no longer the involved. Mind you I’m not convinced that he has finally accepted , at nearly 21, rhat arsenal aren’t still waiting for him,

weebarra · 12/03/2023 21:26

DH is a coach (volunteer) for DD's team. She is 9. The complete ethos at their stage is that it is not competitive. There is a league but no track is kept of wins or losses.
It's difficult as a lot of parents are competitive but, especially for girls who are often starting from scratch at 7, the aim is for them to enjoy it and not give it up when they get to high school.

ncedforthisone · 12/03/2023 21:22

As a non-Brit living here, this has always surprised me about British sports. They are so competitive so very early on, and people don't seem to understand that recreation brought about by doing sport has value in itself. This is astonishing in a country where youth and adult obesity is such a big problem.

waterrat · 12/03/2023 21:20

And no it does not have to be about winning at all. Children could - in a different approach - enjoy playing! They could enjoy a match and if it got unbalanced - ie. one team winning - you could do something like take a player off the winning team.

The FA guidelines state very clearly that under 11 football should be about play and enjoyment. There is no reason children cant enjoy a game whatever the outcome - its only because coaches tell them winning matters above and beyond

Some very sad things Ive seen include - my own childs team losing 15 - 0 at about 7 years old - the kids were crushed. the FA rules actually say this should not be allowed to happen - there are lots of ways you can stop it -

Ive seen my own sons team beat another by about 15 goals - again, seeing kids in tears and crushed

what is the benefit? The chldren should be coming out to have a good day and enjoy playingl.

waterrat · 12/03/2023 21:17

I have an 11 year old who has been playing since he was 3 - I have seen it all - and YES it is insane the pressure put on kids to 'win' or 'be good' - there is a total loss of appreciation for childhood, for play, for fun - for developing kids skills in a way that is about the child.

It is not child focused - too many coaches obsessed with getting a team of 7/ 8 year olds to 'win' - I have seen coaches scream at kids and make them cry -

My husband is a referee at kids games - he gets abuse off kids and parents - and coaches! you would not believe it

We - me / dh - and most parents we know - hate this shit - but the coaches are just totally obsessed with winning and getting the 'best' kids

So so many things wrong with kids football - children made to be 'substitutes' - whY??? Just have enough kids to enjoy a game - I've seen in recent weeks alone - mums crying cos their child is left sitting on the bench at age 8 - not what a child needs - dont take on so many kids you have to leave them on a bench

So much wrong with it all - it should be about childhood/ play and fun at least until 11 or 12

WandaWonder · 12/03/2023 21:10

I would presume athletics or individual sports would be more non competitive

Sure I don't get football really but the point is winning really

Changemaname1 · 12/03/2023 21:08

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 20:23

There's id say 150-200 players paying £35pcm across all age ranges. The majority being coached by volunteer dads who buy their own training kit and do the training session and oversee matches. There will certainly be venue fees and insurance. Then some pay extra for additional sessions on a Saturday night. They also do other stuff in schools and have started to do after school football clubs. I don't knock it as a business venture, I just wouldn't have signed up to a team where there was someone who had to profit which isn't their fault. But as a previous poster said i'm stuck.

Wow ok that’s a decent amount of money then ! Just not something Iv ever seen round here so wasn’t aware it could be run for profit like that thankyou for your explanation

i can see why it’s more competitive then but yes don’t think I’d like that for my ds either

Changemaname1 · 12/03/2023 21:05

RunTowardsTheLight · 12/03/2023 20:18

They don't have to be volunteers @Changemaname1 - many youth football clubs have volunteers running the teams but some paid roles as well (the people running the club).

Ahh I see thankyou I honestly didn’t realise that was a thing !

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 20:42

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/03/2023 20:34

Most parents just want their kids to be put with their peers and getting some exercise. They aren't expecting the next Ronaldo, so all this pushing kids is all to make the coach feel important

I actually don't think that's true - the competitive clubs are not only attractive to a certain type of driven parent who wants to see their child succeed, but also to kids who are good and love football and want to excell at it. They know which clubs and teams are strong, and they would always choose those over a friendly but uncompetitive club.

I would say that's true post 13, 7-9 years olds haven't a clue, there is no league - there is no recording of scores. Parents seek it out

OP posts:
XanaduKira · 12/03/2023 20:41

JaniceBattersby · 12/03/2023 20:32

Why don’t you volunteer to run a ‘for fun’ team at one of the local clubs?

My husband coaches two teams voluntarily. I’ve never heard so much bloody moaning from the parents. The same people who won’t so much as help put the bloody goals away at the end of the game. Pretty much everyone in youth football is a volunteer. If you don’t like the way they do it, that’s fine. Volunteer yourself and start a team you do like the look of.

Absolutely this! My DH runs a team too and the amount of moaning from parents who wouldn't consider putting themselves out at all is ridiculous.

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 20:41

I guess it just is as it is, football is competitive it's not for exercise, enjoyment, team building, friendship or fun. But winning and competing and succeeding. I think that's a shame, and I wasn't prepared for it at such a young age that is my naivety.
I will look into other clubs but just from the fact so many come to ours as others are full im not optimistic.

OP posts:
recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 20:36

JaniceBattersby · 12/03/2023 20:32

Why don’t you volunteer to run a ‘for fun’ team at one of the local clubs?

My husband coaches two teams voluntarily. I’ve never heard so much bloody moaning from the parents. The same people who won’t so much as help put the bloody goals away at the end of the game. Pretty much everyone in youth football is a volunteer. If you don’t like the way they do it, that’s fine. Volunteer yourself and start a team you do like the look of.

My dh is one of the twice weekly volunteers.

Because they're so full they're not at all short of help, in particular lots of dads of the boys want to get stuck in. They doesn't change the ethos and drive of the organisation as a whole.

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/03/2023 20:34

Most parents just want their kids to be put with their peers and getting some exercise. They aren't expecting the next Ronaldo, so all this pushing kids is all to make the coach feel important

I actually don't think that's true - the competitive clubs are not only attractive to a certain type of driven parent who wants to see their child succeed, but also to kids who are good and love football and want to excell at it. They know which clubs and teams are strong, and they would always choose those over a friendly but uncompetitive club.

Zanatdy · 12/03/2023 20:33

To be fair most clubs are quite competitive. My DS is at Uni now and plays more casually but he was very good at one stage and he got a lot of game time compared to many others. I guess just the nature of it but some kids travelled all over for hardly any game time. DS loved it though but eventually he stopped and just played 5 a side until Uni

ItsCalledAConversation · 12/03/2023 20:32

A new footie club is going to open in the local village, I enquired and got told the 6-7 age group would be training twice a week for 3 hours each and matches both days at weekends! It’s mad. What child (what parent) would want to commit that much time? Why can’t it just be an hour a week like every other kids club, because that’s all it is - not a golden ticket to being a professional footballer!

JaniceBattersby · 12/03/2023 20:32

Why don’t you volunteer to run a ‘for fun’ team at one of the local clubs?

My husband coaches two teams voluntarily. I’ve never heard so much bloody moaning from the parents. The same people who won’t so much as help put the bloody goals away at the end of the game. Pretty much everyone in youth football is a volunteer. If you don’t like the way they do it, that’s fine. Volunteer yourself and start a team you do like the look of.

Bigbouncingbaby · 12/03/2023 20:31

I’ve got the opposite issue . My son was one of the good ones but we have to take him out as he was too competitive and not being nice to those who maybe didn’t play as good . It’s hard to balance the super competitive boys to the ones that just life to play . He just couldn’t do it for fun as such it just got all too much 🙈🙈 equally as stressful .

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 20:29

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/03/2023 20:26

I'm in a similar situation - my DS is 8 and he likes playing football (and talking football) but isn't especially good. Up until now this hasn't been a problem, but at this age the game becomes very competitive and the stronger players are visibly better and dominating the play.

I work and can't bring DS to extra practice or weekday evening matches, so even if he were a better player he wouldn't be able to keep up. I wish I could find a club for kids who are not hoping to be selected for Arsenal, will probably grow up to be dentists, and just enjoy playing for fun and exercise. But I suspect there isn't any profit in that!

This exactly. I think if my 9 year old went to all the coaching he could comfortably keep up. But as a secondary school teacher with 15 years served i've seen enough boys experience heartbreak to not even be interested at a sniff of academy.

OP posts:
POTC · 12/03/2023 20:28

They're not all like that. I have 2 boys and for many years our lives revolved around football! Now my eldest works as a referee.

We were always selective about the teams they played in and moved them if it no longer felt right. We were in a similar situation to you and just found a different club that better suited our idea of what it should be about.

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 20:27

RunTowardsTheLight · 12/03/2023 20:24

I advise you to look for a bigger club that has several teams at each age group OP. That way, the less competitive kids can be in a lower team which may suit them better.

It has great facilities and just grows within each age range as there is huge demand locally. So we can't go elsewhere because the other teams say "sorry we're full" whereas the current team say sure join in we will find a spot. I think there's 4 teams in my 9 year olds age range and 3 currently in my 7 year olds.
They do share the match time equally between those who are there.

OP posts:
Passivhaus · 12/03/2023 20:26

Most parents just want their kids to be put with their peers and getting some exercise. They aren't expecting the next Ronaldo, so all this pushing kids is all to make the coach feel important

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/03/2023 20:26

I'm in a similar situation - my DS is 8 and he likes playing football (and talking football) but isn't especially good. Up until now this hasn't been a problem, but at this age the game becomes very competitive and the stronger players are visibly better and dominating the play.

I work and can't bring DS to extra practice or weekday evening matches, so even if he were a better player he wouldn't be able to keep up. I wish I could find a club for kids who are not hoping to be selected for Arsenal, will probably grow up to be dentists, and just enjoy playing for fun and exercise. But I suspect there isn't any profit in that!

Reluctantadult · 12/03/2023 20:24

I heard the women's football team discussing this in a radio interview, or was quite interesting. They said it gets too competitive too young, which excludes kids joining slightly older as they can't keep up, excludes those wanting a kick about which is valuable for fitness at any age, so a good habit to keep for life, stops girls joining in, dominates the playground in quite an aggressive way which stops anyone doing anyone else. Sounds like lots of issues!

RunTowardsTheLight · 12/03/2023 20:24

I advise you to look for a bigger club that has several teams at each age group OP. That way, the less competitive kids can be in a lower team which may suit them better.