Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Manager wants me to be more open about my personal life at work - AIBU?

220 replies

privstelifeprivate · 12/03/2023 19:31

I'm in my mid 20s working in quite a young/creative company where most people are middle class 20-30 year olds. It's a very casual and sociable company e.g. there's happy hour in the office, pool tables and we're told to bring 'our authentic selves' to work.

I'm quite reserved with colleagues, I'm friendly and they know a little about my personal life but not much. My manager has started picking up on that, and wants me to become more well-known in the company. An example my manager gave was sharing if I'd done anything interesting at the weekend, and share things I'm passionate about. They gave an example of a colleague who goes hiking and raises money for charity.

AIBU to want to keep my private life private and not this kind of thing brought up as a measure of my performance?

The truth is my life is very different to most of my colleagues. I try and blend in so they would have no idea that I'm not a middle class Oxbridge graduate like they are. I live in a council flat, have had mental health difficulties (that my manager is aware of), and spend most of my free time helping to care for a disabled relative. I don't go hiking, or do much traveling or run marathons or play sport or any of the other things my colleagues do. AIBU to want to keep these things about my life private at work?

OP posts:
cherish123 · 13/03/2023 18:22

YADNBU
It's none of their business.
I would say nothing. If they keep persisting, say you are not comfortable with it.

Middleagedspreadisreal · 13/03/2023 18:03

Don't let anyone bully you into doing anything you don't want to do. I wouldn't make up a life, lies have a habit of being found out. Just tell him you prefer to keep your private and work life seperate. And try not to be down on yourself, whether you live in a council flat or a mansion, you are worthy.

Rainbowshine · 13/03/2023 14:22

Another vote for the response @usethedata gave on page one. I think I might be tempted to add some legal stuff in passing such as “discrimination by association” and “has there been any risk assessment for safeguarding concerns associated with appearing on social media?”

I work in HR and your manager would get me telling them in no uncertain terms that this is the opposite of inclusivity and that there are better and more appropriate ways of promoting someone’s professional achievements or ability than a sodding TikTok video.

cassiastatham · 13/03/2023 14:16

When your employer says they are one big family and have no secrets and attend team buildings, run sus, run, it's this ---> 🤡

LlynTegid · 13/03/2023 13:44

The valuing neurodiversity I think is a good one to use.

WhereYouLeftIt · 13/03/2023 13:27

NumberTheory · 12/03/2023 22:07

I would just tell her you aren’t paid to share your personal life. You think she is naive if she cannot recognize that her suggestions would make you vulnerable to classist and disablist discrimination. And that you’d really like to become better known at work for your expertise and proven track record - so does she have any ideas on how to push that side instead.

In the meantime, if this is a career you want to do well in and your current company is typical for the industry, I would start looking for a pass time or interest that will be well received. Because, unfortunately, she isn’t wrong that social networking is an effective way of getting on in the work place.

And from your OP:
"The truth is my life is very different to most of my colleagues. I try and blend in so they would have no idea that I'm not a middle class Oxbridge graduate like they are. I live in a council flat, have had mental health difficulties (that my manager is aware of), and spend most of my free time helping to care for a disabled relative."

So, there's a homogeneity to the people they hire - middle-class Oxbridge graduates. They have a recruitment problem - sounds as if they have been hiring in their own image, which will lead to a homogeneity of result and groupthink. I think @NumberTheory 's point about making yourself vulnerable is a very good one, and one that I would absolutely raise with them. It is very naive of them to not see that there is the potential there for you to become 'not one of us' to your colleagues. 'Blending in' is your strategy of choice.

As for "they want me to feature on the company's TikTok account" - Hell, no! And again I think NumberTheory is spot on here

"On this front I would say you’d be happy if it was entirely focused on your professional role, but you are not prepared to have your personal life on the Internet (and if it was intended to cover your personal life I would probably add some judgmental comment about it being irresponsible of the company to encourage people to expose themselves given how toxic social media can be, especially for women)."
Your manager is either spectacularly naive or cynically trying to use you.

cornflakegeneration · 13/03/2023 13:26

2Rebecca · 13/03/2023 12:38

Valuing neurodiversity is a buzz phrase at the moment and I'd maybe suggest to your manager that part of being inclusive is valuing some people's desire for privacy about their personal life and not just valuing extroverts

Especially since a lot of neurodiverse people struggle with social communication.

Catspyjamas17 · 13/03/2023 13:09

I worked (only on an interim contract fortunately) with an ostensibly lovely friendly team of oversharers, a few years ago, mostly ten years my junior and always posting photos of what they were up to outside work on a team whatsapp group.

It was nice at first but it just made me feel like I was never "off", and the boundary between home and work was too blurred. I WFH a lot now and still don't feel like that. With colleagues now it's just the "Nice weekend?" question then get on with stuff. Much better.

NotLactoseFree · 13/03/2023 12:55

Dyslexicwonder · 13/03/2023 12:50

If the ask you “how was your weekend”… “oh, I went to John Lewis to buy new sauce pants, not exciting but needed done…

I said similar recently, told them I was off to the tip and what I was taking (old car battery). Give them something without giving them everything OP.

The tip is a better example. Arguably, it's the casual assumption that John Lewis saucepans are accessible to all that, I suspect, is what makes OP uncomfortable sharing in the first place. When the person sitting next to you is off to John Lewis for saucepans and you bought yours at Wilko, that can make people uncomfortable.

Dyslexicwonder · 13/03/2023 12:50

If the ask you “how was your weekend”… “oh, I went to John Lewis to buy new sauce pants, not exciting but needed done…

I said similar recently, told them I was off to the tip and what I was taking (old car battery). Give them something without giving them everything OP.

watcherintherye · 13/03/2023 12:45

If the ask you “how was your weekend”… “oh, I went to John Lewis to buy new sauce pants, not exciting but needed done…

Oh, I don’t know…sauce pants sound like they could be quite exciting!

MsMarch · 13/03/2023 12:41

there's a bit difference between oversharing (looking at you colleague, and your detailed discussions, every day, about what your child ate for the 6 months you were weaning her....) and being closed off.

And if you don't want to talk about being a carer, that's totally fine and your right, but personally, I'd think that a light reference to it will give people a better understanding of you. Ditto, it's perfectly okay to say you enjoyed the weekend because you love that the weather is getting a bit better or similar - it's personal statement without going into any detail or oversharing.

2Rebecca · 13/03/2023 12:38

Valuing neurodiversity is a buzz phrase at the moment and I'd maybe suggest to your manager that part of being inclusive is valuing some people's desire for privacy about their personal life and not just valuing extroverts

SavBlancTonight · 13/03/2023 12:38

YANBU to feel that how much of your private life you share should not have any impact on how well you are considered to be performing at work.

However, personally, I think keeping your private life secret in an environment that is clearly quite open and interactive will make you stand out. it might be that the culture of this firm is simply not the right one for you.

Also, I can't help but suspect that your. manger wants you to speak out a bit more because you ARE the diversity hire. All the people speaking out are middle class, oxbridge types and he's fully aware that actually, there's more diversity than it appears. But at the end of the day, it's not your responsibility to "educate" others or to be the poster child for any internal diversity programs.

Nevermind31 · 13/03/2023 12:36

You don’t have to share your personal life at work - but someone who never talks about their personal life is hard work. Can’t make chit chat, can’t build a relationship.
bring up something… got stuck on the train, very excited, there is a new Waitrose/ Aldi opening around the corner, something that annoys you about your train station: car park, car needs an MOT, went to the gym, did you watch ABC at the weekend, I visited my aunt, need a new boiler, window cleaner was annoying…
anything that gives people the chance to get to know you.
then with others… ask them questions…. If the ask you “how was your weekend”… “oh, I went to John Lewis to buy new sauce pants, not exciting but needed done… what about you?” And then ask a couple of follow up questions. Next time, ask them.., oh, how was… you’ll be building relationships without giving too much away.

TonightMatthewIamgoingtobecher · 13/03/2023 12:30

greenfingers39 · 12/03/2023 20:23

It's really important for unpaid careers to make themselves known to employers so that they can be supported and stress levels minimised by use of workplace policies and actually, you're protected by law via the Care Act, or Carers Act in Scotland. The more carers that speak up, the more support will be generated, and you may even encourage others to speak up too. You should be proud to get where you are despite not having the privileged background the others have.

All that said, if you want to fade into the background, that's what to do Flowers

So many responses here but agree with this 100% I have caring responsibilities and it meant so much to see others being open about this and especially senior leaders taking time out etc. It made it feel much easier for others to follow. You never know others might be in similar circumstances or indeed future hires.

whathaveidonetomydc · 13/03/2023 12:07

I hate when people at work overshare the minutiae of their home lives - I'm here to do a job. I'm not your best friend, I don't really care about every second of your weekend. I remember being on work experience for 3 days aged 16 and one of the women in the office wouldn't stop talking about her sex life. She'd just been on holiday with her boyfriend and went into great detail about the 'naughty' places they had DTD 🤔.
My dsis has a temporary job in a private health care setting that very much operates on a 'cultural fit' level. They don't recruit for jobs, they prefer a family/friends network (my dsis is friends with one of the workers cousins!) . There was no interview, just a series of informal chats, where her views/interests were discussed at lengths. The clinic owner has a particular hobby that he expects the staff to participate on in 'team building' days and everyone knows everyone's business. They go into work early to eat breakfast together, stay behind to 'chill' and at Christmas the manager suggested that my dsis have everyone over to her house, because they have been to everyone's house but hers 🤔. Dsis is looking forward to moving on to a more professional work setting.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 13/03/2023 11:51

SalviaDivinorum · 12/03/2023 19:35

Now is your chance to make up an entire fantasy life!

I'd be up for that, but be careful not to go too far. Like dating an astronaut or growing up in the circus 🤣

28January · 13/03/2023 11:50

Lie. I hate this oversharing bollocks and don’t think it is my job to educate someone about how inappropriate it is to force someone who clearly doesn’t want to share details of their private lives to do so. Your free time is now devoted to crochet or stamp collecting.

FictionalCharacter · 13/03/2023 11:42

@usethedata @MsInsomniac Agree. “Bring your authentic self” isn’t meant to mean “tell your colleagues as much as they want to know about your private life”. And you are paid to do a day’s work, what you do outside work is your own business.
The current trend for employers becoming involved in their employees’ life outside work, and expecting people to participate in work-related activities outside work time, is not good. It’s blurring the boundaries between work and private life which is the last thing we need, and it’s drifting towards employers owning more of our lives than they have a right to.

user1471538283 · 13/03/2023 11:41

I'm very private and only share with those I am really close to.

This authentic oversharing nonsense is the opposite of inclusion. Not everyone wants to share. I've found that when I have been forced to share it has been used against me. I would tell him that this has made you feel uncomfortable.

I was told once that I didn't gel with the rest of the team. That's right for the first time in my entire career I didn't gel with them. Because they over shared and did
not stop talking. But management do not want to see what the actual problem is.

Your employer is not your friend. No matter if they think they are.

LlynTegid · 13/03/2023 11:41

Even though attitudes have changed over the past 10-15 years, there will be those who are gay or lesbian who may wish to keep this private, and those who may be considering transgendering likewise.

To give examples of why it is reasonable to want to keep some aspects of your life private.

lazycats · 13/03/2023 11:38

Sounds awful but I can imagine a lot of start-ups are like this. If you otherwise like the job and don't think it'll eventually result in them getting rid of you then ignore it.

Beingadiv · 13/03/2023 11:32

Just to add, don't start lying about outlandish things. It'll be embarrassing if you slip up as people will probably assume you're lying to seem more exciting or fit in rather than just get them off your back. you don't want a reputation as a bullshitter. If anything just be vague about what you did at the weekend. It's honestly fine. I don't know if it's my line of work but I've been party to some outrageous oversharing and would much prefer a nice simple 'it was very nice thanks, didnt go far. yours?!'

sally037 · 13/03/2023 11:32

I work in HR and am completely against all this, it's cringy and something that I'd wager 95% of those in the workplace don't want to do.

Last year I had to walk away from a job and company that I loved because of this kind of nonsense. My manager back then was fully subscribed to all this and the whole 'Work Family' thing whereas I just wanted to do my job to the best of my abilities especially as a private person who likes to have firm boundaries and a work/life balance.

She said that because I was in HR (or the 'People Team' as she rebranded it), it was even more important that I was seen and it got to the point where she was sending me cringy motivational quotes to share on the company Team channels. The stress it was causing me was horrendous especially as an introvert, I almost suffered burnout from it as it felt like my actual work was not enough and she wanted me to change my entire personality to fit in with her view of how the company culture should be.

I find the whole thing really infantilises employees and makes it feel like you're at school having to tell the teachers any problems you might have. I think someone mentioned that managers who push this whole agenda also don't have much going on in their life outside of work, this was definitely the case with my former manager - she literally lived and breathed it, working all hours and giving up her weekends for the company.

I'm not sure what you can really do as the kind of people that push this sort of culture are usually the ones that end up in the senior roles and positions of power. End of the day, I had to find a new job.

Swipe left for the next trending thread