Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is boys football unnecessarily competetive?

62 replies

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 19:59

My 2 boys 9&7 love football. Playing, watching, talking. They have been part of a club that started out very community based but subsequently the person who set it up has now made it his living.
They are average players, not bad at all but not noticeably brilliant.
There are some players who are better and the club has created like an additional elite squad from the age range who play up an age as well as their usual team and this then trickles into the usual teams because it's his income they accept any new joiners and thus there are a fair few subs each game competing for match time.
It's all just so competetive and serious and not what i signed up for, i've spoken to the manager and explained the atmosphere i think is being created, but he's not interested he wants to join the JPL next year and become an established team with their own grounds etc, and i'm conscious of being 'that mum'.
There are obviously a lot of 9 year olds who want to play football in the area and all teams are full otherwise i would move. Stopping isn't an option because the boys love it.
IABU - it's not that intense just ignore it
IANBU - kids football is too competetive

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ICanTuckMyBoobsInMyPockets · 13/03/2023 09:08

It's really, really hard to find kids sports clubs, particularly team sports, that aren't horrendously competitive, and that actually coach the kids to be better, rather than running for 10 minutes and playing a match for the remainder of the 'training' session.
Some kids want to play a bit and get better, not play in the Premier League.

lljkk · 13/03/2023 09:03

i want to suggest shifting your mindset about this. It sounds like your boys enjoy going, just you dislike what they get from it. it sounds like other footie clubs I had exposure to. I didn't want to lose my whole Saturday morning every week, standing long cold hours on sidelines for my kid to only play 3 minutes, too.

There are other sports to try. In order of how "elite squad only" they can be about who gets into competitions, I'd guess ...

gymnastics > tennis / pure athletics > footie / rugby > swimming / rowing / dance?/ hockey ? > martial arts / softball > cycling / running / very minority sport clubs.

There's no reason not to get them to try other sports, too.

DS never made elite squad but in yr10 he plays footie with lads most lunchtimes at school, he enjoys the social bonding and that early experience of regular training sessions still gave him good fundamental skills. DS actually quite excels at some other sports.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/03/2023 08:22

I think we knew from U7 which were the best teams.

Everyone knows tbh - it's obvious to adults and children.

LlynTegid · 13/03/2023 08:13

A work colleague has a nine year old son, and what he describes makes me think it is very competitive. What is of concern more is that some parents (usually dads) instilling certain traits in their sons (bad sportsmanship, cheating etc).

converseandjeans · 13/03/2023 08:11

It sounds like your boys are good players but just not the best on their squad - because the squad is one of the better ones.

I doubt they would want to move to a friendly and inclusive set up if they're used to JPL standard matches.

I don't think there's anything wrong with having competitive teams. DS plays on a Saturday with his old school mates and round here the Saturday league is a lower standard. They're in division 2. He enjoys playing with his mates. Sunday he plays for a team which is in top 3 out of all the teams in the more competitive Sunday league (there are 7 divisions). The top Sunday league matches are always more tense & it's less enjoyable. Even within that division 1 there is a difference between top few teams and the rest of the teams in that division. But the players in the top division on a Sunday probably need that challenge. They would gain nothing from playing matches which aren't competitive & also there's no point beating other teams 15-1 each week.

I think we knew from U7 which were the best teams.

XanaduKira · 12/03/2023 23:29

It's the same in our area too @SHM2407 & is that way since year 1 (is that U7s?)

It works well to avoid the 15-0 defeats that PP were discussing & my kids are way more competitive that either me or their dad. They're very competitive about everything, not just football. I think some kids are naturally that way - it must be innate as neither my DH nor I are like that.

SHM2407 · 12/03/2023 23:11

Madreb · 12/03/2023 22:25

@PingPongPiddlyPong sorry that will have been what I meant. A PP implied that kids u11 pick out teams based on what they think they will get out of it. I don't know how you would be aware of which team is the most/least successful based on looking at the fixtures? Nobody keeps track of the score line other than mentally, nothing is recorded.

Why can’t leagues publish tables for u7 to u11 leagues?

The FA’s Youth Review restructured youth football so that it reflects what children want from the game rather than the motivations of the adults that coach or watch them. If league tables are introduced too early, then points rather than the development of players becomes the focus of games played. Standard Code of Rules Youth (SCORY) does not permit the publication of tables for these age groups although it is possible to publicise the results of Trophy events.

In my area the league do keep a record of all the scores so they can put teams in the appropriate division the next season or move a team in the current season if they're getting battered every week. New U7s have seeding days to work out what division to put them in.

In my area the divisions are numbered so it's pretty easy to see who the better teams are even though the results aren't published.

PingPongPiddlyPong · 12/03/2023 22:35

Madreb · 12/03/2023 22:25

@PingPongPiddlyPong sorry that will have been what I meant. A PP implied that kids u11 pick out teams based on what they think they will get out of it. I don't know how you would be aware of which team is the most/least successful based on looking at the fixtures? Nobody keeps track of the score line other than mentally, nothing is recorded.

Why can’t leagues publish tables for u7 to u11 leagues?

The FA’s Youth Review restructured youth football so that it reflects what children want from the game rather than the motivations of the adults that coach or watch them. If league tables are introduced too early, then points rather than the development of players becomes the focus of games played. Standard Code of Rules Youth (SCORY) does not permit the publication of tables for these age groups although it is possible to publicise the results of Trophy events.

My oldest is U11 and we all know who the top teams are for his age in the county. He’s been playing tournaments for a few years so you learn about other teams that way if they aren’t in your league. Also our coach likes to arrange a friendly if there’s no league game on and he wants it to be competitive.
There’s no point driving for 45 minutes out of area to thrash another team 15-0. That’s not fair on either side!

Madreb · 12/03/2023 22:27

Sometimeswinning · 12/03/2023 22:06

You pay monthly for a kids football team? Surely it's a season, one off payment? It sounds more like a fake academy.

Look for a different team.

£35pcm + FA subscription fee, and we dont pay for my youngest as my husband coaches and that's the deal.

Madreb · 12/03/2023 22:26

SHM2407 · 12/03/2023 22:14

I'd keep an eye out for a team in a lower division as they tend to be less obsessed with winning at all costs. Look on Facebook for groups for grassroots football in your area, by about mid May there will be teams advertising for players. I run an U15s team and have done since U9s and there hasn't been a single year when we didn't have kids leave and a massive panic about recruiting replacements before the new season started.

I will definitely be keeping an eye out!

Madreb · 12/03/2023 22:25

@PingPongPiddlyPong sorry that will have been what I meant. A PP implied that kids u11 pick out teams based on what they think they will get out of it. I don't know how you would be aware of which team is the most/least successful based on looking at the fixtures? Nobody keeps track of the score line other than mentally, nothing is recorded.

Why can’t leagues publish tables for u7 to u11 leagues?

The FA’s Youth Review restructured youth football so that it reflects what children want from the game rather than the motivations of the adults that coach or watch them. If league tables are introduced too early, then points rather than the development of players becomes the focus of games played. Standard Code of Rules Youth (SCORY) does not permit the publication of tables for these age groups although it is possible to publicise the results of Trophy events.

HereComesMaleficent · 12/03/2023 22:22

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/03/2023 22:04

As a non-Brit living here, this has always surprised me about British sports. They are so competitive so very early on, and people don't seem to understand that recreation brought about by doing sport has value in itself. This is astonishing in a country where youth and adult obesity is such a big problem.

Oh this is not a British problem - it is a football problem, and it is more extreme in Italy, Spain, most of the countries that have a football culture. A friend moved to Italy when her sons were 8 and 9 and they could find no suitable club because all the local boys had been training since they could walk, and there was zero tolerance for kids who hadn't.

Apart from football I don't think sports in Britain are unusually competitive at all (and I say that as an Irish person who is not averse to taking an occasional pointless dig at Britain Grin).

Rugby in Wales is competitive even at a early age.

Dont look at our national team right now 🤣 but...

My son plays for the Under 9's. In our city alone there are over 15 separate rugby teams. One in each district. Now some of the clubs are super super competitive with A teams , B teams for 6 year olds?!

Children in the super competitive teams if they aren't in the A team, they can enjoy a season of being subs with little game time. It's awful. But hey the team is winning ever weekend.

I deliberately chose a rugby club known for its community and more gentle approach as all I wanted was for DS was to enjoy the game, and get some exercise. Now hes a lovely little scrum half, enjoys the tackling and has great speed and ability to read the game, and hes loving playing every weekend and having fun at training once a week. If he was to go to one of the more competitive teams, poor kid would spend the season on the bench and he would give up.

But all these super competitive teams only want one thing, future internationals and premier club rugby, they also boast massive teams all paying subs each meaning more money for the club.

Its madness how competitive Rugby in Wales can be even for small children.

Madreb · 12/03/2023 22:21

theworldsgonefeckingmad · 12/03/2023 22:13

Just seen you do rugby Sunday, but Sunday leagues seem to be more about the fun than the Saturday leagues. My son plays in a JPL team Saturday and a local team Sunday and they are totally different. As they get older the teams get bigger so go to 9v9 then 11v11 etc so that makes space as well and there's also a few fb groups if you are looking for a team

We do both on Sunday 😭 I think a lot of the current Sunday vibe is to prep some of them for them joining JPL next season. Hopefully that will chill Sunday out a bit!

SHM2407 · 12/03/2023 22:14

I'd keep an eye out for a team in a lower division as they tend to be less obsessed with winning at all costs. Look on Facebook for groups for grassroots football in your area, by about mid May there will be teams advertising for players. I run an U15s team and have done since U9s and there hasn't been a single year when we didn't have kids leave and a massive panic about recruiting replacements before the new season started.

theworldsgonefeckingmad · 12/03/2023 22:13

Just seen you do rugby Sunday, but Sunday leagues seem to be more about the fun than the Saturday leagues. My son plays in a JPL team Saturday and a local team Sunday and they are totally different. As they get older the teams get bigger so go to 9v9 then 11v11 etc so that makes space as well and there's also a few fb groups if you are looking for a team

PingPongPiddlyPong · 12/03/2023 22:12

Sometimeswinning · 12/03/2023 22:06

You pay monthly for a kids football team? Surely it's a season, one off payment? It sounds more like a fake academy.

Look for a different team.

£15 per month which covers training. We occasionally pay extra for a referee for a friendly £2 each (usually a teenager getting experience before reffing tournaments or league games).

PingPongPiddlyPong · 12/03/2023 22:10

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 21:38

Eurgh it's so frustrating

Fwiw your area is breaking the FA rules having a league for 7-11 year olds!

Of course there’s football leagues U11!

Results aren’t published so there’s no “table” but the fixtures are available to see. The league organised the fixtures.
U11’s here are divided into three leagues each with a colour name - so no one can claim they are top of all the teams in the county. From U12 they are in divisions and able to be promoted and champions etc.

Sometimeswinning · 12/03/2023 22:06

You pay monthly for a kids football team? Surely it's a season, one off payment? It sounds more like a fake academy.

Look for a different team.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/03/2023 22:04

As a non-Brit living here, this has always surprised me about British sports. They are so competitive so very early on, and people don't seem to understand that recreation brought about by doing sport has value in itself. This is astonishing in a country where youth and adult obesity is such a big problem.

Oh this is not a British problem - it is a football problem, and it is more extreme in Italy, Spain, most of the countries that have a football culture. A friend moved to Italy when her sons were 8 and 9 and they could find no suitable club because all the local boys had been training since they could walk, and there was zero tolerance for kids who hadn't.

Apart from football I don't think sports in Britain are unusually competitive at all (and I say that as an Irish person who is not averse to taking an occasional pointless dig at Britain Grin).

itsalwayscycling · 12/03/2023 21:57

Totally agree that rugby is so much more inclusive. With football they start selecting for the local prufessional teams junior academies at about 7 which is just silly in my opinion- then have devastated kids dropped at 10 or 11. In rugby the selection / academy system only starts when they are about 15 which is much more appropriate, and the boys who are not on that track are still welcome to train and play every week. Mine played both until about 12 then dropped the football as it wasn’t any fun by then.

Zarqon · 12/03/2023 21:56

YANBU. It’s horrible. Several parents recently left our team over the appalling things the coach was yelling at the (very young) children.

It’s useful to be good enoogh to play football at breaks, but football clubs are full of arseholes. Encourage the boys towards a different way of playing football when you can.

The coach won’t care thet you want a noce atmosphere. Adult professional football is full of shouted abuse and violence and kids football coaches aspire to be pwrt of that scene. 😔

snitzelvoncrumb · 12/03/2023 21:50

I would keep looking around for other teams. You might have to look away from your area, but somewhere will have a more relaxed atmosphere.
Talk to you kids. Do they want to keep playing? If they are just bench warmers everyone week find another sport.

Travelationjubilation · 12/03/2023 21:39

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 21:34

I'm quite competitive too so had to really reflect on whether this was me being competetive for my sons, was i feeling that they were rejected. It really isn't, i absolutely agree with you that it should be recreational, and that is the value of it, my youngest was asked to go to Arsenal (with a fair few others) and i said no, im just not interested.
For what it's worth rugby which my boys also play (Sundays are a killer in my house) is much more recreational and friendly, and if i had my way we'd ditch football all together 😂

Much as the football thing did my head in I a soltely refused to let my kids play rugby, luckily they went to a football school. The behaviour might be better but the danger is too much of a risk for me even with the changes they’re making

recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 21:38

Travelationjubilation · 12/03/2023 21:28

Honestly OP kids football is like nothing I’ve ever experienced. Eldest played from 7 and is still playing at uni. It’s competitive to the extreme for certain parents; the politics of who gets picked each week, the parents getting busy with it all, the blaming each other for when things go wrong. And the girls teams are just as bad. Then each season, the trials, who they’re playing for next season, the bad mood when it doesn’t go their way, the nepotism…..

thank goodness it finally ended at 18 and I’m no longer the involved. Mind you I’m not convinced that he has finally accepted , at nearly 21, rhat arsenal aren’t still waiting for him,

Eurgh it's so frustrating

Fwiw your area is breaking the FA rules having a league for 7-11 year olds!

OP posts:
recreationalforall · 12/03/2023 21:34

ncedforthisone · 12/03/2023 21:22

As a non-Brit living here, this has always surprised me about British sports. They are so competitive so very early on, and people don't seem to understand that recreation brought about by doing sport has value in itself. This is astonishing in a country where youth and adult obesity is such a big problem.

I'm quite competitive too so had to really reflect on whether this was me being competetive for my sons, was i feeling that they were rejected. It really isn't, i absolutely agree with you that it should be recreational, and that is the value of it, my youngest was asked to go to Arsenal (with a fair few others) and i said no, im just not interested.
For what it's worth rugby which my boys also play (Sundays are a killer in my house) is much more recreational and friendly, and if i had my way we'd ditch football all together 😂

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread